BREAKING: Prosecutors to deal first MAJOR BLOW to Trump at trial

The Legal Breakdown with BTC & Glenn Kirschner
19 Apr 202409:16

Summary

TLDRIn this legal analysis, Glenn and Brian discuss the upcoming challenges for Donald Trump in his criminal trial. The focus is on the Sandoval hearing, where prosecutors must disclose any uncharged misconduct they intend to use for cross-examination if Trump chooses to testify. The hosts highlight 13 acts of misconduct, including business fraud and defamation, that could impact the jury's perception of Trump's credibility. They debate whether Trump will opt to testify, considering the risk of perjury and the potential for a hung jury. The discussion also touches on the possibility and timing of a retrial in the event of a hung jury, emphasizing the importance of the trial's outcome for the American public, especially if Trump runs for presidency again.

Takeaways

  • πŸ“š Glenn Donald Trump is facing a trial where prosecutors will expose his misconduct to the jury.
  • πŸ‘₯ The hosts, Brian and Glenn, will provide daily coverage of the Trump trial for viewers to follow.
  • 🎀 A Sandoval hearing will be held, which is a legal proceeding where the prosecution must disclose uncharged misconduct that may be used for cross-examination.
  • 🚫 Trump is charged with 34 felony counts related to falsifying business records to conceal hush money payments, which gave him an advantage in a presidential election.
  • πŸ“ There are 13 acts of uncharged misconduct that the prosecution wants to introduce to the jury if Trump decides to testify.
  • πŸ’Ό The Trump Organization was convicted of 17 felonies for systemic business fraud, which is one of the misconducts the prosecution may question Trump about.
  • πŸ€” The judge will determine which acts of misconduct are admissible for cross-examination and which might be too prejudicial.
  • 🚫 If Trump chooses not to testify, the prosecution will only be able to introduce misconduct that has been previously litigated and ruled admissible.
  • πŸ€” There is speculation that Trump may not testify due to the risk of perjury and the potential impact on jury perception.
  • πŸ” If the jury is unable to reach a unanimous decision (a hung jury), the prosecutors can retry the case, often with a refined presentation.
  • ⏳ A retrial, if necessary, would likely be scheduled for the future, not immediately following the current trial.

Q & A

  • What is the significance of the Sandoval hearing in the context of the trial?

    -The Sandoval hearing is an opportunity for the prosecution to notify the defense of any uncharged misconduct they may want to cross-examine the defendant with. This is particularly relevant when the defendant is deciding whether to testify in their own criminal trial. It provides the jury with information about the defendant's credibility.

  • What are acts of uncharged misconduct?

    -Acts of uncharged misconduct refer to wrongdoings that the defendant may have committed but have not been formally charged with in the current case. These acts can be used by the prosecution during cross-examination to challenge the defendant's credibility if the defendant chooses to testify.

  • What is the current charge against Donald Trump?

    -Donald Trump is charged with 34 felony counts of falsifying business records to cover up the true nature of hush money payments, which were allegedly made to gain an unfair advantage in a presidential election.

  • What are some of the other misconducts that Donald Trump has been involved in, as mentioned in the script?

    -The script mentions several instances of misconduct, including being found liable for assault and defamation of E. Gene Carol, being ordered to pay millions in damages, the conviction of the Trump Corporation for long-term systemic business fraud, illegal fundraisers, and the diversion of charity funds to his campaign.

  • How many acts of misconduct does the prosecution want to introduce to the jury during the cross-examination of Donald Trump?

    -The prosecution wants to introduce 13 acts of misconduct during the cross-examination of Donald Trump if he decides to testify.

  • What happens if Donald Trump does not take the stand in his own defense?

    -If Donald Trump does not testify, the prosecution will not be able to introduce any uncharged misconduct that has not been previously litigated and ruled admissible. The scope of uncharged misconduct that can be introduced would be much narrower.

  • What is the potential impact of the Sandoval notice on Donald Trump's decision to testify?

    -The Sandoval notice, which lists 13 instances of serious misconduct, could be devastating for Donald Trump's case if presented to the jury. It may influence his decision on whether to testify, as it could affect the jury's perception of his guilt or innocence.

  • What are the consequences if the jury is unable to reach a unanimous decision in the trial?

    -If the jury is unable to reach a unanimous decision, resulting in a hung jury, the prosecutors have the option to retry the case. Retrials are typically scheduled for a later date, not immediately following the conclusion of the initial trial.

  • What factors might influence the timing of a retrial if the current trial results in a hung jury?

    -The timing of a retrial depends on various factors, including the judge's schedule, the availability of witnesses, and the coordination of schedules for all parties involved. It is unlikely to happen immediately due to the complexity of rescheduling.

  • Why is it important for the American public to know the outcome of this trial?

    -The outcome of this trial is significant because it involves a former president of the United States who is potentially interfering in an election and is running for presidency again. The American public deserves to know if they are voting for a convicted felon or an exonerated individual.

  • What is the role of the judge in deciding which acts of misconduct can be brought up during cross-examination?

    -The judge has the authority to decide which acts of misconduct are properly subject to cross-examination and which ones might be too prejudicial for the prosecution to introduce. This ensures a fair trial process.

Outlines

00:00

πŸ“š Introduction to Trump's Trial and Acts of Misconduct

This paragraph introduces the video's focus on Glenn Donald Trump's trial and the first opportunity for prosecutors to expose his misconduct to the jury. The video promises comprehensive daily coverage of the trial and encourages viewers to subscribe for updates. The discussion centers on the Sandoval hearing, a legal procedure that allows prosecutors to disclose acts of uncharged misconduct to the defense when a defendant is deciding whether to testify. The video outlines 13 acts of misconduct by Trump that prosecutors wish to introduce, including previous legal judgments against him and his organization's involvement in various illegal activities. The paragraph concludes with a discussion on how this information might influence Trump's decision to testify.

05:03

πŸ€” Trump's Potential Testimony and Its Implications

The second paragraph delves into whether Trump should testify at his trial. It explains that if Trump remains silent, only previously litigated and admissible uncharged misconduct can be introduced by the prosecution. However, if Trump testifies, the jury could hear about all 13 acts of misconduct. The discussion suggests that Trump's propensity for lying could lead to perjury if he takes the stand. The potential for a hung jury is also explored, noting that winning over just one juror could result in a mistrial. The paragraph touches on the likelihood of a retrial in the event of a hung jury, the challenges of rescheduling witnesses, and the importance of resolving the case promptly given Trump's political ambitions.

Mindmap

Keywords

πŸ’‘Sandoval hearing

A Sandoval hearing is a legal proceeding where the prosecution must disclose to the defense any uncharged misconduct they intend to use for cross-examination if the defendant chooses to testify. In the context of the video, this hearing is significant because it allows the jury to learn about Donald Trump's past misconduct, affecting their perception of his credibility. The term originates from a court case in New York where the defendant was named Sandoval.

πŸ’‘Uncharged misconduct

Uncharged misconduct refers to actions or behaviors that, while they may be considered wrongdoings, are not part of the formal charges against a defendant in a criminal trial. In the video, it is mentioned that there are 13 acts of uncharged misconduct by Donald Trump that the prosecutors wish to introduce during cross-examination, which could impact the jury's view of his character and credibility.

πŸ’‘Falsifying business records

Falsifying business records is a criminal offense that involves altering or making false entries in business documents with the intent to deceive or mislead. In the video, it is stated that Donald Trump is charged with 34 felony counts of falsifying business records to hide the true nature of hush money payments, which is a key element of the case being discussed.

πŸ’‘Perjury

Perjury is the act of lying or making false statements under oath, typically in a court setting. The video suggests that there is a concern that if Donald Trump were to testify, he might commit perjury, which is a serious crime and could further damage his case.

πŸ’‘Hung jury

A hung jury occurs when a jury is unable to reach a unanimous decision on whether the defendant is guilty or not guilty. In the context of the video, the discussion revolves around the possibility that if the jury cannot agree on a verdict, the case could result in a mistrial, and the prosecution would have the option to retry the case.

πŸ’‘Retrial

A retrial is a new trial that takes place after a previous trial has ended in a mistrial or hung jury. The video discusses the potential timing and logistics of a retrial for Donald Trump's case, noting that it would likely be delayed due to the scheduling of other trials and the need to reassemble witnesses.

πŸ’‘Jury selection

Jury selection is the process of choosing the individuals who will serve on a jury for a trial. The video mentions that the jury selection process for Trump's trial is progressing quickly, which is significant as it indicates the trial is moving forward at a rapid pace.

πŸ’‘Trump Corporation

The Trump Corporation, also referred to as the Trump Organization in the video, is a conglomerate of businesses. It is mentioned in the context of having been convicted of 17 felonies for long-term systemic business fraud, which is one of the acts of misconduct that the prosecutors want to question Donald Trump about.

πŸ’‘Charitable fraud

Charitable fraud involves the misuse or misdirection of funds intended for charitable purposes. In the video, it is discussed that Donald Trump agreed to dissolve the Trump charity to settle allegations of fraud, where funds meant for charity were instead diverted to his campaign.

πŸ’‘Assault and defamation

Assault and defamation are legal terms referring to physical harm or threat of harm to a person (assault) and damaging someone's reputation through false statements (defamation). The video states that Donald Trump was found liable for these actions in a previous case, which is part of the misconduct the prosecution may introduce during the trial.

πŸ’‘Mistrial

A mistrial is a legal term for a trial that has been rendered invalid due to a procedural error, misconduct, or other issues that prevent a fair trial. In the context of the video, a mistrial is a possible outcome if Donald Trump convinces at least one juror of his innocence through his testimony, potentially leading to a hung jury and the need for a retrial.

Highlights

Glenn Donald Trump is set for a challenging day in trial.

Prosecutors will have their first opportunity to expose Trump's misconduct to the jury.

The Sandoval hearing is a procedural step where the prosecution must disclose uncharged misconduct they may cross-examine the defendant about.

Donald Trump is charged with 34 felony counts of falsifying business records.

The jury may hear about 13 acts of uncharged misconduct if Trump decides to testify.

Previous legal cases have found Trump liable for assault and defamation, with millions in damages awarded.

Trump Organization was convicted of 17 felonies for systemic business fraud.

Illegal fundraisers were held for Trump, with funds diverted from charity to his campaign.

Trump agreed to dissolve his charity to settle fraud allegations.

The judge will decide which acts of misconduct are admissible in cross-examination.

If Trump does not testify, the scope of uncharged misconduct that can be introduced is much narrower.

There is speculation that Trump may not take the stand due to the risk of perjury.

The presentation of 13 instances of serious misconduct could heavily influence the jury's perception of Trump.

If the jury is hung, prosecutors can retry the case, often with a refined presentation.

A retrial would likely be scheduled months later due to judicial backlog and witness coordination.

The urgency of resolving the case is emphasized given Trump's potential run for presidency.

The jury selection process is proceeding quickly, and there may be some flexibility for a retrial.

The complexity of reassembling witnesses and the court's schedule make an immediate retrial unlikely.

The legal breakdown will provide comprehensive daily coverage of the Trump trial.

Transcripts

00:00

you're watching the legal breakdown so

00:01

Glenn Donald Trump is set for a really

00:03

bad day in trial so we're going to talk

00:05

about the first opportunity that

00:07

prosecutors have to expose Trump's

00:08

misconduct to the jury uh but first just

00:10

a reminder to those watching right now

00:12

that Glenn and I will be doing

00:13

comprehensive daily coverage of the

00:15

Trump trial so if you want to follow

00:16

along please make sure to subscribe the

00:18

links to our channels are on this screen

00:20

they're also in the post description of

00:21

this video okay Glenn talk about these

00:24

acts of misconduct that the jury is

00:25

going to hear about what is this process

00:26

that we're going to be uh that we're

00:28

going to be seeing carry out right now

00:30

yes so they're going to hold what's

00:31

called a sand Deval hearing what does

00:33

that mean so every jurisdiction has its

00:36

own name for these kind of hearings

00:39

usually the name comes from the leading

00:41

appell at court case and in in New York

00:44

the defendant was named Sandoval when

00:47

the appell at court decided a case that

00:50

gave birth to this kind of a hearing so

00:51

it is forever known as the sandal

00:53

hearing what is it so when a defendant

00:57

is trying to make the decision whether

00:58

he wants to testify or decline to

01:01

testify in his own criminal trial the

01:04

prosecutors have to give the defense

01:06

notice of all the acts of uncharged

01:09

misconduct I'll talk more about that in

01:12

a minute that's a bit of a mouthful all

01:14

of the acts of uncharged misconduct that

01:17

they might want to cross-examine the

01:19

defendant with to give the jury

01:22

information about the defendants

01:24

credibility so what are acts of

01:26

uncharged misconduct in this case Donald

01:28

Trump is charged with 34 felony counts

01:32

of falsifying business records to cover

01:34

up the true nature of hush money

01:36

payments to gain unfair advantage in a

01:39

presidential election however Donald

01:42

Trump has engaged in so much more

01:44

misconduct even in recent years for

01:48

which he's been held accountable in

01:50

various courts and so under the New York

01:53

state law if Donald Trump testifies this

01:55

jury gets to hear that an earlier jury

01:58

found him liable for assaulting and

02:01

defaming defaming a couple of times over

02:04

egene Carol and that he was ordered to

02:06

pay millions and millions in Damages to

02:09

EEG Carol and Brian I have the sand ofal

02:12

notice here and there are 13 acts of

02:16

misconduct by Donald Trump that the

02:18

prosecutors want to introduce to the

02:20

jury um when they are cross-examining

02:23

Donald Trump there was when the the

02:26

Trump Corporation really the Trump

02:29

organiz ation but it was called the

02:30

Trump Corporation was convicted of 17

02:34

felonies for long-term systemic business

02:37

fraud they want to cross-examine him

02:39

about that they want to cross-examine

02:41

him about how there were illegal

02:44

fundraisers held for Donald Trump and

02:46

the money was supposed to go to the

02:48

Trump charity and instead it was

02:50

diverted to his campaign they then want

02:53

to ask him about the fact that Donald

02:55

Trump stipulated to that is he agreed to

02:58

dissolve the Trump charity as a way to

03:01

sort of settle all of the fraud that had

03:03

been involved there and and Brian it

03:06

goes on and on and on 13 other acts of

03:10

uncharged misconduct or Crimes by Donald

03:13

Trump that the prosecutors want to

03:16

cross-examine Donald Trump with in the

03:18

event Donald Trump takes the stand in

03:20

his own trial so this is an exercise

03:23

where they go through all of these acts

03:26

of misconduct the judge will decide with

03:29

which ones are properly the subject of

03:33

cross-examination and which ones for

03:34

example might be too prejudicial for the

03:37

prosecutors to bring up and then once

03:40

that issue is decided then Donald Trump

03:42

gets to make the decision okay I know

03:45

that the jury is going to learn of 10

03:47

acts of serious misconduct including

03:50

lying under oath in another Court um

03:54

that's going to factor into my decision

03:56

as to whether I actually want to take

03:58

the stand in my own defensive my

03:59

criminal trial so to be clear if he opts

04:02

not to take the stand uh in his own

04:04

defense is it that prosecutors won't be

04:06

able to introduce any of this uncharged

04:09

misconduct they will only be able to

04:11

introduce the uncharged misconduct that

04:13

they litigated previously and that the

04:16

judge ruled was appropriately admissible

04:20

evidence but it will be a much narrower

04:23

scope of uncharged misconduct then if

04:27

Donald Trump ends up taking the stand

04:29

and do you believe that this will have

04:30

any impact on Trump's um willingness to

04:33

actually take the stand or do you think

04:34

he's already made that decision up

04:35

anyway I don't think Donald Trump can

04:38

take the stand for a New York minute

04:40

without lying committing perjury and you

04:43

know his lies are so transparent when he

04:45

tells them uh I I don't think there's

04:48

any chance he was going to take the

04:49

stand even before getting this uh sand

04:53

Deval notice which is devastating if the

04:55

jurors are presented with 13 instances

04:59

of serious misconduct by Donald Trump do

05:02

you really think they're going to give

05:03

him the benefit of the doubt when it

05:05

comes time to judge his guilt of the 34

05:09

falsifying business records crimes for

05:11

which he's been indicted in this case

05:13

Glenn is there any reason that Donald

05:15

Trump might opt to actually take the

05:16

stand and testify here or does he

05:18

actually stand to benefit more from just

05:20

sitting down and shutting up the entire

05:21

time yeah you know Brian he has the

05:23

right to remain silent I don't think

05:24

Donald Trump has the ability to remain

05:27

silent um but I think as a attorneys

05:30

will recommend to him in the strongest

05:32

possible terms that it's not going to

05:34

inure to your advantage if you take the

05:37

stand in this case now listen Donald

05:40

Trump may be so full of himself that he

05:43

thinks he can win over the jurors and

05:45

remember he only has to win over one jur

05:49

if he wins over one jur with his bluff

05:52

and his Bluster and his Bull on the

05:54

stand well then that could result in a

05:57

hung hung jury and a mistrial the good

06:00

news is if the jury hangs in other words

06:03

if they can't decide the case

06:04

unanimously either for guilt or not

06:07

guilty AC quitt then the prosecutors can

06:11

retry it and let me tell you I did a lot

06:12

of retrials in my years ordinarily um

06:16

prosecutors fine-tune their presentation

06:19

of the evidence and the retrial goes a

06:22

little bit better and often will result

06:24

in a conviction even after the first

06:26

case hung and we've spoken about the

06:28

prospect of hung jury before but just

06:30

for posterity here for those who are

06:32

just watching this for the first time uh

06:34

would would would a retrial happen

06:37

immediately what would the timing of

06:38

that look like a retrial would almost

06:41

certainly be pushed off into the future

06:44

at least a month two months three months

06:46

because you know judges actually stack

06:49

up their trials so I can promise you as

06:51

soon as the Trump trial is over judge

06:54

Muran probably has three other trials

06:56

that are in the Chute and ready to go

06:58

just waiting for the Trump trial to

07:00

conclude it doesn't mean that in this

07:03

case which is really unique right a

07:05

former president of the United States

07:07

who interfered in the 2016 election to

07:10

get elected and he's running for

07:12

presidency again I mean I think time is

07:15

of the essence and the American people

07:16

deserve to know if he ends up being the

07:20

nominee for the Republican Party whether

07:22

they're going to the polls and casting

07:24

their vote for a convicted felon or for

07:27

a fully innocent exonerated man so I

07:30

think there's an off chance that judge

07:32

Maran will say listen I'll give you a

07:34

week or two but if the jury hangs we're

07:36

going right back in to a retrial because

07:38

we need to resolve this case well do you

07:41

think the fact that also this jury

07:42

selection process seems to be going whip

07:45

fast and uh and also judge michan likely

07:48

gave himself some padding I mean this is

07:50

a major trial it's probably the biggest

07:51

trial one of the biggest trials that's

07:53

ever happened in American history

07:54

chances are he didn't butt the butt this

07:56

up right against you know his very next

07:58

trial with only like a day or two to

08:00

spare so I'm assuming he gave himself a

08:01

little bit of cushion so in the event

08:04

that there is a hung jury do you imagine

08:05

that they would be able you know given

08:07

how much how quickly the jury selection

08:08

is happening and also some cushion that

08:10

he may have given himself at the end

08:12

that we could see an immediate retrial I

08:14

would say a possibility but not a

08:16

likelihood the other thing that we have

08:18

to keep in mind is that anytime you're

08:21

getting ready to go to trial you have to

08:23

go out and subpoena all of the witnesses

08:25

for the new trial date you have to you

08:27

have to coordinate with their schedules

08:28

I mean you know everybody's got their

08:30

their lives to live and so you know it

08:33

really is a Herculean task to get

08:36

everybody back together to go right back

08:39

into a retrial not impossible I just

08:41

don't see it as all that likely all

08:44

right well obviously everybody's doing

08:45

everything they can to make sure the

08:47

trial worked correctly the first time

08:49

and and that's what we'll continue to

08:50

follow along with so for those watching

08:52

right now if you want to follow along

08:53

with everything that happens in this

08:54

first Trump prosecution as it continues

08:56

to progress please make sure to

08:57

subscribe the links to both of our

08:58

channels are right here on the screen

09:00

you can hover your mouse right over both

09:02

of the links to our channels and just

09:03

hit the Subscribe button I'm Brian

09:04

teller Cohen and I'm Glenn kersner

09:06

you're watching the legal breakdown

09:11

[Music]

Rate This
β˜…
β˜…
β˜…
β˜…
β˜…

5.0 / 5 (0 votes)

Related Tags
Trump TrialLegal BreakdownProsecution StrategyTestimony DecisionUncharged MisconductFalsifying RecordsHush Money ScandalCourt ProceedingsJury DynamicsPerjury RiskRetrial PossibilityElection Implications