It Begins… Texas Sends More Migrants to NYC

Cash Jordan
28 May 202417:38

Summary

TLDRThe video script discusses the ongoing migrant crisis in New York City, highlighting the tension between the city's commitment to providing shelter and the practical limitations it faces. It touches on the Texas governor's plan to send more asylum seekers to New York, the city's eviction of migrants from shelters after 30 or 60 days, and the ensuing protests from activists. The script also explores the political implications, the city's lawsuit against bus companies transporting migrants, and the complexities of navigating humanitarian aid within a strained system. It concludes by questioning the impact of activism on the crisis and the need for a more effective solution.

Takeaways

  • 🚨 The Texas governor plans to continue sending migrants to sanctuary cities, including New York, causing potential issues as thousands continue to arrive weekly.
  • 🏙️ Local residents in New York are pressuring the city to shut down shelters deemed inhumane, which could leave new arrivals without accommodation.
  • 🔄 New York City leaders are not stopping evictions for adult migrants who have reached their shelter limit, leading to a 'revolving door' situation in the shelter system.
  • 📉 The city's lawsuit against bus companies transporting migrants has led to a decrease in arrivals from 4,000 to 1,300 people per week.
  • 🤝 Mayor Adams has been critical of both the Texas governor's actions and the local hypocrisy regarding shelter provision and migrant care.
  • 💼 Mayor Adams is implementing laws with limited resources and facing criticism despite efforts to address the crisis.
  • 🤔 There is a debate over the duration people should stay in shelters, with some advocating for permanent stays and others supporting time limits to accommodate new arrivals.
  • 🛑 The city's shelters are so full that there are lines of people waiting for re-admittance after eviction, highlighting the strain on resources.
  • 📉 Activists are upset with the city's decision to shut down the initial Texas bus program, claiming it has complicated their efforts to assist new arrivals.
  • 🗳️ Polling shows that 80% of New Yorkers are in favor of the right to shelter, but there is local resistance when shelters are placed in specific neighborhoods.
  • 🔄 The city is caught in a cycle of protests against new shelters and pushback when people are unable to stay in them, revealing a conflict between compassion and practicality.

Q & A

  • What is the main issue discussed in the video script regarding migrants in New York City?

    -The main issue discussed is the ongoing migrant crisis in New York City, where thousands of migrants are arriving weekly and the city is struggling to provide adequate shelter and resources, leading to conflicts and evictions from shelters.

  • What is the Texas governor's stance on sending migrants to New York City?

    -The Texas governor has vowed to continue sending migrants to New York City, calling the residents hypocrites for their protests against shelters and claiming that the city is not adequately caring for the migrants.

  • What is the city's response to the Texas governor's actions?

    -New York City's mayor, Eric Adams, has criticized the Texas governor's actions as cowardly and has taken legal action against bus companies involved in transporting migrants, aiming to limit the number of people arriving in the city.

  • Why are there protests and conflicts over the establishment of new shelters in New York City?

    -There are protests and conflicts because local residents often view new shelters as inhumane and believe they contribute to increased crime and strain on public resources, leading to opposition whenever a new shelter is proposed.

  • What is the 'right to shelter' policy in New York City, and why is it controversial?

    -The 'right to shelter' policy in New York City mandates that the city provide temporary shelter to anyone in need. It's controversial because it puts pressure on the city's limited resources and leads to a revolving door situation where people are evicted after a certain period to make room for new arrivals.

  • How has the city's lawsuit against bus companies affected the flow of migrants into New York City?

    -The lawsuit has resulted in some bus companies ceasing their operations, reducing the number of migrants arriving in the city. However, it has also led to a more scattered and unpredictable arrival of migrants, complicating efforts by humanitarian organizations to assist them.

  • What is the city's current approach to dealing with the shelter crisis?

    -The city is attempting to balance the need to provide shelter with the limitations of its resources. This includes enforcing evictions after a certain period and trying to manage the flow of migrants into the city through legal actions against transport companies.

  • What is the role of activism in the current migrant crisis in New York City?

    -Activism plays a significant role, with some groups protesting against shelter evictions and others advocating for more permanent solutions. However, the script suggests that activism has become a trend, leading to conflicting demands and making it difficult for the city to find a satisfactory solution.

  • How does the script describe the public's perception of the migrant crisis and the city's response?

    -The script describes a divide in public perception, with many New Yorkers supporting the right to shelter in principle but opposing specific shelter locations in their neighborhoods. It suggests that there is a disconnect between the compassion people express for migrants and the actual support for solutions in their communities.

  • What are the challenges faced by humanitarian organizations in assisting migrants in New York City?

    -Humanitarian organizations face challenges such as a lack of standard procedures for migrant arrivals due to the city's legal actions against transport companies, limited resources to assist a growing number of migrants, and the difficulty of tracking and providing aid to migrants who are arriving at various locations throughout the city.

  • What is the implication of the 'right to shelter' policy on the city's ability to manage its resources and provide long-term assistance to migrants?

    -The 'right to shelter' policy, while intended to provide immediate assistance, may hinder the city's ability to manage its resources effectively and provide long-term support. It creates a situation where migrants are evicted after a short period, potentially before they can secure work or integrate into society, leading to a cycle of dependency and limited opportunities for improvement.

Outlines

00:00

🚌 Conflict Over Migrant Shelters in New York City

The video script discusses the ongoing migrant crisis in New York City, highlighting the tension between Texas' policy of sending migrants to sanctuary cities and New York's struggle to accommodate them. The speaker mentions the Texas governor's promise to continue bussing migrants to New York, despite local resistance and the city's limited resources. New York City's mayor, Adams, is criticized for evictions of adult migrants who have reached their shelter limit, while also being accused of hypocrisy for his stance on shelters contributing to neighborhood issues. The script touches on the city's failed attempt to repeal the right to shelter requirements, leading to a 'revolving door' situation at shelters. The mayor's response to Texas' threats includes calling the Texas governor a coward and suing bus companies involved in transporting migrants, which has resulted in a significant decrease in arrivals. However, the underlying issue remains the city's inability to provide long-term solutions for asylum seekers amidst political and activist pressures.

05:00

🤔 The Paradox of Activism and Asylum Seeker Support

This paragraph delves into the complexities surrounding the treatment of asylum seekers in New York City. It describes the city's lawsuit against bus companies for transporting migrants, which has led to a reduction in arrivals but also criticism from activists. The city's shelters are portrayed as full and ill-equipped for the influx, leading to evictions that contradict the right to shelter laws. The script mentions the city's demand for $700 million in damages from bus companies and the challenges faced by humanitarians in tracking and assisting new arrivals due to the lack of a standard procedure. The paragraph also highlights the public's divided opinion on shelter policies, with some advocating for permanent shelter and others supporting time limits to accommodate new arrivals. The mayor's efforts to manage the crisis within legal constraints and limited resources are contrasted with the ongoing activism and the city's struggle to find a balanced approach.

10:01

🏚️ The Struggle with Temporary Shelter Solutions

The script addresses the controversy over New York City's shelter system for migrants, which is strained by the high volume of new arrivals. It explains that the city's shelters are designed for temporary stays, leading to evictions after 30 or 60 days, a policy that has been criticized as cruel and inhumane. The video points out the discrepancy between the city's laws, which mandate a right to shelter, and the practical limitations of providing long-term housing for an unlimited number of people. It also discusses the challenges faced by migrants who have filed asylum paperwork but are waiting for work permits, leaving them unable to support themselves. The paragraph highlights the city's dilemma in trying to abide by the law while managing limited resources and the resulting public backlash, which includes protests against both the establishment and closure of shelters.

15:01

📢 The Impact of Activism on Asylum Seeker Policies

The final paragraph of the script explores the role of activism in shaping the city's response to the migrant crisis. It describes how activism has led to conflicting demands and outcomes, with protesters advocating both for the removal of shelters and for the extension of shelter stay limits. The video suggests that activism has become a trend, with some activists opposing any government action without considering the broader implications. It criticizes the city's approach to the crisis, which has resulted in a 'revolving door' of shelter stays and evictions, and questions whether the activism is exacerbating the problem for asylum seekers. The script concludes by questioning the effectiveness of activism when it overshadows the practical needs of the migrants and the city's capacity to support them.

Mindmap

Keywords

💡Sanctuary cities

Sanctuary cities are municipalities that limit their cooperation with federal immigration enforcement. In the video, Texas Governor's plan to bus migrants to sanctuary cities like New York highlights the tensions and practical challenges these cities face in accommodating large numbers of asylum seekers.

💡Shelter system

The shelter system refers to the network of temporary housing facilities for homeless and asylum seekers. The video discusses New York City's shelter system, focusing on the challenges of capacity limits and the policies of evicting individuals after 30 or 60 days to make room for new arrivals.

💡Right to shelter

Right to shelter is a legal mandate that ensures everyone has access to temporary housing. The video mentions New York City's commitment to this right, which has led to debates about the sustainability and fairness of the shelter policies amid increasing numbers of asylum seekers.

💡Activists

Activists are individuals or groups advocating for social change. In the video, various activist groups protest against shelter evictions and the overall handling of the asylum crisis, reflecting the broader political and social conflicts surrounding immigration policies.

💡Mayor Eric Adams

Mayor Eric Adams is the current mayor of New York City. The video details his administration's response to the migrant crisis, including legal actions against bus companies and the implementation of controversial shelter policies, as well as the criticism he faces from both activists and political opponents.

💡Bus program

The bus program refers to the initiative by Texas to transport asylum seekers to sanctuary cities like New York. This program is central to the video's narrative, highlighting the political and logistical challenges it creates for receiving cities and the subsequent legal battles.

💡Evictions

Evictions are the removal of individuals from temporary shelters after a set period. The video discusses the impact of the 30 and 60-day eviction policies in New York City's shelters, emphasizing the strain on resources and the humanitarian concerns raised by activists.

💡Activism

Activism in the context of the video refers to the organized efforts by community groups to advocate for the rights and well-being of asylum seekers. The video illustrates how activism influences city policies and public opinion, but also sometimes leads to conflicting demands.

💡Humanitarian crisis

A humanitarian crisis involves widespread human suffering, often due to displacement or conflict. The video frames the asylum seeker situation in New York City as a humanitarian crisis, highlighting the city's struggle to provide adequate shelter and resources to a growing number of migrants.

💡Legal actions

Legal actions refer to lawsuits and other judicial measures taken to resolve disputes. In the video, Mayor Adams' administration's lawsuit against bus companies involved in transporting migrants to New York is a significant example, showing the legal strategies employed to address the city's immigration challenges.

Highlights

Texas governor's plan to continue busing migrants to sanctuary cities, including New York.

Thousands of migrants arriving in New York City weekly, causing strain on local shelters.

Local residents pressuring city to shut down shelters they consider inhumane.

Community groups opposed to the construction of a 3,000-bed migrant shelter on 8 acres of ball fields.

New York City leaders won't stop evictions for adult migrants who've reached their shelter limit.

Criticism of the 30 and 60-day shelter eviction policy as being counterproductive.

Reports of increased illegal activity and violence around migrant shelters.

Texas governor calling New Yorkers hypocrites for their reactions to shelters.

Mayor Adams also accused New Yorkers of hypocrisy regarding shelter protests.

New York City's attempt to repeal or modify right to shelter requirements faced backlash.

Activists' insistence on the right to shelter for everyone leads to a revolving door shelter system.

Mayor Adams' response to Texas governor's threats reflects frustration with the situation.

Mayor's office calls Texas governor a coward for offloading problems to other cities.

Lawsuit by Mayor Eric Adams against 17 bus companies for transporting migrants.

Activists upset about the city's lawsuit against bus companies, claiming it hinders their work.

City's shelters are full, leading to evictions and long lines of people waiting for re-admittance.

Critics argue that the shelter system is not designed for the number of people it's serving.

The city's struggle to balance providing temporary shelter with the unlimited number of asylum seekers.

Activism and protests against every decision made by the city, regardless of the outcome.

New York City council member's bill to end shelter stay limits, advocating for equity.

The paradox of activism leading to more problems in the shelter system and migrant crisis.

Transcripts

00:00

and know this I will continue to bust

00:03

those migrants to Sanctuary cities

00:05

across the United States of

00:08

America but oh they're going to New York

00:10

trust

00:12

me so this could be a huge problem

00:15

because as you can see from the lines

00:16

behind me thousands are still arriving

00:18

here in New York City every single week

00:20

yet local residents are pressuring the

00:21

city to shut down several shelters that

00:24

they say are inhumane which means if

00:26

Texas makes good on this threat the next

00:28

folks to arrive will have nowhere to St

00:30

but on the street from the outset

00:32

community groups did not like the idea

00:34

of usurping 8 Acres of ball fields for

00:36

3,000 bed migrant shelter it has not

00:39

gone away we're still dealing with this

00:42

every day as the migrant crisis

00:44

continues New York City leaders will not

00:46

stop evictions for adult migrants who've

00:49

reached their 30 or 60-day shelter limit

00:52

a shelter system in New York City was

00:55

created to stabilize people this rule

00:58

does exactly the opposite the 30 and

01:01

60-day shelter eviction roles are some

01:04

of the

01:06

[Applause]

01:17

[Applause]

01:19

cruestv fights and reports of illegal

01:22

activity the randles Island Park

01:24

Alliance says it's time for the city to

01:26

fold its tents remove the Cs and hit the

01:29

road when you see some of the hypocrisy

01:31

of people who are saying bring us your

01:33

tired you're weak your huddle masses

01:35

yearning to be free but not on my

01:39

[Music]

01:42

block so the Texas governor has vowed to

01:45

send more Asylum Seekers to New York

01:46

while calling everyone here A bunch of

01:48

Hypocrites but what nobody's talking

01:50

about is that mayor Adams recently said

01:52

the exact same thing also referring to

01:55

New Yorkers as Hypocrites for protesting

01:57

some of his shelters saying that the

01:59

shelter contribute to violence that they

02:01

occupy public resources and that they

02:03

are bad for the neighborhoods they're in

02:05

but at a recent press conference the

02:06

mayor just laughed it all off and what

02:08

else is he supposed to do just a couple

02:09

of weeks ago when the city tried to

02:10

repeal its right to shelter requirements

02:13

or modify them so that they wouldn't

02:15

have to provide an unlimited number of

02:16

people with temporary shelter activists

02:18

got upset there were rallies there were

02:20

protests there were accusations that the

02:22

mayor and his administration were cruel

02:24

and heartless and had no Humanity in

02:26

their souls even though the city doesn't

02:27

have the resources to house the entire

02:29

World which is impossible yet activists

02:32

were insistent on the right to shelter

02:34

applying to everyone which forced the

02:35

city to start kicking people out of its

02:37

shelters after 30 days just so new

02:39

Asylum Seekers could move in which is

02:40

something else activists are upset about

02:42

they want the shelters to be permanent

02:44

forever but since that's not possible

02:45

the shelter system is now a revolving

02:47

door operation leading many people to

02:49

question whether or not the Asylum

02:50

crisis is helping the very Asylum

02:52

Seekers who are stuck in it and that

02:54

brings us to the real reason why we have

02:55

an asylum crisis in this city to begin

02:57

with and it's because every single time

02:59

City lead tried to care for the people

03:01

everybody says we want to care for they

03:03

get blocked stopped fought against which

03:06

is shocking because polling consistently

03:08

shows that 80% of New Yorkers are in

03:10

favor of right to shelter but the Texas

03:12

governor is going to put that to the

03:15

test which means we're going to find out

03:16

pretty soon where the city stands on

03:25

this and know this I will continue to

03:28

bust those migrates to Sanctuary cities

03:31

across the United States of America

03:34

Adams needs something to do but this

03:36

crisis is about to come to an end in

03:38

just 6 months so this tells us

03:40

everything we need to know about why the

03:42

Asylum crisis is the way it is and it

03:44

also reveals that this entire crisis

03:46

isn't about the people that are coming

03:48

to New York City it's about politics and

03:50

if New York City is really a sanctuary

03:52

for immigrants why are the immigrants

03:53

who are here being treated the way that

03:55

they are getting kicked out of their

03:56

shelters at the same time we've got so

03:58

much activism going on here right now

04:00

that it is starting to conflict with

04:02

itself on the one hand we don't have

04:03

enough shelters on the other hand we

04:05

need more shelters there's also endless

04:07

debate on how long people should be able

04:08

to stay in them some people want it to

04:09

be forever other people think that the

04:11

term limits we have are good because

04:13

those limits help the city free up

04:14

shelter space for new arrivals who come

04:17

every single week and now you've got a

04:19

situation where the mayor's extremely

04:20

frustrated he's implementing the laws

04:23

that were voted for and he's doing it

04:25

with the limited amount of resources

04:26

that the city has yet he's getting all

04:28

the blame for how these things work out

04:29

out but the mayor's response to the

04:31

Texas governor's threats is one many New

04:33

Yorkers will probably appreciate but

04:35

before we look at how New York City is

04:36

going to respond to this latest round of

04:38

threats it's important to understand the

04:39

Texas governor says he's going to

04:41

continue his bus program as long as the

04:43

country's border remains in its current

04:45

state that being said the mayor has a

04:46

few tools at his disposal to fight back

04:48

against another bus program and the

04:50

mayor's not taking the Texas governor's

04:52

criticism of him or his City lying down

04:54

first the mayor's office has called the

04:56

governor of Texas a coward for

04:57

offloading his problems to somebody else

05:00

to deal with and the mayor's office even

05:02

went so far as to mention that crime in

05:03

Texas under Greg evit has risen

05:06

exponentially since he started believe

05:08

who you want to on statistics like that

05:10

but the Adams Administration said it's

05:12

left to pick up the pieces of broken

05:14

policies that use people as political

05:16

ponds while maintaining that the city's

05:18

provided care for over 200,000 people

05:21

since this Crisis began in New York but

05:23

words aren't the only tool the mayor

05:24

plans to use in the face of this in

05:26

January mayor Eric Adams announced that

05:28

he is suing 17 bus companies for their

05:31

role in busing tens of thousands of

05:34

migrants from Texas to New York City

05:36

since a spring of 2022 today's lawsuit

05:40

so last year when Texas started busing

05:42

Asylum Seekers here to New York City

05:43

there was a massive surge in Immigration

05:45

numbers but the city ended up suing the

05:47

very bus companies on which those folks

05:48

were traveling in order to get them to

05:50

stop and this has worked because one of

05:52

the 16 companies involved in that

05:53

operation says they're not going to do

05:55

it anymore and the companies that wish

05:56

to continue transporting people here

05:58

face a blockade of some sort at the

06:00

actual bus terminal and they're limited

06:01

to just dropping off guests at one

06:03

specific location during specific times

06:05

with 48 Hours advance notice and what

06:08

used to effectively be a 24-hour 7-Day a

06:10

week operation is now limited to just a

06:12

few days a week and just a few hours but

06:15

here's where things get interesting in

06:16

New York it is illegal to transport

06:18

someone here so that they can take

06:19

advantage of the city's generous right

06:21

to shelter laws that's why the city city

06:23

thinks they've got standing to sue but

06:25

activists are actually upset that the

06:27

city shut down the busing program which

06:30

was costing the city money caring for

06:31

folks who may not have come here if they

06:33

weren't given a free ticket the city is

06:35

seeking more than $700 million from

06:38

these 17 bus companies to cover the cost

06:40

of carrying and Sheltering these

06:42

migrants as part of the lawsuit the city

06:44

was also requiring these companies to

06:46

post a monetary bond to start covering

06:49

the cost $700 million in Damages related

06:53

to care that's crazy but before we go

06:55

over why activists are upset the mayor

06:57

has been battling this program trying to

06:58

shut it down when the program was still

07:00

active 4,000 people a week were arriving

07:02

in the city those numbers are down

07:04

considerably to around 1,300 people a

07:06

week but if Texas does start sending

07:08

more people here that could change there

07:09

are more ways to get into New York City

07:11

than a bus that goes straight from Texas

07:12

to here you could take a bus part of the

07:14

way and then take another bus part of

07:15

the way plus there's roads Bridges

07:17

trains planes and it may be impossible

07:19

for the mayor to completely close off

07:20

the city's border to just one person

07:23

from one certain part of the world plus

07:25

there are people who would say that

07:26

that's illegal but wait till you hear

07:28

why activists are so upset with the

07:29

mayor for shutting down the initial

07:31

Texas bus program in the first place

07:33

Malo says he is against a lawsuit suing

07:36

these bus companies and adds it has made

07:38

their job more difficult when trying to

07:40

find new arrivals it's a little bit more

07:43

difficult for us to to get a grasp as to

07:46

where they going to exit so we're still

07:47

we're see you know that almost makes it

07:49

seem like the number of people coming

07:51

here remains unchanged because New York

07:53

is such an attractive destination with

07:55

so many things to help Asylum Seekers

07:57

that people would make the journey here

07:58

no matter what and even though it might

08:00

look like the mayor's plan to Block

08:01

Buses coming in from Texas is a win from

08:03

a political standpoint in practice it

08:05

means that people who are coming here

08:07

just have a harder time doing something

08:08

that they already had planned to do when

08:10

they left wherever it is they're from

08:12

and whereas in the past you had people

08:14

arriving at one specific part of this

08:16

very specific location now folks arrive

08:19

everywhere Penn Station Grand Central

08:21

various terminals here roads Planes

08:22

Trains and the limited resources that

08:24

humanitarians have to help are now being

08:26

spread even thinner but now since the

08:28

city's going to war with the companies

08:29

bringing people here there's no standard

08:31

procedure for dropping people off and

08:33

humanitarians have no way of knowing

08:34

where vulnerable folks are going to

08:36

arrive and they're now running around

08:37

the city at all hours of the day trying

08:39

to track down one person from here or

08:41

one person arriving here it's a big mess

08:43

and the most insane thing about this is

08:45

no matter how people end up arriving the

08:47

city's never had any plans to disqualify

08:49

someone for applying for shelter so here

08:51

we have the city on the one hand winning

08:53

points politically but also hurting the

08:55

people it's supposed to care for by

08:57

making their lives tougher and if Texas

08:58

does decide to resume sending larger and

09:00

larger amounts of people to the city and

09:02

if the city continues resisting those

09:04

efforts by just making the journey

09:05

tougher while still offering the help

09:07

people the city is just going to end up

09:09

wasting the little resources that it

09:11

says it has and speaking of resources

09:13

the city's shelters are now so full you

09:15

have lines of people waiting to see if

09:18

the shelter system will reaccept them

09:20

for a place to stay because they've

09:22

started kicking people out can you

09:23

believe that shelter evictions in a

09:26

sanctuary City while at the same time

09:28

you've got activists in syst that the

09:29

people who have been evicted should be

09:31

allowed to stay forever and that we may

09:33

have too many shelters in the first

09:34

place which makes this the most

09:36

confusing development of this story so

09:46

far so behind me this is the line to get

09:48

into the reticketing facility at this

09:51

place everyone who's been evicted from a

09:52

shelter can get a plane ticket bus

09:54

ticket or help with a ride sharing app

09:56

to the destination of their choosing but

09:57

the reason there's a line here is

09:58

because evictions have started which has

10:01

activists fuming yet other activists are

10:03

upset that we have as many shelters as

10:05

we do for some reason the city says they

10:07

have to place these shelter limits

10:09

because they don't have room for

10:11

everyone just last week the city

10:13

received more than 1300 new arrivals

10:16

that's not going away so everyone

10:18

watching this knows the evictions are a

10:20

bad idea because they lead to what you

10:21

see back here but New York City's laws

10:23

stipulate that everyone gets a place to

10:25

stay on a temporary basis even if the

10:27

shelter system is full and when you

10:28

offer for a limited number of resources

10:30

to an unlimited number of people this is

10:32

the predictable result in fact the

10:34

shelter system is now tasked with doing

10:36

something it was never designed to do

10:38

the way that the shelter should be

10:39

operating is they should allow people to

10:41

move in and not force them to move out

10:43

until their time has come to its logical

10:45

conclusion meaning that they've gotten

10:46

the help they need to enter society yet

10:48

The Shelter Systems here have people

10:50

evicted after 30 days when a work permit

10:52

takes a minimum of 6 months and

10:54

obviously this is something that people

10:56

should be and are upset about but it's

10:58

bringing up a question is this the

10:59

city's only option they've got a lot of

11:01

resources but are they doing what they

11:03

have to do to abide by the law or is

11:04

this deliberately cruel we're still

11:06

dealing with this every day as the

11:09

migrant crisis continues New York City

11:11

leaders will not stop evictions for

11:13

adult migrants whove reached their 30 or

11:16

60-day shelter limit critics have called

11:19

the policy so here's the thing the

11:20

mayor's office spent 6 months with local

11:22

activist groups in court going over how

11:24

exactly to implement right to shelter

11:26

when these conditions persist and

11:28

putting up a no V sign on the city's

11:30

shelters and turning people away wasn't

11:31

an idea that was being considered yet

11:34

had the city gone and done that all of

11:35

the folks that you see here would have

11:36

had enough time in the shelter to get

11:38

the requisite assistance yet sadly many

11:39

of the folks getting let go that are now

11:41

here to plead their case for a shelter

11:43

extension are in no better position than

11:45

they were when they got here and that's

11:46

not what a homeless shelter is supposed

11:48

to do people are supposed to be better

11:49

when they leave not worse off in fact

11:51

part of the problem is that people that

11:53

are in line they've filed their Asylum

11:54

paperwork they've gotten everything set

11:56

up with a case worker but since Federal

11:57

Work authorization can take 6 to 8

11:59

months they're now waiting for that to

12:01

happen they can't provide for themselves

12:03

on their own and the second problem

12:04

we've got here is that since right to

12:05

shelter applies to the entire world a

12:07

potentially unlimited number of people

12:09

critics say this means nothing can ever

12:11

be done to address capacity issues at

12:13

the city's limited shelter resources

12:15

which is why we've got revolving

12:17

evictions which help nobody and what's

12:19

upsetting is that after 6 months of

12:21

negotiations this is the compromise

12:23

solution that we got right to shelter

12:24

Remains the law of the land yet it only

12:26

applies on a temporary basis and this is

12:28

the result yet now many of the very same

12:30

people who are in favor of the creation

12:32

of this very same system are now

12:34

activating against it calling the

12:36

mayor's actions cruel and inhumane

12:38

saying he's doing something wrong when

12:40

this is what was agreed on and a judge

12:42

is overseeing it people said it's

12:43

inhumane to put people out during the

12:45

winter time so now they say it's

12:46

inhumane to do it in the summertime it's

12:48

Humane to do in the springtime it's

12:50

inhumane to do in the fall time it's

12:51

always inhumane to have to not be able

12:54

to House

12:56

198,000 people unfortunately this is

12:58

what we see every single time the city

13:00

does anything if they need to build a

13:02

shelter somewhere there are always

13:03

protests there is always local push back

13:05

and then if people can't stay in the

13:06

shelter there's push back if new people

13:09

come and they don't have a place to stay

13:10

there's push back and as you'll soon see

13:12

even with lines of people on the street

13:14

there are still some people advocating

13:16

for certain shelters to go away entirely

13:17

which would just create more of this

13:19

which is very interesting because recent

13:20

polling shows that 80% of New Yorkers

13:22

are in favor of right to shelter just

13:25

not apparently when there is a shelter

13:27

or a facility in their particular

13:29

neighborhood that's always the wrong

13:30

location for some reason which reveals a

13:33

very dark secret underneath all of this

13:35

supposed compassion that's supposed to

13:37

be helping people and might not

13:45

be mayor Adams implied that the randles

13:48

island group was like all the other

13:49

elected officials who want migrants

13:51

taken care of just not where they live

13:54

when you see some of the hypocrisy of

13:56

people who are saying bring us your

13:58

tithe you're weak your huddle masses

14:00

yearning to be free but not on my

14:03

block so mayor Adams starting to sound a

14:06

lot like the Texas governor in some ways

14:09

but it seems like he's just abiding by

14:11

the laws of the land that New Yorkers

14:13

voted for and how else is the mayor

14:15

supposed to House people who come here

14:17

by the thousands every single month as

14:19

we're seeing there's no great solution

14:20

for how to do that and if this is

14:22

something many New Yorkers have a

14:23

problem with why aren't they voting for

14:24

change I will explain to you why that is

14:26

it's because activism for the sake of

14:29

activism has taken over much of

14:31

progressive America including New York

14:33

and that's what you're witnessing here

14:34

and unfortunately for many people

14:36

including legitimate activists activism

14:38

itself is now a fashionable Trend going

14:41

on in America earlier this week a New

14:42

York City council member shahana hanf

14:45

reintroduced a bill that would end

14:46

shelter stay limits all New Yorkers no

14:49

matter when they've arrived deserve

14:51

Equity not harm a public hearing so here

14:54

we have people protesting shelter stay

14:56

limits which obviously are a bad idea

14:59

because they put people back out on the

15:01

streets before they're ready but

15:02

remember these are the very same people

15:04

who were rallying just a month or so ago

15:06

in order to keep the city's right to

15:08

shelter rules in place at all costs and

15:10

what the city's revolving door shelters

15:12

have done is they've created a situation

15:14

of bad outcomes no matter how you slice

15:16

it which means there's always something

15:17

to fight against and get angry about yet

15:19

the mayor and other city leaders are

15:20

starting to figure out that the more

15:21

they cave to various forms of activism

15:24

the more they create other opportunities

15:25

for activists to get upset because

15:27

there's no perfect solution to a

15:29

humanitarian crisis bigger than what the

15:30

city's able to deal with and to help

15:32

make sense of why this is the case

15:34

understand that when this crisis first

15:35

started unlimited shelter stays were how

15:37

everything works and then what ended up

15:38

happening is the shelters filled up so

15:40

what does the city do they go out and

15:41

they build new shelters to house more

15:44

people yet those shelters are cruel and

15:46

inhumane and although these shelters

15:48

might not be perfect the mayor even went

15:50

out of his way to mention that he didn't

15:52

want to use these humanitarian relief

15:53

centers because they're not the same as

15:55

an actual standing building but because

15:57

right to shelter Remains the law of the

15:58

land the mayor had no choice but to

16:00

build those facilities while being

16:01

accused of having no soul by those who

16:03

don't seem to understand that the city

16:05

has limited resources on top of that

16:07

look every single time the city picks a

16:09

location for a new shelter maybe like an

16:11

abandoned school or something somewhere

16:12

there are protests which means that the

16:14

same activists who are protesting the

16:16

tent shelters are also the reason tent

16:18

shelters are all we can have and what

16:20

this means is that the city will

16:21

perpetually be between a rock in a hard

16:23

place every time it tries to obey the

16:25

law and observers are now suggesting

16:27

that this type of mass protest against

16:29

any and all government action no matter

16:31

what it is is the reason this crisis

16:33

looks the way that it does and it's the

16:35

reason that the people in it aren't

16:36

being treated the way that they probably

16:38

should be but the real problem here is

16:40

that people aren't just getting kicked

16:41

out after 30 days and told to go fend

16:43

for themselves since they can't do that

16:45

they are still 100% Reliant upon the

16:48

city and upon the state to care for them

16:50

and even though to some people it looks

16:51

like the right decision may have been to

16:53

temporarily suspend the right to shelter

16:55

and do the right thing by every single

16:57

person that was living in a shelter

16:59

there would have been protests if that

17:00

happened because it would have stopped

17:02

the flow of Asylum Seekers to the city

17:03

but now that Asylum Seekers can come as

17:05

often as they want the city is being

17:07

protested because it just simply doesn't

17:09

have the ability to help everyone the

17:10

way that it knows it should which is why

17:12

some people say we're now watching the

17:13

idea of protesting and making a

17:15

difference Eclipse reality and

17:17

consequence meaning that all of this

17:19

activism against the mayor's every

17:21

single move might be making the problem

17:23

much worse for the very people who are

17:24

stuck in it and can't get out is that

17:26

what's happening is New York turning

17:27

into a city of activists who protest

17:30

every single decision no matter what it

17:31

is just because they aren't the ones who

17:33

made it let me know what you think thank

17:35

you so much for watching I will see you

17:36

in the next video