Cowboys Draft Grades: All 7 Rounds From 2024 NFL Draft Ft. Tyler Guyton, Cooper Beebe, Justin Rogers

Cowboys Report by Chat Sports
27 Apr 202414:45

Summary

TLDRIn this Cowboys Report, Tom Downey provides an in-depth analysis of the Dallas Cowboys' 2024 NFL draft picks. The discussion starts with the first-round selection, Tyler Smith, who is expected to become a left tackle, and continues with the second-round pick, Marshon Lattimore, a defensive end from Western Michigan. Cooper BB, a guard from Kansas State, is highlighted as a favorite pick, offering great value in the third round. The conversation also touches on the team's decision to not draft a running back, despite perceived need, and the potential impact of later-round selections like Kayin Carson, Ryan Floro, Nathan Thomas, and Justin Rogers. Downey concludes with a grade of B- for the Cowboys' draft class, expressing concern over the team's running back situation and the need for further development of the drafted players.

Takeaways

  • 🏈 The 2024 NFL draft is complete, and it's time to evaluate the Dallas Cowboys' performance in the draft.
  • πŸ”„ Tyler Smith, the Cowboys' first-round pick (29th overall), is expected to transition to left tackle, a position he's more comfortable with.
  • 🎯 The Cowboys addressed their need for a left tackle early and also focused on strengthening the offensive line throughout the draft.
  • 🏁 Cooper Bishop, picked in the third round (73rd overall), is a favorite selection who could contribute significantly to the offensive line.
  • πŸ€” There was some surprise regarding the selection of Maurice Lefau in the third round (87th overall), as some analysts had the Cowboys with a higher grade on him.
  • πŸ‘€ Kayin Carson, a corner from Wake Forest, was picked in the fifth round (174th overall), adding depth to a position that was underrated in terms of need.
  • πŸ‹οΈβ€β™‚οΈ Ryan Floro, a wide receiver from Southeast Missouri State, was selected for his speed, which is a characteristic lacking in the current Cowboys' receivers.
  • πŸ”„ The Cowboys triple-dipped in the offensive line, indicating a strong focus on improving a unit that struggled in the previous season.
  • πŸ‘ Nathan Thomas, picked in the sixth round (185th overall), is seen as a good value pick who could potentially transition to guard.
  • πŸ‘ Justin Rogers, a nose guard from Auburn, was selected in the seventh round (270th overall) to bolster the run defense.
  • 🚨 The biggest concern for the Cowboys post-draft is the lack of a significant addition at the running back position, which is considered the team's most pressing need.

Q & A

  • What was the Dallas Cowboys' first round pick in the 2024 NFL draft?

    -The Cowboys' first round pick was Tyler Smith, the soon-to-be left tackle from Oklahoma, who was selected with the 29th overall pick.

  • Who did the Cowboys select in the second round of the draft?

    -In the second round, the Cowboys selected Marshon L'Heureux, an edge rusher from Western Michigan with the 56th overall pick.

  • What was the general consensus on Cooper BB's draft position?

    -Cooper BB was considered a top 42 player and was the Cowboys' pick at 41st overall, which was round three, pick number 73.

  • Which player was picked in the fifth round by the Cowboys, and what was the general sentiment about this choice?

    -The Cowboys selected Kayvon Thibodeaux in the fifth round, with the 174th overall pick. The sentiment was mixed, as some felt the team should have focused on a running back.

  • What was the host's opinion on the Cowboys' running back selection?

    -The host expressed concern that the Cowboys did not select a running back, which he considers to be a significant need for the team.

  • Who was the Cowboys' first selection in the sixth round of the draft?

    -The Cowboys selected Ryan Floi, a wide receiver from Southeast Missouri State, in the sixth round.

  • What was the host's final grade for the Cowboys' 2024 NFL draft class?

    -The host gave the Cowboys' draft class a B minus grade.

  • Which player was the host's favorite pick for the Cowboys in the 2024 NFL draft?

    -The host's favorite pick was Cooper BB, a guard from Kansas State.

  • What was the position change for Cooper BB?

    -Cooper BB was expected to transition from guard to center for the Dallas Cowboys.

  • Which player was selected in the seventh round by the Cowboys, and what is their position?

    -The Cowboys selected Justin Rogers, a nose guard from Auburn, in the seventh round.

  • What is the host's concern regarding the Cowboys' running back situation?

    -The host is concerned that the Cowboys' running back room is in poor shape and is currently the worst in the NFL.

Outlines

00:00

🏈 NFL Draft Recap for Cowboys

The first paragraph discusses the 2024 NFL draft for the Cowboys. It covers the team's picks, trades, and the potential impact of each player. The focus is on Tyler Smith, the left tackle from Oklahoma, Marshon Neand, the defensive end from Western Michigan, and Cooper BB, a guard from Kansas State. The commentary also touches on the team's need for a running back and the potential value in later round picks.

05:01

πŸ‹οΈβ€β™‚οΈ Assessing the Cowboys' Defensive Strengths and Needs

In the second paragraph, the discussion shifts to the Cowboys' defensive needs, particularly the addition of Marshon Neand as a run stopper. The paragraph also highlights the potential of Cooper BB as a center for the Dallas Cowboys and the value of later round picks like Kayin Carson and Ryan Floro. The narrative emphasizes the importance of the offensive line and the team's strategy in the draft.

10:01

πŸ“ˆ Evaluating the Cowboys' Draft Strategy and Player Fit

The third paragraph evaluates the Cowboys' draft strategy, focusing on the selection of Nathan Thomas and Justin Rogers. It discusses the potential position changes for these players and their fit within the Cowboys' scheme. The paragraph also addresses the team's lack of a running back pick and the implications for the team's roster. The final grade given to the Cowboys' draft class is a B minus, reflecting concerns about the running back position.

Mindmap

Keywords

πŸ’‘2024 NFL Draft

The 2024 NFL Draft is the event where American football teams select eligible players to join their rosters. It is a significant event for teams to improve their performance and fill gaps in their lineup. In the video, the host is grading the Dallas Cowboys' performance in the draft.

πŸ’‘Tyler Biadasz

Tyler Biadasz is a football player who was selected by the Dallas Cowboys in the first round of the 2024 NFL Draft. The host mentions him as a soon-to-be left tackle, indicating his expected position and the team's need for a player in that role.

πŸ’‘Marshon L'Heureux

Marshon L'Heureux is another player drafted by the Cowboys in the second round. He is described as a potential long-term replacement for Tank Lawrence, highlighting his defensive capabilities and the team's strategy to strengthen their defense.

πŸ’‘Cooper Bassin

Cooper Bassin was the Cowboys' third-round pick and is noted by the host as a favorite selection. He is mentioned as a powerful downhill run blocker, emphasizing his potential contribution to the team's offensive line.

πŸ’‘Kayin Carson

Kayin Carson, drafted in the fifth round, is from Wake Forest and is considered a good fit for the Cowboys' defensive strategy under coach Mike Zimmer. The host discusses the team's need for a cornerback and Carson's potential to fill that role.

πŸ’‘Ryan Floro

Ryan Floro is a wide receiver from Southeast Missouri State who was picked by the Cowboys. The host points out the team's lack of speed at the receiver position and sees Floro as a player who could bring that element to the team.

πŸ’‘Nathan Thomas

Nathan Thomas is an offensive tackle selected in the sixth round by the Cowboys. The host suggests that Thomas might transition to playing guard due to his size and strength, indicating a strategic move to optimize the player's skills.

πŸ’‘Justin Rogers

Justin Rogers, a nose guard from Auburn, was the Cowboys' seventh-round pick. The host describes him as a powerful player with the ability to anchor against double teams, emphasizing his potential impact on the team's defensive line.

πŸ’‘Running Back

The term 'running back' refers to a position in American football where the player carries the ball during running plays. The host expresses concern about the Cowboys' lack of drafting a running back, which is a critical position for a balanced offensive strategy.

πŸ’‘Grade

In the context of the video, 'grade' refers to the host's assessment of the Cowboys' draft picks. The host gives the team a 'B minus' grade, indicating a mixed review of their selections and strategy in the 2024 NFL Draft.

πŸ’‘Undarafted Free Agency (UDFA)

UDFA refers to players who were not selected in the NFL Draft but are still eligible to be signed as free agents by any team. The host mentions U DFA as an upcoming event where the Cowboys might find additional talent to bolster their roster.

Highlights

The 2024 NFL draft is complete, and it's time to evaluate the Dallas Cowboys' performance.

Tyler Smith was selected in a trade to the Cowboys as the soon-to-be left tackle in the first round, pick number 29.

Round two saw the Cowboys pick Marshon Lattimore, an edge rusher from Western Michigan, at pick number 56.

Cooper Bess, from Kansas State, was a favorite pick for the Cowboys in round three, selected at number 73.

The Cowboys' selection of Maurice Lefau, a running back from Notre Dame, at pick number 87 was a surprise.

In round five, the Cowboys chose Kayin Carson, a corner from Wake Forest, at pick number 174.

Ryan Floro, a wide receiver from Southeast Missouri State, was picked in the sixth round, adding speed to the Cowboys' roster.

Nathan Thomas, an offensive tackle, was selected in the seventh round, with the Cowboys focusing on the offensive line.

Justin Rogers, a nose guard from Auburn, was the final pick for the Cowboys in the seventh round.

The lack of a running back pick is a significant concern for the Cowboys' draft strategy.

The Cowboys' draft class is graded as a B-, reflecting a mix of strategic and surprising picks.

Tyler Smith's comfort on the left side of the offensive line was a key factor in his selection.

The potential for Tyler Smith to become a top-three tackle from the draft class is highlighted.

Cooper Bess's value pick at 41st on the board versus 73rd in the draft is noted as a great selection.

The Cowboys' triple dip on the offensive line indicates a focus on improving a previously weak area.

The selection of Ryan Floro is praised for adding a much-needed speed element to the wide receiver group.

The potential of Justin Rogers as a powerful run stopper and anchor is emphasized.

The final grade of B- reflects concerns over the running back position despite individual picks being well-received.

Transcripts

00:05

[Music]

00:09

welcome into the Cowboys report I am Tom

00:12

Downey the 2024 NFL draft officially in

00:15

the books that means it is time to grade

00:18

what the Cowboys did knowing undrafted

00:20

FR agency here to come the Cowboys will

00:22

probably have some nice success on that

00:24

but that's tomorrow's video first a

00:26

recap of the picks made part of a trade

00:28

down Tyler gon to the Cowboys the soon

00:32

to be left tackle he says he's more

00:33

comfortable there by the way out of

00:35

Oklahoma round one pick number 29

00:38

overall that was very expected bit of a

00:40

surprise in round two pick number 56

00:43

Marshon neand The Edge out of Western

00:47

Michigan that is your long-term most

00:49

likely tank Lawrence replacement he can

00:51

help stop the run you don't have guys

00:52

that can do that right now especially at

00:54

defensive end on this roster Beyond tank

00:57

my favorite pick Cooper BB who was the

00:59

top 42 player 41st overall for me on my

01:01

board out of Kansas state that was round

01:05

three pick number 73 I love that

01:08

selection two starters along the

01:10

offensive line then the one that I think

01:13

most people have more interest with it

01:15

was the outlier relative to the

01:16

consensus draft board uh the pick that

01:19

you regret maybe not getting a running

01:21

back uh with potentially Maurice lefau

01:24

out of Notre Dame that was pick number

01:26

87 overall uh clearly Cowboys much High

01:29

higher on him than myself and most

01:32

people were round five I love the value

01:36

and we'll talk about the whole running

01:37

back debacle in a little bit here round

01:39

five pick number 174 kayn Carson out of

01:43

Wake Forest I think is a good Mike

01:45

Zimmer type of corner corner was an

01:47

underrated need because you had needs

01:49

everywhere there that's 174 for Dallas

01:53

Ryan floro the wide receiver out of

01:56

Southeast Missouri State Simo the rare

01:59

small scho pick FCS by the I think it's

02:02

FCS or D2 Whatever It Is by the Dallas

02:05

Cowboys there's no speed at receiver

02:07

foro actually has that the seventh

02:10

rounders didn't do cuts for those guys

02:12

we'll spend some more time on them today

02:14

Nathan Thomas was 185 overall on my

02:17

board was my best available offensive

02:19

tackle Cowboys triple dip on the

02:22

offensive line uh as they look for some

02:24

help after a pretty rough go uh in terms

02:28

of the offensive line play this past

02:30

year especially some key pieces there uh

02:33

185 for me 233 for the Cowboys and then

02:37

they did get another run stopping nose

02:39

guard Justin Rogers Fatty's only Rides

02:41

Again 270 overall he was my second best

02:45

available nose guard left not surprised

02:47

he was drafted there big addition uh

02:49

literally for the Cowboys there in round

02:52

seven so my grade still a B minus and if

02:55

you had taken Jaylen Wright over Maurice

02:57

lefou I'd have been feel pretty good

02:59

right now but man I think your biggest

03:00

need was running back and you got none

03:01

of those guys you're gonna ride with

03:04

Rico dowle and and ruce vongh and and Le

03:08

Davis and Royce Freeman and we assume

03:10

Zeke Elliott

03:11

I that's dicey but the individual picks

03:14

for the most part I did like so grade

03:17

the Cowboys 2024 NFL draft class A B C D

03:22

or F goad and sound off for me at the

03:24

pin comment of today's video especially

03:27

if the ad comes here on YouTube

03:30

Tyler gon the pick in round one he was

03:33

30th overall on my board he was 29th

03:36

pick for the Cowboys I I didn't love the

03:38

value once you got outside the top like

03:39

27 is picks and I would have loved grah

03:42

Barton you traded down you got extra

03:44

assets that helps your overall grade

03:45

there he's raw he's not inexperienced

03:47

he's raw well he's inexperienced too but

03:49

but he's raw he says he's more

03:52

comfortable on the left side of the

03:54

offensive line the Cowboys knew that

03:56

they desperately wanted a left tackle

03:58

I'm not see if he's ever was the actual

04:00

top player on the board uh at that

04:02

particular time but gon was a need Phils

04:05

a need the upside is that he can become

04:07

a top three tackle from this loaded

04:10

class but there is development to be

04:13

done the bright side is historically

04:16

speaking this team tends to do a pretty

04:19

good job of maximizing offensive line

04:22

pick specifically in the first round so

04:25

of all the spots I trust them and I've

04:27

been very negative this off season

04:29

tackle round one I tend to trust them

04:31

with now if you have not already hit

04:33

that sub button here on the Cowboys

04:36

report 188k is the next goal 187 is the

04:41

new number a lot of new people I

04:43

guarantee watching this video hit that

04:45

sub button so you don't miss out udfa is

04:47

coming to you guys

04:49

tomorrow go to the edge rusher Marshon

04:51

neand who I was a little bit lower on

04:54

than the consensus you know Dame bro

04:56

hadam is a top 32 overall player split

04:58

the difference uh between Dan and I here

05:00

for this

05:01

pick you don't have good run Stoppers at

05:04

the edge rusher spot you have tank

05:06

Lawrence he's great Mike is not a great

05:08

run stopper at this time that's okay he

05:09

still pass it's fine Sam Williams has

05:12

growth to do junior foko is didn't do

05:15

anything at all last season so adding I

05:18

think a tank Lawrence type of player in

05:21

Marsha neand in terms of being able to

05:24

be a run stopper is intriguing he's a

05:26

good athlete really good athlete so the

05:28

hope is there's more up as a pass rusher

05:31

the problem is he hasn't produced his

05:32

pass rusher um he had a great

05:34

performance against Eastern Michigan had

05:36

three and a half I think was three and a

05:37

half sacks in that game or three sacks

05:38

whatever it was and then had like one or

05:41

one and a half the rest of the season I

05:42

need more that dominance that's why I

05:44

was a bit lower the Easter Michigan game

05:46

showed what he can be where was the rest

05:48

of that over the course of the season is

05:50

is my my main question mark there

05:53

Today's Show is made possible by Mando

05:56

spring into the season with ad that can

05:59

handle the heat Mando is clinically

06:01

proven to work hard all day instead of

06:03

covering Bo with heavy fragrances Mando

06:06

stops odor at the source stopping the

06:09

stink from happening before it even gets

06:11

going in the first place created by a

06:13

doctor Mando wholebody deodorant is

06:17

powerful enough for the toughest body

06:19

odor but gentle in terms of being able

06:21

to use on your uh your old Family Jewels

06:24

Mando's starter pack is perfect for new

06:26

customers it comes with a solid Stick

06:28

deodorant cream tube deodorant two free

06:30

products of your choice like the mini

06:32

body wash and deodorant wipes and free

06:34

shipping by the way there's also a

06:36

discount code for you guys to get hooked

06:38

and it saves $5 off the starter pack

06:41

which is equivalent to over

06:43

40% off 40% off with code chat CH h a t

06:48

over at

06:49

shop.com that's s h o p m n d o

06:54

shop.com it is skinsafe and it is based

06:57

in science as well links in the comments

07:00

section and the description of today's

07:03

show go to round three Cooper BB the

07:06

guard who will be a center for the

07:09

Dallas Cowboys look there is position

07:11

change involved here BB did get practice

07:15

reps at Center at Kansas State his arm

07:16

length probably makes him a pretty good

07:18

option there at Center uh I had him 41st

07:21

on my board relative to Val this one of

07:23

my favorite picks in the drafts straight

07:24

up you got him at 41 vers 73 on the top

07:28

that's really rare value value in terms

07:30

of how my board ends up playing out

07:32

there so I love that pick he is a

07:34

powerful downhill run blocker I think

07:37

especially with BB coming in maybe not

07:39

week one but as the year goes on I think

07:41

the ability to have a better ground game

07:43

from a blocking

07:45

perspective talk about the players in

07:47

the schem the scheme I still don't love

07:48

that much I think the Run blockers up

07:50

front if gon can develop into what I

07:52

think he can be has the ability to be

07:54

much better than what it was in previous

07:57

Seasons especially this past year by by

07:59

the way 14 picks later Rees leow out of

08:03

Notre Dame I have talked to people

08:06

outside of the Cowboys organization that

08:08

are in the NFL that I know uh were much

08:10

higher on him than me I was pretty

08:13

similar to the consensus board he was in

08:14

the 180s on that I had him at 200 um I

08:19

know some guys that had him in the

08:20

fourth that had him you know Fringe top

08:22

100 I'm not mad about passing on pton

08:25

Wilson that's medical that's not a big

08:26

deal for me I I just didn't see Splash

08:28

impact plays

08:30

I think it's a good Mike Zimmer fit um I

08:32

think there's some good coverage stuff

08:33

involved there I hope Mike Zimmer's got

08:35

this one right I hope this is more like

08:38

ah you know I wasn't as high relative to

08:41

the Cowboys pick on Osa odiga also a

08:44

third round pick I liked him but not I

08:46

it was a half round round early there

08:48

and this is not a Nishan wri 2.0 pick

08:50

that's my that's my goal uh from that

08:53

perspective this ends up being not a uh

08:55

not a disaster uh from the Cowboys

08:58

perspective I hope that ends up up being

09:00

a better outcome for the

09:02

Cowboys so grade that Cowboys draft

09:04

class for me A B C D or F if you haven't

09:08

already please do so for me in the

09:11

comment section I want to see the

09:13

comments flooded today that's why we're

09:15

asking it twice of you guys on today's

09:17

show as we move forward here to some of

09:19

the day three selections uh out of the

09:22

Dallas Cowboys A B C D or F get those

09:27

comments in for me in the comments

09:29

section

09:30

kayin Carson Wake Forest again the lack

09:33

of a running back I know kind of rears

09:34

its edly head these last two picks there

09:36

I liked kayin Carson though uh 137

09:39

overall on my board he's 174 I thought I

09:42

was going to be lower than cons the than

09:44

where he ended up going because I got

09:46

questions if he's top end speed enough

09:48

to play some good man but he's High

09:50

football IQ guy I think that will fit

09:52

Mike Zimmer really well I want to see

09:54

more ball skill more production from

09:56

that uh from that angle but he's a

09:59

willing tackler there is some special

10:01

teams value I don't believe in Deshawn

10:03

Wright it's a new regime we'll see how

10:05

they feel about Eric Scott Corner was a

10:07

need because one guy goes down you're in

10:09

trouble again I think Carson in the

10:11

fifth I bet they had at least the fourth

10:12

round grade on him frankly so I I do

10:14

like the the value angle of getting

10:17

kayen Carson there individual of the

10:19

pick itself I I did like that pick quite

10:22

a bit who was your favorite pick this

10:25

season for the Dallas Cowboys in the any

10:28

round any pick maybe it's gu it's Cooper

10:29

BB for me by the way but drop that

10:32

player name for me your favorite draft

10:34

pick by the Dallas Cowboys this

10:37

season round six again you didn't have

10:40

as much day three capital as you would

10:42

have liked Ryan floi the Cowboys don't

10:45

have any speed at wide receiver CD Lambs

10:47

is not a burner kante Turpin is but he's

10:48

undersized Ryan floi is the exact type

10:51

of receiver I've been looking for this

10:53

team to add for several years now he

10:55

just happens to be the very rare small

10:57

school player and not a lot of those

10:58

guys the Cowboys by the way uh 235 for

11:01

me pick 216 so again when we're in we're

11:04

in the day three range six round picks

11:07

it's no worse than a c individual grade

11:08

for me it's a sixth round pick who cares

11:10

like you're taking shots anyway the the

11:13

expectation is low almost 61 202 three

11:17

drops in his career or sorry four drops

11:19

a a sub 3.5% career drop rate big hands

11:23

big body fast

11:25

4440 yard dash becomes probably your

11:28

second fastest wide receiver barring

11:30

maybe some udfas will break down later

11:32

on this week here I like the value there

11:35

it brings you a different type of

11:37

receiver than what this team has will he

11:39

make the roster who knows it's going to

11:41

be a lot of udfa competition coming in

11:43

here this Cowboys roster as

11:45

well round seven Nathan Thomas uh all

11:50

but two of his snaps have come at left

11:53

tackle I am interested in maybe putting

11:56

him inside the guard uh big guy 65 332

12:01

has sub 34in arms normally a red flag

12:04

for Dallas but again I had a fifth sl6

12:07

round grade on him he's 185 for me on my

12:10

board powerful player he's a really good

12:12

run blocker especially in zone schemes

12:15

which I'd love to run more of in Dallas

12:17

uh he will hit he will hit hard the the

12:19

hands are powerful the testing was good

12:22

enough at his size he is not the

12:24

quickest player though and that's why

12:26

I'm intrigued by a transition inside the

12:28

guard where I think you can let him use

12:30

his power a little bit more and helps

12:33

negate some of the potential lunging

12:35

issues he tends to run into again I know

12:37

it's not a running back I like the

12:39

Nathan Thomas pick I surprised they

12:40

triple dipped on the offensive line I

12:43

got a good value pick there though for

12:45

me Justin roggers out of Auburn uh this

12:49

his game is summed up like this it's all

12:51

about that anchor he is a powerful

12:54

player this is a Fatty's only pick Mike

12:57

Zimmer cares about big defense lineman

12:59

baby 62 and2 322 33in arms fantastic

13:03

length he doesn't get moved very much in

13:06

the Run game this is a two gapping nose

13:09

guard who can take on double teams and

13:11

not get pushed a lot he will anchor as a

13:15

run stopper and he will get anchored as

13:18

a pass rusher he he doesn't get moved in

13:21

the Run game and he does not move in the

13:24

passing game this is Lou Nicks if you

13:26

remember him the former Notre Dame

13:28

defensive lineman as a a run stopper

13:31

there he's not a good athlete he's

13:32

actually he's actually a really bad

13:33

athlete uh but two gappy nose guard fact

13:37

go Theory just just don't move that much

13:39

so my final grade I'm going to go with

13:41

the B minus I I I am very concerned

13:45

about this running back room for the

13:47

Dallas Cowboys it is not in good shape

13:49

it is the worst running back room in the

13:51

NFL no matter who you sign as a free

13:53

agent or a udfa the Cowboys have not

13:57

addressed that position running back

13:59

don't matter but they still matter a

14:00

little bit right uh they don't matter as

14:03

much as other spots maybe someone gets

14:06

cut maybe a trade for somebody coming

14:08

down the line in the end who ends up

14:12

being rv1 for this Dallas Cowboys

14:13

football team very well might be Zeke

14:16

Elliott and i' I've made my thoughts

14:17

clear on that I'll stop complaining at

14:19

some point hit that sub button and tell

14:21

me who you got his rb1 for the Cowboys

14:25

[Music]