Best AI Music Generator in 2024 - SUNO vs UDIO

Alec Wilcock
19 Apr 202412:45

Summary

TLDR在这段视频脚本中,作者对两款AI音乐生成器——Sunno和Udio进行了详细的比较。首先,从定价方面来看,两者都提供免费计划,但Udio目前完全免费,而Sunno的付费计划则提供更多的歌曲生成和商业使用权。在用户体验方面,两者界面相似,但Udio在顶部始终显示生成栏,而Sunno则需要在创建页面上操作。所有生成的音乐默认为私密,但可以公开分享或删除。作者通过几个不同的音乐提示对两者进行了测试,包括自动模式和自定义模式,发现Udio在音质上更为清晰和高质量,但有时生成的歌曲与提示不太匹配;而Sunno在电子音乐和歌词创作方面表现更好,尽管音质和人声方面略逊一筹。最后,作者尝试了实验性的提示,发现Udio的手动模式对结果有显著影响。整体而言,Sunno适合电子音乐和歌词创作,Udio则在音质和清晰度上更胜一筹。作者鼓励观众分享自己的看法和使用体验,并决定哪款AI音乐生成器更优秀。

Takeaways

  • 🎶 **Sunno 和 Udio 都是音乐生成器,但 Udio 目前完全免费,而 Sunno 提供有限的免费计划和付费计划。
  • 💰 **Sunno 的免费计划每天提供 10 首歌曲生成,而 Udio 在测试阶段每月可以生成多达 1200 首歌曲。
  • 📈 **Sunno 的付费计划每月 10 美元,提供 500 首歌曲生成,并且可以商业使用,而 Udio 尚未推出付费计划。
  • 🔍 **Sunno 和 Udio 的用户界面非常相似,都允许用户创建播放列表和查看个人资料。
  • 🔒 **两个工具都默认将生成的音乐设为私有,但可以轻松切换为公开或链接分享。
  • 🎵 **在自动模式下,Udio 生成的音乐在质量和匹配度上似乎比 Sunno 更好。
  • 🎧 **Sunno 在自定义模式下表现更好,尤其是在生成特定风格的歌词方面。
  • 🎼 **在器乐特性测试中,Udio 生成的音乐比 Sunno 更具动态性和不重复性。
  • 📞 **在实验性提示方面,Sunno 和 Udio 都没有很好地捕捉到“电话铃声”的概念,但 Udio 的手动模式对结果有显著影响。
  • 📉 **Sunno 在电子音乐和歌词创作方面表现更好,而 Udio 在音质和清晰度方面更胜一筹。
  • 📝 **视频作者认为 Sunno 适合电子音乐和歌词创作,而 Udio 在音质上更胜一筹,但可能在匹配用户提示方面有所不足。
  • ✉️ **作者邀请观众分享他们对这两个音乐生成器的看法,并讨论他们自己的使用体验。

Q & A

  • 在比较Sunno和Udio时,作者认为哪个音乐生成器在免费计划中更胜一筹?

    -作者认为在免费计划中,Udio更胜一筹,因为它每月可以生成450首歌曲,比Sunno的免费计划更灵活,并且可以一次性生成更多歌曲,而不是每天限制在五次生成。

  • Sunno的付费计划有哪些优势?

    -null

  • Udio目前是否提供付费计划?

    -截至作者录制视频时,Udio还没有付费计划,因为它仍处于测试阶段,完全免费。但作者预计一旦Udio推出付费计划,当前的免费限制可能会减少。

  • 在用户界面方面,Sunno和Udio有哪些主要区别?

    -Udio在顶部始终显示生成栏,而Sunno只有在创建页面上才有。Sunno有主页、库、探索和发现等功能,而Udio则有类似的功能,但信息显示在右上角,并且提供了更多的文档。

  • 作者提到了哪些关于生成的音乐作品的隐私设置?

    -在Sunno和Udio中,所有的生成都是默认私密的。如果用户想要公开作品,可以点击切换按钮,使其变为公开,也可以通过链接分享,或者将其移动到垃圾箱并清空。

  • 在自动模式下,作者对Sunno和Udio生成的音乐有何评价?

    -在自动模式下,作者认为Udio生成的音乐在匹配提示和歌词方面比Sunno更好。

  • 作者在进行更复杂的提示测试时,Sunno和Udio的表现如何?

    -在进行更复杂的提示测试时,Sunno生成的歌曲《speeding Ducks》在作者看来听起来不错,但并不惊人。而Udio生成的《ducks and drive》则在New Wave Rock风格和歌词方面表现得更好。

  • 在自定义模式下,Sunno和Udio对特定提示的反应有何不同?

    -在自定义模式下,Sunno能够很好地将用户提供的歌词和风格(如Citron techno)融入到生成的音乐中。而Udio在尝试相同的提示时,由于可能的版权问题,未能生成相应的音乐,并且在手动模式下生成的音乐与提示不匹配。

  • 作者对Sunno和Udio生成的器乐音乐有何评价?

    -作者认为Udio生成的器乐音乐更好,因为它们不那么重复,具有更多的老派嘻哈节奏感和动态性。相比之下,Sunno生成的器乐音乐则较为简单和重复。

  • 在实验性提示方面,Sunno和Udio的表现如何?

    -在实验性提示方面,Sunno生成的音乐听起来像是一个糟糕的手机铃声,而Udio在标准模式下生成的音乐则与电话铃声相去甚远。在Udio的手动模式下,生成的音乐仍然不符合电话铃声的预期。

  • 作者认为Sunno和Udio在哪些方面各有优势?

    -作者认为Sunno在电子音乐和歌词创作方面表现更好,生成的音乐能够很好地匹配给定的提示,但音质和人声部分还有待提高。而Udio在音质方面表现更出色,生成的音乐清晰且高质量,但有时生成的音乐与给定的提示不完全匹配。

  • 观众如何可以表达他们对视频和音乐生成器的看法?

    -观众可以通过在视频下方留言,分享他们对Sunno和Udio生成的音乐的看法,以及他们自己的使用体验。如果他们觉得视频有帮助,也可以通过订阅频道和点赞来支持作者。

Outlines

00:00

🎼 音乐生成器对比:sunno AI vs udio

在这段视频中,作者对sunno AI和udio两个音乐生成器进行了比较。首先,他讨论了两者的定价策略,提到sunno AI和udio都有免费计划,用户可以免费生成歌曲。尽管udio目前处于测试阶段,完全免费,但作者预计一旦推出付费计划,免费生成的歌曲数量可能会减少。对于sunno AI,作者提到了其付费Pro计划,该计划每月收费10美元,提供每月500首歌曲的生成额度,并且可以商业使用。接下来,作者比较了两个平台的用户界面和功能,包括创建播放列表和歌曲的隐私设置。最后,通过几个音乐生成的实例,作者展示了两个平台在生成音乐时的不同表现,包括自动模式和自定义模式下的结果,以及它们在处理复杂提示和实验性提示时的差异。

05:04

🎵 sunno AI与udio音乐生成效果对比

作者通过几个不同的音乐提示,比较了sunno AI和udio在音乐生成上的效果。在第一个例子中,作者提到udio生成的音乐更符合提示,并且歌词听起来更好。在第二个例子中,尽管sunno AI提供了直接的提示,但作者认为udio生成的“ducks and drive”听起来更符合新浪潮摇滚风格,且音质更清晰。然而,当作者在sunno AI上使用自定义模式并输入特定歌词和风格时,sunno AI生成的音乐质量更高,而udio则因识别到著名歌词而未能生成。在没有歌词的器乐部分,作者认为udio生成的器乐音乐更好,因为它们不那么重复,具有更多的动态变化。

10:06

📱 实验性音乐提示的生成效果

作者尝试了使用实验性提示“telephone ringing”在sunno AI和udio上生成音乐。在sunno AI上,生成的音乐听起来像是一个质量较差的手机铃声。而在udio上,生成的音乐听起来并不像电话铃声,更像是一个环境音景。作者还提到了udio的一个特色功能——手动模式,该模式允许用户不经过平台的提示重写直接生成音乐。尽管手动模式对结果有显著影响,但作者发现即使是手动模式下,生成的音乐也与预期的电话铃声相差甚远。最后,作者总结了sunno AI在电子音乐和歌词生成方面的优势,而udio则在音质上更胜一筹,尽管有时生成的音乐与给定的提示不完全匹配。

Mindmap

Keywords

💡音乐生成器

音乐生成器是一种利用人工智能技术自动创作音乐的软件工具。在视频中,音乐生成器是主要讨论的主题,特别是比较了两个不同的音乐生成器:Sunno和Udio。

💡Sunno

Sunno是一个音乐生成器,它允许用户通过输入提示来生成歌曲。在视频中,Sunno被用来与Udio进行比较,展示了其在电子音乐和歌词创作方面的优势。

💡Udio

Udio是另一个音乐生成器,目前处于测试阶段,完全免费。视频中提到Udio在音质清晰度和生成速度方面优于Sunno,但在某些特定风格如Techno音乐的生成上不如Sunno。

💡定价

定价是视频中讨论的一个关键点,比较了Sunno和Udio的免费计划以及Sunno的付费计划。Sunno的付费计划提供了更多的歌曲生成次数和商业使用权。

💡用户体验

用户体验指的是用户与产品交互时的感受,视频中提到了Sunno和Udio的用户界面设计,以及它们如何影响用户生成音乐的过程。

💡自动模式

自动模式是指用户只需输入提示,音乐生成器就会自动创作音乐的一种操作方式。在视频中,自动模式被用于快速生成音乐样本以进行比较。

💡自定义模式

自定义模式允许用户输入特定的风格和歌词来生成音乐。视频中提到,使用自定义模式可以更精确地控制生成的音乐风格和内容。

💡商业使用权

商业使用权是指用户可以将其生成的音乐用于商业目的的权利。Sunno的付费计划提供了这一权利,而Udio目前尚未提供。

💡生成限制

生成限制是指用户在使用免费计划时可以生成的音乐数量的限制。视频中提到Udio的免费计划提供了大量的生成次数,但预计未来会有所减少。

💡音质

音质是指音乐生成器输出的音乐的听觉质量。在视频中,音质是评价Sunno和Udio性能的一个重要标准,Udio在音质方面被认为优于Sunno。

💡实验性

实验性指的是尝试新的或非传统的音乐生成方法。视频中提到了使用实验性提示,如“电话铃声”,来测试音乐生成器的创造性和多样性。

Highlights

sunno AI 和 udio 是两款音乐生成器,作者将对它们进行比较以决定哪个更好。

两款音乐生成器都有免费计划,用户可以在不付费的情况下生成歌曲。

udio 目前完全免费,因为仍处于测试阶段,每月可以生成多达1200首歌曲。

sunno 的免费计划每天提供50个积分,每首歌曲消耗5个积分,因此每天最多可以生成10首歌曲。

作者因为想要一次性生成多首歌曲而选择了 sunno 的付费计划。

sunno 的付费计划提供每月500首歌曲,可以商业使用,并且有优先生成队列。

udio 的用户界面与 sunno 类似,但在 udio 中,生成栏始终位于顶部。

在 sunno 中,所有生成的音乐默认是私有的,用户可以选择将其公开。

udio 也提供了类似的隐私控制,用户可以发布或取消发布自己的音乐。

作者通过几个不同的提示对两款音乐生成器进行了测试,以比较它们的生成质量。

在自动模式下,udio 生成的音乐在匹配提示和歌词方面似乎更胜一筹。

sunno 在生成特定风格的音乐,如电子音乐时,表现得更好,尽管声乐部分和音质可能不如 udio。

在实验性提示下,sunno 生成了更符合预期的音乐,而 udio 则出现了内容不匹配的问题。

在器乐特性测试中,udio 生成的音乐更加动态,不重复,而 sunno 的音乐则相对简单。

作者发现 udio 的手动模式可以显著影响生成结果,可能绕过了某些自动重写提示的机制。

作者认为 sunno 在电子音乐和歌词创作方面更胜一筹,而 udio 在音质和清晰度方面更优秀。

作者邀请观众分享他们对这两款音乐生成器的看法和使用体验。

Transcripts

00:00

sunno AI was in my opinion the best

00:01

music generator until a few days ago

00:03

when it competition showed up udio so

00:06

today I want to compare sunno versus

00:08

udio to see which is the best music

00:09

generator and I'm going to be comparing

00:11

the two bar for bar pound

00:13

[Music]

00:14

intended is the

00:16

best

00:18

Generator First we're going to be

00:20

starting with the pricing then we want

00:21

to talk about the features and the user

00:23

experience and then I want to show you

00:24

guys a bunch of prompts so you guys can

00:26

decide which one is best because I think

00:28

there are some pros and cons to both but

00:30

with that being said let's get started

00:31

with the most important pricing first of

00:34

all they both have free plans and you

00:35

can generate songs on both for free and

00:37

udio doesn't actually yet have a paid

00:39

plan it's entirely free for now because

00:42

it's still in beta so it's 100% free

00:44

there's no way you could actually give

00:45

the money if you wanted to but that's

00:46

likely to change in the near future of

00:48

course as soon as it's out of beta but

00:49

right now with udio you can generate up

00:51

to 1,200 songs a month every time you

00:54

generate a prompt it does two songs so

00:57

you get 600 Generations a month and the

00:59

fact that you can already get so much

01:00

for free again will probably also change

01:02

once they have a paid plan I'm sure

01:03

these limits will be reduced now looking

01:05

ato's free plan you get 50 credits that

01:08

renewed daily and it costs five credits

01:09

per song so you do get 10 songs a day

01:12

but again every prompt generates two

01:14

songs just like with udio so technically

01:16

you get five generations a day if you

01:18

add this all up it adds to about 150

01:20

Generations a month for 300 songs but to

01:22

get the maximum amount of songs a month

01:24

with sunno you'd have to use your five

01:25

generations every day which you most

01:27

likely won't do the reason I started

01:29

paying for Sun you know before audio

01:30

actually came out is because I wanted to

01:32

do 20 songs and 20 Generations at a time

01:34

I didn't want to have to wait and spread

01:36

it across 4 days because you rarely get

01:38

the exact song you want or that you need

01:41

with the first generation and speaking

01:43

of paid plan I'm actually on the $10 a

01:45

month Pro Plan and I'm paying monthly

01:47

and the reason is is because I get 500

01:48

songs a month which would equal to about

01:50

250 generations and I can also then use

01:53

this music commercially which means I

01:55

can use it in my videos and then

01:56

monetize them and you also get priority

01:58

generation queue but I haven't really

02:00

notice too much of a difference and then

02:01

the final thing is you can run up to 10

02:03

jobs at once compared to just doing two

02:05

but I rarely generate multiple songs at

02:08

the same time I think the max I've done

02:09

maybe is two just because I like to hear

02:12

what I got from the first prom before

02:13

giving it another one and soon those

02:15

Generations have never taken more than

02:17

30 seconds Max I think whereas udio is

02:20

actually a lot slower but I'll get to

02:21

that in a minute but if we had to

02:22

compare udio to sunno on just the free

02:25

plans in my opinion udio wins because

02:27

you can get 450 songs more a month mon

02:30

than sunos free plan and you've got way

02:32

more flexibility because you can

02:33

generate a bunch at a time instead of

02:35

being limited to five generations a day

02:37

but again likely to change however when

02:39

it comes to the pay plan sunno wins

02:40

because udio doesn't yet have one and

02:42

the pay plan with sunno gives you

02:45

commercial rights which udio you don't

02:48

actually have yet so I'll be curious to

02:50

know what audio's paid plans look like

02:52

and now when you sign up to the tools

02:54

they're both very similar this is sunno

02:55

you've got the menu bar on the top left

02:58

and then if we take a look at udio we've

02:59

also got got the menus here on the top

03:01

left the biggest difference is on udio

03:03

you have the generation bar at the top

03:04

at all times compared to sunno you have

03:06

to be on the create page but then you've

03:08

also got home library and explore and

03:11

here you've also got discover and then

03:13

like songs and then down here you've got

03:14

your playlists because on both you can

03:16

create your own playlists if you want to

03:18

see your profile on sunno it's down in

03:20

the bottom left and you've got some

03:21

other tabs you can also see your credit

03:23

consumption and then on audio all of

03:25

this information is actually on the top

03:26

right and you've also got a bunch of

03:27

documentation Etc right here but you're

03:29

notice if I click on pricing as you can

03:31

see it's currently in beta so it's all

03:33

free now one thing I do like about both

03:35

tools is that all generations are

03:36

private by default so for an example as

03:39

you can see here they are all private if

03:40

I did want to make one public I can just

03:42

click toggle and then it becomes public

03:44

but I can just quickly switch that off

03:46

right now and as you can see it's now

03:48

link only so I can share it and I can

03:50

also delete them I can move it to trash

03:52

and then I have to go and empty my trash

03:53

on audio it's a pretty similar

03:54

experience if I wanted to publish one I

03:57

just click publish and then if I want to

03:59

unpublish it I just click unpublish but

04:01

enough about the actual user interface

04:03

let's compare some of the results and

04:05

every time I'm going to put about a 5 to

04:07

10 second stipp of the song and we're

04:08

going to compare them both side by side

04:10

so now the first generation I did was

04:12

this one right here on both the prompt I

04:15

used was realm of melodic Tranquility WP

04:18

and for this one I was on automatic mode

04:22

so essentially I just put in the prompt

04:24

and click create and on audio same thing

04:26

here I just click autogenerated put in

04:28

the prompt and click create so these are

04:30

the automatic settings side by side and

04:32

now if we take a listen here

04:36

through Melodies

04:40

mys I don't think that sounds amazing

04:43

wondering through the CLS I

04:47

my sounds okay but if we go to udio give

04:50

these two a

04:55

listen you D now so I don't know

04:59

[Music]

05:03

realm of calm where my thoughts compos

05:06

like Whispers see here they sound much

05:08

better on udio in my opinion I think it

05:10

matches the prompt a lot better and the

05:13

lyrics sound better so for the second

05:15

one I decided to do a prompt that was a

05:17

little bit more complex and from sunno

05:19

we got the song called speeding Ducks

05:20

and the prompt here was New Wave rock

05:22

song about driving fast down the highway

05:24

with a fleet of ducks flying just above

05:26

you while feeling the breeze in your

05:28

hair and by the way I do want to mention

05:30

that I really like the fact that sunno

05:32

directly gives you the prompts on the

05:33

side you can get this from udio but you

05:35

actually have to click on the song just

05:37

like this but let's see what it sounds

05:40

like on

05:42

[Music]

05:52

sunno

05:55

feeling production

05:57

[Music]

06:00

good Generations but they don't sound

06:02

amazing now if we go to udio and we

06:04

listen to ducks and drive which I think

06:06

is a better name than speeding

06:09

[Music]

06:13

Ducks

06:15

Lan ducks a line a fleet and

06:23

flight accelerating

06:27

now the winds rushes all

06:30

around this to me sounds a little bit

06:32

more New Wave Rock and it also sounds

06:34

clearer I think the lyrics are better in

06:36

this one as well but remember I did say

06:39

that sunno wins in some areas compared

06:42

to udio so if we go back to sunno

06:45

because I think udio is winning quite a

06:46

lot right now here is the first song

06:49

where sunno Takes the Cake so for this

06:51

one what I decided to do if I just click

06:54

open is I actually used custom mode this

06:56

time and for the lyrics I entered eat

06:58

sleep r repeat which will sound familiar

07:00

for obvious reasons and then for the

07:03

style I actually input Citron techno and

07:05

now give these to a

07:07

[Music]

07:12

listen s repeat so use the lyrics there

07:16

and the next

07:17

[Music]

07:26

one so used the lyrics there as well and

07:29

I actually think these sound really good

07:31

but now if we go to udio again I did the

07:34

same things I put in pitron techno

07:37

obviously on custom mode and then we put

07:39

in Eat Sleep R repeat and what actually

07:41

happened is we got a moderation error

07:43

and I'm guessing is because udio picked

07:45

up the Eat Sleep Rave Repeat at already

07:47

very famous lyrics or it's I think the

07:50

name of the actual song as well and so

07:52

it couldn't generate it but what I ended

07:54

up doing is if I click on here is I just

07:57

changed it to beat Leap Day repeat so

08:01

very different and so these two songs

08:03

are supposed to be PID chance techno now

08:04

let's take a listen compared to the

08:06

sunno

08:22

ones I don't think either of these are

08:25

anywhere near as good as the pance

08:27

techno songs we got from sunno and it

08:30

doesn't also use the custom lyrics that

08:32

I input orbe it the lyrics were weird

08:35

sunno still Incorporated them into the

08:37

tracks here they don't in my opinion fit

08:39

the prompt and so now that we've done

08:41

lyric ones what I wanted to do is test

08:43

out the instrumental features so here

08:45

for the instrumental feature I decided

08:47

to go pretty simple and so here we've

08:49

got back to the classics the simple

08:52

prompt was rhythmic old school hip-hop

08:54

and obviously no lyrics because it's an

08:55

instrumental but let's take a listen

09:06

good but super simple nothing

09:08

[Music]

09:15

crazy good again super simple quite

09:17

repetitive nothing crazy but if we go

09:20

back to udio now let's take a listen to

09:23

these two right here

09:32

[Music]

09:46

so here I think these instrumentals are

09:48

better and the reason being is because

09:50

they're not as repetitive they've got

09:52

more of a feel to old school hip-hop

09:55

beats and they are a lot more Dynamic

09:58

basically so like I said they're lot

09:59

less repetitive you've got different

10:00

elements that come in and come out and

10:02

they're not just repeating the same four

10:03

bar so here for the instrumentals I

10:06

think that audio wins whereas going back

10:08

to the Techno and electronic music I

10:10

think sunos is a lot better and now the

10:12

last thing I wanted to try was something

10:14

quite experimental because I've seen

10:16

some people on Reddit with experimental

10:17

prompting and so here all I decided to

10:19

do was prompt telephone ringing and

10:22

let's go to sunno first and see what

10:24

this sounds like

10:27

[Applause]

10:36

okay so this was obviously set on

10:38

instrumental mode they kind of sounded

10:40

like one of those really bad ring tones

10:41

you get on a Samsung phone but if we go

10:44

to udio take a listen to

10:46

[Music]

10:51

this this doesn't sound like a telephone

10:53

ringing at all and then if we go to this

10:55

one

11:01

again it sounds like some ambient

11:02

soundscape even though it's supposed to

11:04

just be a telephone ringing and so what

11:06

I decided to do is on udio there's

11:08

actually this feature which is called

11:10

manual mode because basically udio

11:12

actually rewrites the prompts for you to

11:14

get better outputs so I decided to

11:17

toggle this on so the audio doesn't

11:19

rewrite the prompts for me okay and then

11:21

I put in the same thing so telephone

11:23

ringing and this is what we got

11:27

[Music]

11:35

doesn't sound like a telephone ringing

11:37

at all not quite sure where these

11:38

Generations are coming from but manual

11:39

mode seems to have a super big input on

11:43

the results and I'm guessing it almost

11:45

bypasses any of these so the results

11:48

what is the best AI music generator

11:49

first of all I'd love to hear what you

11:51

think but I think that sunno is good for

11:54

electronic music it comes up with some

11:56

good lyrics When You're prompting get a

11:58

song but the vocals in the songs don't

12:01

quite sound as good and these songs

12:03

don't sound super high quality however I

12:05

feel like they match the prompts that I

12:07

give it quite well but taking a look at

12:09

udio things sound super crisp super

12:12

clear super high quality honestly it's

12:14

pretty insane but I'm guessing there's a

12:16

lot of rewriting of the actual prompts

12:18

to get it to sound good and because of

12:20

that I often feel like the prompts that

12:22

I give it don't match the kind of song

12:26

that I'm trying to go for but it wins in

12:28

terms of quity but with that being said

12:30

I would love to know what do you guys

12:31

think what do you think of the

12:32

generations in this video have you tried

12:34

them and what do you think of the

12:35

results that you guys have been getting

12:36

and tell me between sunno and udio which

12:39

one do you think is the best AI music

12:41

generator you found this video helpful

12:42

you enjoyed it subscribe hit the like

12:44

button peace

Rate This

5.0 / 5 (0 votes)

العلامات ذات الصلة
AI音乐生成SunnoUdio音乐比较免费计划付费计划用户界面音乐质量音乐生成技术评测音乐制作
هل تحتاج إلى ملخص باللغة العربية؟