Microsoft Windows Wants To Record Your Screen...
Summary
TLDRThe video script discusses concerns about Microsoft's AI advancements, particularly the 'Microsoft co-pilot plus PC' feature that records user activities. The speaker expresses distrust in Microsoft and highlights the potential privacy issues with AI functionalities like 'recall,' which can store snapshots of user actions on their device. The script also touches on Microsoft's investment in AI, the introduction of new hardware like the Processing Unit (NPU) for AI acceleration, and the security features of their new system architecture. The speaker advocates for Linux as an alternative to Windows due to privacy concerns and concludes by questioning the necessity of such AI features in everyday computing.
Takeaways
- ๐ค Microsoft has announced an AI feature that records user activities on the computer, raising privacy concerns.
- ๐ง The AI feature is part of Microsoft's 'Co-pilot' system, which is integrated into Windows 11 and provides various AI-driven functionalities.
- ๐ก Co-pilot Plus Computers are designed to be more powerful and efficient for running AI workloads, with specific hardware to assist the system.
- ๐ป The recall feature allows users to look back at their activities on a specific day, similar to a time machine for computer usage.
- ๐ก๏ธ Microsoft claims that the data for the recall feature is processed locally and not uploaded to the cloud, aiming to address privacy concerns.
- ๐ผ Microsoft has invested heavily in AI, with over $11.3 billion into OpenAI, indicating a strong commitment to integrating AI into their products.
- ๐ฎ AI is being utilized in various Microsoft products, including video games and other applications, to enhance user experience.
- ๐ The Pluton security processor is mentioned as a means to secure systems and keep them up to date, suggesting a focus on security.
- ๐ฑ The script discusses the shift towards ARM processors in computing devices, which could lead to more efficient and longer-lasting systems.
- ๐ The script also mentions the potential for encrypted snapshots and user control over what is recorded, stored, and deleted on their devices.
- ๐ There is skepticism and distrust expressed towards Microsoft and its handling of user privacy, suggesting a preference for alternative operating systems like Linux.
Q & A
What is Microsoft's AI feature that has raised privacy concerns?
-Microsoft's AI feature that has raised privacy concerns is called 'recall', which allows users to look back at their activities on a specific day, effectively recording everything done on the computer.
What is the main purpose of Microsoft's co-pilot feature?
-The main purpose of Microsoft's co-pilot feature is to provide an AI assistant that can generate images, search for information, and perform various tasks related to the Windows operating system, aiming to make the user's experience more efficient and interactive.
How does Microsoft plan to integrate AI into its products and services?
-Microsoft plans to integrate AI by embedding it into its operating systems, using it in video games, and even creating specific hardware accelerators known as npu (neural processing units) to assist with AI computations and improve performance.
What is the significance of the npu in Microsoft's AI strategy?
-The npu, or neural processing unit, is significant in Microsoft's AI strategy as it is designed to accelerate the calculations and computations needed for AI software, allowing for more powerful and efficient AI workloads directly on the device.
How does Microsoft ensure the security of the data collected by the recall feature?
-Microsoft claims that the data collected by the recall feature is stored entirely on the user's device, not uploaded to the cloud. It is processed locally, and users have control over deleting individual snapshots or adjusting and deleting ranges of time.
What is the role of the Pluton security processor in Microsoft's AI-enabled computers?
-The Pluton security processor is designed to protect the systems and ensure that everything stays up to date, providing a secure environment for the operation of AI features like co-pilot and recall.
What is the 'prism' feature mentioned in the script, and how does it relate to AI in Microsoft's systems?
-The 'prism' feature is an emulator that allows x86 software to run on ARM processors. This is important for AI in Microsoft's systems as it ensures compatibility and smooth operation of AI workloads and applications on different types of processors.
Why might some users be skeptical about Microsoft's claims regarding local processing and privacy?
-Some users might be skeptical because of past experiences with Microsoft's data handling and privacy practices. They may also be concerned about potential security breaches that could expose locally stored data, despite encryption measures.
What alternatives to Microsoft's AI features are suggested in the script for users concerned about privacy?
-The script suggests using Linux as an alternative to Microsoft's AI features for users concerned about privacy. It mentions that Linux is user-friendly and can serve as a daily driver for many tasks, including gaming.
How does the script's author view the future of AI integration in Microsoft's products?
-The author views the future of AI integration in Microsoft's products with skepticism, predicting that as hardware and software requirements evolve, privacy concerns will grow, and users may need to consider alternative operating systems like Linux.
Outlines
๐จ Concerns Over Microsoft's AI Surveillance Capabilities
The speaker expresses concern over Microsoft's announcement of an AI system that records user activities on their computer, likening it to a surveillance camera rather than artificial intelligence. The discussion centers around Microsoft's 'Co-Pilot' feature in Windows 11, which includes a chatbot for generating images and searching for information. The speaker is particularly worried about the 'recall' feature, which allows users to revisit their past activities on the computer. While Microsoft claims that all data is processed locally and not uploaded to the cloud, the speaker remains skeptical and suggests that this could lead to privacy issues. The speaker also mentions Microsoft's significant investment in AI, particularly its partnership with OpenAI, and speculates about the future requirements and features of Microsoft's operating systems.
๐ค The Future of AI-Integrated Hardware and Privacy Concerns
The script delves into Microsoft's new system architecture that includes a Processing Unit (NPU) for AI acceleration, aiming to create powerful and secure Windows computers. It discusses the 'Co-Pilot Plus Computers' that are claimed to be significantly more powerful and efficient for AI workloads. The speaker also touches on the topic of architecture and emulation, mentioning 'prism', an emulator for x86 software on ARM processors. The focus then shifts to privacy concerns, with the speaker expressing distrust in Microsoft's assurance that the AI system operates locally and securely on the device. The potential for hacking and misuse of the stored data is highlighted, and the speaker suggests that switching to Linux might be a viable alternative for those concerned about privacy.
๐ก๏ธ Addressing Privacy and Security Features of Microsoft's AI
The speaker addresses the encryption and security measures that Microsoft has purportedly implemented to protect the data recorded by its AI system. They mention that snapshots are not taken during private browsing sessions or when DRM-protected content is being viewed. The script also notes that the 'recall' feature does not perform content moderation, meaning sensitive information like passwords could potentially be captured. The speaker advocates for the use of tools to disable telemetry and privacy-invasive features in Windows and suggests that users might consider switching to alternative operating systems like Linux if they are uncomfortable with Microsoft's approach to AI and privacy.
๐ญ The Debate Over Microsoft's AI Direction and User Trust
The final paragraph discusses a Reddit exchange where users share their efforts to secure and privatize their Windows systems, suggesting that the effort required to maintain privacy might indicate a lack of trust in the operating system. The speaker reflects on whether the risk and reward of using Microsoft's AI features are worth it, expressing a personal preference for not using Microsoft products due to their AI functionalities and potential privacy concerns. The speaker concludes by encouraging viewers to consider the implications of Microsoft's direction and to explore alternatives like Linux.
Mindmap
Keywords
๐กAI
๐กMicrosoft co-pilot
๐กDigital tape
๐กSurveillance camera
๐กOpen AI
๐กCo-pilot Plus Computers
๐กNPU
๐กPluton security processor
๐กARM processors
๐กRecall feature
๐กLinux
Highlights
Microsoft announces an AI that records everything you do on your computer, raising privacy concerns.
The speaker expresses distrust in Microsoft and Windows, citing privacy as a primary concern.
Introduction of Microsoft Co-Pilot Plus PC, an AI integrated into Windows 11.
Co-Pilot is a chatbot in Windows 11 for generating images, searching, and other tasks.
Microsoft's investment of over $1 billion in AI, particularly with OpenAI.
AI integration in Microsoft products beyond the operating system, such as in video games.
Microsoft's Recall feature allows users to look back at their computer activity on specific days.
Local processing of AI, avoiding the need for data upload to the cloud.
New system architecture with CPU, GPU, and an AI accelerator called the Processing Unit (NPU).
Co-Pilot Plus Computers are claimed to be 20 times more powerful and 100 times more efficient for AI workloads.
Pluton security processor ensures systems are protected and up-to-date.
PRISM technology for app compatibility with ARM processors, including an emulator for x86 software.
Local AI processing eliminates latency and keeps user data secure on the device.
Snapshots from the Recall feature are stored locally and can be managed by the user.
Concerns about potential hacking and misuse of locally stored data.
Recall will not snapshot private browsing sessions or DRM-protected content.
Tools like 'Shut Up 10' exist to disable telemetry and privacy-invading features in Windows.
The speaker advocates for Linux as a privacy-focused alternative to Windows.
Co-Pilot Plus PCs will be available in June from major OEMs, starting at around $1000.
AI functionalities like Recall may become standard in future versions of Windows.
Transcripts
oh hell yeah Microsoft announces an AI
that records everything you see and you
do on your computer who that's crazy man
you know when I say I don't use Windows
or I don't trust Microsoft this is one
of the reasons why I don't okay the last
thing I ever thought about was having a
digital tape running and recording every
single thing that I did on my computer
dog that ain't artificial intelligence
that's a videotape okay that's a
surveillance
camera now to understand I'm going to
sit here and demystify things because
I've seen a lot of people talk about
this in the last day because Microsoft
basically had a huge event where they
were showcasing Microsoft co-pilot plus
PC okay so for anybody that doesn't know
what co-pilot is it's basically
Microsoft AI if you use Windows 11
you'll probably notice in the bottom
right corner there's a little button
that you click on and it opens a cute
little chatbot and in that chat bot you
can use it to generate images ask it to
search things for you or do anything
windows related Microsoft really wants
you to use an artificial intelligence
dog they are installing Ed right to your
system okay so you can just basically
have a little AI pal that does
everything for you Microsoft is bringing
back [ย __ย ] clippy okay and they're
making sure it can do things like
removing backgrounds off of like images
and whatnot and of course this is
Microsoft's big uh push and it's one of
the reasons why utilizing Microsoft
operating systems going into the future
are going to have some kind of heft to
your requirements as compared to
previous releases okay this is like
using Windows Vista all the way from
Windows XP all of a sudden the
requirements jump up and Microsoft
introduces a whole slew of features a
lot of which most people really don't
give all that much of a care about so to
give you an idea Microsoft has put a lot
of money into artificial intelligence to
the point where they've poured more than
$1 13 billion into working with open AI
so Microsoft really wants artificial
intelligence to be like the future and
they're not just using it for again
Microsoft products well I guess
technically they are using it just for
Microsoft products but they're not just
using it for people in the operating
system space for instance they're using
it to actually use inside things like
video games for instance so AI can
assist you while you play Microsoft
where it comes up with recipes or
identifies [ย __ย ] on screen so instead of
looking up a guide like we used to we
can just use our AI pal to tell us about
what the [ย __ย ] going on in the game
okay hey buddy tell me the best places
to grind in this RPG and it probably
will look up things for you now on the
surface this sounds kind of cool but
then you start peeking into some more of
their actual like AI features and one of
them is recall which has been getting
the internet kind of freaked out a
little bit so this is a 5-second clip
from Microsoft windows's like YouTube
channel where they showcase how recall
works so right here there's a bar at the
top that allows you to go all the way
from the current time to back to like
June 19 and inside this one application
which I believe is micros soft Edge they
can actually look back and see just what
they were doing on a specific day so
it's kind of like that time machine [ย __ย ]
from uh you know Apple where you could
like recover files that you deleted or
something here you're just looking at
stuff that you did on your computer now
maybe this is useful in some key ways
but there are people rightfully freaked
out about the fact that Microsoft is
straight up spying on them through their
computer now that's a bit of a misnomer
because to understand Microsoft is not
downloading this information as far as
they claim or uploading it to their
Cloud this is all supposed to be
processed locally so I decided I'm going
to read through exactly what Microsoft
said just so we can get the actual facts
and not the fear-mongering in the
situation so according to Microsoft what
this is is they want to build like the
newest most powerful most secure Windows
computers imaginable and to do that they
brought a new system architecture that
brings the power of the CPU the GPU and
something they call the Processing Unit
or the npu now for anybody that doesn't
know what an npu is these are like AI
accelerators so right now in order to
function with artificial intelligence we
need to have specific pieces of Hardware
that accelerate the type of calculations
and computations AI software needs so
Microsoft wants to implement this or at
least have it implemented in actual
pieces of Hardware so what they've said
is co-pilot Plus Computers can now
achieve a level of performance never
seen before they are up to 20 times more
powerful and 100 times as efficient for
running Ai workloads and delivering that
AI acceleration so they basically say it
outperforms Apple by 58% and like
multi-threaded performance blah blah
blah but the point is they have specific
Hardware to assist that co-pilot system
that they have bundled with Microsoft
systems going in forward they've also
said all of this [ย __ย ] comes secured out
of the box meaning that their pluton
security processor is going to protect
systems and make sure that everything
stays up to date and if you're wondering
about architecture and emulation and
compatibility Microsoft also talks about
something known as prism where if your
apps don't work underneath arm
processors which is what the processor
for this is then they will have an
emulator that from my understanding
converts x86 software to arm if you have
things like video games or specific
applications it will work underneath
their operating system so it's kind of
cool stuff to come around it seems like
the world at least as far as OEM
Hardware where like laptop wise is
Shifting to arm processors which means
we're going to have like full day
battery lives more efficient systems
cooler systems so on and so forth in
fact most big computers one good example
is Apple their entire like desktop
laptop lineup the MacBooks the Mac Pros
they are all running arm-based chips M1
M2 M3 and soon M4 they're not even
touching x86 processors which is what
your gaming laptop gaming computer steam
desk deck Le Legion go whatever device
you have right now that you use to game
under in fact most of your desktop
devices now when looking at the
situation they said co-pilot computers
leverage powerful processors on their
systems and because of this they are
designed to run locally directly on the
device and that removes previous things
like latency which means instead of you
know opening up co-pilot and talking to
it and then having to send your input to
a server and send the result back all of
this can locally be processed on your
local system and you can kind of do this
today if you wanted to there are plenty
of tools like GPT for all where you can
get actual chat Bots running underneath
your actual computer right here in fact
there's Cobalt CPP which allows you to
again set up a web-based chatbot on your
local system you've got uaba all right
which is another text generation web UI
the names are kind of wild but if you
want to run a local AI you can download
all of these tools because the big
benefit of it is you don't actually send
your information out of your device it's
all running locally so you can you don't
have to worry about privacy or any of
any of that nonsense and that's kind of
the thing that Microsoft wants to bring
to the table Microsoft even made an
incredibly small but powerful model the
53 which allows from my understanding to
get this stuff running locally on a
device Microsoft doesn't want you to
offload the information to a server
because I assume it's going to be
cheaper for them down the road because
they don't have to worry about the
bandwidth stuff and it also means that
people can be given that sense of
security knowing that all of their
information runs locally on the device
which is ultimately a net benefit when
they talk about that recall feature they
said that all of the stuff is stored
entirely on your device your snapshots
are yours they stay locally on your PC
you can delete individual snapshots
adjust and delete ranges of time in
settings and pause at any point right
from the icon in the system tray on your
taskbar so you have I guess full control
and it's all locally stored and that's
what Microsoft says so you kind of have
to sit down and [ย __ย ] believe them at
their word okay now for me I don't trust
Microsoft I don't trust windows and
that's one of the reasons I put my money
where my mouth is okay I have been a
Linux user for years okay I've
specifically said I have used Linux
constantly I pretty much use this as my
daily driver in fact right now as I'm
playing this gaming underneath it
playing GTA 5 is something that you know
probably wouldn't have been possible
several years ago using Linux a daily
driver or something I've made videos on
from time to time I've shown it
literally months ago where I was
installing Linux Mint and showing people
literally how easy it was and it's
easier in some cases than using just
Windows right out of the box it's
intuitive it's gotten to the point where
I think most people who just play a few
games and they just us your system can
use Linux as they do Mac OS or Windows
you don't need to use Windows okay if
you're worried about Microsoft spying on
you switching to Linux is incredibly
easy but again I I really don't think
most people in this case are going to
care I think most people are still going
to use Microsoft despite constantly
tweeting and saying that oh they're
spying on us you have options you don't
have to specifically use them but
anyways let's get back to the meat and
potatoes at hand now these kind of
computers are currently not available
yet they will be available this June
from actual uh you know oems like Acer
Asus Dell HP Lenovo and Samsung and
these are these are computers that are
going to start at around 1,000 bucks
these devices are up to $200 less than
similar spec devices and I think they're
comparing them to like the iPads or you
know MacBooks or anything so here's
again a situation where it also comes
down to security as well for instance
Microsoft is saying this is going to be
secured locally on your device now
anything that is recording your system
okay and taking snapshots periodically
is data that you know people are
rightfully worried about could it be
hacked and hackers you know Ransom your
system exfiltrate this data and can now
look through your screenshots your
history and you know do nefarious things
with and from my understanding all right
and please correct me if I'm wrong a lot
of this information is supposed to be
encrypted relatively well so even if you
do get hacked and this information does
get stolen by a hacker hopefully it will
be secure enough and encrypted to the
point where hackers can't really do
anything with it and Microsoft still
says that you can turn this [ย __ย ] off for
now another cause for concern over here
is even though that this is specifically
for the Snapdragon X Series processors
right and again this is just the start
you know processors down the road even
if you're in the x86 Camp will probably
have to level out and the requirements
will probably have to be met by
Microsoft's oems down the road I don't
doubt this I don't actually feel this
won't be a thing that happens but of
course looking into what they've got
over here is they said recall will not
take snapshots of certain kinds of
content so including the private web
browsing sessions in Microsoft Edge and
anything that's protected with DRM like
Netflix application or Netflix movies or
any DRM protected video content it does
say that recall does not perform content
moderation so it will not hide info such
as passwords or financial account
numbers and that data may be in
snapshots that are stored on your device
so even if this is encrypted it's
probably ideal not to have the stored on
your device just again it's it's I don't
think this is something many people will
find any actual utility out of okay and
I don't think it's good to have screen
recordings of points where you're
dealing with tax information or anything
sensitive just stored on your device
even if it is encrypted and it's
supposed to stay on the system now again
this is Microsoft sort of like game and
it's because of this that you started to
have like actual tools like on and O's
shut up 10 Plus+ which is a anti-py tool
for Windows 10 and 11 that is designed
to turn off all of these Telemetry
features for Microsoft products in fact
they're entire free
private Zilla which allow you to turn
off all of these features that again
relate to privacy Microsoft's Cortana
bloatware and various app permissions I
think personally speaking if you are
using any [ย __ย ] operating system that
almost requires you to download tools
like this to cut down on the privacy and
spying that can potentially happen you
probably [ย __ย ] shouldn't use that
operating system right you probably
should switch to something that you can
trust this is a sign of people that have
no goddamn trust for their system and
you might be sitting here and saying but
muda I need Microsoft to do this
specific thing for me look at the end of
the day Linux is not far off from being
a daily driver pattern okay a lot of
people who game on things like the steam
deck have inadvertedly switched to Linux
saying that maybe it's not so bad it
actually feels a lot like Windows there
might be a learning curve there always
is to New pieces of software or Hardware
but typically by taxing yourself and
learning something you can freak
yourself from a lifetime of worrying
about you being spied on your privacy
being encroached on or your computer
effectively being turned into ashes just
because you don't meet some arbitrary
system requirement that Microsoft brings
in now there's going to be people who
say that obviously this is relegated
specifically to those co-pilot plus PCS
now again this is just for now down in
the future as AMD and Intel the
processors the companies that we use for
our big computers now are eventually
going to be matching up to spec so these
kind of tools are going to be part of
Windows and they're going to be in
everyone's life at some point down the
road when you use a future version of
Windows 11 or you update to something
like Windows 12 where this is just
basically caked into the system to begin
with so yeah these are Microsoft's AI
features and there are people that are
rightfully worried about Microsoft
recording everything you do because
that's what they're doing they are
effectively recording you and
screenshotting your system and if that
sounds creepy to you it probably is a
further extension of how you're thinking
privacy focused and it's probably
worthwhile switching off from Microsoft
products to Linux or something else look
I use Windows exclusively just to play
Rainbow Six Siege on that computer back
there I might occasionally use Windows
in a virtual machine just to play
certain games with enhanced graphical
features that aren't currently available
underneath Linux for now but
understanding Microsoft's place and the
future of their company
the last thing I ever want to do is use
Microsoft products I have no interest in
AI functionalities or dedicating pieces
of my actual computer hardware to AI
tasks like recall that I personally will
never use in any feature going forward
I'm not saying all AI is [ย __ย ] useful
there's some things in this entire thing
that I think are kind of cool but in
general I really don't think the the the
direction Microsoft is taking is
interesting me and many of other people
out there I think one of the important
like uh actual exchanges I've seen
regarding this topic was actually on
Reddit when one of the users primarily
was talking about running multiple tools
like shut up 10 on their system like
disabling updates and whatnot I think
it's actually quite impressive that
people will stick around with Windows
but go through the Hoops of getting rid
of critical updates sometimes uh
preventing features from being installed
and actually trying to stop Telemetry
between actual updates at that point you
should probably consider switching
because clearly your trust is not in the
system even under a virtual machine I
don't go through the excesses some of
these people do when trying to private
windows or secure it I guess for their
personal consumption so this is
something where you're going to have to
ask is the risk and a reward worth it
for me and I think for most people that
I talk to in this situation probably
doesn't seem that way but anyways if you
like what you saw please like comment
and subscribe dislike if dislike it I am
out
5.0 / 5 (0 votes)
Microsoft CEO on How New Windows AI Copilot+ PCs Beat Apple's Macs | WSJ
Oh, Snap
These new computers are getting creepyโฆ Copilot+ PC first look
HW News - Major Windows Privacy Concerns, Noctua's "New" Fan, AMD Epyc in AM5 Desktops
Microsoft Surface Copilot + PC Event: Everything Revealed in 13 Minutes
You Just Don't Get It