ASUS... Why are you the way that you are?!
Summary
TLDRThe video script discusses the ongoing issues with Intel's 13th and 14th generation CPUs and the push by motherboard manufacturers to exceed the CPU's specified performance limits, leading to physical damage to the CPUs. The speaker, using an Asus z690 Maximus formula with a 13900 K, highlights the confusion among Intel's power profiles and the need for motherboard manufacturers to enforce Intel's limits. The script also criticizes Asus for not following Intel's guidelines and for making it difficult for users to achieve the CPU's default parameters without manual BIOS adjustments. The frustration is palpable as the speaker details the process of adjusting BIOS settings to meet Intel's recommended power limits and the impact on performance benchmarks.
Takeaways
- ð« **Intel's Power Limit Enforcement**: Intel has had to enforce power limits on motherboard manufacturers to prevent CPUs from being damaged due to excessive power settings.
- ð **Stealth Sense Technology**: A new technology that eliminates the need for sense wires on 40 series GPUs, providing a more stable connection and avoiding issues like black screens and fan overdrive.
- ðŸ **Motherboard Manufacturer Overclocking**: There has been a history of motherboard manufacturers like ASUS pushing CPUs beyond their specified limits, leading to inconsistent performance and potential physical damage.
- ð **CPU Damage**: The practice of pushing CPUs beyond their limits has resulted in CPUs failing or becoming unstable at stock speeds.
- ð€ **Intel Profiles Confusion**: Intel has multiple profiles (Baseline, Performance, Extreme), and there is confusion among users and even Intel about the differences and the correct settings.
- ð ïž **Manual BIOS Settings**: Users are forced to manually adjust BIOS settings to achieve the correct CPU parameters, which is not user-friendly and can lead to incorrect configurations.
- ð **Performance Impact**: Incorrect BIOS settings can lead to lower performance, as seen in the script where the user loses 3,000 points in a benchmark due to suboptimal settings.
- âïž **BIOS Update**: The user downloaded and updated the BIOS to the latest version dated April 24th, 2024, to address some of the issues mentioned.
- ð **Hidden BIOS Options**: The BIOS has hidden or not easily accessible options that, when adjusted correctly, can align with Intel's guidelines and improve CPU performance.
- ð **Multicore Enhancement (MCE)**: MCE is a feature in BIOS that, when enabled, can push CPU performance higher but may also lead to instability or damage if not configured properly.
- ð **Intel's Guidelines**: Intel has provided guidelines for power limits, and motherboard manufacturers are now expected to adhere to these to ensure CPU safety and performance.
Q & A
What is the main issue discussed in the transcript regarding Intel CPUs and motherboards?
-The main issue is that motherboard manufacturers, particularly Asus, have been pushing the limits of Intel CPUs beyond the specifications set by Intel, which can lead to CPUs being physically damaged and inconsistent performance.
What is the 'Stealth Sense' technology mentioned in the transcript?
-Stealth Sense is a technology that effectively eliminates the need for sense wires for 40 series GPUs. It features a hidden bridge that signals the GPU that a full 600W is available without the need for fragile sense wires.
Why did Intel have to rein in the motherboard manufacturers?
-Intel had to rein in the motherboard manufacturers because the liberties they were taking with CPU performance were leading to CPUs failing or becoming unstable at stock speeds.
What is the 'Intel Baseline' profile?
-The Intel Baseline profile is a set of power and performance parameters set by Intel to ensure that CPUs operate within safe limits and deliver consistent performance.
What is the complaint about the Asus Z690 Maximus Formula motherboard?
-The complaint is that Asus Z690 Maximus Formula motherboard does not follow Intel's guidelines properly, leading to incorrect power settings and the potential for CPU damage.
What is the 'Auto BIOS Optimize' feature?
-The 'Auto BIOS Optimize' feature is a setting that enables multicore enhancement, which adjusts power and performance parameters automatically, but can lead to settings that are not in line with Intel's recommended limits.
Why is it a problem if a user has to manually enter values into their motherboard BIOS settings?
-It is a problem because it indicates that the motherboard's default settings are not aligned with the CPU manufacturer's specifications, which can lead to suboptimal performance or even damage to the CPU.
What is the 'C Excursion protection' mentioned in the transcript?
-C Excursion protection is a safety feature that should be enabled in the BIOS to protect the CPU from voltage fluctuations that could potentially damage it.
What is the significance of the 'Intel extreme profile' in the context of the transcript?
-The Intel extreme profile is a setting that adheres to Intel's recommended power and performance parameters, ensuring that the CPU operates safely and efficiently.
Why is there frustration with the BIOS settings on Asus motherboards?
-The frustration stems from the complexity and inconsistency of the BIOS settings, which do not always align with Intel's guidelines and can lead to the need for manual adjustments by the user to achieve optimal and safe CPU operation.
What is the 'multicore enhancement' and why is it a point of contention?
-Multicore enhancement is a feature that can improve CPU performance by adjusting power and performance parameters. It is a point of contention because it often pushes CPU operation beyond Intel's recommended limits, leading to potential instability and damage.
Why is the user suggesting that Asus has 'drunk their own Kool-Aid'?
-The user is suggesting that Asus is overly confident in their approach and has become complacent, not acknowledging the potential issues their BIOS settings can cause for users and their CPUs.
Outlines
ð Introduction to Intel's Stealth Sense Technology and Overclocking Concerns
The first paragraph introduces Intel's Stealth Sense technology, which aims to eliminate the need for sense wires on 40 series GPUs by using a hidden bridge to signal the GPU about the availability of a full 600W power supply. It also discusses the ongoing issue with motherboard manufacturers pushing CPUs beyond their specified limits, leading to performance variations and potential physical damage to CPUs. The speaker shares their personal complaints about 13th and 14th gen CPUs and the confusion among different performance profiles set by Intel and motherboard manufacturers. The paragraph highlights the need for motherboard manufacturers to enforce Intel's limits and the complications that arise when using auto BIOS optimization, which often leads to higher power limits and the disabling of multicore enhancements.
ð€ Critique of Asus BIOS and Its Impact on CPU Performance
The second paragraph delves into the critique of Asus BIOS settings, particularly the difficulty in achieving Intel's recommended power limits and profiles due to the lack of straightforward options in the BIOS. The speaker expresses frustration with the need to manually adjust BIOS settings to meet Intel's guidelines, which is not a user-friendly approach. The paragraph also discusses the impact of incorrect BIOS settings on CPU performance, using the example of a system with an Asus z690 Maximus formula motherboard and a 13900 K CPU. The speaker demonstrates how the system's power settings are not in line with Intel's recommendations, even after applying the latest BIOS update, and how this leads to lower than expected performance scores.
ð€¬ Asus's BIOS Shortcomings and the Need for Compliance with Intel Guidelines
The third paragraph continues the discussion on Asus's BIOS issues, focusing on the lack of a simple way to select different Intel profiles within the BIOS, which is available in other brands' systems. The speaker questions why Asus has not implemented a more user-friendly approach to BIOS settings, especially when compared to other manufacturers. The paragraph emphasizes the frustration with Asus's BIOS design and the potential harm it can cause to CPUs due to non-compliance with Intel's guidelines. The speaker also touches upon their experience with another system, referred to as 'Skunk Works,' which also has BIOS settings issues.
Mindmap
Keywords
ð¡Stealth Sense Technology
ð¡Motherboard Manufacturers
ð¡Intel CPUs
ð¡Multicore Enhancement
ð¡BIOS
ð¡Auto BIOS Optimize
ð¡Intel Baseline Profile
ð¡Current Excursion Protection
ð¡AMPs
ð¡ASUS Z690 Maximus Formula
ð¡Intel Extreme Profile
Highlights
Intel is addressing the issue of motherboard manufacturers pushing CPUs beyond their specified limits, which has led to physical damage to CPUs.
The new stealth Sense Technology eliminates the need for sense wires on 40 series GPUs, reducing the risk of dislodgement and black screens.
There has been ongoing confusion and complaints about motherboard manufacturers like ASUS pushing CPU performance beyond Intel's specifications, starting from the 8th gen CPUs.
The ASUS Z690 Maximus Formula motherboard is used in the discussion, highlighting issues with 13th and 14th gen Intel CPUs.
Different profiles for CPU performance exist, including Intel Baseline, Intel Performance, and Intel Extreme, causing confusion among users.
Motherboard manufacturers add their own enhancements, leading to unpredictable CPU performance when a CPU is installed.
Intel has enforced limits on motherboard manufacturers to prevent CPUs from being damaged due to excessive performance tuning.
The ASUS Prime board and potentially the Formula board are mentioned as going against Intel's guidelines, potentially leading to CPU damage.
The term 'Auto BIOS Optimize' is revealed to be a setting for multicore enhancement, which can lead to higher than intended CPU performance.
Disabling multicore enhancement should enforce all limits, but in practice, certain settings like amp limits still need manual adjustment.
The latest BIOS from ASUS, dated April 24th, 2024, includes a new message advising users to disable multicore enhancement for Intel's stock power limits.
The Intel Baseline profile is mentioned as a safe option, but it is not part of the multicore enhancement and requires manual selection.
Current Excursion protection should be enabled for safety, but it was found disabled in the ASUS BIOS settings.
The discussion highlights the frustration of having to manually adjust BIOS settings to achieve the CPU's default parameters, which should be automatic.
The ASUS BIOS was criticized for not having a simple selection menu for different Intel profiles, unlike other brands.
The user demonstrates how a single setting in the ASUS BIOS can cost users a significant performance decrease in benchmarks.
The user expresses frustration with ASUS for not following Intel's guidelines and potentially damaging CPUs with their BIOS settings.
Intel is trying to correct the situation by enforcing guidelines, but the damage to CPUs has already occurred due to previous leniency.
Transcripts
okay so Intel has been kind of like
putting the on the motherboard
manufacturer saying hey all you guys get
your together problem is they
they're not really getting their
together cable Mod's new stealth Sense
Technology effectively eliminates the
need for sense wires for your 40 series
GPU Ste sense features a hidden Bridge
which signals the GPU that a full 600
WTS is available all without the need
for fragile sense wires that can easily
be dislodged leading to a black screen
and 100% fans to see the full spec list
and Power suppli supported follow the
link in the description below okay so
this story's been kind of like ongoing
now for a while um just a little back
story if you haven't watched already
I've well I've personally been
complaining about 13th and 14th gen
since they launched but the complaints
about motherboard manufacturers pushing
limits and making CPUs perform higher
than the real outof the boox like Intel
specs would be has been going on since
like 8th gen like 8th gen 8000 series
like 8700k CPU was the first time we saw
in reviews that there was really massive
varying scores between reviewers because
we a lot of us weren't catching the fact
that board manufacturers like Asus were
pushing limits and pushing values and
and multi-core enhancement out of the
box giving a very different out of the
box experience and up until now it's
kind of been a complaint but it hasn't
been a problem until now where CPUs are
now starting to actually be physically
damaged by the Liberties that
motherboard manufacturers are taken now
I'm using an Asus z690 Maximus formula
on a 13900 K now the issue between like
the I9 CPUs for 13th and 14th gen which
are essentially just the same CPU
they're the exact same die process so
that's why they're really kind of lumped
together in these particular discussions
when it comes to the I9 stuff um there's
confusion even amongst like Intel's
explanations of the different profiles
and stuff because there are multiple
profiles so there is an Intel Baseline
we'll talk about that in a second cuz
that's sort of a ghost number if you
will then there's Intel performance and
then there's Intel extreme now that's
just the Intel side then you take the
motherboard manufacturers kind of
putting their own secret sauce into it
then you never know what the you're
getting when you put in a CPU into a
motherboard and turn it on and now that
we've had plenty of CPUs fail either no
longer stable at stock speeds or dying
all together Intel finally had to like
rein in the motherboard manufacturers to
say hey you need to start enforcing our
limits which are on this table right
here we'll talk about these these limits
in a second the problem is like Asus on
their Prime board and I don't know if
it's going to exist on the the formula
board we're going to figure this out
together went like so far the other
direction it's almost like they did as
spite it's almost like Asus was like
fine you me tell us what you then we're
going to go ahead and your
performance well okay let's talk about
that first and foremost one of the
biggest complaints I've talked about a
million times and I'll go ahead and do
it right now is that when you load
optimize
defaults and then we go ahead ahe and
restart you'll notice optimized defaults
is nothing more than enabling multicore
enhancement now those multicore
enhancements have numbers built into
them that depending on your BIOS version
by the way and based on the motherboard
manufacturer they all kind of like live
in the auto overclocking realm of
whatever the hell they decide they want
it to be so it's going to be different
between board manufacturer and board
manufacturer and different between board
and board because this is an
overclocking board so of course it's
going to and push those limits even
higher but the point is as a consumer
this is this is remember this is a recap
of the problem so if you've already seen
the video and you're like why are you
repeating yourself as for those that
haven't is auto let bios optimize is
multicore enhancement on so autolet bios
optimize is on they we have disabled
enforce all limits so really what you're
disabling is the multicore enhancement
right so by turning that off you should
be enforcing all limits that's where we
get the 400 amps and the 253 long
duration 253 short duration but if I was
to enfor uh enabled Auto let bios
optimize for multicore enhancement it
sets that to 511 amps it sets the the
short duration to
4,096 which is then just unlimited so
what we're going to do today I've now
downloaded their latest bios the latest
bios dated April 24th 2024 so
42424 it's a p
drone so this is actually a new message
this is the first time I've seen this it
just got done flashing our bio so I'm
going to remove the drive um it says
press F1 to continue and take advantage
of Asus optimized
performance if you wish to follow Intel
guidelines and apply it stock power
limits please disable the esus multicore
enhancement MCE in the bio settings next
you will enter the U you know I feel
like if that setting if that message was
always there on first boot I kind of
would have been okay but that was never
there until now this is from 8th gen
until now so no matter what it's going
to apply it you have to go into the buy
so there should be an F2 to just load
Intel def why why aren't they doing that
it's literally F1 to go to setup but
when you go to setup it's also going to
automatically turn on optimized
performance so it should give you an
option on the boot right now to F1 for
optimized performance or F2 for Intel
Bas baselines we'll talk about that now
because that that's the next part of
this so
F1 okay optimized defaults are on we're
now on 3501 41924 build date and uh
there we go so there's a bunch of stuff
we need to check right now so Auto let
optimize is now enabled 51.75 amps cuz
it's as high as you could possibly go
before 512 there's our 4,95 Watts it is
56 seconds and 495
Watts okay so what kind of profiles do
we get now if we look
under okay so all we get is auto let
bios optimized disable enforce all
limits enabled remove all limits so the
exactly the same settings there's
nothing there listed as Intel
defaults which is kind of crazy okay so
okay disabled enforce all limits there
we go let's do that okay 280
amp which is below the 307 performance
already so that's kind of weird long
package duration 253 short package 25356
those numbers are good that's what we'd
expect right here that's what we have
we're going to be looking for C current
Excursion protection needs to be enabled
oh they're
disabled I thought you were following
Intel's chart Asus can't wait for the
17-page email about how I'm dumb on this
one okay uh C Excursion protection
enable enable well they're off for
whatever reason so let's enable those
okay so unlimited ICC Mac should be set
to
disable well again I don't know what
it's doing cuz it's not telling me what
it's doing so we'll disable that
[Music]
one okay
wait so I just went through all that and
I
noticed there's Intel Baseline profile
up
here I guess I I guess that makes sense
cuz it's not a part of multicore
enhancement okay you know what fine
let's just undo everything they just did
let's enable that so AC multicore
enhancement autolet bias optimize is
going to disabled enforce all limits
svid Behavior auto Intel's failsafe okay
IIA C and sa C to enabled I a TDC
current limit Auto to Intel's default if
you remember that message if we go and
pop it back up on the screen it says if
you want to use Intel's Baseline
settings to go into BIOS and disable
multicore enhancement which is that
disabled enable all limits but as you
saw there's that whole separate section
that you have to actually select and hit
enter and reboot to truly get the
baselines and then on top of it it's
still not even accurate based on Intel's
chart because it should be 400 amps but
it's 280 so this is why Intel is also
saying don't use Baseline but if you
don't use Baseline then you have to use
their multicore enhancement which means
as a PC user now you have to go in and
go in and manually turn on this sh this
is why it's so
infuriating here 67c so it probably Maxs
out 75 once the coolant fully hot our
clocks though immediately are at 4.7 GHz
all core it's only pulling 208 Watts
right now under load I guarantee it's
because of the amps that are set too low
33701 that is not what you paid for do
you know why because again Asus is
incapable of following a simple chart so
I'm going to set this to 400 right now
and make sure that 400 applied we're
going to run it again okay so this is
now the Intel extreme profile 253 253
and 400 amps so we still don't have as
much clock speed as we really would like
to see but we are getting the Intel
numbers and 5 gigs makes sense it's
probably going to be like a 35,000 score
36,0
220 so do you see how one setting that
Asus was too stupid to actually be able
to put into a profile cost you 3,000
points in tend bench the biggest problem
here is absolutely no endend user should
ever have to go in and man ually enter a
value into their motherboard bio
settings to get the
CPUs default parameters to run if if you
recall in the Bios we had to go to two
two spots to get the wrong thing to
apply we had to disable the multicore
and then we had to click on
Intel Baseline say yes reboot it and
then go in and manipulate the amps to
even get to the score where we are right
now which is actually believe it or not
still scoring a little bit low it should
be more like 37 38,000
that's where it should be even gigabyte
a brand that I have complained about in
the past hardcore about having some of
the worst bios on the planet even has a
drop down where you can select different
Intel profiles why is Asus not able to
do that they band-aided these bios
together to add that button to appease
Intel because Intel finally had to get
involved and say WTF bro and then they
still
up anyway if I see mad at Asus they
deserve it Asus has drank their own
Kool-Aid for so long they don't think
they ever can possibly do anything wrong
but I'm here to tell you right now Asus
has no problems killing your CPU they
don't they don't have any problem with
it at all do you know why because Intel
let them get away with it long enough
now so now the Intel is trying to you
know bring a stray dog back in the house
it's no longer house broken so it's
going to take some time and I'm now I'm
dealing with this on Skunk Works too
because the Maximus board on that one is
all borked with settings too so it's
spoonfed
5.0 / 5 (0 votes)
Motherboard Default settings could be COOKING your CPU!
HW News - Unstable Intel CPUs, New Ryzen CPUs, Legion Go "2," RGB Light Staining GPUs
HW News - Intel is a Cluster, NVIDIA Blackwell Boosts Production, Sony "Still Learning"
Intel is Gunning for NVIDIA
HW News - EVGA Responds, Apple Sued by US, ASUS ROG Ally Price Drop, RTX 50 Rumors
ASUS Scammed Us