'Shouldn't We Be Deporting These Students?': Hawley Questions Witness About Non-Citizen Protesters
Summary
TLDR在这段视频脚本中,一位参议员正在询问一个名为“梦想美国”的组织负责人,该组织为无证年轻人提供大学和职业成功的支持,包括奖学金。参议员表达了对无证学生在校园非法占领和对犹太学生进行威胁行为的担忧。他引用了哥伦比亚大学和乔治华盛顿大学发生的事件,包括焚烧美国国旗、呼吁对以色列的支持者进行斩首等极端行为。参议员强调,如果无证学生违反法律并煽动对特定种族的迫害,他们应该被驱逐出境,如果他们持有学生签证,签证也应被取消。他呼吁发出明确的道德信息,表明美国不会容忍这种行为。
Takeaways
- 📚 该组织为无证年轻人提供大学和职业成功的支持,包括提供奖学金。
- 🤔 组织代表不确定是否有他们资助的学生参与了校园内的非法露营活动。
- 🚫 代表明确表示,他们不知道是否有他们资助的学生在校园内对犹太学生进行身体威胁。
- 📰 NBC新闻报道了一名哥伦比亚大学的无证移民学生参与了非法露营活动。
- 🎓 在校园内,一些学生参与了违反法律和校园政策的活动,包括在校园内建立非法露营地。
- 🔥 有报道提到,在乔治华盛顿大学,露营的学生在建筑物上投影了焚烧美国国旗和亲巴勒斯坦的口号。
- 🗣️ 哥伦比亚大学的学生对犹太学生发出了威胁性言论,并提到了日期“10月7日”。
- ❌ 参议员提出,如果有无证学生违法并煽动对特定种族的迫害,应当将他们驱逐出境。
- 🇺🇸 参议员强调,美国不会容忍对犹太人的暴力威胁和实际暴力行为,呼吁取消参与此类活动的学生签证。
- 💭 小组成员对于是否应该驱逐这些学生没有直接回应,参议员对此表示了失望。
- 📣 参议员呼吁发出明确的道德信息,表明美国不会容忍此类行为,无论是非法侵入还是对特定群体的威胁。
Q & A
组织Dream.US为无证年轻人提供哪些支持?
-Dream.US为无证年轻人提供大学和职业成功的支持,包括提供奖学金。
是否有Dream.US奖学金获得者参与了校园内的非法露营活动?
-根据对话内容,没有Dream.US奖学金获得者参与非法露营活动。
哥伦比亚大学一名未公开身份的无证移民学生是否参与了非法露营?
-根据NBC新闻的报道,确实有一名哥伦比亚大学的无证移民学生参与了非法露营。
在乔治华盛顿大学的学生露营中,学生展示了哪些具有争议性的行为?
-学生露营中展示了包括焚烧美国国旗、高呼支持巴勒斯坦的口号以及呼吁对支持以色列的人进行斩首等争议性行为。
哥伦比亚大学的学生在4月20日做了什么?
-哥伦比亚大学的学生对犹太学生进行了威胁,包括高呼针对犹太学生的威胁性口号。
参议员对于无证学生参与违法活动并威胁他人安全的看法是什么?
-参议员认为,如果无证学生违法并故意煽动对特定种族的迫害,应当被驱逐出境。
参议员是否认为应该取消参与此类活动的学生签证?
-参议员认为应该取消那些参与违法活动的学生签证,并发送一个明确的信息。
Dream.US的学者们对美国的期望是什么?
-Dream.US的学者们期望他们的学生能热爱、尊重这个国家,并且希望他们能丰富校园和国家。
参议员如何描述对于在校园内违法活动的道德立场?
-参议员强调,美国不会容忍校园内的暴力威胁和非法行为,如果学生在此非法逗留并从事此类活动,应当被驱逐出境。
参议员希望如何就此事发出信息?
-参议员希望以一种道德的声音就此事发出信息,明确表示美国不会容忍对犹太人的暴力威胁和非法行为。
为什么参议员强调需要就此事发出道德信息?
-参议员强调道德信息的重要性是为了表明美国对于违法活动和对特定群体的威胁的零容忍态度。
在讨论中,是否有小组成员对参议员的观点提出异议?
-根据对话内容,小组成员在参议员提问后保持沉默,没有提出异议。
Outlines
📚 讨论无证学生奖学金与校园抗议活动
第一段对话主要围绕一个名为'US'的组织,该组织为无证年轻人提供大学和职业成功的支持。讨论集中在该组织是否为这些学生提供奖学金,以及是否有奖学金获得者参与了校园内的非法抗议活动。提到了哥伦比亚大学一名无证学生参与抗议活动的情况,以及乔治华盛顿大学校园内发生的一些抗议行为,包括焚烧美国国旗和对以色列的支持者发出威胁。最后,提出了是否应该将这些违法的无证学生驱逐出境的问题。
🗣️ 强烈谴责校园暴力和抗议活动的立场
第二段对话中,发言者强烈谴责了校园内的暴力威胁和实际暴力行为,特别是针对犹太学生的威胁。强调了如果学生在校园内进行违法行为,尤其是如果他们是以学生签证入境的,那么应该取消他们的签证,并明确表示美国不会容忍这种行为。发言者呼吁在这一问题上发出一致的道德声音,并表达了对这种行为的零容忍态度。
Mindmap
Keywords
💡undocumented students
💡scholarships
💡encampments
💡Columbia University
💡Palestinian
💡Jewish students
💡deportation
💡student visas
💡violence
💡moral message
💡United States of America
Highlights
The organization provides support for undocumented young people for college and career success.
They also provide scholarships to these undocumented students.
None of the students who received scholarships are part of the encampments on college campuses.
There is no knowledge of any scholarship recipients physically threatening Jewish students on campus.
A Columbia University undergraduate, who is an undocumented immigrant, spent hours a day in an illegal encampment.
Students in the encampment projected images of the US flag being burned with pro-Palestinian slogans.
They called for the beheading of individuals who support Israel, including putting their own Board of Trustees on trial.
Columbia University students yelled at Jewish students, threatening violence and making reference to a specific date.
The Senator questions whether undocumented students who are here unlawfully and inciting violence should be deported.
The Senator calls for canceling student visas of those involved in such activities.
The Senator emphasizes the need to send a moral message that the US will not tolerate violence and persecution against Jewish students.
The panel is silent on the question of deporting these students.
The Senator urges speaking with one moral voice against such violence and illegal activities.
The Senator commends Miss Peko's opening statement about representing the character of the country.
The transcript highlights the issue of undocumented students engaging in illegal activities and inciting violence on campus.
Transcripts
thank you Senator Senator Holly thank
you very much Mr chairman thanks to all
of the witnesses for being here U Mr PCO
if I could just start with you your
organization at the dream. US you
provide support for undocumented uh
young people for College and Career
Success is that broadly right am I
getting it right that's correct and and
among the things you do is you provide
scholarships to these undocumented
students have I got that correct that's
right and so college scholarships just
to be clear correct okay gotcha can you
can you tell me maybe you know the
answer to this maybe you don't any of
the students do you know if any of the
students to whom your organization has
provided a college scholarship are
currently part of the encampments on any
of these college campuses like the
picture you see behind me I'm sure we've
all seen these videos no Senator um no
none of no nobody who to whom you
provide scholarships are are part of the
encampments I do not know you don't know
um what about do do you know if if any
of the students who to whom you provided
scholarships have threatened physically
threatened Jewish students on on campus
I do not know here's why I'm asking NBC
News just reported and I'm just going to
quote now from the article quote a
Colombia that's is Columbia University a
Colombia undergraduate Who provided only
her initials because she is an
undocumented immigrant and fears
deportation said last week she spent
hours a day in the encampment this would
be the illegal encampment that's
violation of the law as well as student
as well as campus policy spent hours a
day in the encampment I'm quoting still
now before University officials
threatened to suspend those students the
article goes on she joined this uh uh
this student joined a supplies platoon
that's a subgroup formed by Pro
Palestinian campus organizers in quote
uh let me just review some of the things
that these
students these in the encampments that
is are saying of course we often don't
know who these students are they're
conce their identities this is I'm going
to read to you now and I just warn folks
this is not pleasant stuff but but these
are the facts and we have to tell the
truth this is just from last night at
George Washington University that's here
in this town uh they projected these the
students in the encampment there
projected onto various buildings images
of the United States flag being burned
with the with the graphics Gaza lights
the spark that will set the Empire
Ablaze they projected the following long
live the student inata
down with the settler state that would
be the state of Israel I suppose glory
to the martyrs of Palestine it's a
jihadist slogan stained with the blood
of 44,000 Palestinians that's last night
at GW also at GW they're now calling for
beheading this student encampment
beheading
beheading of individuals who support the
state of Israel including holding a
people's tribunal where they're putting
on trial quote unquote various members
of their own Board of Trustees and
calling for a guillotine here's Columbia
University students on April the 20th
2024 this is all public record I'm
reading this now this is on uh I guess
it's X Columbia University students
yelling at Jewish students and I quote
never forget October 7th it will not
happen I'm sorry it will happen not one
more time not five more times not 10 not
100 not 1,000 but 10,000 times the 7th
of October is going to be every day for
you the 7th of October this is to Jewish
students is going to be every day for
you end
quote I guess my question is M peo and
for anybody else on the panel too
shouldn't we be deporting these students
if we have undocumented students who are
here unlaw in the country who are
violating the law let's just be clear
here now this is a violation of the law
and if they're also deliberately
inciting persecution of a person on
account of their race which surely
calling for the murder of Jews does
that shouldn't we be deporting them does
anybody think we shouldn't be shouldn't
we be deporting these students who are
here unlawfully Mr peo Senator we expect
a lot from our Scholars and the scholars
and the the students that I know love
this country respect this country and
want to and and enrich not only the
campuses but also this country that's
fantastic and I hope and and bet that
none of the people that that you sponsor
are are part of this uh and I certainly
hope that's the case but I I just
wondered is there anybody in the panel
who thinks that we should not
Deport students who are here on lawfully
who are engaging in in this activity who
are calling for the death of Jewish
students who are violating laws of the
United States I mean should shouldn't we
be deporting these people does anybody
want to defend it and say no we
shouldn't they should absolutely be
here I think it's
indefensible I the record reflects
there's total Silence from the panel you
know I also think we ought to cancel the
student visas and I've called for this
for those who are here from other
countries with a Visa I think if they're
part of this we ought to be canceling
their visas and we ought to send a clear
message actually miss Peko I think it
was you in your opening statement put it
really beautiful beautifully about how
how part of what we're talking here
today represents the character of the
country I think that's I think that's
very appropriate and we need to send a
message about this
activity not just about the trespassing
and the destruction of buildings that's
bad that's unlawful but the threats of
violence and in some cases the outright
acts of violence against Jewish students
we should send a moral message that if
you do that and you are here unlawfully
you should be deported if you were here
on a student visa you ought to have your
Visa canceled this is the United States
of
America and we are not going to stand
for it and I would just hope we could
speak with one moral voice on this issue
thank you Mr
chairman Senator White
House thank you chairman um
5.0 / 5 (0 votes)