Celebrating 1.7K Subs With Some Bad Writing Advice! (Featuring J.R. Traas)

Virtual Muse AI
5 Apr 202432:57

TLDRIn this enlightening discussion, experienced authors J.R. TR and Abby share insights to guide young artists away from common pitfalls. They emphasize the importance of staying true to one's unique voice, understanding that creativity is an evolving process, and recognizing that there's always room for fresh perspectives in storytelling. The conversation debunks myths like 'write what you know' and 'kill your darlings,' offering nuanced advice for navigating the complexities of writing with both passion and precision.

Takeaways

  • 🎨 Embrace creativity and mistakes in the artistic process; this leads to growth and improvement.
  • 🚀 Don't let fear or timidity hold you back from exploring and experimenting with your art.
  • ✍️ 'Write what you know' should be interpreted as understanding and connecting with what you write, not limiting yourself to personal experiences.
  • 📚 Be open to learning and incorporating knowledge outside your direct experiences to enrich your storytelling.
  • 🔄 Writing is not just about physically putting words on a page; it involves a mental process that happens outside of writing sessions.
  • 📈 Develop consistency and discipline in starting and finishing projects rather than focusing solely on daily word counts.
  • 🌟 Allow your ideas to evolve and transform throughout the writing process; don't be rigidly attached to the initial concept.
  • ✂️ 'Kill Your Darlings' should be about being willing to edit and change parts of the story for the betterment of the overall narrative, not just removing favorite parts.
  • 💡 Keep your writing clear, concise, and creative; prioritize clarity in communication above all.
  • 🌐 There are always new ideas to explore; don't believe the notion that all ideas have been exhausted.
  • 🛠️ Writing is a craft that improves with time and practice; enjoy the journey and continue to learn and grow as a writer.

Q & A

  • What is the main advice given to young artists in the transcript?

    -The main advice given to young artists is to stay loose, not worry about making mistakes, have fun, and enjoy the excitement of creation. It emphasizes the importance of approaching art without fear and timidity.

  • How does the author, J.R. TR, describe the 'Elf Raver Trilogy'?

    -J.R. TR describes the 'Elf Raver Trilogy' as an Arcane Punk cyber fantasy, a niche fantasy story about a pacifist monster hunter in a futuristic fantasy universe. He mentions that it is as amazing as it sounds from the abstract description.

  • What are the two ways advice can be considered bad according to the discussion?

    -Advice can be considered bad in two ways: 1) It is fundamentally flawed, meaning it won't help solve the problem it's meant to address and may lead to new issues. 2) It's bad at being advice, where the core idea is good but it's not conveyed well to beginners, making it unhelpful, confusing, or misleading.

  • What is the critique of the advice 'write what you know'?

    -The critique is that 'write what you know' can be limiting if taken too literally, as it may prevent writers from exploring topics outside their direct experiences. Instead, the advice should be 'know what you write', encouraging research and understanding of subjects rather than just relying on personal experience.

  • How does the speaker suggest we should approach the concept of 'writing every day'?

    -The speaker suggests that while consistency is important, it's not about physically writing every day. Instead, writing is a mental process that happens outside of physically typing words. It's about developing discipline in starting and finishing projects, and being flexible with one's writing schedule.

  • What is the issue with the advice 'Kill Your Darlings' for beginners?

    -The issue is that beginners may not have a strong sense of their own style and preferences, and asking them to cut out parts they love can be destructive. It can lead to removing essential elements without adding value, and it may reduce the story to a series of emotional gut punches.

  • What alternative advice is given instead of 'Kill Your Darlings'?

    -The alternative advice is to remain open and flexible about how ideas will develop and transform over the course of the project. It's about not being too attached to the initial idea and being willing to change it as the story evolves.

  • What does the speaker say about the idea that 'there are no new ideas left'?

    -The speaker refutes this idea, stating that there are infinite possibilities in storytelling and every author brings a unique perspective. They emphasize that technology and changes in publishing have opened up new horizons for creativity and diversity in storytelling.

  • How does the speaker describe the core purpose of a writer?

    -The speaker describes the core purpose of a writer as communicating complex ideas in a simple and understandable way. It's about making complicated ideas as simple as possible while maintaining clarity, conciseness, and creativity.

  • What advice does the speaker give to aspiring writers?

    -The speaker advises aspiring writers to keep writing, learning, and experimenting with different styles. They should enjoy the process, not be too hard on themselves, and take what is useful from advice related to the craft of writing.

  • What is the significance of the expression 'good writers borrow, great writers steal'?

    -The expression signifies that great writers take inspiration from a wide variety of sources, recontextualizing and reimagining them to create something unique. It emphasizes the importance of creativity in combining and transforming existing ideas into new ones.

Outlines

00:00

🎨 Embracing Creativity and Overcoming Fear in Art

The paragraph discusses the importance of staying relaxed and not worrying about making mistakes in the artistic process. It emphasizes the need to enjoy creation and feel the excitement of it. The speaker warns against approaching art with fear and timidity, as this can hinder one's ability to fully express themselves. The introduction of the podcast is made, and the guests are welcomed. The conversation aims to address common bad advice given to beginner writers and to provide practical guidance based on decades of combined writing experience.

05:01

📝 Debunking Common Writing Advice

This section delves into the critique of common writing advice, such as 'write what you know', which can be limiting if taken too literally. The discussion highlights the importance of using one's personal experiences but also encourages learning and incorporating new knowledge into one's writing. The paragraph also addresses the potential pitfalls of writing only what one has directly experienced, suggesting instead that writers should focus on creating a personal connection to their work. The conversation touches on the importance of understanding and effectively communicating themes and emotions through storytelling.

10:04

🖋️ The Misconceptions of Daily Writing Routines

The paragraph critiques the advice of writing every day and emphasizes that life can sometimes interfere with such strict routines. It argues for a more flexible approach to writing, acknowledging that creativity cannot be forced. The discussion suggests that mental work on characters and stories outside of physical writing is equally important. The paragraph also addresses the fallacy that one must write a certain number of words per day to be a successful writer, advocating for a more personalized and adaptable writing practice.

15:05

🗑️ 'Kill Your Darlings': A Misguided Writing Principle

This section critiques the advice 'Kill Your Darlings', which can be harmful to new writers who are still developing their style. The discussion explains that this advice can lead to the removal of important and loved parts of a story without adding value. Instead, the advice should focus on being open to the evolution of ideas and the transformation of a story throughout the writing process. The importance of not removing elements simply because they are personally appealing is stressed, encouraging writers to focus on the overall narrative rather than individual parts.

20:06

🌟 The Endless Potential for New Ideas in Writing

The paragraph refutes the notion that there are no new ideas left in writing. It highlights the infinite possibilities in storytelling and the unique perspectives each author brings to their work. The discussion emphasizes the role of evolving technology and changing publishing methods in opening up new horizons for creativity. It also touches on the cyclical nature of human storytelling and the importance of sharing and remixing ideas. The paragraph encourages writers to draw inspiration from a wide range of sources to create something unique.

25:08

✍️ The Craft of Writing and the Journey of the Writer

The final paragraph encourages aspiring writers to view writing as a craft that requires time, practice, and patience. It advises writers not to be too hard on themselves and to enjoy the process of writing. The conversation ends with a reminder that every writer, regardless of their level of experience, can contribute something unique to the world of storytelling. The paragraph concludes with a call to action for writers to continue writing, learning, and growing, embracing their passion and creativity in their work.

Mindmap

Keywords

💡Creativity

Creativity refers to the use of imagination or original ideas to create something new and valuable. In the context of the video, it is the driving force behind artistic expression and the development of unique stories. The speakers encourage young artists to embrace their creativity, explore different styles, and not be afraid of making mistakes as they hone their craft.

💡Writing Advice

Writing advice encompasses the various tips, guidelines, and suggestions given to writers to improve their craft. The video discusses common pieces of writing advice that are often given to beginners, highlighting both their potential value and their limitations. The speakers provide their insights on how to interpret and apply such advice effectively, emphasizing the importance of understanding the underlying principles rather than following advice blindly.

💡Fear and Timidity

Fear and timidity in the context of the video refer to the apprehension and lack of confidence that can hinder an artist's creative process. The speakers advise against approaching art with these negative emotions, as they can restrict creativity and prevent the artist from fully exploring their potential. Instead, they encourage embracing the excitement of creation and taking risks to foster artistic growth.

💡Writing Consistency

Writing consistency refers to the regular practice of writing, which is often seen as a key to improving one's craft. In the video, the speakers discuss the common advice of writing every day, but also acknowledge that life can get in the way. They suggest that while consistency is important, it should not lead to feelings of guilt or pressure, and that the quality of writing should not be sacrificed for the sake of meeting a daily word count or time commitment.

💡Kill Your Darlings

The phrase 'Kill Your Darlings' is a piece of writing advice that suggests an author should be willing to remove their favorite parts of a story if they do not serve the overall narrative. The video speakers critique this advice for beginners, arguing that it can be destructive without a solid foundation of skills and personal style. Instead, they recommend being open to the evolution of ideas and the transformation of the story, rather than blindly cutting elements one is attached to.

💡Artistic Expression

Artistic expression is the communication of thoughts, emotions, and ideas through various art forms, including writing. The video emphasizes the importance of staying true to one's artistic expression, even as one grows and evolves as an artist. It suggests that the process of creating art should be enjoyable and not solely focused on external validation or adherence to rigid rules.

💡Personal Connection

Personal connection refers to the link between an artist and their work, often reflecting their experiences, emotions, and perspectives. In the video, the speakers argue that art is more resonant and powerful when it is grounded in the artist's introspection and personal connection to the subject matter. They advise young artists to ensure that their work is not shallow or derivative but is instead deeply connected to their own experiences and understanding.

💡Writing Process

The writing process encompasses the steps an author takes from the initial idea to the final draft of their work. The video speakers discuss various aspects of the writing process, including the mental energy put into character development and story构思, the physical act of typing, and the editing and revising stages. They emphasize that writing is a complex and multifaceted process that goes beyond just the physical act of putting words on a page.

💡Storytelling

Storytelling is the art of telling stories, a fundamental aspect of human culture and communication. In the video, storytelling is discussed as a dynamic and evolving process, with the speakers highlighting the importance of allowing stories to grow and change as the author delves deeper into them. They also touch on the idea that every author brings a unique perspective to their storytelling, ensuring that there is always potential for new and innovative narratives.

💡Writing Style

Writing style refers to the unique way in which an author expresses their ideas and stories through language and narrative techniques. The video speakers caution against rigidly adhering to advice that might stifle an author's individual style, such as 'write what you know' or 'keep it simple'. Instead, they advocate for understanding the core principles behind such advice and adapting them to fit one's own writing style and creative vision.

Highlights

The advice for young artists to stay loose and not worry about making mistakes

The importance of enjoying the process of creation and feeling the excitement of it

The discussion on common bad advice given to beginner writers and how to navigate it with experience

The significance of having a personal connection to your art, and the potential pitfalls of only writing what you know

The idea that there is a vast amount of human knowledge available for learning and incorporating into your writing

The misconception that writing only happens when physically typing and the importance of mental writing processes

The advice of writing a certain number of words or hours per day and its limitations

The importance of being open to the evolution and transformation of ideas throughout a writing project

The concept of 'killing your darlings' and its potential harm to beginners if misunderstood

The value of keeping writing simple and understandable while effectively communicating complex themes

The myth that there are no new ideas left and the infinite possibilities in storytelling

The encouragement for aspiring writers to keep writing, learning, and enjoying the process

The notion that good writing can make complex themes easy to follow and understand

The advice to communicate complex ideas in simple, understandable terms

The importance of being clear, concise, and creative in writing

The idea that borrowing and stealing from various sources can lead to unique and innovative writing