The Last Airbender: An Abomination
Summary
TLDRThe video script offers a critical analysis of M. Night Shyamalan's 'The Last Airbender' movie, highlighting its numerous shortcomings. It discusses the film's failure as an adaptation, its poor storytelling, and the controversial casting choices. The script also delves into the director's career trajectory and the potential reasons behind his missteps in handling the project. Despite its criticisms, it acknowledges a few aspects of the film's background design that still hold up. Overall, the video serves as a retrospective critique on what could have been a beloved adaptation, but instead became a point of ridicule and disappointment for fans of the original animated series.
Takeaways
- 📺 The Last Airbender movie adaptation was widely criticized for its failure to capture the essence of the original animated series.
- 🎬 M. Night Shyamalan's direction and storytelling were seen as a significant factor in the film's failure, with critics pointing out the lack of character development and awkward dialogue.
- 🎥 The casting choices, particularly the whitewashing of certain roles, sparked controversy and were seen as a misstep in representing the diverse cultural backgrounds of the four nations in the Avatar universe.
- 🌍 The film's portrayal of the four nations and their bending styles did not align well with the source material, leading to confusion and disappointment among fans.
- 🤯 The pacing and structure of the movie were criticized for not effectively condensing the rich narrative of the series into a coherent film format.
- 🔥 The action sequences and bending abilities in the film were underwhelming, with firebenders, for example, relying on external sources for fire instead of generating it themselves.
- 🌊 The concept of the Avatar was altered in the film, presenting Aang as a pacifist figure rather than the powerful bridge between the physical and spiritual worlds as in the series.
- 🎭 The performances of the young actors, particularly Noah Ringer as Aang, were seen as uneven and not up to the standards of a major blockbuster film.
- 🏰 The change in setting and atmosphere, such as the portrayal of the Northern Water Tribe, deviated from the show's original depiction and did not resonate with fans.
- 🗣️ The film's dialogue was criticized for being stilted and unnatural, with characters often speaking in a roundabout way that did not feel true to their personalities or the world they inhabited.
- 🚫 The overall sentiment towards the film was overwhelmingly negative, with many feeling that it failed to honor the legacy of the original show and instead created a new set of problems.
Q & A
What was the initial reaction of kids at school to the premiere of Avatar: The Last Airbender?
-The kids at school were excited and imitated the bending moves from the show, with some even throwing rocks at others, showing a wide range of responses to the show's popularity.
How did the speaker feel when they were singled out for liking the water element?
-The speaker felt embarrassed and devastated because they were told that only girls could be waterbenders, which made them question their preference and feel out of place.
What is the speaker's overall opinion of the movie adaptation of Avatar: The Last Airbender?
-The speaker considers the movie a fascinating failure on multiple levels, including as an adaptation, an introduction to the show, and in terms of storytelling and character behavior.
Why was M. Night Shyamalan chosen to direct the Avatar: The Last Airbender movie?
-Shyamalan was chosen due to his previous success with small-scale thrillers and his desire to revive his career, as well as his personal interest in the show, which he watched with his children.
What was the main criticism regarding the casting decisions in the movie?
-The main criticism was the whitewashing of the cast, particularly the choice of actors for the waterbenders, which was seen as either a result of Hollywood nepotism or a lack of consideration for the source material's cultural backgrounds.
What did the speaker appreciate about the movie despite its numerous flaws?
-The speaker appreciated the backgrounds in the movie, particularly the aesthetic of the Fire Nation Capital, which they felt still held up well despite the movie's shortcomings.
What was the speaker's issue with the pacing and structure of the movie?
-The speaker felt that the movie failed in pacing and structure by trying to condense too much plot from the series into a single film, resulting in a disjointed and rushed narrative.
How did the movie's portrayal of the Avatar differ from the original show?
-The movie portrayed the Avatar as a pacifist figure who couldn't hurt others, which was a significant departure from the show, where the Avatar was a symbol of hope but not necessarily bound by pacifism.
What was the speaker's view on the performances of the main cast in the movie?
-The speaker was critical of the main cast's performances, particularly Noah Ringer as Aang, and felt that the actors were not well-utilized, with their characters lacking depth and motivation.
What was the speaker's final verdict on the live-action adaptation of Avatar: The Last Airbender?
-The speaker concluded that the live-action adaptation was a failure that did not capture the essence of the original show and suggested that a better approach would have been to create a new, original story in a different timeline.
Outlines
📺 Nostalgic Misunderstandings in 'The Last Airbender'
The paragraph discusses the author's childhood memories of the excitement surrounding the premiere of 'Avatar: The Last Airbender' and the subsequent playground discussions about the show's elements. It also touches on a personal anecdote where the author was singled out for liking the water element, leading to feelings of embarrassment. The paragraph transitions into a critique of the live-action adaptation 'The Last Airbender,' highlighting the film's failure as an adaptation and introduction to the series, as well as its storytelling shortcomings.
🎬 M. Night Shyamalan's Inconsistencies and Casting Choices
This paragraph delves into the career of director M. Night Shyamalan, noting his inconsistent track record with films. It explores why Shyamalan was chosen to direct 'The Last Airbender,' suggesting that his intention was to revive his career and fit into the Hollywood mainstream. The discussion includes the controversial casting decisions, attributing them to a mix of nepotism and Shyamalan's vision, which led to the 'whitewashing' of the characters. The paragraph also reflects on Shyamalan's realization of the film's shortcomings and his return to smaller-scale movies.
🌄 Appreciating the Backgrounds in 'The Last Airbender'
Despite the overall negative reception of 'The Last Airbender,' the paragraph expresses appreciation for the film's backgrounds, particularly the Fire Nation Capital. The author acknowledges the visual appeal of the CGI and the aesthetic combination of Southeast Asian styles. However, the paragraph also criticizes the film's script, pacing, and character development, arguing that the movie fails to engage the audience due to its focus on exposition and lack of character depth.
🔥 The Fire Nation's Flawed Fire Benders
The paragraph criticizes the depiction of fire benders in 'The Last Airbender,' arguing that the film's decision to have them rely on external sources of fire makes them less interesting and less threatening. It contrasts this with the original show's portrayal of fire benders as powerful and capable of generating their own fire. The author also discusses the film's action sequences, suggesting that they fall short of the original show's excitement and that the live-action adaptation fails to capture the essence of the bending arts.
🎭 Disappointing Performances and Character Depth
This paragraph focuses on the performances of the actors in 'The Last Airbender,' particularly Noah Ringer as Aang and Nicola Peltz as Katara. It discusses the challenges faced by the young actors and the impact of the film's failure on their careers. The paragraph also touches on the lack of character development and the film's inability to capture the essence of the original characters, resulting in a disconnect between the audience and the characters on screen.
🗣️ The Misguided Direction of 'The Last Airbender'
The paragraph critiques M. Night Shyamalan's direction of 'The Last Airbender,' arguing that his approach to storytelling and character development was misguided. It discusses the film's failure to establish a central theme and its mishandling of the concept of the Avatar as a symbol of hope. The paragraph also highlights the film's changes to the original show's narrative, suggesting that these alterations detract from the story's impact and emotional resonance.
🎥 The Folly of Live-Action Adaptations
The final paragraph reflects on the broader implications of 'The Last Airbender' and other live-action adaptations, questioning the necessity and value of retelling stories that have already been perfectly executed in their original form. It argues that adaptations like 'The Last Airbender' can inadvertently increase appreciation for the original work by showcasing how not to adapt a story. The paragraph concludes with a plea for filmmakers to avoid creating major blockbusters that fail to capture the magic of their source material.
Mindmap
Keywords
💡Avatar: The Last Airbender
💡M. Night Shyamalan
💡Adaptation
💡Whitewashing
💡Pacing
💡Exposition
💡Bending
💡Casting
💡Character Development
💡Cultural Representation
Highlights
The impact of 'Avatar: The Last Airbender' on children and their play, with kids imitating the elements and the social dynamics it created.
The personal anecdote of being singled out for liking the 'water' element, reflecting broader societal gender stereotypes.
The critical failure of 'The Last Airbender' film as an adaptation, failing to capture the essence of the original show and alienating its fanbase.
M. Night Shyamalan's inconsistent directorial record and his misstep with taking on a major blockbuster like 'The Last Airbender'.
The irony of Shyamalan's career resurgence being linked to his children and their interest in 'Avatar: The Last Airbender'.
The questionable casting decisions in 'The Last Airbender' and the controversies surrounding them, including allegations of nepotism.
Shyamalan's admission of his lack of fit for blockbuster films and his better niche in smaller scale thrillers or horror concepts.
The disconnect between the ethnicities of the four nations in the film and the source material, highlighting Hollywood's casting issues.
The critique of the film's script, pacing, and character development, emphasizing the importance of a well-written narrative.
The observation that the backgrounds and visual effects in 'The Last Airbender' were one of the few redeeming qualities of the film.
The analysis of the film's action sequences and how they failed to translate the animated show's dynamic into a live-action format.
The critique of the film's handling of the Avatar's role and power, contrasting it with the original show's portrayal.
The disappointment with the main cast's performances and the lack of depth given to their characters.
The contrast between the original show's complex characters and the film's one-dimensional representations.
The examination of the film's tonal inconsistencies and its failure to capture the spirit of adventure and humor from the animated series.
The critique of the film's handling of the Fire Nation and the loss of cultural significance in the adaptation process.
The discussion on the film's missed opportunities and the broader implications for the potential of a live-action 'Avatar' adaptation.
The final verdict on 'The Last Airbender' as a film that failed on multiple levels and the appreciation for the original show it inspired.
Transcripts
when I was a kid avatar The Last
Airbender had just premiered its first
few episodes it took the school by force
every dumb kid was swooshing and
slashing the air like they were bending
the elements some were just chucking
rocks at people I remember one day at
recess all the guys were gathered around
and we discussed which element we like
the best some kids said fire others
Earth and then there was me I said that
I liked water some little [ __ ]
immediately singled me out and said
don't you know only girls are water
benders that caught me off guard it
devastated me I couldn't recall any guy
water benders water I felt embarrassed
and I slunk away yeah you know in the
end the kid was just wrong uh we see a
lot of male water benders later on I
guess the lesson here is that uh in that
brief span of time before the gang got
to the northern water tribe a bunch of
dumb kids in rural Ohio
thought that just girls could waterbend
because our only reference was qara this
has nothing to do with the rest of the
video uh I just didn't want to be
another video essay that starts off
saying the last air bender is absolute
trash The Last Airbender the movie the
game is an utterly fascinating film for
me it's one of those brilliant moments
in Hollywood where absolutely nothing
works that's a penis it fails as an
adaptation of one of the greatest shows
to ever exist and it fails as an
introduction to anyone unfamiliar with
said show it fails at storytelling in
general hell it even fails in emulating
how humans behave and speak are really
powerful Benders in the the northern
water tribe my dad told me about it
before he left it's led by a princess
because her father died there a teacher
how does that even happen who forgets
how humans work oh that that's why
complaining about this movie is one of
the most done to death things on YouTube
for most late Millennials and early
Zoomers the cartoon was like a holy text
and this movie was the equivalent of
sacrilege burn him at the stake they
said Stone the
Shyamalan make him pay for his sins and
if they had just called him a once and
look I'm a major fan of Avatar it's
certainly the Best Western animated kid
show by a long mile friendly mushroom
she jo friend I understand the outrage
but now just so many years have passed
uh this whole experience is more funny
to me than anything the show exists I'm
glad it exists and you can never
replicate it no matter how many times
they try I think I've genuinely got more
entertainment from this movie being bad
than I ever could have if it was just
mediocre or even good and now here I am
making a video trashing that movie in
2024
I'm a little late to the party on this
one I got a feeling that Avatar fans are
going to make fun of something else for
the next 10 years so before that takes
over I decide to be the last one out
goodbye Last Airbender we got a new
thing to make fun of but before sending
this movie off to the farm and never
talking about it again I want to explore
just one question what the hell was
anyone
thinking if there is something that has
baffled people for over a decade it is
the question why ight Shyamalan why was
he the director chosen for this project
and to answer that we have to first ask
another question where was ight
Shyamalan in his career the answer is he
wasn't doing great some directors are
consistently good some are consistently
bad but Shyamalan is consistent in not
being consistent you might as well roll
the dice on his quality some of his
films are all right and then there's
those times that he just rolls a crit
fail the rebounding explosion makes a
critical
bomb ight shamalan works best with small
scale Thrillers or horror Concepts
doesn't mean they'll always be good what
no but it's what he's best at so why why
did he take on a major Blockbuster two
reasons one to fit in and two to bring
back his career from the verge of death
shyamalan's catalog is like a roller
coaster a lot more UPS than Downs
Shyamalan always has this ability of
releasing one decent movie right before
everyone has given up on him he really
has that knack for occasionally hitting
a home run so everyone just keeps him
around like Stanton so he's never really
done actual
Blockbusters except for those two times
and even he admits now he wasn't cut out
for it you know he says now after
everyone's clowned on it looking at the
interviews he used every COPE in the
book you know I always had a European
sensibility to my movies so they the the
pacing is always light little bit off
for for them you know and it feels a
little stilted and they need more they
need more electricity and all that stuff
and I'm like this is the way I I think
of things cuz you know Hitchcock and
corar and stany kubri these are like my
teachers and I'm the
Avatar I ran away but I'm back now who
do you think you are ight coima which
look it makes sense that nobody wants to
take the project they worked on and
throw it under the bus except if it's
Madam web but now that he's been removed
from it and he's been humbled went back
to midsize movie land where he belongs
he realizes that uh yeah this movie's
trash at the same time though why did he
have to learn this lesson with Avatar
why is your hair white young lady you
look very
odd it's because of his kids that's it
they were watching it in the room one
day and M Night waltzed up and started
watching it with them it was all over
from there imagine just liking a show
and your dad walks in on you and decides
to make his own version of it what a
nightmare by all accounts Shyamalan was
the one who came up with the idea of an
Avatar movie Paramount were kind of just
like oh okay I guess we're doing this
and Shyamalan really over promised he
wanted to do a three movie trilogy that
he would write into direct all by
himself he wanted to ride that Avatar IP
all the way back to the top and oh man
did he not do that at
all in hindsight betting at all on ight
Shyamalan was the first mistake the
second more Infamous reason uh one that
everyone has forever talked about is the
casting why do the water benders look
like that why do the fire Benders look
like that why do the Earth ERS look like
that well the Earth kingdom is literally
based off China so that makes sense why
did they do this was it malicious was it
racist and uh no best that I could find
Shyamalan kind of just didn't think
about it you see the ethnicities of the
four nations were determined by whoever
he decided to work with that was it the
reason Ang was white was because Noah
Ringer was a short 12-year-old black
belt in Taekwondo he had literally no
acting experience but he he sure could
do that go go go Shyamalan wanted to
cast Nia peltz's guara saying she was a
talented young actress who he envisioned
in the role if you watch my Transformers
4 video you could kind of tell that was
absolute [ __ ] 100 years ago all was
right with our world prosperity and
peace filled our days Fire Lord
son you took him from our village but
how did she work in two major Hollywood
films without any experience allegedly
pelts was only hired because of her
billionaire father Nelson pelts
allegedly a producer owed her dad a
favor like I said
allegedly but considering how bad she is
and how Hollywood works I 100% could see
this being true because of that well
Saka had to be the same ethnicity as
qara and all the other water benders had
to kind of resemble them too we'll never
get the true story but there is always
the possibility that this whole
unfortunate whitewashing incident was
never caused by actual racism but just
Classic Hollywood nepotism yippe it's
funny how much one casting Choice
drastically affected the film like
originally Zuko was supposed to be
played by Jesse McCartney yes that one
but he had a tour at the time or
something and dropped out so shyamalan's
next choice was Dev tell oh my God
imagine this trash fire of Jesse
McCartney in regards to the fire
nation's ethnicity Shyamalan said this
in a Gizmodo article from 2010 the fire
nation was the most complicated I kept
switching who was playing Zuko it was
such a complicated and drawn out thing
about practical matters but the first
person I was considering casting for
Zuko was Ecuadorian so I started
thinking that way then when that person
couldn't do it the next person who came
in was much more C asion and then we had
to switch everything around so here's my
personal Theory whoever was going to be
Zuko was going to determine the
nationality of the entire Fire Nation
like it sounds like here we almost got
ecuadorians Conquering the world but
since Dev Patel got the role well in
shyamalan's mind all the fire Benders
had to be Indian now not a single neuron
was activated in that brain but hey hey
I don't like being too negative before
going down that path of just completely
bashing this movie I want to say what I
actually like about the last air bender
the backgrounds I like the backgrounds
man that says a lot about modern CGI at
The Last Airbender movie still kind of
holds up and I like one specific
background more than any of them uh this
background the Fire Nation Capital yeah
it doesn't resemble the show's capital
in the slightest but I really like the
aesthetic it's like a grandiose
combination of multiple s Southeast
Asian Styles it doesn't fit at all as
the capital of the Fire Nation I I just
like the atmosphere okay that's
it oh to be a fly on the wall when ight
was writing this movie what was the
thought process how can you get so
invested in the show approach Paramount
with the idea go through all this work
and then that's the script you write
what what if we found you teachers
teachers to teach you bending Which
element would the last air bend fails
first and foremost because of its script
the greatest production and effects in
the world can't save a movie from Bad
writing unless you're the Star Wars
prequels but then again those are
actually funny another happy Landing the
last air bender is very similar to the
prequels dry Bland expository dialogue a
screenplay that was probably a first
draft directing that didn't work well
with the actors at all and a film that
was tonally strange and a often bizarre
yet still the backgrounds were strangely
good crazy how that happens while the
prequels have been redeemed by childhood
Nostalgia the Clone Wars and Battlefront
2 brainwashing well of course I know him
he's me the last air bender did not have
that luxury nor should it it's time for
you to stop doing
this the Avatar would have to be an
airbender are you an air bender
boy leave him like like no amount of
time is going to redeem this movie nor
future bad adaptations two bad things
can exist at once the only thing this
film has is exposition a house of
exposition built on a shaky Bedrock of
more Exposition there are no characters
here only Wikipedia articles that badly
retell World building that may or may
not pertain to the situation at hand as
you know I conducted a raid on The Great
Library which most said didn't even
exist good one with adapting a cartoon
that just aired is already a dumb idea
and adapting an entire season of
character growth and relationships into
a 3A structure is even worse yeah here's
my opinion this movie didn't fail
because it tried to condense a season of
plot into a single movie no this movie
uniquely failed because it didn't know
how to do anything it didn't know how to
condense it didn't know how to write it
especially didn't know how to Pace
itself because it's entally the first
three episodes of the show and
then the blue spirit and then the next
half of the film is the climax at the
northern water tribe so that's the first
issue I'd say act two begins once they
leave the southern air Temple they get
captured cuz this little dick was
slinging rocks and they're brought to
the Fire Nation prison you just know
what ight was thinking see the show had
anep episode where the earthbenders were
imprisoned and it's just like that but
you know that prison was a metal barge
in the middle of the ocean the one place
the prisoners couldn't earthbend in the
movie it's a dirt pit I can't think of a
place more surrounded by Earth and yet
the earthbenders still do nothing why
are you acting this way you are powerful
and amazing people they're just too sad
poor little guys what's their excuse
here I don't know they're just sitting
there so a can go up to him and say hey
guys know you can throw rocks right and
then they're like
okay is that even fighting back I don't
know maybe they should have given up the
movie is just chock full of these little
tidbits from the show that are
disconnected from their original purpose
like why does the earthbending village
have a waterbending scroll why didn't
the firebenders just burn all the stuff
down did you guys want to lose the war
see it's the scroll like in the show you
never see it again after the shot though
Avatar Koshi loves games I do too I mean
I still
do yeah when I think about Avatar Koshi
the first thing I think about is how
much he loved
games k who knows maybe having
disconnected chunks of the show that
play no relevance in the story was just
part of shyamalan's European artistic
taste maybe the swedes absolutely love
this scene I don't know look we don't
need every plot point we could have
survived without the episode where a
gets his fortune told or the two tribes
that hate each other actually I take it
back I will defend the Great Divide
until the day I die I like that Ang just
lied to these people about their
foundational myth after this Montage a
gets captured and saved by the blue
spirit and then the rest of the movie is
at the northern water tribe yeah so
there's a pacing
issue so in writing there's the term
called cheze off's gun act one there's a
gun on the wall seems pretty unimportant
then an act three the gun is used to
shoot the bad
guy setup payoff you get it Mite does
the exact opposite of that in act one
there's like five guns on the wall the
characters talk about why they're five
guns in the wall and then in act three
the main bad guy gets ran over by a
truck will the exposition being said be
relevant who knows but there are really
powerful Benders in the the northern
water tribe my dad told me about it
before he left it's led by a princess
because her father died why did Saka
need to mention that the water tribe is
ruled by a princess because her father
died that information won't be relevant
until they reach the north actually I
don't think that information is relevant
ever like she doesn't reflect on her dad
dying once it doesn't contribute to her
character at all she has no character
why did he say this they could have just
shown her when they reached the north
why' you waste our time like that M
night this Exposition problem is what
brings down the entire movie Ang air
bended a sphere around them and ice
formed and he couldn't remember anything
after that instead of having characters
that interact with motivations and
attributes that the audience would care
about ight instead wrote lore dumping
machines that explain Common Sense
things that people in the world should
already know it's not a place made up of