MAGA Backpedals When They Find Out About Trump Killing A Bill That Would've Closed The Border

The Young Turks
31 Mar 202409:15

Summary

TLDRThe transcript captures a discussion on the importance of border control, with strong support expressed for a bill that would grant the president the authority to close border crossings at will, particularly during surges in migration. The conversation also touches on the participant's support for Donald Trump's stance on immigration, despite some confusion over his position on a specific bipartisan bill. The speaker emphasizes the need for legal immigration and expresses concerns about the current administration's approach to border management.

Takeaways

  • 🚨 The interviewee strongly believes in the importance of border control and is supportive of a bill that allows the president to close sections of the border at will during surges in migration.
  • 🤔 The interviewee questions why Donald Trump would urge Congress not to support a bipartisan bill that would give the president authority over border closures.
  • 💪 The interviewee expresses full support for Trump's position on border control despite the president's opposition to the mentioned bipartisan bill.
  • 🏛️ The interviewee acknowledges that the issue is complex and refrains from commenting on Trump's strategy, but maintains their stance on the necessity of border control.
  • 🌍 The interviewee is concerned about the current administration's approach to border protection and believes that Trump could implement effective policies if he were to return to office.
  • 📈 The interviewee views the influx of immigrants as a threat to national sovereignty and the social fabric of the country.
  • 🔒 The interviewee advocates for legal immigration and expresses concern about the lack of background checks and tracking for those entering the country illegally.
  • 🎉 The interviewee associates the excitement and support for Trump with his perceived honesty and commitment to addressing border issues.
  • 🔄 The interviewee suggests that the Democrats may be motivated by a desire to gain additional congressional seats through increased immigrant populations.
  • 🚫 The interviewee is critical of the recent immigration bill, believing it does not adequately address the issue of illegal immigration and border security.

Q & A

  • What is the speaker's stance on border control?

    -The speaker strongly supports border control and believes it is very important. They advocate for the president to have the authority to close sections of the border at will, especially during a surge in migration.

  • How does the speaker feel about the bipartisan bill that would give the president authority to close the border?

    -The speaker is in favor of such a bill. They believe that other countries have border control and the United States should have it too. They support giving the president the power to close border crossings to manage migration surges.

  • What was the speaker's reaction to Donald Trump's urging against the bipartisan bill?

    -The speaker seems to be confused but still supportive of Trump. They believe that Trump must have had a better plan in mind and trusts that he can handle border issues effectively.

  • What does the speaker think about the current administration's approach to border control?

    -The speaker is critical of the current administration, stating that they believe President Biden is protecting illegal immigrants and that his actions are not appropriate for his position.

  • How does the speaker feel about the recent immigration bill in Congress?

    -The speaker is against the recent immigration bill, believing it does not support border security. They mention that the bill would codify the entry of 5,000 illegal aliens a day, which they see as a problem.

  • What is the speaker's view on the impact of immigration on the United States?

    -The speaker is concerned about the impact of immigration, particularly illegal immigration. They believe it leads to crime and burdens the country with the cost of supporting immigrants who have not entered legally.

  • What does the speaker suggest as a solution to the issue of illegal immigration?

    -The speaker advocates for stronger measures to stop the 'flood' of migrants. They mention the construction of a wall as a solution and suggest that states should have the power to enforce their own immigration policies.

  • How does the speaker feel about the historical context of immigration in the United States?

    -The speaker acknowledges the history of the United States as a nation of immigrants but differentiates between past immigration and the current situation, emphasizing the need for legal entry and self-sufficiency upon arrival.

  • What is the speaker's opinion on the potential political motivations behind immigration policies?

    -The speaker suggests that the Democratic party may be motivated by a desire to gain more votes and congressional seats through increased immigration, implying that they believe this is not in the best interest of the country.

  • How does the speaker view the idea of physically preventing border crossings?

    -The speaker entertains extreme ideas such as using alligators or snakes to deter border crossings. However, they also express a desire for a more controlled and legal immigration process, suggesting a conflict between their emotions and their understanding of what is morally and legally acceptable.

  • What does the speaker believe should be the criteria for immigration?

    -The speaker believes that immigrants should enter the country legally, providing necessary documentation and going through proper channels. They emphasize the importance of knowing who is entering the country and supporting themselves without relying on government assistance.

Outlines

00:00

🛃 Border Control Advocacy

The speaker expresses strong support for stringent border control measures, including the idea of giving the president the authority to close sections of the border at will. They mention a bipartisan bill in Congress that would have granted such power but were surprised that Donald Trump urged against its support. The speaker trusts Trump's intentions and believes in the importance of legal immigration, expressing concern about the current administration's approach to border management.

05:00

🗳️ Political Impact of Immigration

The speaker discusses the political implications of immigration, suggesting that the Democratic party may be motivated by the potential for additional votes and congressional seats due to the influx of immigrants. They argue that there should be a focus on legal immigration and express skepticism about the current policies, citing concerns about the potential for crime and the burden on American citizens. The speaker also touches on the historical context of immigration in the United States and the need for a more selective and regulated approach to newcomers.

Mindmap

Keywords

💡Border Control

Border control refers to the management and regulation of the movement of people, goods, and vehicles into and out of a country. In the context of the video, it emphasizes the importance of having strict policies and measures in place to monitor and manage immigration, particularly to prevent illegal entry. The speaker supports the idea of the president having the authority to close sections of the border when necessary, highlighting the significance of border control for national security and sovereignty.

💡Immigration Bill

An immigration bill is a proposed law that addresses various aspects of immigration policy, such as border security, legal pathways for entry, and the status of undocumented immigrants. In the video, the speaker discusses a specific bipartisan bill in Congress that would grant the president authority over border closures. The speaker also mentions another recent immigration bill that they believe does not effectively address border security, suggesting a conflict between different legislative approaches to immigration.

💡Donald Trump

Donald Trump, mentioned in the video, is a former President of the United States. The speaker references Trump's stance on immigration and border control, noting his past actions to urge Congress not to support certain immigration bills. This keyword is significant as it highlights the speaker's alignment with Trump's policies and their anticipation of future actions that might align with their own views on border control and immigration.

💡Surge in Migration

A surge in migration refers to a sudden, significant increase in the number of people moving from one place to another, often across borders. In the context of the video, the speaker is concerned about such a surge leading to uncontrolled influx of immigrants, which they believe could strain resources and pose security risks. The speaker advocates for measures to manage and mitigate the impact of such surges, including the closure of border crossings when necessary.

💡Legal Immigration

Legal immigration refers to the process by which individuals enter and reside in a country in accordance with its laws and regulations. The speaker in the video emphasizes the importance of individuals entering the country legally, suggesting that this ensures that immigrants are properly vetted and that they contribute positively to society. The speaker contrasts legal immigration with the perceived chaos and risks associated with illegal immigration.

💡National Sovereignty

National sovereignty is the principle that a state has the ultimate authority and power to govern itself without interference from external sources. In the video, the speaker connects border control and immigration policies to the concept of national sovereignty, arguing that strong borders are essential to maintaining a country's independence and control over its affairs. The speaker believes that unchecked migration can undermine this sovereignty, hence their support for strict border control measures.

💡Congressional Action

Congressional action refers to the process by which the United States Congress debates, votes on, and passes legislation. In the context of the video, the speaker expresses frustration with Congress's handling of immigration bills, particularly when it comes to granting the president authority over border closures. The speaker perceives a lack of decisive action or alignment with their preferred policies, leading to a sense of disillusionment with the legislative process.

💡Bipartisanship

Bipartisanship refers to the cooperation and collaboration between members of different political parties to achieve common goals. In the video, the speaker mentions a bipartisan bill in Congress related to border control, indicating that they value the idea of working across party lines to address important issues. However, the speaker also expresses skepticism about the effectiveness of such bipartisan efforts, particularly when they do not align with their own views on immigration policy.

💡Track and Trace

Track and trace refers to the ability to monitor and follow the movement of people or objects through a system or across different points. In the context of the video, the speaker expresses concern about the inability to track and trace immigrants who enter the country illegally, which they believe poses security risks and makes it difficult to manage the population effectively. The speaker advocates for stricter border control measures to improve the track and trace capabilities of the country.

💡Build the Wall

The phrase 'Build the Wall' refers to a campaign promise and policy advocacy by Donald Trump during his presidency, aimed at constructing a physical barrier along the U.S.-Mexico border to prevent illegal immigration and drug trafficking. In the video, the speaker's mention of 'Build that Wall' indicates their support for such a physical barrier as a solution to the perceived problems of uncontrolled migration and its impact on the country.

💡Illegal Aliens

The term 'illegal aliens' is a controversial and politically charged phrase used to describe individuals who are in a country without legal immigration status. In the video, the speaker uses this term to express concern about the impact of undocumented immigrants on the country, particularly in terms of crime, resource allocation, and the political landscape. The use of this term reflects the speaker's negative view of illegal immigration and their support for stricter enforcement measures.

Highlights

Border control is considered a crucial issue, with support for a bill allowing the president to close sections of the border at will.

The speaker expresses full support for a bill that would grant the president authority over border closures in response to high migration levels.

The speaker questions why other countries have border control and the United States does not.

The speaker was supportive of Donald Trump and his policies, even though Trump urged Congress not to support a bipartisan bill for border control.

The speaker believes that Trump may have a better plan for border control than just shutting the border down.

The speaker is adamant about wanting the border closed and legal immigration processes followed.

The speaker expresses concern about the inability to track immigrants and the potential security risks associated with open borders.

The speaker criticizes the current administration for protecting undocumented immigrants and believes Trump can improve the situation.

The speaker is against the recent immigration bill and believes it does not provide adequate border security.

The speaker suggests that the Democratic party may be encouraging illegal immigration for political gains, such as additional congressional seats.

The speaker is in favor of legal immigration and against the current influx of undocumented immigrants.

The speaker expresses a desire for stronger measures to prevent illegal border crossings, even suggesting extreme measures like using force.

The speaker believes that immigrants should be required to provide documentation and go through proper channels to enter the country legally.

The speaker compares the current situation to ancient Rome, where letting in too many people eventually led to the empire's downfall.

The speaker values the principles of self-reliance and contribution to society that historical immigrants embodied, as opposed to reliance on government support.

Transcripts

00:00

is the Border an important issue for you

00:01

yes it is very important goad would you

00:04

be supportive of a bill that gave the

00:07

president the authority to close

00:09

sections of the border at his will at

00:11

any time uh if if the migration got too

00:14

high yes I close it all I mean that's

00:17

what I'm saying yes I'm I'm going

00:19

support it 100% there has to be border

00:21

control other countries have it why

00:24

don't we so why were you supportive then

00:26

of Donald Trump when he urged members of

00:28

Congress to vote against such a

00:31

bipartisan Bill yes yes but if you if

00:34

you want that why wouldn't Trump want

00:37

that is what I'm saying well okay wait

00:39

Trump maybe Trump wants to close the

00:42

bill correct there is a bipartisan Bill

00:45

in Congress that would have given the

00:48

president authority to close the border

00:50

or different border crossings Trump

00:52

wanted people to vote against it in

00:54

Congress and both Republicans and

00:56

Democrats were dismayed at that do you

00:58

still support Trump's position on that

01:00

is what I'm asking I just my position

01:03

would be and I don't get into the whole

01:06

thing I wanted closed I want areas open

01:10

if they're going to do it legal do it

01:11

legal I don't care if it's Democrat

01:13

Republican I want the Border closed and

01:15

people come in like we normal come in

01:18

legal one of the issues that I can't

01:21

hard hardly bear to even think about is

01:23

is the Border I know anything else is

01:26

going to be easy but this is not going

01:28

to be easy there's too many of them in

01:30

here and we don't know where they are or

01:33

what they look like or they're not

01:35

there's no track we can't track

01:38

them and Biden right now is protecting

01:41

them so he's got no business being where

01:45

he is and Trump will fix that we just

01:48

got to be sure that they don't cheat and

01:51

make it not possible for Trump to get in

01:54

there do you think they cheated last

01:55

time I know they did this was the same

01:59

kind of people this much that was in

02:02

here in 20 was the same buildup and the

02:08

same exciting EXC ex exciting excitement

02:13

that you felt tonight he's honest and he

02:16

wants what we want we want to close the

02:19

borders and 11,000 immigrants came in

02:22

and so the border is an important issue

02:24

to you would you support a Bill in

02:26

Congress that gave the president the

02:27

authority to close the border at his whm

02:30

if there's a surge in immigrants to say

02:31

we're going to close that border

02:32

crossing and the president has the

02:34

authority to do

02:35

that sure CU that that bill was just in

02:39

Congress and Donald Trump urged many

02:41

members of Congress not to support such

02:43

a bill how what would you say to Donald

02:45

Trump about

02:46

that I don't

02:48

know I'm sure he's got a good a better

02:51

plan than just shutting the Border I

02:53

don't

02:54

know I don't know what I would do he

02:57

kept the borders safe so the borders are

02:59

important oh oh yeah oh yeah borders

03:02

yeah would you like the president to

03:03

have the power to close um different

03:06

border crossing uh at at his whim to

03:09

close it whenever he wanted yes yes so

03:12

there was a Bill in Congress recently

03:14

that Donald Trump had people uh in in

03:17

congress not support it was a bipartisan

03:20

Bill to give the president the authority

03:22

to close different border crossings are

03:24

you upset with Trump that he urged them

03:25

not to pass that bill

03:28

um no because I know I know that he um

03:33

can handle he's handled it before and I

03:36

know that once he gets back into the

03:39

administration he can um bring back the

03:41

policies that he did have and um

03:44

hopefully get control over the Border

03:46

again so and what about immigration is

03:48

that an important issue for you

03:50

absolutely because the border is being

03:52

flooded right now so we actually do need

03:56

to cut that back a little bit so that we

03:58

can take care of the people people that

04:00

are here in this country right now if

04:02

there was a bipartisan Bill in Congress

04:04

that did cut that that also gave the

04:06

president the power to shut down

04:09

specific border crossings at their whim

04:12

what would would you support

04:14

that anything that stops this flood of

04:18

migrants right now is just too much

04:21

because the US Congress just had a bill

04:22

an immigration Bill and Donald Trump

04:24

who's not in office now is trying to

04:26

urge members of his party not to support

04:29

it even though it did what I just said

04:31

what do you think about that and would

04:32

you would you like to tell Trump to

04:34

actually support it cuz that's what you

04:36

were saying you wanted all I have to say

04:38

is Build That Wall that's all I have to

04:41

say about that is the Border an

04:43

important issue for you it's the most

04:44

important issue the most our sovereignty

04:46

of our country is at stake yes there was

04:48

a Bill in Congress that gave the

04:50

president power to shut off different

04:52

border crossings as the surges were

04:54

happening and close them entirely would

04:56

you be supportive of that Congress is

04:58

never going to do that well Congress

05:00

just had a bill that would have given

05:01

the president power for that no the

05:03

Congress had a bill that's codified

05:05

5,000 illegal aliens a day that's not

05:08

border security so there's no middle

05:11

ground then it's either All or Nothing

05:12

in Your op or Nothing in Your in your

05:15

tape I believe the Democrats want 10

05:18

million more votes and they'll get them

05:20

at the next census with all these

05:22

illegal aliens coming across that's what

05:24

I believe they want Congressional House

05:25

Seats but these aren't people that are

05:27

getting citizenship right I mean they're

05:29

not Grant but eventually they probably

05:31

will

05:33

and I just think the extra congressional

05:35

seats for the Democrats is what they're

05:37

after is the Border an important issue

05:40

to you very much so very much so would

05:42

you be supportive of a bill that gave

05:45

the president the authority to close

05:47

different border crossings at will when

05:49

the surge got too high oh yes oh yes so

05:53

Donald Trump just urged people in his

05:55

own party in Congress to oppose such a

05:58

bill how did you feel about that thank

06:00

you uh I can't comment on that I'm I'm

06:03

not sure you know I'm I'm not going to

06:05

comment on something I don't don't know

06:07

about is the Border an important issue

06:09

for you oh 110% I think there's been a

06:11

lot of crime driven from the border and

06:14

the infant tractor from there and I

06:16

don't think uh I don't think that it's

06:17

helping the American people and that's

06:19

what I care about in in my eyes is the

06:21

Americans we're giving money to

06:23

immigrants that are coming over here for

06:25

a free $10,000 would you support a bill

06:27

that gave the president the authority to

06:29

close border crossings at his or her

06:32

whim Whenever there was a surge in

06:34

migration oh 110% so were you at When

06:37

Donald Trump went and told people in

06:39

Congress that they shouldn't support a

06:41

bill that had that as a provision that

06:43

was the most recent immigration bill I I

06:46

don't support it I think that he should

06:47

have the authority to do such um but

06:50

there's a lot of a lot of legality

06:52

behind that and I understand Donald

06:54

Trump is trying to protect his back and

06:56

and what happens with him is immigration

06:57

an important issue to you it is now and

07:01

and why is that why do you say it like

07:02

that oh those couple of million that

07:04

came in

07:05

illegally and what do you uh what what

07:08

is it about them and what what is it

07:10

about immigration that gives you Paws I

07:13

would just prefer that the people that

07:14

come into our country do it legally we

07:17

don't know anything about them uh if I

07:20

go to another country I have to provide

07:22

all kinds of things including a birth

07:25

certificate when we were talking earlier

07:27

when you said you would support that

07:29

bill he urged members of Congress to not

07:31

support such a bill what would you say

07:32

to Trump about that you pretty much have

07:34

to do what Texas do and you have to make

07:35

make it a crime to force it by the

07:37

states because because what happens is

07:39

when different parties come in they

07:40

don't want to force certain things you

07:42

know so you need to have that each state

07:44

have make it legal but it's Texas is a

07:46

state and it's a federal law so you

07:47

still support Texas overriding the US

07:50

government hell yeah yeah it's just it's

07:53

just like maybe it's not legal like

07:55

legally like you know right but morally

07:57

like it's what people want like a lot

08:00

more people think they if you could just

08:02

literally just shoot people at the B

08:04

like they wouldn't come they wouldn't

08:05

come anymore would you put alligators

08:07

out there or or snakes in the water

08:09

would we want to be would we want to be

08:10

a country that shot people who came

08:12

across the border though yeah I mean

08:15

because you like you can't just let

08:16

everyone overrun the country because

08:18

you're going to make it so the whole the

08:20

whole boat crashes you know tips over

08:22

and sinks you want to only let in

08:24

certain amount and you want to marry you

08:25

don't want and you want to scream too

08:27

you don't want just people to walk in by

08:28

foot you want them come by by airplanes

08:30

you want them come by trains you you you

08:32

know you want to screen them you don't

08:33

know who they are before they come in

08:35

you know so once in a while if you shot

08:37

some you think it would scare people

08:39

from coming and and like why do why does

08:41

people think that we have to be the

08:42

country that lets everyone in you know

08:45

like like everyone's under this like

08:46

brainwashing that you have to let

08:47

everyone in or or you're a mean person

08:49

or something well we were a country of

08:50

immigrants right I mean you could you

08:52

could go back to like ancient Rome the

08:53

same thing they let in too many like

08:55

people from around their their empire

08:56

I'm just talking about our country was

08:58

founded on principles about you know

09:00

give us you're tired you're poor you're

09:02

hungry but but we but we didn't have

09:04

they they weren't getting food stamps

09:06

they weren't getting supported by the

09:07

government when they came here they had

09:08

they were they were they were on their

09:09

own when they came here if people if

09:11

they did that now people would like

09:12

respect them more you know if they did

09:14

that

Rate This

5.0 / 5 (0 votes)

العلامات ذات الصلة
BorderControlImmigrationPolicyPoliticalDebatePresidentialPowerCongressionalActionsPublicOpinionTrumpAdministrationBipartisanshipNationalSecuritySovereignty
هل تحتاج إلى ملخص باللغة العربية؟