Midjourney VS Leonardo: Full REVIEW

AI Samson
21 Mar 202312:38

TLDRThis video compares two AI art generation tools, mid-journey and Leonardo, evaluating their user experience, interface, features, pricing, and performance across various prompts. It highlights the unique algorithms and model customization options of Leonardo, as well as the coherent and aesthetic outputs of mid-journey. The video concludes that both platforms have their strengths and are suitable for different use cases, with Leonardo offering more control and features, while mid-journey provides quick, aesthetic results.

Takeaways

  • 🎨 Mid-journey and Leonardo are two AI art generation tools with different approaches to user interface and experience.
  • 🛠️ Mid-journey operates through Discord, offering a chat-based interface, while Leonardo has its own visual interface.
  • 💡 Leonardo is built on stable diffusion and provides a well-rounded UI for it, whereas Mid-journey uses its own unique algorithm.
  • 🌐 Accessing Mid-journey is through Discord, which has its benefits and limitations, while Leonardo offers a standalone visual interface.
  • 🔍 Leonardo allows users to change parameters such as image count, dimensions, and guidance scale easily within its interface.
  • 🎭 Both platforms offer the ability to run different algorithms, with Mid-journey providing various iterations of its own algorithm and Leonardo offering a range of models including the option to create custom models.
  • 🚀 Leonardo stands out with additional features like background removal and prompt generation tools, which are not available in Mid-journey.
  • 📈 Leonardo currently offers a free platform with a daily credit system, while Mid-journey has a tiered pricing structure.
  • 🖼️ When comparing outputs, Mid-journey tends to produce more coherent and aesthetically pleasing images, whereas Leonardo offers more control and the ability to fine-tune results.
  • 🤖 Negative prompts are often necessary to improve images in Leonardo, while Mid-journey is more forgiving and can produce beautiful results with less fine-tuning.
  • 📚 Both AI art tools have their strengths and are suitable for different use cases; Mid-journey is great for quick, aesthetic outputs, while Leonardo offers more control and advanced features.

Q & A

  • What are the two AI art generation tools being compared in the video?

    -The two AI art generation tools being compared are Mid-Journey and Leonardo.

  • What is the primary difference between how Mid-Journey and Leonardo are accessed?

    -Mid-Journey is accessed via Discord, within a chat application, while Leonardo has its own visual interface separate from Discord.

  • How does the user interface of Leonardo differ from that of Mid-Journey?

    -Leonardo's interface is more visual and intuitive, allowing users to easily change parameters such as the number of images, dimensions, and guidance scale. In contrast, Mid-Journey requires users to type in settings and commands within the chat interface.

  • What unique feature does Leonardo offer in terms of algorithm selection?

    -Leonardo offers the ability to use different models, including a Leonardo diffusion model for high contrast images and specific models like origami paper art style or pixel art. It also allows users to create their own fine-tuned models by uploading a set of images.

  • How does Mid-Journey handle algorithm changes and what are the available options?

    -In Mid-Journey, users can change the algorithm within the settings, with options including various iterations of the MJ algorithm, an anime-specific algorithm, and older algorithms focused on photorealistic images.

  • What are some additional features that Leonardo offers for image manipulation?

    -Leonardo provides features like instant background removal for images and a prompt generation tool to help build more complete prompts. It also allows concurrent jobs, which can speed up the creative process.

  • How does the pricing structure of Mid-Journey compare to Leonardo's credit system?

    -Mid-Journey has three pricing tiers: $10, $30, and $60 per month, with the $30 and $60 plans offering unlimited generations. Leonardo currently offers a free platform with 250 credits per day, and a premium option is expected to be introduced in the future.

  • What is the main advantage of using Mid-Journey for quick aesthetic results?

    -Mid-Journey is beneficial for quick aesthetic results as it creates more coherent and consistent images without requiring much fine-tuning. It's easier to use for those who want immediate, visually pleasing outputs.

  • In what situations might a user prefer to use Leonardo over Mid-Journey?

    -A user might prefer Leonardo when seeking more control over the output, wanting to refine and improve the generated images, or needing to use additional features like outpainting and model training. Leonardo is ideal for users who are willing to invest time in crafting their prompts and have specific vision in mind.

  • How do the outputs of Mid-Journey and Leonardo differ in terms of detail and coherence?

    -Mid-Journey tends to produce more detailed and coherent images that closely follow the style prompts, whereas Leonardo might require more specific and intentional prompt crafting to achieve similar results. However, Leonardo offers a wider set of tools and capabilities for users who want more control over their creations.

  • What is the narrator's final verdict on the use of both AI art tools?

    -The narrator believes that both Mid-Journey and Leonardo are extremely capable tools, each with their own strengths, and suitable for different use cases. They suggest that there is a place for both platforms in any artist's workload and that they are excited to create more with them.

Outlines

00:00

🎨 Introduction to AI Art Tools: Mid-Journey and Leonardo

The video begins by welcoming AI art enthusiasts and tech aficionados to explore two AI art generation tools: Mid-Journey and Leonardo. The host intends to compare these platforms based on various factors such as user experience, interface, features, pricing, and their performance when given the same prompts. The goal is to help viewers understand the strengths and weaknesses of each tool and determine which one suits their projects best. Notably, Leonardo is built on stable diffusion, an open-source AI generator, while Mid-Journey is based on a unique algorithm and accessed via Discord, which brings both benefits and limitations.

05:01

💻 Interface and Accessibility Comparison

This paragraph discusses the differences in how users access and interact with Mid-Journey and Leonardo. Mid-Journey operates through Discord, presenting a chat-based interface that can be limiting for feature expansion. In contrast, Leonardo has its own visual interface, allowing for easier adjustments of parameters such as image count, dimensions, and guidance scale. Additionally, Leonardo's platform is more coherent as all creations and modifications stay within the same environment, unlike Mid-Journey, which requires a separate app to view work. The paragraph also touches on the algorithms and models available on each platform, highlighting Leonardo's ability to run different algorithms and even create custom models, a feature not currently offered by Mid-Journey.

10:04

🚀 Feature Set and Performance

The host delves into the additional features and capabilities of Leonardo, such as the instant background removal for images and the prompt generation tool. These features enhance the user experience and streamline the creative process. In terms of performance, Leonardo allows for concurrent jobs, which can significantly speed up workflow, especially for users with the free plan that offers 250 credits per day. On the other hand, Mid-Journey has a tiered pricing structure with different plans offering varying levels of concurrency and unlimited generations. The paragraph concludes with a brief mention of the generation speed and detail level, noting that while Leonardo may take longer at higher resolutions, it maintains a relatively similar output quality to Mid-Journey.

🖌️ Prompt Comparison and Artistic Outcomes

The video script presents a detailed comparison of the artistic outputs from Mid-Journey and Leonardo when given the same prompts. The host examines various scenarios, such as a female working on a laptop atop a mountain, a mystical landscape in a Studio Ghibli style, and portraits. The comparison reveals that while Mid-Journey tends to produce more coherent and detailed images, Leonardo offers a different aesthetic with striking contrasts and the potential for more control over the final product. The paragraph emphasizes the importance of crafting prompts differently for each platform to achieve the best results and mentions the possibility of refining images in Leonardo, which is not as straightforward in Mid-Journey. The host also notes the community-generated models in Leonardo and the potential for outpainting, a feature not available in Mid-Journey.

📸 Final Thoughts on AI Art Tools

In the concluding paragraph, the host reflects on the key differences between Leonardo and Mid-Journey. With Leonardo, users need to be more specific and intentional with their prompts, which can yield a wider range of creative possibilities and greater control over the final image. In contrast, Mid-Journey is praised for its quick, aesthetic outputs that require less effort to craft but offer less control over the refinement process. The host suggests that both tools have their place in an artist's toolkit, depending on the desired outcome and level of control needed. The video ends with a call to action for viewers to share their thoughts on these AI art tools and to look forward to more explorations in the future.

Mindmap

Keywords

💡AI art generation tools

AI art generation tools refer to software platforms that utilize artificial intelligence algorithms to create visual art. In the context of the video, these tools are used to generate images based on user input, such as prompts or descriptions. The video compares two specific tools, mid-journey and Leonardo, which are designed to produce different styles and qualities of AI-generated art.

💡User interface

User interface, or UI, refers to the space where interactions between users and a digital device occur, including the layout, visual design, and controls. In the video, the comparison of mid-journey and Leonardo highlights the differences in their UIs, with mid-journey being accessible through Discord and Leonardo having its own visual interface.

💡Stable diffusion

Stable diffusion is an open-source AI image generator that forms the foundation for some AI art tools. It uses machine learning to generate images from textual descriptions. In the video, Leonardo is mentioned as being built on top of stable diffusion, which contributes to its well-rounded user interface and capabilities.

💡Discord

Discord is a communication platform originally designed for gamers but has since expanded to various communities. In the context of the video, mid-journey is accessed via Discord, meaning users interact with the AI art tool through the chat application's interface. This method of access comes with its own set of advantages and disadvantages.

💡Algorithms

Algorithms in the context of AI art generation refer to the underlying sets of rules and computations that the AI uses to create images. Different algorithms can produce different styles or qualities of images. The video discusses the ability of mid-journey and Leonardo to run various algorithms, with mid-journey offering multiple iterations of its own algorithm and Leonardo providing a range of models, including the option to create custom models.

💡Community models

Community models refer to AI models that are created or refined by the collective efforts of a community of users. These models can be shared and used by others, contributing to a collaborative and dynamic ecosystem of AI art generation. In the video, it is mentioned that Leonardo allows users to explore and utilize community-created models, enhancing the tool's versatility and capabilities.

💡Background removal

Background removal is a feature that allows users to eliminate the background of an image, often used for creating transparent backgrounds for icons, game assets, or stickers. The video mentions that Leonardo has a built-in feature for instantly removing backgrounds, which can be a time-saving tool for certain projects.

💡Concurrent jobs

Concurrent jobs refer to the ability of a system to handle multiple tasks or processes at the same time. In the context of AI art generation, this means the platform can generate multiple images simultaneously. The video compares the number of concurrent jobs allowed in mid-journey and Leonardo, with Leonardo offering the ability to run a higher number of concurrent jobs without restrictions based on pricing plans.

💡Upscaler

An upscaler is a tool or feature that increases the resolution of an image without losing quality or introducing noticeable artifacts. In the video, the upscaler is used to improve the detail and clarity of AI-generated images, particularly in the case of Leonardo's outputs, which sometimes require upscaling to achieve better visual coherence and aesthetic appeal.

💡Prompts

Prompts are the textual descriptions or commands that users input into AI art generation tools to guide the creation of the image. The video emphasizes the importance of crafting prompts carefully for different platforms, as the way they interpret and respond to prompts can vary. Crafting prompts involves being specific and intentional with the desired output.

💡Aesthetic quality

Aesthetic quality refers to the visual appeal and artistic value of an image or artwork. In the context of AI-generated art, it encompasses factors such as color, composition, detail, and overall coherence. The video compares the aesthetic quality of images produced by mid-journey and Leonardo, noting differences in style, detail, and the need for refinement.

Highlights

Comparison of two AI art generation tools, mid-journey and Leonardo, based on various factors.

User experience and interface comparison, noting the differences in accessibility and visual design.

Leonardo is built on stable diffusion, an open-source AI generator, while mid-journey uses its own unique algorithm.

Mid-journey is accessed via Discord, offering benefits and challenges due to its chat application interface.

Leonardo has its own visual interface, allowing easy parameter changes and a more coherent user experience.

Mid-journey offers different algorithms, including an anime-specific one and photorealistic image focus.

Leonardo provides the ability to create custom models by uploading a set of images for training.

Leonardo has additional features like background removal and prompt generation tools.

Comparing the two platforms on prompts like 'female working on a laptop at top of Mountain' and 'mystical landscape in Studio Ghibli style'.

Upscaler output differences between mid-journey and Leonardo, with mid-journey maintaining coherence and aesthetic.

The importance of prompt crafting differently for each platform to achieve the best results.

Leonardo's capability for concurrent job processing, whereas mid-journey has limits based on the plan.

Pricing and credit system of both platforms, with Leonardo currently offering a free platform and mid-journey having a tiered pricing structure.

Examples of alien planet landscapes and pet portraits showcasing the unique aesthetics of mid-journey and Leonardo.

The nuanced differences in rendering details like fur and fine hairs between the two AI tools.

The potential for both platforms to coexist in an artist's workflow, each serving different needs and preferences.

The video concludes with an invitation for feedback on the AI art tools and a teaser for future content.