"Her Hypocrisies Are ASTOUNDING" Winston Marshall On Taking On Nancy Pelosi
Summary
TLDRIn this insightful debate, Winston Marshall, former member of Mumford and Sons, confronts Congresswoman Nancy Pelosi on the topic of populism and its threat to democracy. Marshall challenges Pelosi's double standards, highlighting her selective outrage over the January 6th insurrection while ignoring the Portland, Oregon siege. He criticizes the left's tendency to label Trump supporters as ethnonationalists and deplorables, arguing this alienates voters. The conversation delves into the nuances of populism, the dangers of demagogy, and the importance of respecting diverse perspectives to foster healthy political discourse.
Takeaways
- π€ Winston Marshall, a former member of Mumford and Sons, was invited to debate former US House Speaker Nancy Pelosi at the Oxford Union on the topic of populism.
- π£οΈ Marshall expressed his views on cancel culture and his experience of being forced out of his band due to his support for a book critical of the Antifa movement.
- π€ He discussed the double standards he observed in American politics, particularly regarding the reactions to the January 6th Capitol riots and the Portland, Oregon courthouse siege.
- π₯ Marshall argued that both sides of the political spectrum can be guilty of not accepting election results and engaging in populist rhetoric.
- π He pointed out that the term 'ethnonationalist' is being used by some politicians to demonize and generalize large groups of people, which he sees as demagoguery.
- π Marshall highlighted the growing support for Trump among minority groups, suggesting that the narrative of Trump supporters being ethnonationalists is flawed.
- π‘ He believes that the best way to combat populism is through respect and understanding, rather than through cancellation and suppression.
- ποΈ Marshall's debate with Pelosi at the Oxford Union exposed her perceived hypocrisy and double standards, particularly in her reactions to different instances of unrest.
- π΅ Despite missing the stage and performing with his former band, Marshall is currently focused on building businesses and enterprises as a way to serve his country.
- π€ The conversation emphasized the importance of exposing hypocrisy regardless of political affiliation and the need for open and honest debate on contentious issues.
- π Marshall suggested that the 'woke' culture may be past its peak, but it could potentially resurge if certain political figures return to power, indicating a cyclical nature to such movements.
Q & A
What was the topic of debate between Winston Marshall and Nancy Pelosi at the Oxford Union?
-The topic of debate was whether populism is a threat to democracy.
What was Winston Marshall's initial reaction to being invited to debate at the Oxford Union?
-Initially, Winston Marshall did not want to participate and had plans to be elsewhere, but his friends encouraged him to do it, and learning that his opponent would be Nancy Pelosi changed his approach to the debate.
How did Winston Marshall describe his experience at the Oxford Union?
-Winston Marshall described his experience as being on adrenaline, speaking quickly, and having done thorough research to be prepared for the debate.
What was the reaction of Nancy Pelosi when Winston Marshall brought up the Insurrection in Portland, Oregon?
-Nancy Pelosi reacted with astonishment and seemed to be unaware of the arguments presented by Winston Marshall, questioning why he was doing so and who he was.
What was Winston Marshall's stance on the January 6th riots and the events in Portland, Oregon?
-Winston Marshall condemned both the January 6th riots and the events in Portland, Oregon, stating that refusal to accept the results of elections is wrong regardless of which side does it.
How did Winston Marshall describe the language used by politicians like Hillary Clinton and Nancy Pelosi about Trump supporters?
-Winston Marshall described the language as demagogic, playing to the prejudice of some progressive or elite Americans, and demonizing a large group of people with terms like 'ethnonationalist' and 'deplorable'.
What was the point made by Winston Marshall regarding the increase in Trump's support among minority groups?
-Winston Marshall pointed out that Trump's support among black Americans increased from 12% to 28% and among Hispanic Americans to 48%, challenging the notion that these groups are ethnonationalists.
What is Winston Marshall's current view on the best way to serve Britain?
-Winston Marshall believes that the best way to serve Britain is by building things, such as businesses and social enterprises, rather than working in politics.
What was the subject of the discussion regarding the term 'populism' and its connotations?
-The discussion revolved around how 'populism' has become synonymously used with racist, ethnonationalist, and other derogatory terms, and the importance of distinguishing between healthy and unhealthy forms of populism.
How did Winston Marshall perceive the reaction to his support for a book that criticized the far-left?
-Winston Marshall felt that the backlash he faced for supporting the book was due to the peak of 'woke' culture and cancel culture, which he believes may have been destructive.
What is Winston Marshall's opinion on the current state of free speech on American campuses?
-Winston Marshall finds the war on free speech on American campuses to be scary, as universities are suppressing alternative thoughts or opinions instead of promoting open debate.
Outlines
π Winston's Debate on Populism and Cultural Heroism
In this paragraph, Winston, a former member of Mumford and Sons, is praised for his debate skills and his stance against cancel culture. He discusses his recent debate with former US House Speaker Nancy Pelosi on populism at the Oxford Union. Winston highlights the hypocrisy of the left, especially regarding the handling of the January 6th insurrection and the siege of the federal courthouse in Portland, Oregon. He criticizes Pelosi for her double standards and her inability to recognize the populist sentiment that led to Trump's support. Winston also expresses his patriotism and his belief in serving Britain through enterprise rather than politics.
π€ Winston's Experience Debating Pelosi and Populism's Role in Politics
Winston shares his experience debating Nancy Pelosi at the Oxford Union, emphasizing the intimidation factor and his preparation for the event. He discusses the topic of whether populism is a threat to democracy and his strategy to counter Pelosi's arguments. Winston points out Pelosi's refusal to acknowledge the equivalence between different political insurrections and her condescending attitude towards those with opposing views. He also addresses the increasing support for Trump among minority groups and criticizes the left's elitist approach to politics, which he believes alienates ordinary Americans.
π£οΈ The Dangers of Demagogy and Cancel Culture in Politics
This paragraph delves into the concept of populism as the politics of ordinary people in contention with elites. Winston argues that all political movements are susceptible to violence and demagogy, which he sees as unhealthy when it involves lying and playing to prejudices. He criticizes the left for their inability to combat populism effectively, suggesting that their attempts to cancel and suppress voices only serve to strengthen populist leaders. Winston also shares his personal journey of understanding America's political divide and the importance of recognizing the diversity of opinions within the country.
πΆ Reflections on Cancel Culture, Free Speech, and Winston's Life After Music
In the final paragraph, the discussion turns to the potential resurgence of cancel culture if Trump were to become president again. Winston speculates that the left's inability to deal with Trump could lead to a resurgence of wokeness. He also touches on the war on free speech in American universities and the recent anti-Semitism awareness act. The conversation concludes with Winston reflecting on his departure from Mumford and Sons due to backlash over his political views and his current happiness with his life outside of the band, hinting at a possible return to music in the future.
Mindmap
Keywords
π‘Cancel culture
π‘Populism
π‘Oxford Union
π‘Nancy Pelosi
π‘Double standard
π‘Ethnonationalist
π‘3G's (guns, gays, God)
π‘Demagogy
π‘Trump's support among minorities
π‘Elitism
π‘Free speech
Highlights
Winston Marshall, a former member of Mumford and Sons, debates Nancy Pelosi on populism at the Oxford Union.
Marshall was forced out of his band for supporting a book critical of the Antifa movement.
Republicans accused of spreading 'fake news' and accused of blocking views on guns, gays, and God.
Pelosi's debate performance criticized for hypocrisy and double standards regarding political violence and election results.
Marshall challenges Pelosi on her stance towards the Portland, Oregon insurrection and her refusal to accept its equivalence to January 6th events.
Pelosi's reaction to Marshall's arguments suggests unfamiliarity with opposing viewpoints.
Marshall's debate performance went viral, highlighting the exposure of double standards and hypocrisy.
Discussion on the term 'ethnonationalist' being used as a derogatory label for Trump supporters.
Pelosi's speech criticized for condescension and the assumption that certain policies are blocked by 'culture and God'.
Marshall's experience with cancel culture and his departure from Mumford and Sons due to supporting a controversial book.
Debate on whether 'wokeness' has peaked and the potential resurgence if Trump becomes president again.
Concerns over the suppression of free speech and alternative opinions in American universities.
The Anti-Semitism Awareness Act and its implications for free speech on college campuses.
Marshall's reflections on his time with Mumford and Sons and his current happiness with his career path.
The importance of exposing hypocrisy regardless of political affiliation.
Transcripts
I don't know about that we can't have
him laughing as he reads his own
[Laughter]
intro try and control yourself Wiston
you're a cultural hero for today
anyway W Marshall is a cancel culture
Pioneer he was a member of the British
rock group Mumford and Sons owned to be
forced out and publicly shamed for
supporting a book which criticized the
hardle protest movement antifa who's
recently invited to debate the former US
House speaker Nancy Pelosi at the Oxford
Union on the subject of populism and
millions have now seen what happened
next what do the Republicans say fake
news so they're diminishing that in the
eyes of these poor souls who are looking
for some answers we've given them to
them but they're blocked by some of
their views on guns and they have the 3
G's guns gays God a snake oil sells them
a bill of goods and then takes office
and the only legislation put forth is a
bill that gives a tax bill that gives
83% of the benefits to the top 1%
populism has become a word used
synonymously we've racist we've heard
ethnonationalist we've bigot we've
hillbilly redneck with' deplorables and
I'm sure congresswoman Pelos will agree
that the entire month of June 2020 when
the federal courthouse in Portland
Oregon was under siege and under
Insurrection by radical progressives
those two were dark days for
America not there is no equivalence this
you may be thinking now that Trump is a
populist you are right he didn't accept
the 2020 elections and he should
have so should Hillary in 2016 so should
Brussels and so should Westminster in
2016 and so too should Congresswoman
Pelosi instead of saying the 2016
election was quote hijacked what quote
hijacked it
was that we don't accept the
result well Winston joins me now Winston
first of all Kudos it was fantastic to
watch you in action there um I do see a
life in politics possibly beckoning can
we get that on the table off the start
uh I as far as I can see if you want to
get anything done don't work in politics
that's true so uh at the moment I I'm a
very patriotic person I love my country
but I feel the best way to serve Britain
is to build things build businesses
build uh uh on you know uh social
entrepr uh uh uh Enterprises and and
those kind of things that's I I think is
time is best spent now what I'm curious
about because I've done the oxy it's
quite an intimidating place to go
particularly if you're up against one of
America's most senior and experienced
politicians Nancy Pelosi did you have
any quals about accepting the debate
which was about whether populism is a
threat to democracy it's also quite
intimidating how on your show appears
okay um but you know I did actually
wasn't going to do the thing I had uh
plans to be elsewhere didn't want to and
then a bunch of friends of mine were
like no I think you should do this and
and then about a week before I learned
that Pelosi was my opposition so that
changed what I was going to say quite a
lot I actually care about the topic
quite a lot and and we should talk about
what she said in in the interview
because her hypocrisies are astounding
well that was what you did so
brilliantly was you exposed the double
standard from the left in America
towards a lot of these issues like the
January 6th Insurrection riots whatever
people want to call them and the fact
that they can't see any of that kind of
behavior on their side like the refusal
to accept the results of elections I
remember them all howling when Hillary
lost it's been stolen it was rigged blah
blah blah all the same stuff they don't
apply the same rules yeah to their side
that they do to the conservative side
you're absolutely right in in that uh
interview oh sorry in in in my uh debate
with her she I bring up the Insurrection
that lasted in Portland Oregon now what
I didn't actually mention is that she
and you can look this up she ordered uh
Trump at that time was trying to send in
more police and I think the National
Guard to deal with the Insurrection in
Oregon she ordered against it so it's
one rule when it's radical progressives
leading the Insurrection and it's
another one when it comes to Jan 6 now
she's completely blinded by Jan 6 I read
one of Trump's tweets from Jan 6 when
she says be peaceful we're not like the
other side again that's not exact quote
but you you can look on his Twitter feed
what he actually said when I was doing
that she was looking at me she was going
why are you doing this I don't think
she's ever heard these arguments and uh
another thing from the from the speech
is throughout or maybe maybe two or
three times she looked at me you can't
see this in the camera she goes why are
you doing this sorry she goes who are
you who are you now I'm a nobody right
so fair enough well you're a popster
what she's actually saying is do you
know who I am yeah that and I was like
quite astounded by it now going into it
you mentioned what's it like going to
the ox Union I I was on adrenaline you
can hear from my speech I'm like bombing
through it very quickly I've never done
anything like that I didn't go to
university call control bombing I mean
you've done your research you were ready
for her you'd almost second guessed the
lines of attack that she would come out
with and you just exposed the double
standard and that's why it went viral
these clips and Miss Thing I want to
show another one this is about the
January 6th uh riots where you asked her
directly about
comparisons and I'm sure Congresswoman
Pelosi will agree that the entire month
of June 2020 when the federal courthouse
in Portland Oregon was under siege and
under Insurrection by radical
progressives those two were dark days
for
America there are not there is no
equivalence of this I played that again
just on that little bit because it was
her reaction which I found so striking a
refusal to accept any equivalence even
though people on the left in that
circumstance in Oregon had taken over a
public building and for all intents and
purpos were trying to thwart democracy
yeah at the end of that clip I ask her
do you condemn what happened in Portland
Oregon and she looked at me completely
blankly almost as if she didn't know
what I was because you were happy to
condemn both and that's what made it
that's what made it powerful is that you
were you weren't there of you wer there
saying I think January 6th was
defensible you were saying I think that
was wrong and so is this yeah and so is
refusal to accept the results of
elections it's wrong whichever side does
it exactly I don't think why is that so
hard to to to admit well she's a
politician what do you expect the
beginning the first clip you played was
from her speech and that's really worth
picking at in Her speech she used the
term ethnonationalist maybe five times
she like sprinkled in there this is like
a new word like deplorables now she she
thinks the whole Trump movement magger
conservatives she's saying that they're
E nationalists I would argue she is
practicing demagogy by saying that why
because she is playing to the Prejudice
of some Progressive Americans or Elite
Americans that half of the country are
racists that's demogra it goes It goes
back to Hillary talking about the basket
of deplorables and we see this again
again the language they use about Trump
supporters bearing in mind he got nearly
80 million votes second time 10 million
more than the first time yeah so she's
basically calling a large sway of the
country you know sort of
imbeciles fascists Nazis whatever they
language they want to use this is what I
have a problem with when they do this
they try and demonize a whole group of
tens of millions of Americans in One
Umbrella people people have had enough
of it I I add to a point CNN put out a
poll uh about a month ago showing how
showing how different groups in America
are polling for the upcoming
presidential election Trump's votes
amongst black Americans has gone 12% to
28% from Hispanic Americans it's now at
48 % why do you think that is well that
that's a good question maybe you have
insight into that but the point I want
to make is she wants to um say that
they're all ethn nationalists are we to
believe that all of those minorities in
America have suddenly seen the light and
are white nationalist it's a totally
absurd position it's an odd position
they get themselves into the left in
America where they there's a real kind
of elitist snobbery about the way they
go about combating Trump and I've known
trou a long time very well interviewed
him 40 50 times maybe and the best way
to combat him is not to play to his
strength which is to allow him to Martyr
himself and say look at these people
they think they're better than you I'm
here for the little guy it's a very
effective weapon for him which they
constantly they they've they've taken
him off the ballot in Maine and Colorado
they are making him more popular this
feeds the narrative that the
establishment is out to get Trump which
which makes him more popular if only
only these Democrats would just start
listening and respecting to ordinary
Americans it's so easy they've literally
had power for four years it's absurd to
me that they they they have such disdain
for working people we've had the same
thing with brexit here we've seen a lot
of populism debates around Europe we've
seen some very populous leaders coming
in in countries uh in Europe where's
where's the line for you between what I
would call Healthy populism and
unhealthy populism
that's a good question so um
populism technically speaking is the
politics of Ordinary People In
Contention with Elites
so that itself isn't necessarily by
definition unhealthy or healthy I would
argue that all political movements are
susceptible to political violence we
spoke earlier about the example of
radical progressives who the Democrats
well Biden said antifa was just an idea
they
The Establishment Elite in in America
supported the BLM movement
wholeheartedly and I know that's a
complicated issue but it's the extreme
end of that movement was also not
condemned at least so my point being
that all political movements are
susceptible to violence I think the
where not just populism but all
politics goes to far is when there's
lying when there's demagogy played but
again that's just that could be all any
type of politics don't you think yeah
and I think the best way to combat if
you want to combat it is not
to call everyone that is gravitating to
those people deplorable right the moment
you start to demean those people who are
gravitating to it you're fueling the
support of the populist leader because
he can turn around and see look at these
people they're just snobs they're
elitist they just want to walk around
and think they know what's best for the
country it doesn't involve people like
you yeah and then his popularity or her
popularity whoever it may be will gather
strength he won't be damaged by it yeah
you're absolutely right I I I'll tell
you a story about my own my own Journey
when in 2016 I used to I was living in
New York and I was surrounded by liberal
Elite types and when I I didn't like
Trump at the time and I I thought he was
going to lose I thought it was Hillary
was easy for her when Trump won everyone
around me was like oh my God America is
completely I was in New York the next
day it was like a Ghost Town people were
walking around in trauma they couldn't
believe that the most supposedly most
experienced politician in American
history had lost to the least experience
and if you remember on the night you had
Trump's camp in one hotel and Hillary's
in the other they only a mile apart in
this epicenter of this battle but it was
extraordinary the atmosphere wasn't it
extraordinary atmosphere and I remember
having quite a different reaction to my
friends and contemporaries it was that I
Tau America i' I've now visited 48
states at that time probably 4 45 States
and I lived in the South as well and I
was like America is not racism racist
sure I've seen racism here and there but
as a country I was like it's not racist
like these people say these people who
I'd played before for 10 years were not
deplorables so I then went on a journey
to to try and understand I did the same
because I was doing crime documentaries
and I've done America's Got Talent
around America and things like this and
when you spend a lot of time down in
rural parts of America rural Florida
rural Texas you know Alabama all these
places you get a get a sense of a really
different country in terms of attitudes
but they're not they can't be branded
together in a negative content you're
going to get bad people wherever you are
but I find I find I come across I think
more deplorable people in LA and New
York than I ever do in rural Texas well
this comes back to Madame Pelosi's
speech she described these people in Her
speech and you really have to watch this
CU it's startling that they are blinded
sorry no the word she used was blocked
from seeing sense and thinking
rationally and choosing the policy the
Democrats put before them by their quote
culture and by quote God their thoughts
on God are stopping let's play that to
begin this is her about the three G's uh
let's see what she
said what do the Republicans say fake
news so they're diminishing that in the
eyes of these poor souls who are looking
for some answers we've given them to
them but they're blocked by some of
their views on guns and they have the
3Gs guns gays
God you know poor souls like she's there
to save condescending yeah really
condescending another hypocrisy in that
clip is she starts with saying oh you
know they say fake news I'm sorry for 4
years every single day we hear the word
words disinformation misinformation
malformation the Democrats play exactly
the same game with different words it's
not hard for us all to see what all
these politicians either side of the
aisle are doing it's the same stuff you
you for some reasons that still baffle
me you had to leave M and Sons a great
band because of the backlash to you
having the audacity to support a book
which was exposing some of the bad
behavior of the farle which actually
needed exposing I mean I don't I'm not
sure would have happened today are you
do you think you would have faced the
same backlash or I feel the woke worm is
turning a bit that that kind of cancel
culture has peaked and people are now
beginning to think actually this is very
destructive yeah that's a really good
question and a lot of people asking this
are we past Peak woke and
my thinking is if Trump becomes
president again Trump uh wokeness or or
what we saw the Mania of sort of 2016 to
2020
might come back with aeng it they'll
change name it will come back under
different you know at that period we had
me we had BLM and and it was a kind of
Hysteria it was a Hyer it was like the
Salem wish trials it was like a you know
who's going to be next to be taken down
and destroyed and and so I think that
that it's that it's possible that that
stuff will come back as a reaction to
Trump if he wins the election that's my
that's my sense of it but I think the
reason he may win and I think he got a
very good chance is prec nicely because
the left have been incapable of dealing
with Trump they think the only way to
deal with him is to try and cancel him
suppress him stop him running literally
try and stop him running or if they
can't do that try and incarcerate him
for some money he may have paid off a
porn star with 18 years ago they forget
that most Americans are like really
you're doing that to an next president
of the United States it's almost like
they're admitting that they have no
chance of winning the vote yeah because
it's like well we can't win the vote so
we have to use have to try have to try
and destroy him another way rather than
destroy him at the ballot exactly but
this is exactly populism versus elitism
they're using all the power they have
all the institutions from intelligence
to the media all all of these kind of
the universities these institutions that
they have power and they're using it and
they're mobilizing it against him
because they're actually scared of the
people well the university stuff is I
mean it ironic you're at Oxford but the
the way these universities are behaving
in America now is actually quite
terrifying I mean they're being endorsed
students by professors in their
workplace to basically suppress any
alternative thought or opinion I mean
it's the war on Free Speech in on
American campuses is scary because the
one place you should be exposed to all
speech and and have proper debate and
try and work out what you really think
about things given that many people from
these campuses will go on to run things
is that you have to have a proper
legitimate debate with all views a but
they they're not interested it's taken
an interesting turn in the last month
and I'm sure you'll have be familiar
with the anti-Semitism awareness act now
of course like you like me I'm sure
you've been shocked and and horrified by
some of the anti-Semitism we're seeing
on these campuses however this new act
which has been put forward by Republican
Congressman uh and women that it says
that the department for education has to
embrace these rules about anti-Semitism
as a definition which include even
criticizing let's say the H Holocaust
obviously that's a disgusting thing my
grandmother was a holocaust Survivor I
you know it's it's something that's
horrible I'm not saying that what I'm
saying is we need free speech and so
what we're seeing now since the Gaza War
started was a turn where conservatives
are letting go of their free spee
principles yeah do you miss music I mean
do you still perform do you just come
from the studio and I'm just rushing
back to the studio after you're doing
your own thing now yeah did you miss
being with the band I miss being on
stage a lot I loved that that was there
was a sort of magic there when you when
you're when you're in the music and the
whole band are together and the whole
room is focused on
this this this thing that I I know I
can't do you think You' ever be back
with them uh I am very happy now that's
not a no I'm very
happy well it's good to see you Winston
thanks P keep fighting the fight keep
having your say it's important you know
I just think what happened to you was
ridiculous and I think what happened to
you Oxford Union was very telling in the
it went viral around the world because
people thought yeah good on you calling
out hypocrisy where you see it I don't
care whether it's left or right
Hypocrites should be exposed good to see
thanks thanks very much P good to see
you
5.0 / 5 (0 votes)
Trump Praises Jan. 6 Criminals as SCOTUS Overrules Colorado Ballot Ban: A Closer Look
Robert De Niro spars with bystander during remarks outside Trump trial
Meltdown After 9-0 Supreme Court Ruling Trump Can Be on the Ballot, with Stu Burguiere & Dave Marcus
Brooks and Capehart on Supreme Court arguments over immunity for Trump
Trump STRUGGLES TO SPEAK in Alarming Speech
Tapper presses Crockett over her counterattack about Marjorie Taylor Greene's appearance