Midjourney vs Adobe Firefly 3 | Ultimate Comparison (Best AI Image Generator)

AI Catalyst
10 May 202408:12

TLDRIn this week's comparison, Adobe's latest AI image generator, Firefly 3, is pitted against Midjourney V6 to determine the best AI image generator. Firefly 3, currently in beta, introduces advanced capabilities like structure and style references, promising photorealistic results and a variety of styles. The comparison involves creating images in different styles using the same prompt for both generators. After evaluating photorealism, character portrayal, pop art style, pixel art, minimalist logos, anime style, and sepia effect, Midjourney V6 emerges as the winner with a score of 8 to 3. While Firefly 3 shows significant progress and delivers convincing photorealistic images, it falls short in certain areas such as anime style. Midjourney V6 is recognized for its exceptional photorealism and accuracy in character generation. Both tools have their strengths, with Firefly 3 being best utilized in Adobe Photoshop for editing and Midjourney V6 for its special model for anime style and overall versatility.

Takeaways

  • 🎨 Adobe's Firefly AI, known as Firefly Image 3, has been released with advanced options for stylization and photorealistic results.
  • 🚀 Firefly 3 introduces features like structure reference and style reference, similar to Midjourney, to align created images closely with the original concept.
  • 🌟 Firefly Image 3 promises improvements in rendering with better lighting, positioning, and a rich array of styles for illustrations and icons.
  • 📅 Firefly Image 3 is currently available in beta and accessible through the Firefly web application with both free and paid plans.
  • 💡 A comparison of images in different styles using the same prompt for Midjourney V6 and Adobe Firefly 3 will determine the better AI image generator.
  • 📌 In photorealism, Firefly closely matches Midjourney, resulting in a tie for this category.
  • 🤔 Both Firefly and Midjourney struggle with portraying multiple characters, but Midjourney generates characters more accurately.
  • 🎭 Both generators excel in pop art style, resulting in another tie.
  • 🧩 Firefly 3 still cannot create pixel art, unlike Midjourney V6, which performs well in this category.
  • 🏆 Midjourney is better at creating minimalist logos for brands.
  • 📈 Midjourney's anime style, even with the standard model, outperforms Firefly 3, which misses the mark completely.
  • 🎉 Midjourney wins the comparison with a score of 8 to 3, showcasing its strength in image generation.
  • 📈 Firefly Image 3 shows good progress but still falls short of matching Midjourney's capabilities.

Q & A

  • What is the latest iteration of Adobe's AI image generator called?

    -The latest iteration of Adobe's AI image generator is called Firefly Image 3.

  • What are some of the capabilities introduced in Firefly Image 3?

    -Firefly Image 3 introduces capabilities like structure reference, style reference, improved rendering of photographic quality including better lighting and positioning, and a rich array of styles for illustrations and icons.

  • How is Firefly Image 3's photorealism compared to Midjourney V6?

    -Firefly Image 3 delivers surprisingly convincing photorealistic results that closely match Midjourney V6, leading to a tie in the comparison.

  • Which AI image generator performed better in portraying multiple characters?

    -Midjourney V6 performed better in portraying multiple characters more accurately with fewer artifacts and old details.

  • What is the current availability of Firefly Image 3?

    -Firefly Image 3 is currently available in beta and can be accessed through the Firefly web application with options for both free and paid plans. It is also available in the better version of Adobe Photoshop.

  • How does Domo AI differ from Firefly Image 3 and Midjourney V6?

    -Domo AI offers a range of features for creating stunning artwork, including transforming videos into anime styles, generating images from text prompts, animating photos, and turning anime styles into realistic images. It also allows users to own and freely use their creations.

  • Which AI image generator had a better performance in creating pixel art?

    -Midjourney V6 performed better in creating pixel art, while Firefly Image 3 still cannot create pixel art like previous versions of Midjourney.

  • Who scored a point for creating minimalist logos for brands?

    -Midjourney V6 scored a point for being much better at creating minimalist logos for brands.

  • How did the anime style compare between Firefly Image 3 and Midjourney V6?

    -Firefly Image 3 missed the mark on the anime style, whereas Midjourney V6, even with its standard model, delivered great results, including a special model for anime style called 'nii'.

  • Which AI image generator was more convincing with the sepia effect and the overall feel of an old photo?

    -Midjourney V6 was more convincing with the sepia effect and the overall feel of an old photo, earning the final point in the comparison.

  • Who won the comparison between Midjourney V6 and Firefly Image 3?

    -Midjourney V6 won the comparison with a score of 8 to 3.

  • What is the current state of Firefly Image 3 in terms of image generation compared to Midjourney V6?

    -Firefly Image 3 shows good progress over Firefly 2 but cannot quite match Midjourney V6 in terms of image generation yet. However, it can produce very convincing photorealistic images and is best used in Adobe Photoshop for editing.

Outlines

00:00

🎨 Firefly Image 3 vs Mid Journey V6: AI Image Generation Showdown

Adobe's latest AI image generator, Firefly Image 3, is compared against Mid Journey V6. Firefly 3 introduces advanced features such as structure and style references, aiming to create images with high quality and detail. The comparison involves creating images in different styles using the same prompts for both generators. Points are awarded based on performance, with the highest score determining the winner. Firefly 3 is available in beta and can be accessed through its web application or Adobe Photoshop. In the photo realism style, both Firefly and Mid Journey V6 perform well, resulting in a tie. However, Mid Journey V6 outperforms Firefly 3 in generating multiple characters with fewer artifacts and more accurate details. The pop art style is a tie, but Firefly 3 struggles with pixel art, while Mid Journey V6 does better. Domo AI is also introduced as an alternative AI for creating artwork, offering features like transforming videos into anime styles and generating images from text prompts.

05:02

🏆 Mid Journey V6 Wins the AI Image Generation Face-off

In the minimalist logo creation, Mid Journey V6 is favored over Firefly Image 3, earning it a point. The anime style is a failure for Firefly, while Mid Journey V6, even without its specialized anime model, delivers great results, securing another point. Both generators handle certain tasks well, but Mid Journey V6 is more convincing with the sepia effect and the feel of an old photo, earning the final point. The overall winner is Mid Journey V6 with a score of 8 to 3. Firefly Image 3 shows progress but still falls short of Mid Journey V6 in image generation. It is best utilized in Adobe Photoshop for editing and enhancing images. The video concludes with a teaser about the future of this technology and a reminder to follow for updates on their website and YouTube channel.

Mindmap

Keywords

💡AI image generator

An AI image generator is a software application that uses artificial intelligence to create images based on user input or prompts. In the context of the video, it refers to the comparison between Adobe Firefly 3 and Midjourney, which are both AI-driven tools designed to generate images with varying styles and levels of detail.

💡Photo realism

Photo realism in the context of image generation refers to the ability of an AI to create images that closely resemble real-life photographs. The video discusses the photo realism capabilities of both Firefly 3 and Midjourney, noting that Firefly 3 delivers convincing photorealistic results, especially when compared to Midjourney.

💡Structure reference

Structure reference is a feature in AI image generation that allows the AI to maintain the structural integrity of the objects or scenes it is generating. The script mentions that Firefly 3 introduces capabilities like structure reference, which helps in creating images that align closely with the original concepts.

💡Style reference

Style reference is a tool within AI image generators that enables the AI to mimic or incorporate specific artistic styles into the generated images. The video script discusses how Firefly 3 provides style reference tools to create images with a rich array of styles for illustrations and icons.

💡Rendering

Rendering in the context of image generation is the process of generating a final image from a 2D or 3D model. The video mentions improvements in rendering photographic quality in Firefly 3, including better lighting and positioning.

💡Artistic Styles

Artistic styles refer to the various visual aesthetics or techniques used in creating images. The video compares the performance of Firefly 3 and Midjourney across different artistic styles such as photo realism, pop art, pixel art, minimalist logos, and anime style.

💡Pop art

Pop art is an artistic style that uses popular culture and everyday subjects as its imagery. The script notes that both generators perform well in capturing the aesthetic and style of pop art, resulting in a tie for this category.

💡Pixel art

Pixel art is a form of digital art where images are created on the pixel level, often resulting in a blocky, low-resolution appearance. The video points out that neither Firefly 3 nor previous versions of Midjourney can create pixel art effectively, with Midjourney V6 performing better but still having drawbacks.

💡Minimalist logos

Minimalist logos are simple, clean, and often geometric designs used to represent a brand or company. The video states that Midjourney is better at creating minimalist logos, which is an important aspect for branding purposes.

💡Anime style

Anime style refers to the visual art style commonly used in Japanese animation and comic books. The script mentions that Firefly 3 fails to generate anime-style images, while Midjourney has a special model for anime style and performs well even with its standard model.

💡Sepia effect

The sepia effect is a color grading technique that gives images a brownish tone, often used to give a vintage or old photo appearance. The video discusses how Midjourney was more convincing in achieving the sepia effect and the overall feel of an old photo.

Highlights

Adobe has released a new iteration of their AI image generator, Firefly AI, known as Firefly Image 3, aimed at improving image quality and detail with advanced stylization options.

Firefly Image 3 introduces capabilities like structure and style reference, similar to Midjourney, for creating images that align closely with original concepts.

The new version promises improvements in rendering photographic quality with better lighting, positioning, and a variety of styles for illustrations and icons.

Firefly Image 3 is available in beta and can be accessed through the Firefly web application with both free and paid plans.

Adobe Photoshop's advanced version also includes Firefly Image 3 for image generation.

A comparison will be made between Midjourney V6 and Adobe Firefly 3 using the same prompts to evaluate their performance.

In photorealism, Firefly closely matches Midjourney, resulting in a tie for this category.

Midjourney outperforms Firefly in generating multiple characters more accurately with fewer artifacts.

Both generators excel in pop art style, resulting in another tie.

Midjourney V6 is better at creating pixel art compared to Firefly 3, which still cannot create pixel art.

Midjourney is favored for creating minimalist logos for brands in the simple style category.

Firefly 3 fails to generate anime style, whereas Midjourney has a special model for it and delivers great results.

Both generators handle the sepia effect and old photo feel well, but Midjourney is more convincing.

Midjourney wins the comparison with a score of 8 to 3, showcasing its strength in image generation.

Firefly Image 3 shows progress over its predecessor but still cannot match Midjourney's capabilities.

Firefly is best used in Adobe Photoshop for editing and refining certain parts of the image.

Combining Midjourney with Photoshop's generative AI can help edit images and remove unnecessary details.

The technology is expected to evolve, with updates and advancements to be shared on the website and YouTube channel.

Casual Browsing

Midjourney vs DALL·E 3 | Ultimate Comparison (Best AI Image Generator)

2024-03-30 18:00:02

Adobe Firefly 2 vs Midjourney - Same Prompt Comparison

2024-04-20 18:15:01

Adobe Firefly vs. Midjourney v5 - Same Prompt Comparison

2024-04-20 19:00:00

Adobe Firefly 3 VS Midjourney: Prompt Battle & Full-Review

2024-05-03 03:15:01

Midjourney vs. DALLE 3 vs. Adobe Firefly: Identical Prompts, Who Wins?

2024-04-02 04:10:01

Is Midjourney still best AI image generator in 2024? Comparison vs main rivals

2024-07-20 14:59:00