Lefties losing it: Rita Panahi slams Bill Maher as a ‘delusional Democrat’

Sky News Australia
23 May 202416:41

Summary

TLDRIn this video, the host critiques left-leaning political commentator Bill Maher for his views on election denial and climate change. The discussion includes a debate on Hillary Clinton's stance on the 2016 election, the validity of the Russian collusion narrative, and the selective enforcement of laws regarding classified documents. The show also covers the impact of climate change on black communities, the ESG movement's influence on the energy sector, and the challenges of relying on renewable energy sources. Guest Alex Epstein argues for a balanced approach to energy policy, emphasizing the need for wealth generation and reliable energy sources to address climate concerns effectively.

Takeaways

  • 📚 Bill Maher is criticized for either being ignorant or dishonest about election denial, with the claim that he misunderstands or misrepresents Hillary Clinton's stance on the 2016 election.
  • 🗳️ Hillary Clinton is accused of being the original election denier, having allegedly claimed that Trump's presidency was illegitimate and promoting the Russian collusion narrative.
  • 🤔 The discussion suggests that there is a debate over whether climate change disproportionately affects black people more than others, with some arguing that it's a class issue rather than a racial one.
  • 🌡️ The assistant secretary for health in the Biden Administration is said to have lectured on how global warming is affecting black communities, which some argue is an overemphasis on race.
  • 💡 Alex Epstein, author of 'Fossil Future', argues that climate change policies impact poor people more than any specific racial group, and that wealth creation is key to dealing with climate issues.
  • 📉 Shareholders at Shell rejected a climate change resolution, suggesting a pushback against ESG (Environmental, Social, and Governance) initiatives that some believe are detrimental to business.
  • 🛑 The script implies that ESG movements have been harmful, particularly to the oil and gas industry, and that there is a growing recognition of their negative impacts.
  • 🚫 There is a critique of the idea that solar and wind power can provide reliable energy, with the suggestion that they are not capable of doing so without relying on fossil fuels or nuclear power.
  • 💰 The Australian government's plan to become a battery manufacturing leader is questioned, with Epstein suggesting that current technology is not sufficient to provide reliable energy storage.
  • 🛠️ The script raises concerns about the feasibility and cost of transitioning to renewable energy sources, particularly the challenges associated with mining for materials needed for renewable technologies.
  • 🌐 The reliance on China for elements needed to make batteries is highlighted as a potential issue that may not be adequately considered in renewable energy plans.

Q & A

  • What is the main point of contention between Bill Maher and the host regarding election denial?

    -The main point of contention is whether Hillary Clinton can be considered an 'election denier'. The host argues that Clinton was the original election denier for her actions and statements following the 2016 election, while Maher seems to disagree or be unaware of Clinton's actions.

  • How does the host describe Bill Maher's understanding of Hillary Clinton's stance on the 2016 election?

    -The host suggests that Bill Maher is either 'wildly ignorant or dishonest' regarding Hillary Clinton's actions after the 2016 election, implying that Maher is either misinformed or intentionally misleading about Clinton's claims of an illegitimate presidency.

  • What is the host's view on the January 6th incident at the Capitol?

    -The host dismisses the idea that the January 6th incident was an 'insurrection', instead suggesting that the individuals involved did not break windows, knock down doors, or kill police officers, and that the death of Capitol police officer Brian Sicknick was due to natural causes.

  • What does the host believe is the truth about January 6th and the Capitol incident?

    -According to the host, there was no attack on the Capitol, no windows were broken, no doors knocked down, and no police officers were killed. The host also claims that Brian Sicknick, a Capitol police officer, died of natural causes as determined by the medical examiner.

  • What is the host's opinion on Megan Kelly's ability to educate Bill Maher about election denial?

    -The host believes that Megan Kelly is 'so much smarter, better informed, and better at her job than Maher', suggesting that Kelly was successful in educating Maher about election denial.

  • What is the argument made by the host regarding the selective enforcement of the law in the case of classified documents?

    -The host argues that there is a difference in the handling of classified documents between a sitting president who has the ability to declassify documents and a US senator who does not, implying that the latter's actions would be illegal.

  • What is the host's view on the ESG (Environmental, Social, and Governance) movement?

    -The host views the ESG movement as 'insidious' and believes it hurts oil companies and consumers by promoting the rapid elimination of fossil fuels without considering the need for cheap and reliable energy.

  • How does the host describe the recent shareholder's decision at Shell regarding climate change?

    -The host describes the decision as a 'win for common sense', as only 18% of shareholders backed a climate change resolution, indicating a rejection of the ESG movement's influence.

  • What is the host's opinion on the feasibility of batteries providing base load power for a first-world nation like Australia?

    -The host believes that with current technology, batteries are not capable of providing the necessary base load power for a first-world nation like Australia, as they are not reliable without depending on other energy sources.

  • What does the host think about the challenges and supply chain issues related to making large-scale batteries?

    -The host suggests that the challenges and supply chain issues related to making large-scale batteries are often not given due consideration, and there is a bias that amplifies the negatives of fossil fuels while downplaying the challenges of renewable energy sources.

Outlines

00:00

😠 Political Debate on Election Denial and Media Bias

The first paragraph discusses a political debate centered around the concept of election denial, particularly focusing on Bill Maher's recent media appearances to promote his book. The speaker criticizes Maher for either being ignorant or dishonest about the topic, highlighting a conversation with Megan Kelly where she attempts to educate him on the subject. The paragraph also delves into Hillary Clinton's role as an 'original election denier,' accusing her of undermining the 2016 election's legitimacy and promoting the Russian collusion narrative. The discussion extends to the events of January 6th, with the speaker challenging Maher's portrayal of the incident and emphasizing the importance of accurate reporting and understanding of political events.

05:00

🌍 Climate Change Impact and Energy Policy Debate

In the second paragraph, the focus shifts to climate change and its purported impact on black communities in the United States. The speaker challenges the notion that climate change disproportionately affects black people, arguing instead that economic status, not race, is the determining factor for susceptibility to climate-related health issues. The author of 'Fossil Future', Alex Epstein, is introduced to provide a counterargument, suggesting that wealth creation is the true solution to climate vulnerability. The paragraph also touches on the influence of ESG (Environmental, Social, and Governance) policies on the energy sector, with a shareholder rejection of a climate change resolution at Shell being highlighted as a positive sign against ESG's influence.

10:01

🔋 The Feasibility of Battery Technology for Energy Storage

The third paragraph delves into the topic of energy storage, particularly the role of batteries in supporting renewable energy sources like solar and wind. The speaker expresses skepticism about the ability of batteries to provide baseload power necessary for a developed nation like Australia. Epstein argues that current battery technology is not sufficient to handle the unreliability of solar and wind power without relying on traditional energy sources. The discussion also addresses the costs associated with nuclear energy versus renewable energy, with the speaker suggesting that there is a bias against nuclear power and an unrealistic optimism for solar and wind.

15:02

⚡ The Challenges of Scaling Renewable Energy and Battery Production

The final paragraph continues the conversation on renewable energy, emphasizing the challenges of scaling up solar and wind power, as well as battery production. The speaker points out the environmental and logistical issues related to mining for the materials needed to build batteries, highlighting the contradiction within the green movement that advocates for more mining to achieve 'green energy'. Epstein discusses the need for a realistic approach to energy production, suggesting that the current push for net-zero emissions is not considering the practical implications and costs associated with such a transition.

Mindmap

Keywords

💡Election Denial

Election denial refers to the refusal to accept the results of an election, often by alleging fraud or other irregularities without substantial evidence. In the video, it is mentioned that Hillary Clinton is accused of being an 'original election denier' for her alleged claims about the legitimacy of Donald Trump's presidency, suggesting that she contributed to narratives questioning the integrity of the 2016 U.S. presidential election.

💡Russian Collusion

Russian collusion in this context refers to the unproven allegations that the Trump campaign collaborated with the Russian government to interfere in the 2016 U.S. presidential election. The script implies that Hillary Clinton helped formulate and spread such conspiracies, which the speaker argues undermines democracy in the United States.

💡Insurrection

The term 'Insurrection' is used in the script to describe the events of January 6, 2021, at the U.S. Capitol. The speaker uses air quotes and a different term to suggest skepticism or disagreement with the mainstream narrative of the event being an insurrection, reflecting a contentious debate over the characterization of the incident.

💡Selective Enforcement of the Law

Selective enforcement of the law suggests that laws are applied or enforced in a biased manner, with some individuals or groups being treated differently from others. The script contrasts the treatment of two individuals regarding classified documents, implying that one was unfairly charged while another was not, due to their respective positions of power.

💡Climate Change Policy

Climate change policy refers to government actions and regulations aimed at mitigating the effects of climate change. The script discusses a claim that climate change disproportionately affects black people, which is challenged by an argument that it is poverty, not race, that is the determining factor in vulnerability to climate-related issues.

💡Global Warming

Global warming is the long-term increase in Earth's average surface temperature due primarily to human activities such as the emission of greenhouse gases. The video script uses the term to discuss its impact on different communities, with a particular focus on the claim that it affects black Americans more than others, which is contested in the conversation.

💡ESG Movement

ESG stands for Environmental, Social, and Governance, and the ESG movement refers to a trend where investors consider these factors alongside financial ones when making investment decisions. The script criticizes the ESG movement, suggesting it has led to the underperformance of oil stocks and is detrimental to the economy and energy consumers.

💡Net Zero

Net zero refers to a state where the amount of greenhouse gases emitted into the atmosphere is balanced by an equivalent amount being removed, thus having a net impact of zero. The script mentions companies claiming to aim for net zero emissions, which the speaker argues would be financially ruinous and not practically achievable.

💡Reliable Power

Reliable power refers to a consistent and dependable supply of electricity. The video script contrasts reliable power sources like fossil fuels and nuclear energy with unreliable ones such as solar and wind, which are said to require backup from more traditional power sources to ensure a steady supply.

💡Batteries

In the context of the script, batteries are discussed as a means of energy storage to support renewable energy sources like solar and wind. The speaker argues that current battery technology is insufficient to provide baseload power, which is the continuous and uninterrupted supply of electricity needed to meet the minimum demand of a power grid.

💡Supply Chain

The supply chain refers to the network of organizations, people, activities, information, and resources involved in producing and delivering a product or service. The script raises concerns about the supply chain for batteries, particularly the mining of materials needed for their production and the reliance on countries like China, which may pose geopolitical and environmental challenges.

Highlights

Bill Maher's frequent appearances suggest he is either ignorant or dishonest about election denial.

Megan Kelly attempts to educate Bill Maher on election denial, highlighting his misunderstanding.

Hillary Clinton is referred to as the original election denier for her actions post-2016 election.

Bill Maher's ignorance or dishonesty about Hillary Clinton's election denial is questioned.

Hillary Clinton's statements about the 2016 election being illegitimate are discussed.

Bill Maher's views on January 6th are criticized as paranoid fantasies.

Megan Kelly is praised for being more informed and better at her job than Bill Maher.

Selective enforcement of the law regarding classified documents is debated.

The importance of wealth in addressing climate change susceptibility is emphasized.

Shell shareholders reject a climate change resolution, indicating a shift in sentiment.

The ESG movement is criticized for its impact on oil companies and consumers.

The power of the ESG lobby is discussed, with signs of weakening influence.

The challenges and bias in producing batteries for renewable energy are highlighted.

The Australian government's strategy to become a battery manufacturer is questioned.

The need for reliable energy solutions without reliance on fossil fuels is emphasized.

The supply chain and reliance on China for battery production elements are discussed.

The negative aspects of solar and wind energy are often overlooked, says Alex Epstein.

Transcripts

00:00

now it's time for lefties losing it

00:02

we've been seeing a lot of Bill Mah

00:04

lately he has a book to flog so he's

00:06

been everywhere from the view to Gutfeld

00:09

of course he went on Fox that's where

00:10

the audience is but the more we see of

00:13

him the more clear it is that this Lefty

00:15

who is occasionally sane and Lucid is

00:18

either wildly ignorant or dishonest

00:21

watch as Megan Kelly educates him or

00:24

tries to about election denial I just I

00:26

mean you you keep saying sort of I'm

00:28

nuts because I don't see the difference

00:30

between the elephant and the mouse and

00:31

I'm telling you I identify them

00:32

differently than you do Hillary Clinton

00:34

of course is the original election

00:36

denier I'm sure you voted for her in 16

00:38

well she's not an election Den she

00:40

absolutely was the OG election denier

00:43

she first of all she came out before the

00:46

son had risen to concede the election to

00:49

Trump and then spent the next four years

00:52

saying he was illegitimate he was an

00:54

illegitimate president she okay well

00:56

first of all saying she didn't say he

00:58

was an illegit she did tell me exactly

01:00

what she said she said those exact words

01:04

repeatedly okay yep she did she said

01:07

those exact words bill I believe he

01:10

knows he's an illegitimate president is

01:12

Bill maah really that clueless about

01:15

Hillary Clinton's election denying ways

01:17

was ma hiding under a rock for the years

01:19

she pushed the lie that the 2016

01:22

election was stolen where she helped

01:24

formulate and spread Russian collusion

01:27

conspiracies that undermine democracy in

01:29

the us Mar is either frightfully

01:32

ignorant or lying there are no other

01:33

options at this point let's remind him

01:36

of uh some of the things Hillary has

01:38

said I believe he knows he's an

01:39

illegitimate president he knows he knows

01:43

so I know that he knows that this wasn't

01:46

on the level I don't know that we'll

01:48

ever know everything that happened but

01:50

clearly we know a lot and are learning

01:52

more every day and history will probably

01:54

sort it all out as I've been telling

01:56

candidates who have come to see me you

01:58

can run the best

02:00

campaign you can even become the

02:03

nominee and you can have the election

02:05

stolen from

02:08

you apparently Bill Mah missed that and

02:10

he also missed the truth about January 6

02:13

or as he calls it the Insurrection let's

02:15

listen now to some of his paranoid

02:18

fantasies on January 20th 2025 he'll

02:21

show up at the White House whether he's

02:23

invited or

02:24

not and I don't think that's going to be

02:26

good we he's going to he's going to bomb

02:29

in if if he lost yes oh yeah bomb is a

02:33

word I wouldn't even throw around

02:34

lightly stop it he's not going to do

02:36

that right like there was never an

02:38

attack on the capital oh I hear you I

02:41

hear you but he's not going to show up

02:42

at the in they didn't show up at the

02:44

capital and break windows and and knock

02:47

down doors and kill cops and Chase and

02:51

they didn't break Windows knock cop they

02:53

of course did no they didn't who did

02:56

they died of natural causes that day

02:58

Capital police officer Brian snik the

03:00

medical examiner has determined that he

03:02

suffered two strokes and died of natural

03:05

causes yeah nobody died that day cops no

03:09

not

03:09

true who okay who oh I don't remember

03:12

the names they didn't there was Brian

03:15

snic who died later after the fact Megan

03:19

Kelly is so much smarter better informed

03:22

and better at her job than ma it's

03:24

frightening uh he's the best they've got

03:26

though and the man who prides himself on

03:28

his depth of knowledge and critic

03:30

thinking skills kept on embarrassing

03:32

himself here Megan schools him on the

03:34

selective enforcement of the law that so

03:37

Biden still classified documents and not

03:40

be charged one actually had the ability

03:43

to declassify documents and keep them

03:45

because he'd been the president and one

03:47

didn't because he should have been

03:49

looking at documents only in a skiff

03:51

while a sitting US senator and clearly

03:54

he stole classified documents that he

03:56

wasn't entitled to and never had the

03:58

ability to declassify them

04:01

yeah uh maybe you know more about that

04:04

than I do I don't remember that part of

04:05

it and I I always don't trust anything I

04:08

hear until I vet it from the other side

04:11

because everybody sort of has their

04:12

one-sided view of it and narrative is

04:14

more important than truth I know this is

04:16

the right-wing narrative I thought I'm

04:19

not like that bill I I care about facts

04:21

I practice law for 10 years I want to

04:22

get the cases right you know

04:24

conservatives are guilty of the bigotry

04:27

of low expectations when it comes to

04:29

Bill I've done it too I've praised him

04:32

and played his Clips when he's

04:34

occasionally said something sensible

04:36

something the right has been saying for

04:37

years but at his core he's a delusional

04:40

Democrat who has uh spoken of his dream

04:42

of seeing Gavin newsum becoming

04:44

president yeah the California governor

04:46

that one I think fellow traveler Bill

04:49

Burr summed up Mah nicely during their

04:51

recent chat most of the you say is not

04:54

smart it's just sort of obscure it's not

04:57

obscure to certain person percentage of

05:00

people I'm I'm not some giant eggh egghe

05:04

head I'm just I know I know you're not

05:06

that smart and Greg Gutfeld had the

05:09

right idea about maah who was on his

05:11

show earlier this week that's the most

05:13

important thing that's going on in this

05:14

country he didn't concede the last

05:16

election he's not going to concede this

05:17

election you don't know that when and

05:19

everybody said oh you smoke too much pot

05:21

turned out I smok just the right amount

05:23

of pot there's no right amount so Dr

05:26

Drew sir we you you you're really good

05:28

at diagnosing mental illness what is

05:30

Bill's

05:31

[Laughter]

05:34

[Applause]

05:36

problem wow maybe lay off the pot bill

05:40

that might clear up the

05:42

TDS and let's continue with LEF is

05:44

losing it here we have a biological man

05:47

identifying as a woman using their

05:49

position as the assistant secretary for

05:51

health in the Biden Administration to

05:53

lecture us about how global warming is

05:56

disproportionately affecting black

05:58

people climate change is having a

06:00

disproportionate effect on the physical

06:02

and mental health of black communities

06:05

black Americans are more likely than

06:07

white Americans to live in areas and

06:09

housing that increase their

06:10

susceptibility to climate related health

06:13

issues and 65% of black Americans report

06:16

feeling anxious about climate change's

06:19

impact joining me now is the author of

06:22

fossil future Alex epin Alex uh your

06:26

response to that I would argue climate

06:28

change policy es do disproportionately

06:31

impact poor people not black people poor

06:34

people whatever color they are uh is

06:37

that how you see it because I find it

06:39

hard to understand how global warming is

06:43

impacting black people more than

06:44

everybody

06:46

else I mean the the truth is that you

06:49

know what they're calling global warming

06:51

so bad weather they're saying it's

06:54

racist but it's actually classist in the

06:57

sense of if you're poor it's hard to

06:59

deal with bad weather that's why as the

07:01

world has be has gotten richer we've

07:03

become much much safer from climate we

07:04

have a 98% decline in climate related

07:07

disaster deaths over the last century so

07:10

obviously obviously the solution if you

07:12

care about susceptibility to climate is

07:15

for everyone to get rich even within the

07:16

United States let alone the rest of the

07:18

world where most people are incredibly

07:19

poor even compared to you know the the

07:23

poorest people in the United States so

07:25

on the one hand it's just the exact

07:27

opposite prescription of what's needed

07:29

it's just we need to become wealthier

07:31

and then on top of it this person has

07:34

the goal to say that blacks are

07:36

suffering suffering climate related

07:38

anxiety that's because you're

07:41

catastrophizing climate like maybe the

07:44

government should prescribe fossil

07:45

future that's the solution to climate

07:49

anxiety that is a very good prescription

07:52

indeed uh now here's some good news this

07:54

week's shareholders at oil giant shell

07:58

overwhelmingly rejected a climate change

08:01

resolution filed by Green activists

08:04

urging it to align its reduction targets

08:07

to the Paris climate agreement Alex only

08:10

18% of shareholders back this proposal

08:14

uh in March we saw uh shell weaken its

08:17

2030 carbon reduction Target uh they

08:21

cited strong demand for gas they're

08:24

refocusing on more profitable operations

08:27

like oil and gas seems to be a winful

08:30

common sense

08:32

Alex I think this is a good it's a good

08:35

development and and contrast this to say

08:38

2020 when you know we had a global

08:40

pandemic we had lockdowns that hurt most

08:43

the oil and gas industry particularly

08:45

oil because oil is the basis of modern

08:47

transportation and you had all these

08:49

people saying I was wrong for saying

08:51

that you know we have a fossil future

08:54

that we actually need more oil going

08:55

forward they're like look oil demand is

08:57

low it's not good to invest in oil now

08:59

why am I bringing this up in this

09:00

context because the fact that oil stocks

09:03

happen to be crashing because of those

09:04

circumstances allowed a bunch of

09:06

opportunistic ESG types to claim that

09:10

disinvesting from oil was somehow a wise

09:12

investment thing when in fact what

09:14

happened is right after that oil became

09:16

one of the best performing sectors in

09:18

the world as demand rebounded and then

09:20

continued to increase to record levels

09:23

where we are now and we're still

09:24

increasing so what's happened is all

09:26

these do good or ESG types who were CL

09:28

who were thinking they would get rich

09:30

being ESG are realizing that they're

09:32

getting poor being ESG and that if they

09:34

have shell or BP or all these other

09:36

virtue signaler companies who've claimed

09:38

that they want to go Net Zero that they

09:40

if they actually do that it's going to

09:41

Crater their stock so I'm glad that

09:43

people are waking up to financial

09:45

reality and it's helping defang this

09:47

really Insidious ESG movement because

09:50

that not not only hurts the oil

09:51

companies it most of all hurts the oil

09:54

consumers which is the world's eight

09:55

billion people who need cheap reliable

09:58

energy

10:00

well how powerful is the ESG mob uh the

10:05

environmental social and governance

10:07

Lobby uh they seem to control a great

10:10

deal of the money Alex uh is their power

10:13

weakening with uh the pandemic over and

10:16

things getting back to

10:19

normal I I it's there are signs of

10:21

weakness but we definitely cannot let up

10:25

uh at all I mean you're seeing more and

10:26

more people stand up to it it used to be

10:28

pretty lonely

10:29

to stand up to it now there are a lot

10:31

more people saying that it's it's bad

10:33

and in particular the stuff I'm most

10:35

interested in the environmental side the

10:37

idea of rapidly eliminating fossil fuels

10:39

that that is a global death sentence

10:41

you're increasingly having people

10:43

recognize that to some extent but

10:45

unfortunately the ESG movement has

10:48

totally poisoned so many institutions

10:50

and taken them over and I'll just give

10:52

an example of in the realm of AI which

10:54

is a new huge source of demand in the

10:56

United States and around the world a lot

10:58

of these leading AI users like Microsoft

11:01

and Facebook have been promoting ESG

11:03

poison for years and that's led to the

11:05

shutdown of reliable power plants on our

11:07

grid this should sound familiar to

11:08

Australians and trying to replace them

11:10

with unreliables and now we don't have

11:12

nearly enough electricity for AI so

11:15

you're seeing these these institutions

11:17

are not yet apologizing I'll think it's

11:19

great when Microsoft and Google and

11:21

Facebook apologize for ruining our grid

11:24

with ESG until then I'm not complacent

11:29

well our national science agency the CSO

11:32

has published a report that insists the

11:36

powering our country with nuclear energy

11:38

is going to be far more expensive nearly

11:41

double the cost of doing it with

11:44

Renewables uh $16 billion and 16 years

11:48

is what it will apparently take to build

11:51

a large scale nuclear reactor is this

11:54

true Alex or is this just another sign

11:57

of the csiro being captured by the grain

12:02

ideology I want to draw people's

12:04

attention to a weird kind of

12:06

schizophrenia that that you have going

12:09

on here which you often see which is

12:11

there's a total can't do attitude with

12:13

fossil fuels in a particular Nuclear So

12:15

they act like oh it has to be incredibly

12:17

expensive even though say South Korea is

12:19

able to do it cheaply the United States

12:21

used to be able to do do it cheaply

12:23

before we ruined it with bad regulations

12:25

so they have a total can't do attitude

12:27

with regard to nuclear but with

12:29

unreliable solar and wind which have

12:30

never powered any country anywhere

12:32

without totally parasiting unreliable

12:34

fossil fuels and nuclear they have this

12:36

infinite unicorn fantasy can do attitude

12:40

and so one of the fallacies here is

12:42

they're comparing unreliable power to

12:44

Reliable power so that's you know that's

12:46

like comparing uh rotten oranges to

12:49

Apples so they're just they're not

12:50

comparisons what you need to happen is

12:53

if you want to use solar and wind the

12:54

so-called Renewables those companies

12:56

should figure out how to make them

12:57

actually Supply reliable electricity

12:59

provide the batteries themselves then

13:01

what they see is is just prohibitively

13:03

expensive but they're just comparing the

13:05

cost of unreliable to Reliable so that's

13:07

that's intellectually

13:10

nonserious it is intellectually

13:12

dishonest you're absolutely right now

13:14

prime minister Anthony albanesi has

13:16

unveiled a $550 million strategy aimed

13:21

at turning Australia into a world

13:23

leading battery manufacturer this is

13:26

another step we are told in firming up

13:29

Renewables and supporting the Net Zero

13:32

transition but can batteries ever

13:36

provide that Bas load power that a first

13:39

world nation like Australia

13:42

needs well you know ever is a long time

13:45

but you know with the technology we

13:47

currently have they're they're nowhere

13:49

near close so not even the best form of

13:51

storage what's called pump storage tends

13:53

to be much cheaper we just don't have

13:55

any form of man-made storage right now

13:58

that can accommodate the unreliability

14:00

of solar and wind so what happens is you

14:02

build these battery facilities and what

14:04

happens is they'll say oh we have this

14:06

many megawatts of batteries and isn't

14:08

that going to be great but a megawatt of

14:10

batteries is not the same as a megawatt

14:13

of natural gas because the megawatt of

14:15

batteries usually lasts four hours

14:17

maximum so if it only lasts four hours

14:20

you need a lot more than four hours

14:21

worth to be able to handle highs and

14:24

lows of the sun and the wind over you

14:26

know days let alone let alone weeks so

14:29

it's just this fake it's just it's just

14:31

this fake stuff being added on to

14:34

pretend that solar and wind are being

14:36

reliable but they're not reliable unless

14:38

they can truly be self-sufficient

14:41

without parasiting on the other stuff so

14:42

again I say Australian government anyone

14:44

who thinks they can make it work have

14:46

somebody figure out how to make a

14:47

solution just using solar wind and

14:49

batteries see how much that cost to

14:51

provide reliable electricity with the

14:54

same reliability of coal or as coal or

14:56

natural gas or nuclear you'll be in for

14:58

a rude awakening but but go ahead and

15:00

try but don't just steal everyone's

15:01

money and restrict fossil fuels and

15:04

promise the best because there's no

15:05

evidence it'll work at

15:07

all and what about the elements that go

15:10

into making these giant batteries uh

15:14

where they come from the supply chain

15:17

and the Reliance on China is that

15:20

something that isn't given due

15:22

consideration

15:24

Alex well in general there's just you

15:27

know the the negatives are challenges of

15:29

of solar and wind are never given due

15:31

consideration and then the negatives or

15:33

challenges of fossil fuels are Amplified

15:35

you know 100 times and just exaggerated

15:37

beyond all proportion so there's

15:39

definitely this bias I don't think it

15:41

means fundamentally you can't produce

15:44

batteries at a much larger scale but if

15:46

you look at near term what what people

15:48

are proposing with these different net

15:50

zero plans is just a a totally

15:53

unprecedented increase in mining in a

15:56

very anti-mining global environment