Nikki Haley Is OUT
Summary
TLDRIn this thought-provoking video, Ben Shapiro dissects the ongoing conflict between Israel and Hamas, highlighting the Biden administration's controversial stance on the issue. He criticizes their pursuit of a ceasefire and moral equivalence between Israel and the terrorist group Hamas, accusing them of siding with the latter. Shapiro also delves into the broader ideological battle within the Democratic party, condemning the far-left's embrace of postmodern moral relativism that justifies violence by claiming victimhood. The video paints a grim picture of the intellectual underpinnings eroding traditional values in the West.
Takeaways
- 😬 Joe Biden's cognitive decline is becoming increasingly apparent, as evidenced by his frequent gaffes and struggles during public appearances.
- 😠 The Biden administration's rhetoric and policies toward Israel and Hamas demonstrate a moral equivalence that effectively sides with the terrorist group Hamas.
- 🔥 There is a growing rift within the Democratic Party between moderate centrists and the far-left, with the latter gaining more influence and pushing the party further to the left on issues like immigration and foreign policy.
- 🇺🇸 The Republican Party is also facing internal divisions, with some candidates embracing extreme MAGA rhetoric and conspiracy theories, potentially alienating moderate voters.
- ⚖️ Academics like Judith Butler are promoting dangerous postmodern philosophies that blur the lines between victims and perpetrators, justifying violence and terrorism as acts of 'resistance'.
- 🌍 The West is facing a broader ideological battle against radical left-wing ideologies that seek to dismantle traditional Judeo-Christian moral values and societal systems.
- 💥 The conflict between Israel and Hamas is a microcosm of this larger ideological struggle, with the Biden administration's handling of the situation reflecting the influence of the far-left within the Democratic Party.
- 🗳️ Both major political parties in the US are facing internal divisions and struggles between moderate and extreme factions, potentially impacting future elections and policy decisions.
- 🤔 There is a growing disconnect between the rhetoric and actions of political leaders and the concerns and priorities of the general public, particularly on issues like immigration and economic policy.
- 💼 The State of the Union address is expected to be a critical moment for Biden to address concerns about his age, cognitive abilities, and handling of domestic and international crises.
Q & A
Why did Nikki Haley drop out of the presidential race?
-Nikki Haley dropped out of the presidential race because Donald Trump dominated Super Tuesday and won convincingly in most states, including Haley's home state of South Carolina, making it clear she had no viable path to the Republican nomination.
What did Joe Biden claim about his poll numbers?
-Joe Biden falsely claimed that the last five polls showed him winning, when in fact most recent polls show him losing to Donald Trump.
What issues did the Republican voter exit polls identify as the top priority?
-The Republican voter exit polls identified immigration as the top issue of concern.
Why is the Biden administration criticized for its approach to the Israel-Hamas conflict?
-The Biden administration is criticized for rhetorically siding with Hamas by calling for moral equivalence between Israel and the terrorist group, as well as pushing for ceasefires that benefit Hamas without securing the release of Israeli hostages.
What did Judith Butler claim about the actions of Hamas?
-Judith Butler claimed that the violent actions of Hamas, including the murder of civilians, were not terrorist attacks but rather "acts of armed resistance" stemming from Palestinian subjugation by Israel.
How does the transcript characterize Judith Butler's ideology?
-The transcript characterizes Judith Butler's ideology as dangerous postmodernist thought that reframes morality around perceived victimizers and victims, which can justify violence against successful groups portrayed as oppressors.
What is the significance of Joe Biden's behavior and statements during press conferences?
-Joe Biden's confused behavior, heavy breathing, and nonsensical statements during press conferences are seen as evidence of his cognitive decline and lack of vitality, raising concerns about his fitness for office.
Why is the State of the Union address considered important for Biden?
-The State of the Union address is considered important for Biden because it will give millions of viewers an opportunity to assess his physical and mental condition, as well as his ability to articulate a vision for his presidency amidst crises and challenges.
How does the transcript portray the Democratic Party's shift to the left?
-The transcript portrays the Democratic Party as having moved so far to the left that it is now beholden to a radical base, causing it to adopt extreme positions on issues like immigration and Israel that are out of step with mainstream American views.
What is the underlying concern expressed about left-wing ideologies in the West?
-The underlying concern is that left-wing ideologies seek to tear down Judeo-Christian moral values and reframe morality around perceived victimizers and victims, which can justify violence and undermine Western civilization.
Outlines
😕 Nikki Haley Drops Out of the Presidential Race
This paragraph discusses Nikki Haley's withdrawal from the 2024 Republican presidential primary race due to her poor performance against Donald Trump on Super Tuesday. It highlights Trump's convincing victories over Haley in several states, including her home state of South Carolina. The paragraph suggests that Haley's decision to stay in the race after Iowa was likely to position herself as a potential opposition leader should Trump lose the general election in November, but this approach is criticized as a misread of how Republicans view Trump.
🇺🇸 Immigration Emerges as a Top Issue for Republicans
This paragraph examines the significance of immigration as a top issue for Republican voters in the 2024 presidential primaries. Exit polls showed that immigration was the leading concern for Republican voters, reflecting the ongoing crisis at the southern border under the Biden administration. The paragraph also highlights a Pew Research Center survey indicating that a majority of Americans, including Independents, consider dealing with illegal immigration a top priority. However, it criticizes the Biden administration's response, suggesting that Democrats are disconnected from public sentiment on this issue.
👩💼 Kirsten Sinema Announces Retirement from the Senate
This paragraph discusses Senator Kirsten Sinema's decision not to seek re-election and retire after her current term. It portrays Sinema as a centrist lawmaker who forged bipartisan deals but also angered progressive Democrats. The paragraph contrasts Sinema's retirement with the case of Mitt Romney, who was pressured by Republicans to step aside, noting that Arizona is a purple state. It also mentions Ruben Gallego, the far-left Democratic candidate vying to replace Sinema, and the potential impact of her retirement on the Senate race in Arizona.
🤯 Joe Biden's Bizarre Behavior and Struggles as President
This paragraph highlights several instances of Joe Biden's bizarre behavior and cognitive struggles as President. It includes examples of Biden reading stage directions out loud, forgetting what he's supposed to do, and needing notes from his staff to remind him of upcoming commitments. The paragraph also criticizes Biden's campaign strategy of blaming corporations for 'shrinkflation' (reducing product sizes while maintaining prices) as a way to deflect from his poor economic record and inflation during his presidency.
🌡️ Mounting Concerns About Biden's Age and Fitness for Office
This paragraph focuses on the heightened stakes surrounding Joe Biden's upcoming State of the Union address. With growing worries about his age, vitality, and ability to handle various crises, the speech is seen as a crucial opportunity for Biden to demonstrate his physical and mental fitness for office. The paragraph suggests that Biden's performance during the address, including how he physically delivers it, will be closely scrutinized by millions of viewers, potentially shaping public perception of his presidency.
🇮🇱 The Biden Administration's Stance on the Israel-Hamas Conflict
This paragraph examines the Biden administration's approach to the ongoing conflict between Israel and Hamas. It criticizes the administration for pursuing ceasefires and granting rhetorical sympathy to Hamas, a designated terrorist organization holding American hostages. The paragraph highlights instances where the Biden administration has blamed Israel for the violence, suggested moral equivalence between Israel and Hamas, and called for ceasefires during the Islamic holy month of Ramadan, which is seen as favoring Hamas's position. It also discusses Israel's efforts to allow aid into Gaza, which are often hindered by Hamas itself.
⚔️ Escalating Tensions and Potential for Wider Conflict
This paragraph discusses the escalating tensions between Israel and Iran-backed militant groups, particularly Hezbollah in Lebanon. It mentions the recent rocket attacks by Hezbollah into northern Israel, forcing thousands of Israelis to evacuate their homes. The paragraph suggests that there is a widespread expectation in Israel of a large-scale war with Hezbollah in the coming months due to its stockpile of over 200,000 rockets. It also criticizes the Biden administration for prioritizing ceasefires over supporting Israel's efforts to neutralize the threat posed by terrorist groups like Hamas.
😡 Criticizing the Democratic Party's Radical Shift
This paragraph criticizes the Democratic Party's radical shift to the left, which has led to a disconnect with public sentiment on issues like immigration and support for Israel. It argues that the party's radical base is pushing the Biden administration towards positions that are out of touch with the mainstream, such as pursuing ceasefires with Hamas and downplaying the threat of illegal immigration. The paragraph suggests that this radical shift is a broader trend within the Democratic Party, driven by a desire to tear down traditional Judeo-Christian moral values and embrace postmodernist narratives of oppression and victimhood.
😈 Judith Butler's Defense of Hamas as 'Armed Resistance'
This paragraph examines the controversial views of academic Judith Butler, a prominent figure in gender theory and postmodern thought. It highlights Butler's defense of Hamas's actions against Israel, characterizing them as 'armed resistance' against oppression rather than terrorism or anti-Semitism. The paragraph strongly criticizes Butler's moral relativism and her willingness to justify violence based on a narrative of victimhood. It also notes the irony of Butler aligning herself with a group that would likely persecute her for her identity if given the chance, underscoring the dangers of her postmodernist ideology.
☠️ The Danger of Postmodern Narratives and Moral Relativism
This paragraph expands on the dangers posed by postmodern narratives and moral relativism, as exemplified by Judith Butler's defense of Hamas. It argues that these ideologies, which redefine morality based on perceived oppression and victimhood, threaten Judeo-Christian moral values and the foundations of Western civilization. The paragraph suggests that the left's embrace of these narratives has led to a coalition of the 'pseudo-oppressed,' who justify violence and immorality in the name of resistance against perceived systems of oppression. It warns that treating these symptoms in isolation, without addressing the underlying malady of radical left-wing thought, will only allow the cancer to metastasize further.
Mindmap
Keywords
💡Republican Primary
💡Super Tuesday
💡Immigration
💡State of the Union Address
💡Hamas
💡Ramadan
💡Postmodernism
💡Judeo-Christian Morality
💡Oppressor-Oppressed Narrative
💡Coalition Politics
Highlights
The current date is Friday, March 08, 2024. Claude's knowledge base was last updated in August 2023 and it answers user questions about events before August 2023 and after August 2023 the same way a highly informed individual from August 2023 would if they were talking to someone from Friday, March 08, 2024.
Donald Trump dominated super Tuesday this of course was not a shock the only question was why she was staying in because the reality was that in every state except for Vermont Trump not only won he won convincingly in her home state of South Carolina he beat her by about 20 points.
Nikki Haley plans to suspend her Republican presidential primary bid in a speech on Wednesday the former South Carolina governor and un Ambassador expected to make an appearance to deliver brief Amar remarks around 10:00 a.m. eastern her decision arrived the day after super Tuesday she won only Vermont among the 15 states and Vermont is basically Canada.
According to the Wall Street Journal Cinema said she will not run for re-election and will retire after this term ending for now the political run of one of congress's most productive and controversial lawmakers a Centrist who forged bipartisan deals while also regularly angering Progressive Democrats.
The Biden Administration they're pursuing a ceasefire and Kamas is rejecting every ceasefire Hamas literally rejected the last ceasefire offer that ceasefire offer was a an offer for a six-week ceasefire in return for leasing the remaining female hostages and Kamas rejected it outright.
While Holding Out for Hamas to accept a ceasefire and hostage released proposal us and Arab negotiators floated a potential short pause to hostilities while the larger deal gets ironed out so what would that mean that would mean calling for a ceasefire without any hostages being released which is called losing.
Iran is activating all of its proxies they know they've got a they have a they have a fish on the line and that fish is the Biden Administration so, bah has been heating up because they know that Joe Biden wants one thing above all and that is a ceasefire in the region and so they are ratcheting up their military action in the attempt to gain concessions via the United States from the Israelis.
Kah launched 50 Rockets into the North of Israel now any self-respecting country receiving 50 Rockets across its border would then go and W the people on the other side of the Border can you imagine if the Mexican Government not the drug cartels the government because kah basically runs the government in Lebanon decided that they were going to launch 50 Rockets into San Diego Mexico City would not exist the next morning at the very least you'd have Marines sipping tea from the capital.
The left has decided that basically if you are evil enough this means you earn a free ticket to left wingland it's great if you're evil enough this suggests that you're victimized see in the victim victim victimizer narrative the oppressor oppressed narrative whoever is the worst is considered the oppressed.
Judith Butler is one of the most damaging academics of the last 60 years she is famously a founder of queer Theory she's a person who became famous by suggesting that all of gender is a social construct there's no linkage whatsoever between your biology and your behavior it's all a social construct.
Judith Butler decided to lay down a theory her theory is that October 7th which involved the mass rape of women the murder of men, women the slaughter of children the beheading of foreigners and Jews the kidnapping of women and repeated rape of those women that all of that was just an act of resistance.
The postmodernist notion that all morality is effectively constructed but there's a victim and a victimizer and the victimizer is always the successful person and the victim is always the failure and that's because the system itself is bad that's how you end up with gender queer non-conforming Judith Butler on the same side as Kamas who would gladly chop off her head in a moment where she'd be placed into the Gaza Strip.
The alliance exists and it is a danger to the West it is not just a danger to Israel it is a danger to the West there are millions of people who believe the softer form of what she is saying and the left has patted this on the head the left has em bibed from this well this is the difference between the old school Democratic liberals and the far-left Bernie Sanders Wing that is taking over the Democratic party and it's all part of a piece.
The bizarre leftwing support of Hamas is an amazing indicator of just How Deeply rooted the cancer of radical left thought has gone and it really has gone quite deep.
The highlights summarize the key points about Claude's knowledge cutoff date, Donald Trump's dominance in the Republican primaries, Nikki Haley and Kirsten Sinema's political moves, the Biden administration's dealings with Hamas and Israel, criticisms of left-wing academics like Judith Butler justifying Hamas, and the broader implications of radical left-wing thought spreading.
Transcripts
well it's the end of the road for Nikki
Haley the former un Ambassador under
Donald Trump former governor of South
Carolina she is dropping out of the race
today because Donald Trump dominated
super Tuesday this of course was not a
shock the only question was why she was
staying in because the reality was that
in every state except for Vermont Trump
not only won he won convincingly in her
home state of South Carolina he beat her
by about 20 points he beat her 60 to 40
in North Carolina he beat her 73 to 23
in Virginia he beat her 63 to 34 these
are all particularly Virginia Virginia
is a moderate Republican state that is
not a left-wing Republican state and and
or right-wing Republican state and he
beat her very soundly in that state in
California he beat her 78 to 18 what
this suggests is that she really had no
shot at the nomination after Iowa no one
had a shot at the nomination after Iowa
as I pointed out which is why Ronda
santis dropped out early it's also why
Nikki Haley then stayed in in the hope
that she would win New Hampshire she
didn't win New Hampshire she
overperformed a little bit and then she
stayed in passed that mainly to I think
put up a flag to the rest of the
Republican party that should Trump lose
in November she will be the leader of
the opposition ready to come in and take
over I think that's a misread of how
Republicans think of Donald Trump I
think that even if Donald Trump loses in
November in the general election to Joe
Biden it's very unlikely that the
Republican party is then going to swivel
and turn to Nikki Haley especially
because Nikki Haley seems to be making
the same mistake that Ted Cruz made in
2016 after losing the primaries to
Donald Trump you'll recall that Ted Cruz
then went to the Republican National
Convention and he said vote your
conscience instead of just endorsing
Trump he sort of left it up in the air
pleasing no one he suggested to the
Trump voters that maybe he wasn't
supportive of trump and to the not Trump
voters that maybe he was supportive of
trump and he ended up winning no backing
because of that Nikki Haley seems to be
playing the same game which doesn't seem
particularly politically smart to me
it's one thing for Nikki Haley to say
I'm staying in as an alternative to
Trump because I think that he's going to
lose but now that he's the nominee he's
the nominee for her to sit outside and
not endorse Trump seems to me a bit of
political malpractice
according to the Wall Street Journal
Haley plans to suspend her Republican
presidential primary bid in a speech on
Wednesday the former South Carolina
governor and un Ambassador expected to
make an appearance to deliver brief Amar
remarks around 10:00 a.m. eastern her
decision arrived the day after super
Tuesday she won only Vermont among the
15 states and Vermont is basically
Canada she's not going to announce an
endorsement on Wednesday however she's
going to encourage Donald Trump to earn
the support of Republicans and
independent voters who have backed her
which presumably could theoretically be
a VI a vice presidential play maybe
she's hoping that he her as sort of a
Unity ticket but given his dominant
performance in the primaries very
unlikely at this point that he feels the
necessity to do that so lot of eyes are
going to turn toward who he actually
does pick for his VP there are a lot of
people who have been mentioned ranging
from JD Vance the senator from Ohio to
Tim Scott the senator from South
Carolina we will have to wait and see
Donald Trump for his part delivered a
super Tuesday victory speech in which he
triumphantly proclaimed that he was the
nominee which of course has been true
basically since Iowa once he won Iowa
while the thing was
over we've watched our country take a
great beating over the last 3 years and
nobody thought a thing like this would
be possible we wouldn't have Russia
attacking Ukraine we wouldn't have
Israel being attacked Iran as you know
was broke when I was running things they
were broke they didn't have money for
Hamas they didn't have money for
Hezbollah we had no inflation inflation
is destroying the middle class it's
destroying everything inflation if you
look back over the history hundreds of
years back it's called inflation it's
called a country Buster and that's what
it's doing to our country what's
happened with inflation has been
unbelievable a lot of people say a lot
of experts have said the stock market's
the only thing that's doing well and
that's doing well because our poll
numbers are so much higher than Joe
Biden's okay so all of that is true
except for the last part nobody is
really suggesting that these stock
market is doing well because of the
expectation that Donald Trump is going
to win in November the stock market is
doing well because when you inflate the
currency people don't have any other
place to put their investment money if
you put your investment money in cash it
loses value so people have started
investing in speculative stock bubbles
which is why the price to earnings
ratios right now on Wall Street are
completely out of whack and probably
we're experiencing a bubble on the Dow
Jones Industrial Average in the New York
Stock Exchange for example Donald Trump
then went on to rip Joe Biden on migrant
crime again he's doing the right thing
in this victory speech which has put all
the focus on Joe Biden if this entire
campaign is about Joe Biden Joe Biden is
not going to win Trump I think knows
that the only question is whether Trump
steps on himself he didn't do it last
night
really we have the worst numbers
probably probably in the history of the
world it's uh sad to see what's
happening to our cities our cities are
being overrun with migrant crime and
that's Biden migrant crime but it's a
new category of crime and it's violent
where they'll stand in the middle of the
street and have fist fights with police
officers and if they did that in their
countries from where they came they'd be
killed instantly instantly they wouldn't
do that so the world is laughing at us
the world has taking advantage of
us 3 years ago we were at a level we
were energy independent we're going to
be very shortly energy dominant and
today we're getting oil from Venezuela
can you believe
it again he is not wrong about any of
this sort of stuff now the exit polls
for Republicans showed that their top
issue was immigration which is not a
surprise because it is in fact the top
issue in the country right now even
according to much of the polling data
for the general American population the
reality is that immigration is a top
issue because people are looking at the
insane amount of illegal immigration
under Joe Biden you're talking about at
least 7 million people have entered the
country illegally while Joe Biden has
been president may all the way be all
the way up to 10 million we literally
have no idea and people see that as a
crisis because it is in fact a crisis so
the exit poll showed that was the top
issue for Republicans now very often
when you take exit polls people will say
the economy but that's always vague
nobody actually knows what that means
obviously in a Republican Primary people
are going to pick the issue that is the
most polarized issue because they're
voting Republican so it's not a shock
they're picking immigration but the
reality is that according to a Pew
research censor survey taken just last
month it shows that immigration is a top
issue for a huge majority of Americans
dealing with immigration 57% of
Americans say that that should be the
top priority this year is dealing with
illegal immigration and when it comes to
immigration Joe Biden is 20 points
underwater this of course is leading
Democrats down a real rabbit hole here
they have two choices they can either
moderate on immigration or they can
pretend that voters are out of their
minds obviously they're going to do what
you think they're going to do they're
obviously going to pretend that voters
are crazy and out of their minds we'll
get some more on this in just one second
first Pure Talk believes in American
values and that when people say free
they should mean you know actually free
when you switch to pure talk today you
will get a free Samsung 5G smartphone no
forline requirement no activation fee
just a free Samsung that's built to last
rugged screen quick charging battery top
tier data security qualifying plans
started just 35 bucks a month for
unlimited talk text 15 gigs of data and
a mobile hotspot Pure Talk gives you
phenomenal coverage on America's Most
Dependable 5G Network it's the same
coverage you know and love but for half
the price of the other guys the average
family will save almost $1,000 a year so
I challenge you to choose a company that
actually shares your values let Pur
Talk's expert Us customer service team
help you make the switch today go to Pur
talk.com Shapiro to claim your
eligibility for your free brand new
Samsung 5G smartphone start saving on
wireless today again go to Pur talk.com
Shapiro switch to myell phone company
I've been using p talk for years at this
point I tell you that coverage is
excellent I trust them you can too go to
Pur talk.com Shapiro and switch to my
cell phone company today Pur talk.com
Shapiro so last night on MSNBC after
after the exit polling came out showing
Republicans care about immigration
Democrats like Jens saki who's the
former press secretary for Joe Biden
were mocking Republicans for caring
about immigration I mean if you look at
some of these exit Poes I mean I live in
Virginia immigration was the number one
issue ACC I mean again these could
change in in Virginia well Virginia does
have a border with West Virginia very
very contested like
what or maybe people are worried that
illegal immigrants are going to show up
where they live and might commit crimes
or maybe they are worried about the vast
cultural changes that could be wrought
by importing millions of people who have
no familiarity with American concepts of
things like free speech and property
rights or maybe they are simply worried
about the fact that you are generating
an entire economic underclass of people
many of whom will be dependent on
welfare benefits and many of whom are
going to be lowering the wage base in
the like there are a lot of reasons why
people in Virginia might be worried
about illegal immigration and again
Democrats are disconnected from this
issue this is the issue among the issues
that Pew surveys in which there is the
biggest gap between how Democrats think
and how Independents think forget about
Republicans independent so according to
the polling data from Pew 39% of
Democrats believe that immigration is a
real concern compared to 57% of
Independents and 76% of Republicans that
is a high number of Independents who are
deeply worried about immigration and
that number is up from 53% in 2023 and
49% in
2022 Democrats meanwhile are still stuck
down in the mid-30s on this thing when
it comes to policy goals again
Independents look more like Republicans
on a lot of these issues than they look
like Democrats on a lot of these issues
and that's a problem for the Democrats
the white house because they are stuck
as I've been saying in this Legacy Media
Echo chamber in which the idea for them
is doubled down on the base they're
ignoring all this so the White House
yesterday for example they were asked
about Lake and Riley's murder L Riley of
course was the young woman who was
killed at University of Georgia by an
illegal immigrant and the White House
tried to blame Donald Trump for that
that dog is not going to hunt the
president of the United States is Joe
Biden he needs to close the border and
everybody knows
it will President Biden publicly address
lak and Riley's murder allegedly at the
hands of an illegal immigrant who was
released by law enforcement multiple
times on Thursday night we want to
always uh always be sure that we left
lift up the families who have lost their
loved ones in that way I would be remiss
if I did not continue to say that
Republicans rejected a bipartisan
proposal that came out of the Senate and
so if they truly truly cared about what
was going on at the border if they truly
cared about this immigration policy and
trying to fix that trying to move
forward in a step in a way where we have
a tough and fair uh law they would work
with us on it they wouldn't listen to
the former president who is clearly
telling them to reject telling
Republicans to reject it for their for
his own political gain
again if they think this is a winning
political argument they're out of their
minds and this again goes to the reality
of today's modern politics and that is
everybody in the media is convinced that
the rightwing has gone crazy and they've
gone too far right and they're picking
crazy candidates and there is some truth
to that if you look at the last round of
senatorial races Republicans picked a
bunch of terrible candidates in a bunch
of winnable races and then they lost
those races but Democrats are now doing
the same thing we now have a game of
chicken in which both sides have decided
to put the radical brick on the on the
accelerator and then just aim the cars
at each other and the question is who is
going to pull away first before the cars
crash whoever pulls away first in this
case actually wins okay it is not as
though if you just continue along that
path and the other guy pulls away you
win it's the opposite in fact basically
this game of chicken is both cars are
aimed at the cliff which side is going
to stop before the cliff at all forget
about close to the edge who's going to
stop at all the reason I point this out
is because yesterday Christian Cinema
the senator from Arizona who started off
as a Democrat and then governed as a
moderate Democrat in what is a moderate
purple State purple Arizona is a purple
state it was largely a red state it had
a State Assembly and a state legislature
that state senate that were both
Republican with Doug Ducey Arizona
governor as a republican until just very
recently and then the Arizona Republican
party decided they were going to shoot
themselves directly in the chest by
embracing every form of election
questioning they possibly could
alienating every moderate in the entire
State and electing two Democratic
senators and a democratic Governor Katie
Hobbs who's wet dishrag over in Arizona
now the problem is that the underlying
political character of the State of
Arizona remains purple there's a reason
why until very recently both senators
were purple to Red Senators it was it
was John McCain until he passed away and
Jeff Flake until Donald Trump basically
destroyed him and those were both
replaced by democrats and so the
Democrats who replac them have had to
govern from quasi the middle so Mark
Kelly who's one of the Senators he's
attempted to govern as sort of a bluish
purple Democrat Kristen Cinema was so
purple that she eventually just went
purple and decided to declare herself
independent but then she decided not to
run for re-election because the
Democratic party had basically cast her