Duet AI vs GitHub Copilot vs ChatGPT: Direct Testing with Coding Challenges
TLDRIn this video, the creator compares Google's Duet AI, GitHub Copilot, and Chat GPT in a series of coding challenges involving a simple calculator, web scraping, and solving a coding problem from LeetCode. The aim is to evaluate their effectiveness in providing code solutions and their ability to integrate with TypeScript. The results highlight the strengths and weaknesses of each AI tool, offering insights for developers on how they can best utilize these technologies in their day-to-day coding tasks.
Takeaways
- 🚀 Google launched its Duet AI, a new competitor to GitHub Copilot.
- 📝 The installation process for Duet AI is straightforward, involving the use of extensions and Google Cloud.
- 🔍 The video compares Duet AI, Copilot, and Chat GPT by having them solve four simple coding tasks.
- 🧠 Duet AI struggled with creating a simple calculator in TypeScript, indicating potential limitations in understanding task requirements.
- 🛠️ Copilot provided a more accurate solution for the calculator task, showcasing its strength in code generation.
- 🌐 A web scraper task using Puppeteer was attempted by both AIs, with Duet AI failing to use Puppeteer correctly.
- 🔢 Duet AI and Copilot were tested on solving a 'hard' LeetCode problem, with mixed results and the need for multiple attempts.
- 🤖 When creating a chatbot, Duet AI struggled with using the latest Open AI API, while Copilot did not perform well on this task either.
- 📈 The video suggests that AI tools can assist with coding but should not replace a programmer's understanding and skill.
- 🎯 The effectiveness of AI coding assistants varies based on the task and the specificity of the user's instructions.
- 📊 The comparison highlights the importance of using AI tools as a supplement to coding, rather than a complete solution provider.
Q & A
What was the main purpose of the video?
-The main purpose of the video was to compare the capabilities of Google's Duet AI, GitHub Copilot, and Chat GPT in solving coding tasks and to provide insights into their performance and utility in a coding environment.
How was the Duet AI extension installed in the video?
-The Duet AI extension was installed by navigating to the extensions section and typing in 'Du AI', selecting it from the Google Cloud options, and then selecting a Duet AI project.
What was the first coding task that the video attempted to solve using Duet AI?
-The first coding task was to create a simple calculator in the terminal where the user can choose an operation and two numbers to apply the operation to, and then the program returns the answer and asks if the user wants to continue.
What issue did the video encounter when trying to run the code generated by Duet AI for the simple calculator?
-The video encountered issues where the generated code did not work as expected, and there were problems with types and typings that needed to be corrected.
How did the video demonstrate the use of Duet AI and GitHub Copilot for web scraping from Wikipedia?
-The video attempted to use both Duet AI and GitHub Copilot to create a web scraper that would extract the first paragraph from the Lion's Wikipedia page. However, both AI tools had difficulties, with Duet AI not using Puppeteer as instructed and GitHub Copilot facing issues launching the browser process.
What was the 'point drum' problem that the video tried to solve using the AI tools?
-The 'point drum' problem, also known as the shortest palindrome problem, involves converting a given string into a palindrome by adding the fewest number of characters to the front of the string.
How did the video compare the performance of Duet AI, GitHub Copilot, and Chat GPT in creating a chatbot?
-The video tested each AI tool's ability to create a chatbot using the latest Open AI beta API. Duet AI provided an incomplete and incorrect code snippet, GitHub Copilot froze and did not continue, while Chat GPT provided a tutorial-like response rather than a direct code solution.
What advice does the video give on using AI tools for coding?
-The video advises that AI tools like Duet AI, GitHub Copilot, and Chat GPT should be used as aids to remember coding structures and to speed up the typing process, rather than relying on them to create entire scripts or codes from scratch.
How did the video conclude the comparison between the three AI tools?
-The video concluded that each AI tool has its strengths and weaknesses, and the best way to measure their effectiveness is through practical use and assessing the value they add to one's daily coding tasks.
What was the final verdict on Duet AI's performance in the video?
-The video found that Duet AI struggled with some tasks, particularly with typescript and web scraping, and was not as successful as GitHub Copilot in creating a working solution for the tasks tested.
What was the viewer engagement strategy suggested at the end of the video?
-The video suggested that viewers who found the content useful should hit the like button and subscribe for more similar videos, and it also mentioned the potential for a follow-up video discussing first impressions of Duet AI.
Outlines
🚀 Introduction to Google's Duet AI and Comparison with GitHub Copilot
The video begins with the introduction of Google's Duet AI, a new AI assistant that is being compared to GitHub Copilot. The creator discusses the installation process of Duet AI and its simplicity. The main focus of the video is to compare Duet AI and Chat GPT in solving four simple coding tasks. The first task involves creating a simple calculator in the terminal, where the user can choose an operation and two numbers to apply the operation to. The AI is expected to provide value and perform the tasks as intended, with the creator noting that it's not about the AI solving the entire code alone but rather how far it can go in assisting with the task.
🔍 Analysis of Duet AI's Performance in Building a Web Scraper
The second paragraph focuses on the performance of Duet AI in building a web scraper using Puppeteer. The creator instructs Duet AI to scrape the first paragraph from the Lion's Wikipedia page. Initially, the AI does not use Puppeteer as expected, leading to a forced correction and a new attempt. The AI then generates a code that imports Puppeteer and creates a synchronous function. Despite some issues and warnings, the AI attempts to build a scraper, indicating that it tries to follow instructions but may not handle TypeScript well. The creator concludes that Duet AI did not successfully build the scraper but acknowledges its effort.
💡 Duet AI's Approach to Solving a Coding Challenge
In this paragraph, the creator tests Duet AI's ability to solve a coding challenge from LeetCode, specifically the 'Palindrome' problem. The AI initially provides an incorrect solution by repeating the input string, but after a second attempt, it successfully generates a correct solution. The creator is impressed with Duet AI's ability to search and provide a correct solution, indicating that it can be a valuable tool for solving algorithmic problems, especially if the solutions are readily available online.
🤖 Testing Duet AI's Capability to Create a Chatbot
The creator challenges Duet AI to create a chatbot, expecting it to utilize the recent beta API from OpenAI. Despite the AI's attempt to generate a chatbot, it fails to import necessary modules correctly and does not create a functional chatbot. The creator notes that Duet AI seems to be using outdated information and lacks the ability to use the latest features effectively. The paragraph highlights the limitations of Duet AI in handling up-to-date and complex coding tasks like creating a chatbot using the latest APIs.
📊 Evaluating GitHub Copilot and Duet AI in Various Coding Scenarios
In the final paragraph, the creator evaluates both GitHub Copilot and Duet AI across different coding scenarios. Copilot is tested for creating a simple calculator, scraping a website, and solving a LeetCode problem. The creator finds that Copilot performs better than Duet AI in these tasks, providing correct and functional code. However, the creator emphasizes that neither AI should be used to create entire scripts but rather to assist in coding tasks. The video concludes with the creator's belief that Chat GPT might outperform both Duet AI and Copilot, suggesting that the true measure of an AI's value lies in its practical application and the assistance it provides in day-to-day coding work.
🎨 Comparing TypeScript, Duet AI, and Chat GPT in Coding
The video concludes with a comparison of TypeScript, Duet AI, and Chat GPT in coding. The creator has conducted a series of tests to evaluate the performance of each in various coding tasks. The creator expresses a preference for Duet AI as a copilot, not just for code generation, but for assisting in remembering coding structures and typing tasks faster. The creator also suggests using Chat GPT for learning how to design entire codes rather than letting it write the code entirely. The video ends with the creator's intention to create an image comparing TypeScript, Duet AI, and Chat GPT, hoping that the video was informative and helpful for the viewers.
Mindmap
Keywords
💡Duet AI
💡Copilot
💡Chat GPT
💡TypeScript
💡Code Generation
💡Web Scraper
💡Chatbot
💡Code Completion
💡Open AI API
💡Error Handling
💡Programming Language
Highlights
Google launched its Duet AI, a new competitor to GitHub Copilot.
Duvet AI's installation process is simple through the extensions.
The video compares Duet AI, Copilot, and Chat GPT in solving four simple codes.
Duvet AI's initial attempt at creating a terminal calculator did not work.
Duvet AI provides a squiggly line alert with suggested code, but it disappears upon hovering.
The second attempt at the calculator problem resulted in a working solution.
Duvet AI failed to build a Wikipedia scraper using Puppeteer as requested.
Lead code problem about creating the shortest palindrome was solved by Duvet AI on the second attempt.
Duvet AI's chatbot creation was not successful and lacked recent API usage.
GitHub Copilot provided multiple suggestions for the simple calculator task.
Copilot successfully created a Wikipedia scraper using Puppeteer.
Copilot quickly solved the lead code problem with a smaller code snippet.
Chat GPT was tested for creating a TypeScript simple calculator and performed well.
Chat GPT was instructed to browse the internet for creating a chatbot using the latest beta API.
The video concludes that AI tools should be used to assist and enhance coding rather than replace it entirely.
The video provides a comparative analysis of Duet AI, Copilot, and Chat GPT for day-to-day coding work.
The importance of using these AI tools as aids for coding is emphasized rather than complete code creation.