❌ THE FUNDAMENTAL PROBLEM WITH AI ART
TLDRThe video discusses the impact of AI-generated art on the artistic community, highlighting the rapid improvement in AI art quality and the ethical concerns surrounding its training data. The creator argues that AI art should be used as a tool rather than a replacement for human artists, emphasizing the unique human ability to innovate and express individuality in art. The video also addresses common arguments for and against AI art and offers guidelines for ethical engagement with AI in the art world.
Takeaways
- 🎨 AI art is created using prompt-based image generators like Mid-journey, Lensa AI, and Stable Diffusion.
- 🚀 AI art technology has improved exponentially, raising concerns among artists due to its potential impact on the art community.
- 🌐 AI is trained on massive databases, many of which include images and text scraped without permission from artists worldwide.
- 🤖 The core issue with AI art is the lack of ethical training data, as it often uses artwork without artists' consent or compensation.
- 🚫 The current implementation of AI art and its profit-driven model is seen as morally wrong and potentially damaging to the art industry.
- 👩🎨 Artists should not give up on their craft due to AI art; art is about personal growth and expression, not just technical skill.
- 💡 AI can be a tool in an artist's workflow, but it should not replace the human element of creativity and innovation.
- 🔄 AI art can be seen as similar to cloning technology, which is regulated due to potential negative consequences for humanity.
- 🎭 The value of AI-generated art is questioned when the creator is not a human, and there are concerns about the authenticity and ownership of such art.
- 📈 AI should be embraced as a tool but regulated to prevent potential harm; just because it's possible doesn't mean it should be used without boundaries.
- 🌟 The future of AI in art could be bright if it's retrained with ethically sourced data and used to enhance, not replace, human artistic creation.
Q & A
What is AI Art and how has it been developed?
-AI Art refers to art created by prompt-based image generators such as mid-journey, lensa AI, and stable diffusion. It has been developed through extensive training involving billions of examples of text and image data, often sourced from the internet without permission from artists.
Why is the art community concerned about AI Art?
-The art community is concerned because AI Art can be created by anyone, regardless of artistic skill, by simply inputting a few words. This ease of creation, coupled with the fact that AI Art is often generated from artwork used without artists' consent, raises ethical and copyright issues.
How does the training of AI in art generation impact its quality?
-The quality of AI-generated art is directly related to the vast amount of data used for training. The more examples the AI is trained on, the better it becomes at generating high-quality images. However, the source of this data and the lack of artist consent is a significant ethical problem.
What is the speaker's stance on AI Art technology?
-The speaker is not against the technology itself but is critical of how it has been implemented. They believe that the use of AI Art should be heavily regulated and that it should be retrained using only voluntary submissions and public domain images to address ethical concerns.
How does AI Art affect the motivation of artists?
-Some artists may feel discouraged and consider giving up on art because AI Art can produce high-quality images that seem beyond their capabilities. However, the speaker argues that the pursuit of art is about personal growth and expression, not competition with others.
What are the potential future applications of AI Art?
-The speaker believes that AI Art has the potential to be a valuable tool in speeding up certain parts of the artistic workflow and generating ideas for brainstorming. However, it should be used as a tool, not as a replacement for human creativity.
How does the speaker differentiate between AI and human art creation?
-The speaker emphasizes that AI creates art based on a combination of a prompt, resulting image, and a seed number, whereas humans create art with consciousness, emotion, and the ability to innovate and develop new styles. AI is limited to what it has been trained on and cannot innovate in the same way.
What are the ethical concerns regarding AI Art?
-The ethical concerns include the unauthorized use of artists' work for training AI, the potential devaluation of human art, and the issue of people claiming AI-generated art as their own. The speaker suggests that AI Art should be retrained with ethically sourced data and its use in the art industry should be regulated.
What guidelines does the speaker suggest for artists dealing with AI Art?
-The speaker suggests that AI-generated images should be clearly labeled as such, not used as the final product on portfolio websites or in professional settings, and that artists should wait until AI is retrained on ethically sourced data before fully embracing it as a tool.
What is the speaker's prediction for the future of AI and the art industry?
-The speaker predicts that with proper regulation and ethical training, AI can become a significant tool for artists, helping to speed up workflows and generate new ideas. They envision a future where artists train their own AI models using their content, thus pushing art forward rather than stagnating it.
How does the speaker view the role of AI in relation to human creativity?
-The speaker views AI as a tool to enhance human creativity rather than replace it. They believe that artists should be supported by increasingly advanced tools that unlock their full potential, and that the art industry will continue to grow and evolve with new technologies and careers emerging in the future.
Outlines
🎨 The Concerns with AI Arts
The video begins by addressing the growing concerns within the art community about AI Arts. The creator expresses disbelief in the loss of motivation among artists due to AI's advancements. The video aims to discuss the serious issues with AI Arts, the creator's stance, and predictions for the future. AI Arts are defined as art created by prompt-based image generators like Mid-journey, Lensa AI, and Stable Diffusion. The art community's discontent is highlighted by the display of AI-generated art on platforms like ArtStation. The core issue lies in how AIs were trained, using vast amounts of data scraped from the internet without artists' consent or compensation, leading to ethical concerns.
🚫 Ethical and Moral Implications of AI Art
The second paragraph delves into the ethical and moral implications of AI Art. The creator argues that the current state of AI Art is akin to using stolen car parts, as the training data was obtained unethically. The creator also addresses common arguments for and against AI Art. These include the notion that AI Art is too good and discourages artists from pursuing their craft, the fear that AI will take over art jobs, and the comparison between AI's learning process and human artists'. The creator emphasizes that AI cannot innovate or create new styles like humans and that art should continue to evolve with human consciousness and emotions.
🤖 The Future of AI in Art and Recommendations
The final paragraph discusses the potential future of AI in the art industry and offers recommendations for artists. The creator sees AI as a tool to speed up workflows and generate ideas, but cautions against using AI as the final product. The video suggests guidelines for dealing with AI Art, including proper disclosure of AI involvement and not using AI-generated images as portfolio pieces. The creator calls for a halt in using current AI image generators until they are retrained with ethically sourced data. The video ends with a call to action for the art community to educate others about the potential dangers of AI Art and to work together for a future where artists are supported by technology rather than replaced by it.
Mindmap
Keywords
💡AI Arts
💡Motivation
💡Training Data
💡Art Community
💡Innovation
💡Ethical Concerns
💡Artistic Expression
💡Workflow
💡Regulation
💡Future of Art
💡Artistic Value
Highlights
AI Arts have been improving exponentially, raising concerns in the art community.
AI art is created using prompt-based image generators like mid-journey, lensa AI, and stable diffusion.
The art community is unhappy with AI art displays, as they see it as a threat to traditional art.
AI learns from vast databases, such as The Lion 5B database, which contains 5.8 billion text and image data scraped from the internet.
AI was trained on art taken without artists' permission, leading to ethical concerns about AI art.
The speaker is not against AI technology but is against the current implementation and its potential negative impact on artists.
AI art could be a tool in artists' workflows if trained ethically, but currently, it's being used as a final product.
Art is about human connection and expression, which AI cannot replicate.
AI can only generate images based on its training data and cannot innovate or create new styles.
The value of art is questioned when AI-generated images are claimed as one's own.
AI should be regulated in the art industry, similar to how cloning and genetic engineering are controlled.
AI art should be used as a brainstorming tool, not as the final result.
The speaker suggests that AI art should be retrained with ethically sourced data before being widely accepted.
Artists should embrace AI as a tool to enhance their work, not replace them.
The future of art should involve artists training AI with their own content.
The art industry will continue to grow, and new careers will emerge in the future.
Artists should unite to educate others about the potential dangers of unregulated AI in art.