I Edited a Photo in Every Program.

Harrison Tong
9 Jun 202325:28

TLDRIn this video, the creator discusses their exploration of various photo editing software beyond the industry standard Adobe Photoshop and Lightroom. They test a range of programs, including Capture One, Luminar Neo, Sony Imaging Edge, Darktable, Apple Photos, Affinity Photo, Photometer, Raw Therapy, Photopea, DxO Labs, and ON1 Photo RAW. Each software is evaluated based on its features, ease of use, performance, and suitability for different types of editing tasks. The creator emphasizes the importance of trying different tools and encourages viewers to take advantage of free trials to find the best fit for their needs. The summary underscores the potential of some alternatives and the creator's intention to continue monitoring the development of these programs.

Takeaways

  • 📷 Adobe Lightroom and Photoshop are the industry standards for photo editing, but many photographers have not explored alternatives due to their dominance and widespread use in tutorials and discussions.
  • 💻 The author experimented with editing a photo in every available program to compare features and performance, inspired by similar initiatives in graphic and game design.
  • 🔍 Lightroom offers all-in-one editing, organization, and cataloging, with AI-based tools that speed up the editing process, though its healing tool is not as powerful as Photoshop's.
  • ✂️ Photoshop is renowned for its layer-based editing, with a vast array of options and the highly praised removal suite, including content-aware fill and generative fill.
  • 🌟 Capture One stands out for its tailored raw engine for each camera and sensor, an impressive color module, and a perpetual license option, though its healing tool lacks AI capabilities.
  • 🆕 Luminar Neo emphasizes AI, providing quick editing through presets and a user-friendly interface, but its AI presets can be overbearing and it requires Photoshop for more complex removal tasks.
  • 📚 Sony Imaging Edge, which comes with Sony Alpha cameras, has a clunky download process and lacks a dedicated color module, making it a less desirable choice for serious editing.
  • 🎨 Darktable, a free and open-source alternative, is highly technical and may appeal to programmers but is not user-friendly, with a steep learning curve and outdated interface.
  • 🍎 Apple Photos is a powerful editor with a similar interface to iPhone editing, but it is limited by iCloud storage, making it difficult to export photos without sufficient space.
  • 🏆 Affinity Photo is a strong Photoshop alternative with a similar interface and tools, but it lacks advanced removal tools like content-aware fill, making it less versatile for certain tasks.
  • 🌐 Photopea is a free, online version of Photoshop that offers a powerful layer-based editor in a browser, with content-aware features and a user experience close to the original Photoshop.
  • 🤔 The author encourages photographers to try different programs, as many offer free trials, and to not be afraid to explore alternatives to the industry-standard software for potentially better results or a more efficient workflow.

Q & A

  • How much does it cost annually to use Lightroom and Photoshop?

    -It costs $240 every year to use Lightroom and Photoshop.

  • Why do most photographers use Lightroom and Photoshop?

    -Most photographers use Lightroom and Photoshop because they are the industry standard and are the primary tools taught in tutorials and recommended by others in the field.

  • What is the main advantage of using Lightroom for photo editing?

    -Lightroom is an all-in-one editing, organization, and cataloging software that offers a comprehensive suite of basic adjustments to advanced calibrations, as well as AI-based tools that speed up the editing process.

  • What is the most compelling feature of Photoshop mentioned in the script?

    -The most compelling feature of Photoshop mentioned is the removal suite, particularly content-aware fill and the generative fill from the AI beta feature, which are considered unrivaled in the industry.

  • What is Capture One known for in comparison to Lightroom?

    -Capture One is known for its tailored raw engine that adjusts to every camera and sensor, providing one of the best color modules and professional editing tools, making it a popular alternative to Lightroom.

  • What is the main drawback of Capture One's healing tool compared to Photoshop?

    -Capture One's healing tool is not as powerful or advanced as Photoshop's equivalent. It lacks AI smarts, such as AI masking and AI denoising, which are available in Photoshop.

  • What is the primary focus of Luminar Neo?

    -Luminar Neo has a heavy emphasis on AI, providing presets and editing modules that utilize AI to detect and enhance various aspects of an image.

  • Why is Sony Imaging Edge not recommended for users looking for advanced color editing features?

    -Sony Imaging Edge lacks an HSL (Hue, Saturation, Luminance) module, which is a basic feature needed for advanced color adjustments, limiting its utility for users requiring more control over color editing.

  • What is the main issue with Darktable for users who are not programmers?

    -Darktable is designed by programmers for programmers, featuring a complex interface with terminology and options that can be overwhelming for users without a technical background.

  • How does Apple Photos differ from other editing software mentioned in the script?

    -Apple Photos is user-friendly and similar to editing on an iPhone, but it is limited by iCloud storage, which can prevent users from exporting their photos if they do not have sufficient storage available.

  • What is the main advantage of Affinity Photo over other Photoshop alternatives?

    -Affinity Photo is a powerful raster-based editor that closely resembles Photoshop in terms of features and layout, making it an excellent alternative for users looking for a non-Adobe solution.

Outlines

00:00

📷 Industry Standard Software: Lightroom & Photoshop

The speaker discusses the annual expense of using Adobe's Lightroom and Photoshop, which are considered the industry standard for photographers. Despite the prevalence of competition in other areas of photography, such as camera and lens brands, software seems to be dominated by Adobe. The speaker expresses a desire to explore alternative programs, highlighting the features of Lightroom, such as its all-in-one editing, organization, and cataloging capabilities, as well as AI-based tools. Photoshop is praised for its layer-based editing and powerful options, particularly the removal suite, which is considered unparalleled.

05:03

🔍 Exploring Capture One: An Alternative to Lightroom

The speaker reviews Capture One, an all-in-one editing and organizing software that is often compared to Lightroom. They note that Capture One offers a tailored raw engine for each camera and sensor, providing professional-level editing tools, including a highly praised color module with advanced HSL adjustments and a skin toning tool. While the performance is noted to be superior to Lightroom, the healing tool is criticized for not being as good as Photoshop's, and there's a lack of AI features such as AI masking and denoising.

10:04

🌐 Luminar Neo: AI-Focused Photo Editing

The speaker evaluates Luminar Neo, which emphasizes AI in its editing process. Initially, they find the AI presets to be overcooked and not useful for their needs. However, once they delve into the editing module, they find the program to be responsive and feature-rich, with tools that simplify editing for beginners while still offering power for experienced users. Despite this, the removal feature is found to be lacking, necessitating the use of Photoshop for certain tasks.

15:06

📚 Sony Imaging Edge: A Clunky Experience

The speaker expresses disappointment with Sony Imaging Edge, which comes with Sony Alpha cameras. They criticize the software's initial download process and find the editing process to be somewhat outdated and clunky. While there are some positive aspects, such as dynamic range optimization and color presets, the lack of an HSL module is a significant drawback, making the software less versatile for color adjustments.

20:07

🎨 Darktable and Apple Photos: A Mixed Bag

Darktable is described as a free and open-source alternative to Lightroom, but the speaker finds it to be overly complex and not user-friendly. On the other hand, Apple Photos is praised for its ease of use and feature set, but it is limited by iCloud storage restrictions. The speaker also laments the discontinuation of Aperture, a professional software previously offered by Apple.

25:08

🏆 Affinity Photo: A Strong Photoshop Alternative

The speaker reviews Affinity Photo as a raster-based editor similar to Photoshop. They find the raw editor to be lacking, particularly in the absence of an HSL module, but appreciate the program as a viable Photoshop alternative. The interface is familiar, and it includes essential features for editing, although it falls short in comparison to Photoshop's advanced removal tools.

🌟 Photometer and Other Editors: A Glimpse into the Future

Photometer is highlighted as a promising Lightroom competitor with AI masking and other advanced features, despite current limitations related to iCloud storage. Raw Therapy is dismissed as being too complex and not user-friendly. Photopea is praised as a powerful online version of Photoshop, offering a similar experience to the desktop version. DxO Labs is acknowledged for its technical aspects and noise correction features, though it doesn't particularly stand out. On1 is compared to Luminar but is seen as less polished. The speaker concludes by encouraging experimentation with different programs, emphasizing that good results can be achieved with any software if one takes the time to learn it.

🔄 Final Thoughts: Encouraging Exploration

The speaker wraps up by suggesting that photographers should try out different programs, especially if they are considering moving away from Lightroom. They note that while some programs may be more challenging in certain aspects, the potential for good results exists across the board. They express an intention to keep an eye on the development of some programs in the coming months and years.

Mindmap

Keywords

💡Lightroom

Lightroom is an all-in-one photo editing, organization, and cataloging software developed by Adobe. It is widely recognized as an industry standard among photographers for its comprehensive suite of tools that range from basic adjustments to advanced calibrations. In the video, the creator discusses using Lightroom for its AI-based tools, which expedite the editing process, and its vast array of available presets and tutorials that aid in enhancing one's editing skills.

💡Photoshop

Photoshop, also by Adobe, is a raster-based image editor renowned for its extensive capabilities in creating and manipulating images. It is often the go-to software for professionals requiring advanced editing features. The video mentions Photoshop's powerful layer-based editor and its 'removal suite', which includes content-aware fill and generative fill, as standout features that set it apart from other editing software.

💡Capture One

Capture One is an alternative to Lightroom that offers both editing and organizing functionalities. It is highlighted in the video for its tailored raw engine that adjusts to specific camera sensors, particularly those from Fujifilm. The software is praised for its color module and skin toning tool, which allows for selective editing of skin tones. However, it is noted to have a less effective healing tool compared to Photoshop.

💡AI Masking

AI Masking refers to the use of artificial intelligence to automatically detect and select subjects or objects within an image for editing purposes. In the context of the video, AI Masking is mentioned as a time-saving feature in both Lightroom and Capture One, which simplifies tasks like applying effects to specific areas of a photo without manual selection.

💡Luminar Neo

Luminar Neo is an editing program with a strong emphasis on AI capabilities. It is presented in the video as a beginner-friendly editor that uses AI to detect the subject of a photo and suggest presets accordingly. Despite initial criticisms of its presets, Luminar Neo is recognized for its responsive interface and powerful editing modules that simplify complex adjustments for novices.

💡Sony Imaging Edge

Sony Imaging Edge is the default software that comes with Sony Alpha cameras. The video describes a cumbersome initial download process followed by a functional, albeit somewhat outdated, editing experience. It is criticized for its lack of a robust color module, including the absence of HSL adjustments, which limits its utility for more advanced color editing.

💡Darktable

Darktable is a free and open-source alternative to Lightroom, designed with a focus on programming and advanced features. The video portrays it as a complex and user-unfriendly option, with a steep learning curve due to its terminology and design by programmers for programmers. Despite powerful features like the Dehaze tool, the overall user experience is described as frustrating.

💡Apple Photos

Apple Photos is a photo editing and management software for Apple devices. It is noted for its user-friendly interface and robust editing features that mirror those found on iPhones. However, the video points out its reliance on iCloud storage, which can be a limitation for users without sufficient space, and the lack of advanced features like spot healing.

💡Affinity Photo

Affinity Photo is an award-winning raster-based editor that serves as an alternative to Photoshop. It is lauded in the video for its similarity to Photoshop in terms of features and layout, making it a viable option for those looking to switch from Adobe's software. Despite the absence of certain advanced tools like content-aware fill, it is praised for its performance and feature set.

💡Photo Editing Software

The term 'Photo Editing Software' is used in the video to describe the various programs designed for manipulating digital images. The video script explores different software options, comparing their features, ease of use, and suitability for professional or casual use. It emphasizes the importance of exploring alternatives to industry standards to find tools that best fit individual needs and preferences.

💡AI Features

AI Features in photo editing software refer to functionalities that utilize artificial intelligence to enhance the editing process. The video discusses AI's role in speeding up tasks such as subject detection, noise reduction, and applying presets. It highlights how AI can improve efficiency but also notes that over-reliance on AI presets can sometimes lead to less desirable results.

Highlights

Investing $240 annually in Lightroom and Photoshop due to industry standard.

Photographers rarely explore alternatives to Adobe's Lightroom and Photoshop.

The author experimented with editing a photo in every available program.

Lightroom offers all-in-one editing, organization, and cataloging with AI-based tools.

Photoshop is a raster-based editor with a vast array of options for image styling and editing.

Capture One stands out for its tailored RAW engine and powerful color module.

Luminar Neo emphasizes AI with presets and editing modules that simplify tasks for beginners.

Sony Imaging Edge's initial download experience is cumbersome, lacking in advanced editing features.

Darktable, a free and open-source alternative, is complex and not user-friendly.

Apple Photos is user-friendly but limited by iCloud storage for exporting.

Affinity Photo is a strong Photoshop alternative, lacking advanced removal tools.

Photometer is a powerful, iCloud-based program with a focus on Lightroom-like features.

Raw Therapy, a free and open-source program, is not recommended due to complexity.

Photopea is an online Photoshop alternative that offers powerful editing tools within a browser.

DXO Labs provides a good editor with strong lens corrections and noise reduction features.

ON1 is an editing program with AI features, but it feels less polished compared to others.

Regardless of the software, good results can be achieved with knowledge and time investment.

The author encourages trying free trials of different programs to find the best fit.