BS! Roland CALLS OUT Black Enterprise For 'Diddy Down Bad, Secured Bag' TMZ No Fact Check Rewrite

Roland S. Martin
28 Mar 202435:31

Summary

TLDRThe speaker criticizes black-owned media outlets for their lack of journalistic integrity, highlighting instances where they have simply rewritten stories from other sources without proper fact-checking or verification. The speaker emphasizes the importance of original reporting, the need for black media to maintain high journalistic standards, and the potential dangers of spreading misinformation, especially in the context of upcoming elections. They call for black journalists to adhere to the ethics learned in journalism school and to prioritize accurate reporting over clout culture.

Takeaways

  • 📰 The speaker criticizes black-owned media outlets for not practicing basic journalism and simply rewriting stories from white media sources without fact-checking.
  • 💡 There is a lack of effort in reporting and fact-checking, leading to the spread of misinformation within the black community through media outlets like Black Enterprise and Essence.
  • 🚫 The speaker emphasizes the importance of original reporting and reaching out to sources rather than just rebranding stories from other outlets.
  • 🎯 Journalism standards are being compromised by the practice of taking stories at face value without independent confirmation or reaching out to involved parties.
  • 🤔 The speaker questions why black media outlets feel the need to rewrite stories in a way that may not resonate or respect the black audience.
  • 📉 The credibility of black-owned media is at stake when they fail to uphold journalistic integrity and simply echo information from other sources without verification.
  • 🚨 The speaker warns about the dangers of misinformation and disinformation, especially in the context of upcoming elections and the potential manipulation of black voters.
  • 🌐 The global impact of lazy journalism is highlighted, as unverified stories can spread rapidly and become accepted as truth without any fact-checking.
  • 📌 The speaker shares personal experiences as a journalist and editor, emphasizing the need for reporters to make calls, check sources, and not just rely on rewriting others' work.
  • 📈 The importance of maintaining high journalistic standards, especially in black media, to ensure reliable and accurate reporting is stressed.
  • 💥 The speaker calls for accountability and improvement in black-owned media, urging them to do better and not fall for the pressure of clout culture or the rush to be the first to report.

Q & A

  • What is the main issue the speaker is addressing regarding black-owned media outlets?

    -The speaker is addressing the issue of black-owned media outlets not performing basic journalism and simply rewriting stories from white media without fact-checking or attempting to confirm the information themselves.

  • How does the speaker feel about the reporting of Diddy selling Revolt to an undisclosed buyer?

    -The speaker is frustrated because they have known for a month that the deal has not been closed and it has not been sold yet, yet various media outlets are reporting it as a done deal.

  • What example does the speaker give to illustrate the lack of fact-checking in black-owned media?

    -The speaker cites the example of Black Enterprise reporting on Diddy selling Revolt TV without reaching out to Revolt or Diddy to confirm or deny the story.

  • What is the speaker's concern about the potential impact of misinformation in black-owned media?

    -The speaker is concerned that misinformation in black-owned media can lead to black people assuming that reported information is accurate just because they saw it in multiple sources, which could be dangerous, especially in the context of upcoming elections.

  • What does the speaker suggest is a contributing factor to the lack of quality reporting in black-owned media?

    -The speaker suggests that the lack of advertising money and resources to have top-notch reporters or enough editors is a contributing factor to the lack of quality reporting in black-owned media.

  • How does the speaker describe the importance of fact-checking and original reporting in journalism?

    -The speaker emphasizes that fact-checking and original reporting are crucial in journalism to avoid spreading misinformation and to maintain credibility and trust with the audience.

  • What is the speaker's advice to black-owned media regarding their reporting practices?

    -The speaker advises black-owned media to do better by picking up the phone, developing sources, and adhering to journalism ethics and standards to ensure they are reporting accurate information.

  • Why does the speaker criticize the use of language in some black-owned media outlets?

    -The speaker criticizes the use of language in some black-owned media outlets because they believe it perpetuates stereotypes and disrespects the black audience by assuming they cannot understand complex language and grammar.

  • What is the speaker's stance on the reporting of the HBCU funding story by Newsweek?

    -The speaker claims that Newsweek's reporting of the HBCU funding story was a lie and that the initial $45 billion was never intended for HBCUs alone, but was part of a larger plan that included other minority-serving institutions.

  • How does the speaker describe the role of a reporter in verifying information?

    -The speaker describes the role of a reporter as making calls, sending emails, and using various means of communication to verify information before reporting it, rather than just rewriting what other outlets have reported.

Outlines

00:00

📰 Critique of Black Media's Lack of Fact-Checking

The speaker expresses frustration with black-owned media outlets for not practicing basic journalism and merely rewriting stories from white media without fact-checking. The example of Diddy selling Revolt to an undisclosed buyer is used to illustrate how misinformation can spread without verification. The speaker emphasizes the importance of journalistic integrity and the need for black media to hold themselves to a higher standard to avoid perpetuating false narratives.

05:01

📰 The Dangers of Unverified Reporting

The speaker discusses the negative impact of unverified reporting, especially within black media. They argue that misinformation can lead to a misinformed public and erode trust in media. The speaker shares personal experiences as a journalist to highlight the importance of fact-checking and reaching out to sources before reporting. They also touch on the upcoming elections and warn about the potential spread of disinformation that could manipulate black voters.

10:02

📰 Accountability in Black Media

The speaker calls for accountability in black media, stressing that simply attributing a story to a source is not enough. They argue that journalists should not put their bylines on stories they did not report or verify. The speaker shares specific instances where black media outlets have rewritten stories without proper sourcing, leading to the spread of false information. They urge black media to improve their standards and to respect their audience by providing accurate and reliable information.

15:02

📰 The Importance of Original Reporting

The speaker emphasizes the importance of original reporting and verifying information before publication. They share personal anecdotes to illustrate the consequences of lazy journalism and the potential harm it can cause. The speaker also discusses the need for black media to develop their own sources and to not rely solely on white media narratives. They argue that having independent and verified information empowers black journalists to break news and provide accurate stories to their audience.

20:05

📰 Reflections on Journalism Practices

The speaker reflects on their experiences in journalism and the practices that should be upheld in the industry. They recount specific instances where they had accurate information that was not widely known, highlighting the value of having reliable sources. The speaker also discusses the importance of not relying on clout culture and adhering to the ethics learned in journalism school. They stress that journalists should do their due diligence to ensure they are providing accurate and trustworthy information to their audience.

25:06

💰 Investment Opportunities in Social Media

The speaker introduces an investment opportunity in a new social media app called Fanbase, which has already raised $10 million. The app aims to usher in a new era of social media and investment, and the speaker provides information on how to invest by visiting a website or scanning a QR code. The message is about the potential for growth and innovation in the social media sector and the chance for individuals to get involved in this emerging market.

Mindmap

Keywords

💡Black-owned media

Refers to media outlets that are owned and operated by the Black community. In the context of the video, the speaker criticizes certain black-owned media outlets for not adhering to basic journalistic standards, such as fact-checking and original reporting, instead opting to rewrite stories from white-owned media without proper verification.

💡Journalistic integrity

This concept refers to the ethical principles and practices journalists should follow to ensure the accuracy, fairness, and credibility of their reporting. The video emphasizes the importance of journalistic integrity, especially within black-owned media, to avoid spreading misinformation and to maintain the trust of the community.

💡Fact-checking

The process of verifying the accuracy of information before it is reported in the media. In the video, the speaker argues that fact-checking is a crucial aspect of journalism that has been neglected by some black-owned media outlets, leading to the propagation of false or unverified information.

💡Media aggregation

The practice of collecting content from various sources and republishing it, often with little to no original contribution or verification. The video discusses how some black-owned media outlets engage in aggregation without adding value or conducting their own research, which contributes to the spread of misinformation.

💡Disinformation

Deliberately false or misleading information spread with the intent to deceive or manipulate public opinion. In the video, the speaker warns that the lack of fact-checking and reliance on unverified sources by some black-owned media outlets can contribute to the spread of disinformation, especially during sensitive times like elections.

💡Misinformation

Incorrect or inaccurate information, often spread unintentionally. The video highlights the dangers of misinformation in the media, especially when it is not fact-checked or verified, leading to a distorted understanding of events and issues among the public.

💡Lazy journalism

A term used to describe journalism that lacks effort in research, fact-checking, and original reporting. In the video, the speaker accuses certain black-owned media outlets of practicing lazy journalism by simply rewriting stories from other sources without making an effort to verify the information or add new insights.

💡Clout culture

A social phenomenon where individuals or entities seek influence and recognition, often prioritizing popularity and status over substance and integrity. In the context of the video, the speaker warns against the influence of clout culture in journalism, which may lead journalists to prioritize clicks and shares over accurate and responsible reporting.

💡Media responsibility

The obligation of media outlets and journalists to report accurately, fairly, and responsibly. The video emphasizes the importance of media responsibility, especially for black-owned media, in shaping public perception and maintaining trust within the community.

💡Community trust

The level of confidence and reliance that a community has in its media outlets. In the video, the speaker argues that the repetition of unverified information by black-owned media can erode community trust, which is essential for the media to effectively serve its audience.

Highlights

The speaker expresses frustration with black-owned media outlets that fail to perform basic journalism and simply rewrite stories from white media sources.

The speaker criticizes TMZ for reporting that Diddy sold Revolt to an undisclosed buyer without verifying the information.

Despite knowing for a month that the deal had not been closed, the speaker is upset that multiple media outlets, including Black Enterprise and Essence, reported the sale as fact.

The speaker emphasizes the importance of fact-checking and reaching out to relevant sources before reporting a story.

The speaker recounts their experience as a managing editor at various publications and the high standards they upheld for reporting accuracy.

The speaker highlights the issue of misinformation in black-owned media and its potential to mislead the black community.

The speaker warns about the dangers of disinformation, especially in the context of the upcoming fall elections.

The speaker calls out Black Enterprise for rewriting a story from a conservative newspaper without verifying its accuracy.

The speaker argues that black media should not dumb down their language or writing style to appeal to black audiences, as it disrespects their intelligence.

The speaker shares an anecdote about being misreported as running for judge before even announcing the decision, illustrating the issue of lazy journalism.

The speaker stresses the need for black media to develop their own sources and not rely solely on white media for information.

The speaker criticizes the lack of effort in reporting and the tendency to fit narratives into preconceived stories rather than reporting facts as they are.

The speaker shares a personal experience of being misreported as being held in contempt, highlighting the importance of accurate reporting.

The speaker calls for excellence in journalism, emphasizing the need for black media to adhere to high standards and not perpetuate lower standards for black audiences.

The speaker concludes by urging black journalists to step up and maintain the ethics and standards they learned in journalism school.

Transcripts

00:00

all right now yesterday I told y'all how

00:02

I'm sick and tired of these black own

00:04

media Outlets uh that don't even do

00:07

basic journalism all folk doing a just

00:10

rewriting whatever the hell they see in

00:13

White media so yeah you know TMZ

00:16

reported yesterday that Diddy had sold

00:20

Revolt uh to an undisclosed buyer now I

00:24

talked to four sources the deal has not

00:26

been closed it has not been sold yet

00:30

okay I've known this for a month but all

00:35

these folks all these blogs Essence

00:39

wrote a story about the whole ddy

00:40

investigation didn't call nobody just

00:43

pulled from Fox 11 called from from from

00:46

CNBC and I'm like what are we doing why

00:49

are we putting a stamp of approval on

00:51

this nonsense so go to my iPad and I

00:54

gotta call out Black Enterprise today so

00:56

Black Enterprise dropped this story

00:59

yesterday y'all and I'm

01:01

sorry this is this is the Tweet

01:05

Diddy may be down bad but he did secure

01:09

his

01:11

bag that's the Tweet now check this out

01:15

you click the story y'all you go to the

01:19

story and it goes to um uh when when you

01:25

go to the story

01:26

here this is what the story says uh uh

01:30

sha Diddy commes is no longer an owner

01:32

at Revolt TV after selling off his

01:35

shares to an anonymous buyer for

01:36

undisclosed

01:37

amount

01:39

now you read the story and they got all

01:43

this sort of stuff in here sources say

01:46

Comm sold his Revolt TV shares to an

01:49

interested buyer but made sure that the

01:51

company remains black own TMZ

01:54

reports you read this story it ain't

01:58

nothing but a whole Rew

02:00

of the TMZ story y this is Black

02:04

Enterprise this is supposed to be the

02:06

black business

02:07

Bible amid news of the Revolt sale it's

02:10

being speculated if Colmes knew a

02:13

federal raid was on the

02:16

way how you report who is the reporter

02:19

on

02:20

here somebody

02:22

named Joselin jovon okay so we got

02:27

speculation in the story when I read

02:30

this story y'all and I read it last

02:33

night there

02:35

literally was nothing that was fact

02:39

check nowhere in this

02:42

article not one like y'all look at the

02:45

nowhere in this article did it say Black

02:49

Enterprise reach out to

02:54

revolt to confirm or deny the

02:57

story nowhere in an article

03:00

nowhere in the article did it say Black

03:03

Enterprise reached out to sha Diddy

03:07

Coles

03:09

nowhere we just slap our name on a story

03:13

and rewrite what TMZ said you put in a

03:17

story

03:22

speculation

03:24

no y'all I was the managing editor of

03:27

the Dallas weekly the Houston Defender

03:31

the Chicago Defender the news Eder at

03:34

seavo magazine was the top Eder at Black

03:37

America web.com and let me be real clear

03:41

if any reporter or intern sent this

03:45

story to me my response would be your

03:50

ass got one shot to fix it or you're

03:54

fired you're

03:57

gone see the reason Reon this bothers me

04:02

is because what we now have in

04:04

blackowned media is a focus on

04:08

aggregation so what we do is we see what

04:12

somebody else report then we rewrite it

04:15

put our name on it and then when black

04:18

folks s around they say did you read

04:21

Black Enterprise did you read Essence

04:23

did you read this to read Hollywood

04:25

unlock you read the shade room to read

04:27

ball alert you read this here and so we

04:30

just spinning and repeat what somebody

04:32

else wrote it ain't true The Breakfast

04:35

Club this morning they read the story

04:38

and they said it had been sold factually

04:41

it has it how do you not

04:46

check and I get it if you're on radio

04:48

and you're reading the story but how are

04:51

you a this is the black business

04:54

Bible how do you rewrite a TMZ story let

04:58

me tell you what happens at is pen when

05:01

somebody else breaks a story they'll

05:04

have a reporters call write the story

05:06

and then they'll put in the article at

05:08

the bottom which is also BS this this

05:12

story this was originally reported by

05:14

the athletic or this was originally

05:17

reported by soand so the reason this is

05:21

a problem for

05:23

me I am a journalist I'm not a media

05:27

personality and when black people see

05:29

stories like this what happens is black

05:32

people then go oh that must be the case

05:37

I told y'all what happened when the same

05:40

thing happened on the Newsweek story

05:43

about Biden cutting uh matter of fact

05:46

I'm G show you how this whole thing

05:48

works go to my

05:50

iPad

05:56

Newsweek and

05:58

Biden

06:00

and

06:03

HBCU what's the first story that comes

06:07

up boom HBCU funding Falls from 45

06:12

billion to 2 billion under latest Bon

06:15

spending plan y'all the story was a lie

06:19

the story was an absolute

06:21

lie HBCU were looking forward to $45

06:24

billion in funding they may may be faced

06:27

with just under two billion the

06:30

Associated Press reported so Newsweek

06:33

rewrote the Associated Press

06:36

story The 3.5 trillion bill was set to

06:39

include 45 billion for

06:42

HBCU operative word here

06:45

y'all and other minority serving

06:50

institutions y'all see

06:53

that HBCU were never going to get 45

06:57

billion that when he ran he announced 4

06:59

5 billion HBCU and Hispanic serving

07:03

institutions those are the

07:06

facts the initial 45 billion was when

07:08

the bill back better plan was 10 billion

07:10

not 3.5 TR see here's what I'm trying to

07:12

explain to

07:14

y'all when we read stories and don't

07:17

fact check and then we black own media

07:20

come right behind them and then rewrite

07:23

what they wrote we're

07:25

feeding a lie to black people and black

07:28

people then go oh I I saw it in blavity

07:30

I saw it in essence I saw it in the root

07:32

I saw it in Black Enterprise I saw it on

07:34

the

07:36

source well they had to check so it must

07:38

be

07:40

right we got to do

07:42

better and stop putting your by lines on

07:46

stories you didn't even report do y'all

07:48

know what what you know what used to

07:50

happen in media I'm going go my panel

07:52

next you know what used to happen in the

07:54

media when they would rewrite a story

07:57

this is what they would do they would go

08:00

we we would go Defender news

08:03

staff CU When you put your by line on a

08:06

story that means you actually reported

08:08

the

08:09

story you don't put your by line on some

08:13

you

08:14

rewrote you don't slap your by line I

08:17

criticize the essence person yesterday

08:20

I'm criticizing the person with black

08:22

Enterprise today I saw the same thing um

08:27

by uh the source put out a story same

08:30

thing on the whole Diddy deal you know

08:32

I'mma pull up right now did they do the

08:35

same thing oh well at least well at

08:38

least the source got it

08:40

right at least the source rewrote the

08:44

TMZ story go to my iPad and put Source

08:48

staff but you don't put your name on

08:52

nothing that you didn't report

08:55

on this is a problem and I told y'all

08:57

one of the problems that we do not have

08:59

have because we're not getting the

09:00

advertising money we don't have the

09:03

resources to have top-notch reporters or

09:06

enough editors or whatever but I need

09:09

black own media to do better and I need

09:12

black own media to at least pick the

09:14

damn phone up and at least attempt to

09:17

fact check something for just running

09:19

with it

09:21

Rebecca you know Rand all of our

09:23

institutions are under attack right now

09:26

and so when we look at misinformation

09:28

misinformation is when um information is

09:31

misleading or inaccurate so often times

09:34

in social media we'll see oh this famous

09:36

celebrity passed away and it turns out

09:38

they didn't do that but that's an

09:40

example of misinformation but then we

09:42

get into something that's a little bit

09:43

more malicious and that's disinformation

09:46

disinformation occurs when there is an

09:48

intentionally falsehoods that are

09:51

planted out there sometimes covertly so

09:53

that the audience that's intended to go

09:55

run and tell that run with that rumor

09:58

they are not even aware that they're

09:59

being specifically targeted and so what

10:01

we're seeing right now with certain

10:03

black media just just rubber stamping

10:06

information that they're getting off the

10:08

wire or that they're reading from

10:09

elsewhere if you don't verify it it's

10:12

misinformation but what's going to

10:14

happen as we go into the fall elections

10:16

this is just a test case for then what

10:19

disinformation is going to look like

10:21

when people are just pulling down on

10:23

substantiated reports that they also

10:25

don't have the budget to actually

10:26

substantiate and they're rubber stamping

10:28

and out and now black voters going into

10:32

the fall election is going to assume

10:35

because Black Enterprise because of

10:37

blackity because of the Grio because of

10:39

The Breakfast Club is putting out

10:41

information therefore it must be

10:42

accurate but guess what going into this

10:45

fall a lot of information that you're

10:47

going to see from a a variety of sources

10:50

that you normally would just assume has

10:52

accurate reporting it's not going to be

10:54

true and that's the thing that I'm

10:56

fearful about listen I I I Robert this

11:00

real basic go back to my iPad I want

11:02

y'all to read what the source wrote I

11:04

ain't letting them off the hook they

11:06

wrote now get this sources in the know

11:11

about the purported deal say the

11:14

embattled Mogul sold off all his shares

11:17

to a mystery buyer for a sum that has

11:20

not been disclosed now the word is the

11:23

company in itself quote remains

11:26

blackowned which is supposed to be

11:28

aligned with as timz puts it upholding

11:31

quotes its original connection and

11:33

dedication to furthering the culture

11:36

it's still hazy as to what revoke was

11:38

let go for regarding the sale but one

11:40

thing is clear the new owner is keeping

11:43

a low profile for now and for good

11:45

reason there's a lot of heat around the

11:47

Shan coms with Monday's raid by the feds

11:51

so now may not be the best time to

11:53

announce a business deal of that

11:55

magnitude for one of Diddy's Brands Now

11:58

sources to say that the owners or owners

12:01

share a passion for Black Culture which

12:03

is a broad statement but they intend to

12:05

introduce themselves formally in the

12:07

coming weeks everything that you just

12:09

read right there is complete utter

12:12

and you know what they're doing

12:14

now go back to it they are simply

12:16

repeating what they saw in TMZ but they

12:19

trying to make it sound like they have

12:22

the sources let me be clear with all

12:24

y'all who

12:25

watching I talk to four people who are

12:30

actually in the

12:32

know the sale has not been

12:35

completed I've known about to sale for

12:38

more than a

12:39

month and there is a real deal the

12:42

source goes the owner or the owners it's

12:45

not

12:47

owners I know who the person

12:50

is but when you write this oh they maybe

12:53

want to keep a low

12:55

profile

12:57

then

13:00

uh if woman C all you know it's all you

13:02

know the whole day which is a broad

13:06

State you're feeding to black

13:11

people and then they go well I read the

13:13

source and they said this it's a lie I

13:16

read Black Enterprise and they were all

13:18

they did was rewrite what TMZ said which

13:20

ain't

13:22

true this is dangerous when Rebecca said

13:26

you now do this and you apply it to

13:30

other areas and we've seen it and this

13:32

look this ain't about trying to take

13:34

somebody down but Black Enterprise

13:36

rewrote a Washington Free Beacon story

13:39

about the Biden Administration handing

13:41

out crack pipes and I sent them an email

13:43

and said y do y'all know y'all were

13:46

rewriting a story from a conservative

13:48

newspaper that was a lie they never

13:51

responded but it was the same

13:54

Robert well look r two points the first

13:57

is just an editorial Point why is it

13:59

when they were trying to appeal to Black

14:01

audiences they just take what white

14:03

people wrote and then rewrite it in

14:05

slave dialect why do they think that is

14:07

something that appeals to Black

14:08

audiences why do you have to write these

14:10

things I know what get like they're

14:12

straight off the step and fetch it

14:13

Comedy Tour well I had heard that they

14:16

be about to tell some people that we

14:17

going to go down here we going to

14:19

against this bag you don't have to write

14:22

like that for black people to understand

14:24

you and I think that that's the part of

14:26

the place where we get to this

14:28

disservice of black media because if you

14:30

think that you have to dumb yourself

14:32

down to the point that we can't

14:34

understand you know complex words and

14:36

prepositions and the grammar and commas

14:39

and stuff uh when you're already

14:40

starting from a point of uh uh of

14:43

disrespecting your audience when you

14:45

think that's how you have to write and

14:47

look to Rebecca's point this isn't going

14:49

to start this has started look R when

14:51

when uh we first found out about be

14:53

running for judge me and you found out

14:55

at the same time because there was a

14:57

article on the front page of the Atlanta

14:58

Journal Constitution saying that I was

15:00

running before I had even announced that

15:02

I was running before I had even uh

15:03

decided I was running and then from

15:05

there we saw other Outlet secondhand

15:08

pick up that article and pick up that

15:10

information and they started casting me

15:12

in all sorts of experion to the point

15:13

Megan Kelly is sending out uh tweets oh

15:16

yeah Shea oh oh this this liberal who

15:19

who worked with Reverend Jackson and

15:21

Robert when I saw it what did I do you

15:25

tweeted about it you called him out I no

15:27

no no no no no before I called him out

15:29

I no before I called them out you

15:31

reached out to me I called you yes the

15:34

first thing I did and here's the deal if

15:36

I did not know you personally I would

15:39

have

15:39

went okay who is this Robert dude let me

15:42

see if he has a website uh oh he follows

15:45

me on Twitter send him a DM oh I'm G

15:48

send him a DM on Instagram oh let me see

15:50

if he has a LinkedIn profile let me see

15:52

if he has a website oh hold up oh he's a

15:54

lawyer in Atlanta oh oh hold up the

15:57

story says that he used to work for

15:59

rainbow push uh oh boom let me call

16:01

Revan Jackson let me call John Mitchell

16:03

let me call Shelly Davis that's what

16:05

reporters do they make calls

16:08

before they report stuff and before they

16:11

tweet it and and before any of that

16:14

happened before my phone rang even one

16:16

time of any reporter except for you I

16:18

had uh Outlets reporting on in the

16:20

United Kingdom New Zealand uh Central

16:23

America all across the globe because as

16:25

Mark Twain said a lie goes around the

16:26

world before the truth puts on its pants

16:29

we know that because Mark TW never

16:30

actually said that that's just something

16:31

they was attributed to him so when we

16:33

talk about this this level of lazy

16:35

journalism that we have now we have

16:37

journalists and just assume people are

16:38

only going to read the headline no one's

16:40

going to look into it any deeper and

16:42

that their words will just be part of a

16:44

12h hour not 24-hour news cycle and

16:46

that's why they put absolutely no effort

16:48

into reporting actual media reporting

16:50

actual journalism and after reporting

16:52

the story they pick what the narrative

16:54

is first and then they find a story to

16:56

fit it as opposed to taking the facts as

16:58

they are just reporting to the public

17:00

and Scott here's the deal and again I I

17:02

need everybody watching to understand

17:03

that y'all watch this show I called out

17:06

NBC News when they did it I remember

17:09

when a root did it so this ain't oh man

17:12

you picking on Black Enterprise but

17:14

I'mma tell you when they ran that

17:16

crackpipe story and I just checked now

17:18

mind you nobody responded ain't even

17:21

going to name who I emailed but I email

17:23

the top people um but this was literally

17:26

the email that I sent jent y'all really

17:29

should take this story down it's awful

17:32

because it was Rewritten from the

17:33

right-wing website the Free Beacon the

17:36

goop come on y'all go to my iPad thank

17:39

you the GOP has spread this nonsense all

17:42

day me personally I would never write

17:45

anything based on the quote reporting

17:48

from that right-wing rag the headline

17:50

was called B Administration to fund the

17:53

distribution of crack pipes and syringes

17:55

to promote racial Equity by rewriting it

17:58

under the the be you're essentially

18:00

spreading the right-wing misinformation

18:02

here is rissi cobbert breaking down the

18:04

program look at hash crack pipes on

18:07

Twitter to see how it is being spread by

18:09

the right wing just letting y'all know

18:12

now here's the whole deal I sent that

18:15

because my whole deal was like y'all

18:17

what we doing like and y'all had

18:19

somebody which means some some little

18:22

person who did no research didn't check

18:25

the source Scott just rewrote it you put

18:29

it up on blackenterprise.com

18:30

which means did it go through an editor

18:33

did it go through any factchecking

18:35

procedure and now somebody sees it and

18:37

goes well Black Enterprise wrote it so H

18:40

they must have fact check it it

18:42

shouldn't take me to call them out the

18:44

same story got spread by I think by uh

18:46

the same story got spread by some other

18:48

people and I remember I called news one

18:50

before after after I left TV1 I called

18:53

BL I was like yo that story y'all got up

18:56

that story wrong take that down and

18:59

so again for me the Jasmine brand and

19:02

this this is just innocent I was reading

19:05

a post on the Jasmine brand once and I

19:07

saw it and that was like one or two

19:09

words that actually threw the store off

19:11

and it was wrong and I was like hey let

19:13

y'all know that's not correct y'all

19:15

might want to fix

19:17

that I

19:19

respect news and I need black on media

19:23

to give a damn and not fall for the oky

19:26

do Scott go ahead yeah you know lazy

19:30

lawyering lazy doctoring and lazy lazy

19:34

writers in the media all very dangerous

19:36

the problem with lazy writers in the

19:39

media is that it goes

19:41

worldwide makes it even more dangerous

19:43

so so I I I agree with you but but

19:46

here's a question Roland so I get the

19:48

lazy part right nobody's gonna argue

19:50

with you about that I guess for me in it

19:53

and I don't know in journalistic

19:55

standards of excellence or just basic

19:57

journalism standards

19:59

if I cite a source for my article and

20:02

I'm repeating what TMZ or the Washington

20:05

Post said and I'm rewriting it and

20:08

giving them credit aren't I minimally

20:12

okay with that haven't I minimum

20:14

standard or not right right right right

20:16

that's me what happens is now that

20:18

happens you credit The Source the assoc

20:22

the Atlanta all the time right right you

20:24

credit The Source but here's how I

20:26

operate if you black

20:29

and it's a black story if if I'm so when

20:33

I criticized Essence yesterday they

20:36

quoted foxy 11 LA and then they said A A

20:40

source told CNBC that the raid was tied

20:44

to a sex trafficking deal now as an

20:47

editor the moment I see that story I

20:50

go I'm sorry one we as an organization

20:55

media organization we don't run any

20:57

story without two

20:59

sources that's first two you have in

21:03

your story a source from CNBC you don't

21:06

know nobody at CNBC you don't know who

21:09

that source is so when as a so when I'm

21:11

sitting there telling y'all I talk to

21:14

four

21:16

sources my I know their involvement in

21:21

the sale of

21:22

revote so when I come on and say I got

21:27

four sources your ass can damn well take

21:30

to the bank that my folk are real are

21:36

significant now a lot of times a source

21:39

let me explain the journalism lingo

21:42

someone familiar with the thinking of

21:46

that means they ain't close to the

21:48

source a a family member of see it's all

21:52

kind different phrases we use that sort

21:55

of give you a sense of how close they

21:58

are

21:59

to the source so when you're writing a

22:01

story you can say TM this how you do it

22:04

TMZ is reporting that revote has been

22:07

sailed has been sold blah blah blah

22:11

blah black Enterprise reach out to

22:14

revote called and emailed and by press

22:20

time we did not get a call back what

22:23

that says is we made an effort to try to

22:26

confirm TMZ is reporting Black

22:30

Enterprise at Essence and they ain't

22:32

tried none of that in the essence story

22:34

where they talked about cour to CNBC and

22:36

fox1 they never said essence.com reach

22:40

out to Diddy his lawyers and his press

22:43

person to get a comment so in their

22:46

article they quoted CNBC quoting

22:49

Cassie's lawyer but not quoting anybody

22:52

on Diddy side that's a failure of

22:55

Journalism all I'm saying is pick up the

22:57

phone call somebody email somebody DM

23:01

somebody make an attempt but when you

23:03

make no attempt then you just rewriting

23:06

somebody's stuff and slapping your name

23:08

on it and I'm sorry that don't pass

23:10

mustard and I'm telling you in news

23:13

rooms that I run you will get

23:16

fired no I got you the other thing that

23:18

they do is they will say mainstream

23:20

media will say um TMZ is reporting X Y

23:23

andz uh NBC has not been able to

23:26

independently confirm this hold up

23:29

Michael Michael Jackson dies I'm in

23:31

Jamaica I'm the the resort I'm at as a

23:34

sports complex I'm walking across the

23:36

street Roland it's so man it's so sad

23:41

about Michael say what dude was in the

23:44

car say what Michael Jackson's dead we

23:49

used to the we used to them killing some

23:51

celebrity I was like man Michael Jackson

23:54

ain't dead no Michael's dead now I'm on

23:57

the resort I'm here Michael Jackson

23:59

music rolling been the journalist

24:02

go I go back to my

24:09

villa Marlin how you doing say man I'm

24:13

in

24:14

Jamaica Roland hold

24:17

on say something to his

24:19

daughter my brother's

24:22

gone oh yeah I

24:26

go Marlin when you say your brother's

24:29

gone my mom called me my brother's

24:33

Dead with my other phone this is my

24:36

personal

24:37

phone pick it up I'm emailing

24:41

CNN I have confirmed from Marlon Jackson

24:45

now mind you CNN is on Air Wolf Blitzer

24:48

is giving TMZ credit CNN has not

24:52

independently confirmed from anybody

24:54

that Michael Jackson is dead my email to

24:57

CN was the first confirmation by anybody

25:01

at CNN outside of TMZ that's called

25:05

reporting and that's the problem I'm

25:08

simply saying to Black on media pick

25:10

make an attempt to call respect the

25:14

black audience enough that you don't

25:16

just repeat what you hear and I don't

25:17

give a damn it's the New York Times if

25:19

it's a story involving black people and

25:21

I see that story and it's the times boom

25:25

say bro I'm seeing this and that's what

25:27

I'm saying so what end up happening

25:29

Scott we then are spreading what they

25:31

report and didn't even attempt and I'm

25:34

telling you I know for a fact the seller

25:36

Revolt is not final so all these people

25:38

reported everywhere Revolt sold sold

25:41

sold sold sold did got a bag sold it's

25:44

not true the sale could actually fall

25:46

through between now and I've already

25:48

been told when it's going to get

25:49

announced it could actually fall through

25:51

so what then happens if it does fall

25:54

through oh everybody said the deal was

25:56

done that's why you call go ahead final

26:02

Point well I I think you're talking

26:05

about Excellence right no I'm talking

26:07

about I'm talking about journalism 101

26:10

not journalism 401 not journalism 401

26:14

not journalism 301 not 2011 it's 101 you

26:19

were taught real you're taught to

26:22

call it's if a story came out if

26:26

somebody said rolling Scott Bowden got

26:29

arrested no no no no seriously no wait

26:32

hold up I'm going to use a real example

26:35

the judge held Scott in cont I mean hold

26:38

Scott Bolding in contempt what's the

26:40

first thing I did Scott if you didn't

26:43

pick up you know what I would have done

26:46

right emailed you if you didn't respond

26:48

in five minutes I would have called The

26:50

Firm and asked for your secretary see

26:54

that's what you're supposed to do you

26:56

don't just go hey Scott got arrested

26:59

Scott going to jail Scott Scott got held

27:02

in contempt and then you go no Roland I

27:04

wasn't held in contempt the judge is

27:07

threatening to hold me in contempt so

27:09

being held in contempt and threatening

27:11

to hold in contempt are two totally

27:13

different things that's all I'm saying

27:15

to Black on media damn use the phone

27:19

call somebody but you know when you but

27:21

when black on media is lazy like that it

27:25

perpetuates white privileges View of

27:28

black people and their their product if

27:31

you will and and that somehow it's

27:34

almost acceptable to have a have a non-

27:37

excellent or below standard uh product

27:41

that's acceptable to black people so

27:43

it's not reliable if you will somebody

27:45

white looking at it and saying well

27:47

that's from a black publication so we

27:49

can't really rely on it because they're

27:51

white privileged kicks in to me that's

27:53

another danger if you're not if you're

27:56

not practicing excellent journalism so I

27:59

mean nobody's going to disagree with you

28:00

about this I just wish we no no no there

28:04

are people who have disagreed with me

28:05

man why you make a big deal out of this

28:07

about because I dare say because I've

28:10

called people out I'm just going to

28:12

leave this one with y'all but I'm I'mma

28:14

give you an example that's not

28:16

blackowned

28:17

media y'all y'all three GNA love this

28:20

one so remember when remember when uh

28:24

President Obama uh had the news

28:27

conference and he he was asked the

28:28

question regarding the arrest of skip

28:31

Gates and remember he said that the cops

28:35

acted

28:37

stupidly after arresting him after

28:40

ascertaining that he actually owned the

28:42

house remember that that's actually what

28:43

he

28:44

said Sean hany Fox News in the right

28:48

Obama called cop

28:49

stupid no he said they acted

28:53

stupidly after learning he owned the

28:56

house and still arresting him as

28:58

actually what he said so I'm on CNN and

29:01

we're in the air and we're discussing it

29:04

and so I'd already found out what

29:07

happened at the meeting that morning

29:10

what happened at the so in the White

29:12

House there are two meetings that's a

29:14

7:00 meeting and that's a 8:00 meeting

29:18

the 7:00 meeting is the real real

29:20

meeting okay it's more people in the

29:23

8:00 meeting but the seven is the real

29:25

real meeting so so we're the air and

29:29

Candy Crowley great respect for Candy

29:31

Crowley Candy Crowley goes well you know

29:35

my understanding from um from the um you

29:39

know that the White House would really

29:43

prefer to walk that black walk that back

29:45

I went no they

29:48

not they all turned to me I said my

29:52

understanding is Obama is very clear as

29:54

to what he

29:55

said well Roland you know I've talked to

29:59

my sources in the white house and I

30:02

went I ain't lying I never forget I went

30:06

oh I got sources

30:08

too and I can tell you now here was the

30:12

reality the reality was the reality was

30:16

in a 7:00 meeting the white boys came in

30:19

were like yeah we got to walk this back

30:21

the black folks like

30:23

no we not and and a black

30:26

staffer I ain't going to name him said

30:29

outside this building I left the office

30:32

yesterday and I'm a senior staffer in

30:34

this white house and I flagged I

30:37

couldn't flag down the cab and they

30:39

passed me by the whole room went silent

30:43

so when so when the white advisers when

30:45

they all went into the Oval Office Obama

30:48

made it clear he was walking back

30:51

nothing I know who I got the story

30:54

from and I was like I got sources too so

30:58

here so at CNN was kind of like well you

31:00

know that's Candy Crowley I don't give a

31:02

damn that's Candy

31:04

Crowley I know people

31:06

too but what happens is in those sort of

31:10

like they like to defer to the last I

31:12

just remember I remember and again I

31:14

love candy but the bottom line is I know

31:16

people too y'all may remember that was a

31:19

general James

31:21

Jones he had friction with um Bill uh

31:25

Robert

31:26

Gates and and I remember I made some

31:29

comment and then it was like well

31:31

General Jones is very well liked I was

31:34

like yeah he ain't going to be that long

31:36

though I said that's he ain't G be that

31:39

long and it was and it was sort of like

31:42

the response to me was sort of like like

31:45

what do you know I said okay we GNA see

31:48

who go

31:50

first why don't y'all Google General

31:52

James Jones and see when he resigned and

31:56

then Google Robert gate to see when he

31:58

resigned Jones left first this is an

32:02

example even when you're in White media

32:05

why you got to have your own sources

32:08

close to the action because there were

32:10

numerous times even at CNN where I had

32:13

stuff and other people didn't have and

32:16

and I I just I I don't want to hold

32:19

y'all I gota but just Scott you man we

32:22

way late no no Scott Scott you'll be all

32:24

right I'm give I'm just gonna give you

32:26

I'm gonna give y this de got one thing

32:28

cuz Rebecca I'm going get it they they

32:30

wouldn't let me put this in my book CNN

32:32

said no I'm Rebecca we going to close on

32:34

you but they wouldn't let me put this in

32:35

my book The Night of the Iowa caucus

32:39

when Obama won so I didn't get on the

32:42

air for three and a half hours so we off

32:44

air and somebody on the air and they

32:46

saying um uh we don't know where Obama

32:49

is tonight in De Mo I was like he had

32:52

dinner um and then I said he then uh

32:56

then then of course then then when he

32:58

wins they goes well not sure when Obama

33:00

is coming to the convention center he

33:02

leaving dinner in 20 minutes uh and they

33:05

come to me and they're like oh my God

33:07

where are you getting this from I see it

33:09

from the person sitting next to him at

33:10

dinner um and and then it was and so

33:14

then uh they would I was getting all

33:16

this information all night and they were

33:17

just like oh my God and I said well if

33:20

y'all put my ass on the air the audience

33:22

will be getting this information as well

33:24

but y'all got me sit here on the

33:25

sideline this is what they also do to us

33:28

so all I'm saying to our black folk I

33:30

need us to learn how to pick the phone

33:32

up develop sources so when stuff happens

33:35

you can speak authoritatively and you

33:37

can be the one breaking news and giving

33:39

facts and not relying on White media

33:41

Rebecca close us out and I just want to

33:45

make it clear and being careful that

33:46

we're not calling black journalists lazy

33:49

because I know that that was a comment

33:50

that was made earlier that's not the

33:52

issue here the issue is don't fall for

33:54

clout culture but actually do your due

33:58

diligence the way you learned in J

33:59

School the ethics that you learn in

34:01

journalism School more than any other

34:04

time we need you all to step up and to

34:06

adhere to those standards well I am

34:09

calling you lazy if you don't pick the

34:12

phone up to get attribution or to get

34:16

the right information and what you do is

34:18

you write a story and you slap your name

34:21

on it as if you actually reported the

34:23

story and I'm calling whoever edited the

34:26

story lazy if they actually approve that

34:29

story because both individuals the

34:31

reporter and the editor or editors

34:34

failed journalism

34:36

101 I will say that Robert Rebecca Scott

34:41

always a pleasure Scott you know you're

34:44

wrong when it comes to the stadium but

34:46

nice effort nice effort Rebecca owned

34:49

you on that one nice you people

34:52

Rebecca Rebecca owned you on that one

34:54

but I know you got to protect your

34:55

chamber of commer you got you got to

34:57

protect Chamber of Commerce position but

34:59

uh we spoke we spoke truth all right fan

35:02

base is pioneering a new era of social

35:04

media and investment this next

35:07

Generation social app has already raised

35:09

$10 million and has just opened a new

35:11

round to

35:13

invest for details on how to invest

35:15

visit startengine.com fanbase or scan

35:18

the QR

35:24

code another way we're giving you the

35:26

freedom to You Without

35:30

Limits

Rate This

5.0 / 5 (0 votes)

Tags associés
Media IntegrityMisinformationBlack-Owned MediaFact-CheckingJournalistic EthicsPress ResponsibilityDiddy Sale ControversyHBCU FundingSocial MediaInvestment
Avez-vous besoin d'un résumé en français?