“Nuclear War Cannot Be Won” - Tulsi Gabbard Reacts to Tucker Carlson's Opinions About Nukes on JRE

Valuetainment
25 Apr 202410:48

Summary

TLDRThe transcript captures a thought-provoking discussion involving Tucker Carlson and Joe Rogan, where they delve into the topic of nuclear weapons. The conversation explores the ethical implications of using nuclear weapons, with Carlson challenging the notion that it's acceptable to drop such weapons on civilians. The dialogue also touches on the importance of critical thinking and questioning the narratives presented by the establishment. The speakers emphasize the catastrophic consequences of nuclear war, referencing historical figures like JFK and Ronald Reagan, who both advocated for diplomacy over the use of nuclear weapons. The discussion highlights the urgency of reducing the risk of nuclear conflict and the need for global cooperation to prevent such a devastating outcome.

Takeaways

  • 📢 Tucker Carlson and Joe Rogan discuss the topic of nuclear weapons and their implications on a podcast.
  • 💣 The conversation touches on the historical use of nuclear weapons, with Carlson defending the necessity of their development to prevent Nazi Germany from having them first.
  • 🤔 Rogan challenges the idea of using nuclear weapons on civilians, arguing that it is inherently wrong and equating those who justify it to being evil.
  • 🧐 The dialogue explores the concept of critical thinking and questioning established narratives, including the moon landing and government involvement in 9/11.
  • 🇺🇸 Jeremy Boreing, co-founder of The Daily Wire, is mentioned, with his stance that questioning certain historical events reflects a hatred for the country.
  • 🤨 The importance of questioning and being anti-establishment is emphasized, as opposed to blindly trusting the government.
  • ✝️ The discussion includes a comparison to religious faith, suggesting that believing in government narratives requires a similar leap of faith.
  • 🚨 The potential for nuclear war and its catastrophic consequences are highlighted, referencing the Cuban Missile Crisis and the false alarm in Hawaii.
  • 🌍 The call for diplomacy and leadership to prevent nuclear war is made, with references to JFK and Ronald Reagan's approaches to avoiding nuclear conflict.
  • 🔒 The reality of nuclear weapons' destructive power is underscored, noting that even one is enough to cause massive devastation.
  • 🤝 The need for global cooperation to reduce the risk of nuclear war and the proliferation of nuclear weapons is stressed.

Q & A

  • Who is Tucker Carlson?

    -Tucker Carlson is a prominent political commentator and host of 'Tucker Carlson Tonight' on Fox News. He is known for his conservative views and his ability to provoke reactions from his audience.

  • What is the general perception of Tucker Carlson's style of communication?

    -Tucker Carlson is perceived as someone who knows how to get under people's skin, often intentionally provoking reactions and discussions, whether it's through his television show or other media appearances.

  • Who is Joe Rogan, and how is he related to Tucker Carlson in the context of this transcript?

    -Joe Rogan is a comedian, podcast host, and commentator known for 'The Joe Rogan Experience'. In the transcript, he is mentioned as being on a podcast with Tucker Carlson, where they discuss various topics, including nuclear weapons.

  • What is the topic of discussion between Tucker Carlson and Joe Rogan in the podcast?

    -The topic of discussion is centered around nuclear weapons, their use, and the ethical considerations surrounding the development and potential deployment of such weapons.

  • What is the stance of the speaker on the use of nuclear weapons on civilian populations?

    -The speaker strongly condemns the use of nuclear weapons on civilian populations, considering it inherently evil and morally wrong.

  • What historical event is mentioned in the context of the development of nuclear weapons?

    -The development of the atomic bomb during World War II is mentioned, with reference to J. Robert Oppenheimer's role and the fear that the Nazis might develop a similar weapon first.

  • What is the position of the speaker regarding the justification of nuclear weapons?

    -The speaker argues against the justification of nuclear weapons, advocating instead for efforts to prevent their use and proliferation, emphasizing the catastrophic humanitarian consequences of nuclear warfare.

  • What is the 'Baby Hitler' hypothetical mentioned in the transcript?

    -The 'Baby Hitler' hypothetical is a thought experiment that asks whether it would be morally justifiable to kill Adolf Hitler as a baby to prevent the Holocaust and World War II. It is used here to illustrate the complexity of moral decisions in hypothetical scenarios.

  • Who is Jeremy Boreing, and what are his views on critical thinking?

    -Jeremy Boreing is the co-founder and CEO of The Daily Wire, a conservative media company. He argues that denying the moon landing, suggesting America's evil for using atomic weapons in World War II, or claiming George Bush was behind 9/11 are not examples of critical thinking but rather a rejection of it.

  • What is the importance of diplomacy and leadership in preventing nuclear war according to the speaker?

    -The speaker emphasizes that diplomacy and leadership are crucial in reducing the risk of nuclear war. They highlight the need for cooperation with other nations, even those with adversarial interests, to work towards reducing nuclear proliferation and avoiding a nuclear catastrophe.

  • What is the significance of the missile scare in Hawaii mentioned in the transcript?

    -The missile scare in Hawaii serves as a real-life example of the immediate threat and panic that a potential nuclear attack can cause. It underscores the urgency and importance of diplomatic efforts to prevent such scenarios and the lack of preparedness for the general public in the face of a nuclear threat.

Outlines

00:00

🗣️ Controversial Discussion on Nuclear Weapons

In this paragraph, Tucker Carlson and Joe Rogan engage in a deep conversation about nuclear weapons. They discuss the ethical implications of using nuclear weapons against civilians, referencing historical instances such as the atomic bombs dropped on Japan during World War II. The dialogue touches on the responsibility to prevent nuclear proliferation and the moral dilemma of whether it's justifiable to use such weapons. The discussion also includes a debate on the value of nuclear weapons in the current geopolitical climate and the importance of critical thinking in understanding the consequences of nuclear warfare.

05:01

🌍 The Dire Consequences of Nuclear War

This paragraph focuses on the catastrophic outcomes of nuclear warfare, as highlighted by historical figures like President John F. Kennedy and President Ronald Reagan. The speaker emphasizes the importance of diplomacy and leadership in preventing a nuclear conflict. They recount a personal experience related to a false missile alarm in Hawaii, illustrating the very real and immediate threat that nuclear weapons pose to humanity. The paragraph also addresses the current state of nuclear weapons, the potential for their use, and the urgent need for global cooperation to reduce nuclear arsenals and the risk of nuclear war.

10:03

📚 Promoting Awareness and Engagement

The final paragraph shifts from the discussion on nuclear weapons to a promotional offer. The speaker encourages viewers to interact with Tulsi Gabbard, a political figure, by 'manning' with her, which likely refers to showing support or engaging with her on social media. The first 50 people to do so are promised a signed copy of a book, with the condition that they reside in America. This part of the script serves to mobilize the audience and promote active participation in political discourse.

Mindmap

Keywords

💡Tucker Carlson

Tucker Carlson is a prominent conservative political commentator and television host known for his controversial and provocative style. In the transcript, he is mentioned as a guest on Joe Rogan's podcast where they discuss sensitive topics such as nuclear weapons. His role in the conversation is to challenge conventional thinking and provoke a reaction, which is a characteristic of his public persona.

💡Joe Rogan

Joe Rogan is a comedian, podcast host, and former television presenter known for his show 'The Joe Rogan Experience.' In the transcript, he is the host of the podcast where Tucker Carlson is a guest. Rogan is noted for his ability to engage in long-form conversations on a wide range of topics, including controversial ones, which is evident in his discussion with Carlson about nuclear weapons.

💡Nuclear Weapons

Nuclear weapons are powerful explosives with destructive potential resulting from nuclear reactions. The script discusses the ethical and strategic implications of using such weapons, referencing historical instances like the atomic bombings of Hiroshima and Nagasaki. The conversation highlights the ongoing debate about the necessity and morality of possessing nuclear weapons in the context of global security.

💡Oppenheimer

J. Robert Oppenheimer was a theoretical physicist and one of the key figures in the development of the atomic bomb during World War II as part of the Manhattan Project. In the transcript, he is mentioned in the context of the development of nuclear weapons before the Nazis could, emphasizing the urgency and strategic importance of such weapons during that time.

💡Nuclear War

Nuclear war refers to a large-scale conflict involving the use of nuclear weapons. The transcript discusses the catastrophic consequences of such a war, including the potential for the end of civilization and the destruction of humanity. The speakers argue against the idea that a nuclear war could be won and emphasize the importance of diplomacy in preventing such a scenario.

💡Diplomacy

Diplomacy is the practice of conducting negotiations between representatives of groups or states, often to resolve disputes or to engage in international relations. In the transcript, diplomacy is presented as a crucial tool in preventing nuclear war. It is highlighted as a means to reduce the risk of nuclear conflict and to foster international cooperation.

💡North Korea

North Korea is a country in East Asia often mentioned in discussions about nuclear weapons due to its nuclear weapons program and long-range missile development. The transcript references the potential threat posed by North Korea's nuclear capabilities, particularly in relation to its proximity to Hawaii and the United States.

💡Missile Scare

A missile scare refers to a false alarm or alert about an incoming missile attack. The transcript recounts a specific incident in Hawaii where residents received a false alert about an incoming missile, causing panic and highlighting the very real threat of nuclear warfare. This incident is used to emphasize the urgency of diplomatic efforts to prevent nuclear conflict.

💡Baby Hitler

The phrase 'Baby Hitler' is a hypothetical scenario often used in ethical debates about the morality of killing a historical figure in their infancy to prevent future atrocities. In the transcript, it is mentioned as a part of a broader discussion on moral dilemmas and the complexity of making decisions that could impact humanity on a large scale.

💡Jeremy Boreing

Jeremy Boreing is the co-founder and CEO of The Daily Wire, a conservative news and opinion website. He is mentioned in the transcript as having commented on the discussion between Tucker Carlson and Joe Rogan. Boreing's perspective is contrasted with the views of others in the conversation, particularly around the idea of questioning established narratives and the importance of critical thinking.

💡Critical Thinking

Critical thinking is the objective analysis and evaluation of an issue in order to form a judgment. In the context of the transcript, critical thinking is discussed as a necessary skill for questioning and challenging established beliefs, motives, and narratives, particularly in relation to historical events and government actions.

Highlights

Tucker Carlson is a controversial figure who knows how to provoke reactions from people.

Carlson and Joe Rogan discuss the topic of nuclear weapons on a podcast.

The conversation touches on the historical use of atomic bombs and the moral implications.

Carlson expresses his view that defending the use of nuclear weapons on civilians is morally wrong.

The discussion suggests that the development of nuclear weapons was a strategic move to prevent Nazi Germany from having them first.

Jeremy Boreing, CEO of The Daily Wire, is mentioned as having a differing opinion on questioning the establishment.

Boreing argues that denying the moon landing or suggesting government conspiracy in 9/11 is a rejection of critical thinking.

The importance of questioning and being a critical thinker is emphasized, even when it challenges the status quo.

The conversation highlights the potential catastrophic consequences of nuclear war, as recognized by JFK and Ronald Reagan.

The current state of nuclear weapons and the risk of nuclear war is discussed, with a call for diplomacy and leadership.

The false alarm of an incoming missile in Hawaii is referenced as an example of the real threat of nuclear war.

The lack of adequate shelters and protection for the general public in the event of a nuclear attack is highlighted.

The speaker advocates for reducing the proliferation of nuclear weapons and working towards a world without the threat of nuclear war.

The speaker, presumably Tulsi Gabbard, offers a book to the first 50 people who engage with her on social media.

The urgency of the situation is emphasized, with a call to action for leaders to prevent a potential nuclear catastrophe.

The discussion concludes with a plea for global cooperation to reduce the risk of nuclear war for all of humanity.

Transcripts

00:00

this guy named Tucker Carlson which I

00:01

don't know if you know who he is or not

00:03

he's kind of a big deal a little bit

00:04

about him yeah and and he's a guy that

00:06

is another one of those guys part of the

00:08

community that people like him a lot and

00:11

he's also a guy that knows how to get

00:12

under people's skin okay whether he does

00:15

it intentionally or not he kind of knows

00:17

how to piss people off he's on the show

00:19

with this other guy that you like a lot

00:21

and you're friends with his name is Joe

00:22

Rogan Joseph Rogan so they're on this

00:24

podcast they're talking and Rob if you

00:27

can pull up this clip there's this topic

00:29

that comes up about nuclear you know I

00:32

don't know if you saw this Japan go go

00:34

Ahad and play this clip Rob go for it

00:36

well you could say the same about the

00:38

atomic bomb right yes you could and you

00:40

could say that we have to develop it

00:42

like Oppenheimer felt before the Nazis

00:45

did I love that how'd that

00:48

work how' that work well I love by the

00:52

way that people on my side I'll just say

00:55

I'll just admit it on the right you know

00:58

have spent the last 80 years defending

01:00

dropping nuclear weapons on civilians

01:03

like are you joking right that's just

01:05

like Prima fascia evil if you can't well

01:08

if we hadn't done that then this that

01:10

the other thing that was actually a

01:11

great savings to life no it's wrong to

01:13

drop nuclear weapons on people and if

01:15

you find yourself arguing that it's a

01:16

good thing to drop nuclear weapons on

01:18

people then you are evil like it's it's

01:20

not a it's not a tough one right it's

01:21

not a hard call for it's not a hard call

01:23

for me so with that in mind like why

01:26

would you want nuclear weapons it's like

01:28

just a Mindless childish sort of

01:30

intellectual exercise to justify like oh

01:33

no it's really good because someone else

01:34

will get how about no how about like

01:36

spending all of your effort to prevent

01:37

this from happening would you kill Baby

01:40

Hitler you know famously

01:42

right um so I don't know why we're

01:45

sitting back and allowing this to happen

01:47

if we really believe it will extinguish

01:49

the human race or enslave the human race

01:52

like how can that be

01:55

good is that the end of it Rob can you

01:57

pull up the TW so that's that's his

01:59

position right I want to hear your

02:00

position you live in Hawaii you know all

02:02

this other stuff so there's kind of

02:03

history behind it so uh uh what what

02:05

other reaction do you have to it Rob

02:07

tell me which one you got cuz there's a

02:08

a ton of them pick one of them just let

02:10

me know which one you got we'll pull it

02:11

up that was a great com for those of you

02:13

haven't heard that that conversation yet

02:15

it's it's fascinating they they cover a

02:17

lot of ground they cover a lot of ground

02:20

it is so entertaining probably the best

02:23

conversation of the Year those two being

02:24

in together I thought it was fascinating

02:26

Rob maybe pull up the Tweet of Jeremy

02:28

boring with Jeremy boring the the

02:30

co-founder founder of uh uh DA wire uh

02:33

he had the following to say about it he

02:36

says people who deny the moon landing or

02:39

suggest America's evil for the use of

02:41

atomic weapons against Imperial Japan or

02:44

who say that George Bush was behind 911

02:47

actually hate this country who maybe I

02:51

am stupid for asking this who is Jeremy

02:53

boring you being serious I'm being

02:55

serious okay he's the CE of daily wire

02:58

like Ben Shapiro daily Wire yeah that's

03:00

who he is so best friends with Candace

03:02

if you haven't so I've never met him I

03:05

don't no no by the Way's he's actually

03:07

very smart guy we' had on the podcast

03:08

but you know there's a civil war going

03:10

on a little bit right now where Tucker

03:12

Ben Shapiro Ben Shapiro is obviously

03:14

very different position what's your

03:15

position when it comes on to the nuclear

03:17

war response here by the way what's the

03:19

response are you showing that one okay

03:22

uh Jeremy is in the entire premise of

03:24

being a critical thinker to question

03:25

things some of the best podcasters and

03:27

influencers are do to question uh but no

03:29

one else is questioning being

03:31

anti-establishment is to question the

03:33

establishment's motive by the way he

03:35

responds to that Rob if you want to uh

03:37

put the other one then he puts it is not

03:40

critical thinking to say that America

03:42

never landed on the moon or that George

03:44

Bush orchestrated the 911 attacks it is

03:48

a rejection of critical thinking and

03:51

then I had one last respon to him which

03:53

was kind of an interesting one you want

03:54

to play this one Rob I understand your

03:56

point however I'm not a Christian

03:58

because I broke bread with Jesus I've

04:00

never met him face to face that requires

04:02

a level of faith I'm willing to risk

04:05

taken but it also takes Faith to believe

04:08

that we landed on the moon or someone's

04:09

involvement in the 9/11 attacks having

04:12

that level of unwavering faith in the US

04:15

government is what I'm not willing to

04:16

risk history does not favor Blind Faith

04:19

in any government yeah that was my

04:21

position great response where where do

04:23

you stand with

04:26

[Applause]

04:28

this you know I I think of uh you know

04:31

one of the famous speeches that

04:33

President John F Kennedy made when he

04:35

talked about his own experience of being

04:38

confronted with the possibility of a

04:41

nuclear war being launched and how he

04:45

excise the kind of leadership we should

04:47

have in our country where even as people

04:50

in his own cabinet uh were encouraging

04:53

him to take military action that he knew

04:56

could spark a nuclear war with the

04:58

Soviet Union he instead chose to go

05:01

behind their backs and conduct direct

05:04

negotiations with the Soviet Union to

05:06

walk back from the brink because those

05:08

two leaders recognized what Tucker was

05:11

pointing out that nuclear war leads to

05:13

one place the end of civilization the

05:16

destruction of living things people

05:20

Humanity uh on on this planet that is

05:22

where nuclear war leads and so you know

05:25

while while I and Tucker Carlson is a

05:27

good friend we've got we've had a lot of

05:29

amazing conversations I may say things a

05:31

little differently but what he's talking

05:33

about here really is how too many people

05:36

celebrate the use of nuclear weapons and

05:40

so carelessly both pundits on TV and

05:42

people in Washington and those who make

05:45

a lot of money from making these nuclear

05:47

weapons very carelessly talk about a

05:49

nuclear war being waged as though it can

05:52

be won and that that is the real issue

05:54

and Ronald Reagan famously said that a

05:56

nuclear war cannot be one and should

05:59

never be waged I'm paraphrasing it

06:01

slightly but that was his message and so

06:02

you've got a Democrat president and a

06:04

Republican president both who understood

06:07

during that cold war the very

06:10

very catastrophic consequences of a

06:14

nuclear war being waged so we look at

06:15

where we are today you've got the big

06:17

strategic nuclear weapons that can take

06:19

out entire cities or countries you've

06:21

got the tactical nuclear weapons that

06:23

they say Well they're smaller they can

06:25

be mobilized they can be moved and they

06:27

can be used in a very targeted way

06:30

as though it's just another kind of

06:31

mortar or bomb or missile that can be

06:34

launched the reality is is remains true

06:38

that was pointed out by JFK and Ronald

06:41

Reagan uh that our goal should be to

06:44

make it so we are never at a point where

06:47

the nuclear option uh is is being

06:51

considered uh this is where diplomacy

06:55

and Leadership is so necessary because

06:57

under this Administration we are the

06:59

precipice of nuclear war we are facing

07:02

the prospect of a a a nuclear

07:04

catastrophe whether intentionally or

07:08

unintentionally uh because conditions

07:10

have created such an environment more so

07:13

now than than anytime certainly since

07:16

the Cuban Missile Crisis uh this is a

07:19

reality those in Washington have bunkers

07:22

where they will be protected if not from

07:23

the blast itself then the nuclear

07:25

fallout and the nuclear winter that will

07:27

will follow the rest of us don't have

07:29

that luxury we saw this in Hawaii and

07:32

we've talked about this before I think

07:33

on your show about what happened when we

07:35

had that missile scare in Hawaii when on

07:38

a Saturday morning this alert went out

07:40

saying missile inbound to Hawaii take

07:42

shelter immediately this is not a drill

07:45

growing up in Hawaii who who are the

07:47

people closest to Hawaii that could

07:49

reach us North Korea nuclear capable

07:52

they have intercontinental ballistic

07:54

missiles that can carry nuclear warheads

07:56

so for those minutes on that early

07:59

Saturday morning it was just the

08:02

question of how many minutes do we have

08:04

until we are completely

08:07

obliterated while that turned out to be

08:09

a false alarm the reality of that threat

08:12

was very real it was something that I

08:13

had hoped would be a wakeup call for

08:15

leaders across the country because what

08:17

we saw was the message says take shelter

08:19

immediately this is not a drill and for

08:22

us in it for for the people in Hawaii

08:24

just like for those of us sitting here

08:26

if if if our phones were to go off right

08:28

this second

08:30

with that

08:31

message missile inbound right

08:34

here take shelter immediately where do

08:37

we go what do we do how many minutes do

08:39

we have where is there a bomb shelter

08:43

that will will protect us from the blast

08:45

that will give us clean water to drink

08:48

and air to breathe and food to sustain

08:50

ourselves for the time that would allow

08:52

us to survive this it doesn't exist so

08:56

they they spend trillions of dollars

08:58

investing in these nuclear weapons and

08:59

growing them which which you know this

09:02

is not like any other like it's not like

09:04

okay how how many rounds do I have left

09:07

in my

09:08

magazine one of these one of these

09:11

nuclear weapons today is already far

09:14

more powerful many times more powerful

09:16

than the nuclear weapons that were

09:17

dropped in Nagasaki and

09:20

Hiroshima um all it takes is one the

09:23

serious consequences of what we Face are

09:26

very real so what what do we do then we

09:28

should work work towards getting

09:30

ourselves in a place where we are not on

09:33

the brink of nuclear catastrophe we are

09:35

reducing the proliferation of nuclear

09:37

weapons in the world and working with

09:39

leaders of other countries even those

09:41

that we may not like or have adversarial

09:43

interests to try to to get across uh

09:47

what JFK was successful in doing and

09:49

saying hey if we care about the

09:51

existence of our own people and Humanity

09:53

as as as a whole it is in all of our

09:57

best interests to try to reduce this

09:58

risk of nuclear war for everyone out

10:01

there that's watching everyone out there

10:02

that's watching Tulsi is officially on

10:04

man Rob if you can show her man the

10:06

first 50 people that man with Tulsi we

10:10

will send you a copy of the book as well

10:13

signed we bought copies to get it out

10:15

there because we are so confident in her

10:17

message being out there we feel more

10:18

people need to hear from her so the

10:20

first 50 that man with Tulsi ask her

10:23

whatever questions you got and those 50

10:25

names we'll get we're going to send you

10:26

a copy just make sure you're in America

10:28

if you're anywhere we're else outside of

10:29

America we're not shipping to you if

10:31

you're not in America don't do the man

10:33

only in America will ship the copy to

10:34

your first 50 states thank you for that

10:36

so if you like this clip and you want to

10:38

watch another one click right here and

10:39

if you want to watch the entire podcast

10:42

click right here

10:46

[Music]

Rate This

5.0 / 5 (0 votes)

Etiquetas relacionadas
Nuclear DebateTucker CarlsonJoe RoganCold WarNuclear ArmsDiplomacyLeadershipCivilization RiskHawaii Missile AlertNuclear PolicyGlobal SecurityWar PreventionPeace AdvocacyMilitary StrategyHistorical ContextEthical DilemmaSurvival TacticsNuclear Deterrence
¿Necesitas un resumen en español?