Netanyahu: Israel will stand alone if U.S. Withdraws Aid | Jerusalem Dateline - May 10, 2024
Summary
TLDRIn this edition of Jerusalem Dateline, host Chris Mitchell discusses the recent developments in the conflict between Israel and Hamas. Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu asserts that Israel will continue to fight against Hamas in Rafah, even if it means standing alone, following President Biden's announcement of withholding certain ammunition. The program also addresses the use of civilian casualties in Gaza as a propaganda tool by Hamas, the potential legal and political implications for the U.S., and the impact on the 2024 presidential election. Additionally, the show covers a lawsuit against U.S. groups driving anti-Israel protests on campuses, the IDF's preparedness against Hamas, and the spiritual and international response to the conflict. The episode concludes with a story of a family finding a new life in Israel with support from CBN partners.
Takeaways
- ๐ค Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu has pledged that Israel will fight alone against Hamas if necessary, despite President Biden's announcement of halting certain ammunition supplies.
- ๐ก๏ธ IDF Chief Spokesman stated that the military has sufficient munitions to complete their operations, even in the context of the U.S. weapons embargo.
- ๐ Netanyahu emphasized Israel's strength and determination, drawing a parallel to the War of Independence, and vowed to fight with the 'same greatness of spirit'.
- ๐ There are concerns that the U.S. decision to withhold ammunition may prolong the conflict and potentially lead to more civilian casualties in Gaza.
- ๐ The Middle East is closely watching the U.S.'s actions, with some drawing parallels to the U.S. withdrawal from Afghanistan and perceptions of betrayal.
- ๐จ Criticism of President Biden's decision is coming from both Democrats and Republicans, with some accusing the administration of aiding Hamas.
- ๐ Israel is preparing for potential future conflicts, particularly with Hezbollah, as Defense Minister Yoav Gallant reinforces troops.
- ๐๏ธ The U.S. Congress is divided on the issue, with many siding with Israel against the Biden administration's decision to withhold ammunition.
- ๐ The credibility of the Gaza Ministry's casualty figures is being questioned, with accusations that they are inflated for propaganda purposes.
- ๐ Data scientists and analysts have pointed out discrepancies in the reported civilian casualty numbers, suggesting that many of the reported deaths may be combatants.
- ๐ The lawsuit against U.S. groups National Students for Justice in Palestine and American Muslims for Palestine highlights the role of these organizations in fueling anti-Israel sentiment on campuses.
Q & A
What did Israeli Minister Netanyahu say about Israel's determination to fight?
-Israeli Minister Netanyahu stated that Israel will fight with its nails, emphasizing the country's determination to stand alone in its war against Hamas if necessary.
What was President Biden's announcement regarding the U.S. support for Israel's operation in Rafah?
-President Biden announced that the U.S. would halt the supply of certain ammunition if Israel attacks deeper into Rafah.
How did the IDF Chief Spokesman respond to Biden's weapons embargo?
-The IDF Chief Spokesman stated that the military has what it needs to finish the job, despite Biden's weapons embargo.
What is the concern raised by some regarding civilian deaths in Gaza?
-There is a concern that civilian deaths in Gaza are being used as a propaganda tool, with some advocacy groups accused of instigating protests for this purpose.
What is the claim about U.S. university campuses being used as a second battle front by Hamas?
-The claim is that advocacy groups following Hamas's ideology are fueling pro-Palestinian, anti-Israel protests on U.S. university campuses, effectively using them as a second battle front.
What is the potential impact of the U.S. withholding ammunition on the conflict between Israel and Hamas?
-The withholding of ammunition by the U.S. could prolong the conflict, as it may embolden Hamas and force Israel to use more force to reach agreements.
What is the Israeli perspective on the U.S.'s decision to withhold weapons?
-Israel downplayed the threat of the U.S. withholding weapons, asserting that they can continue their operation in Rafah alone if necessary.
What is the significance of the lawsuit against U.S. groups following Hamas's ideology?
-The lawsuit aims to hold these groups accountable for inciting violence, hatred, and anti-Semitism on U.S. campuses by acting as a campus arm of the Hamas terror group.
How does the script describe the role of the media in reporting civilian casualties in Gaza?
-The script suggests that the media may inadvertently contribute to propaganda by reporting civilian casualty numbers provided by the Gaza Ministry, which is overseen by Hamas.
What is the Israeli Defense Force's (IDF) approach to minimizing civilian casualties during conflict?
-The IDF attempts to apply the principles of distinction and proportionality, aiming to strike only military assets with just enough force to achieve military objectives while trying to minimize civilian casualties.
What is the broader concern regarding the credibility of the Gaza Ministry of Health's reports on casualties?
-There are concerns that the Gaza Ministry of Health's reports are not credible, as they are based on unidentified 'reliable media sources' and have been unable to provide names for more than 10,000 of the reported casualties.
Outlines
๐ Israeli Response to U.S. Ammo Embargo
Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu asserts that Israel will continue to fight against Hamas in Rafah, even if it means going it alone. This follows President Joe Biden's announcement that the U.S. will halt certain ammunition if Israel escalates its attacks deeper into Rafah. Despite the potential embargo, the IDF maintains they have sufficient munitions to complete their mission. The situation is tense as Netanyahu's pledge echoes Israel's historical struggle for independence, highlighting the country's resolve and unity against its enemies.
๐จ Civilian Casualties as Propaganda in Gaza Conflict
The ongoing conflict between Israel and Hamas in Gaza has led to civilian deaths, which some argue are being used as a propaganda tool by Hamas. Analysts discuss how the reporting of civilian casualties is manipulated to influence world opinion. They criticize the Gaza Ministry, overseen by Hamas, for inflating casualty numbers and argue that the global media inadvertently aids in this propaganda by reporting unverified figures. The discussion also touches on the importance of discerning between the narratives presented by a democratic government and those of a terrorist organization.
๐ U.S. Campuses as a Battleground for Hamas Propaganda
A lawsuit is filed against two U.S. groups, National Students for Justice in Palestine and American Muslims for Palestine, for their alleged role in inciting pro-Palestinian, anti-Israel protests on university campuses. The groups are accused of being the campus arm of Hamas, promoting the terrorist group's ideology and justifying their actions. The attorney involved in the lawsuit aims to legally designate these groups as terrorist collaborators to prevent their activities on campuses and seek justice for the victims of Hamas's terror attacks.
๐ค Israel's Legal Battle Against Delegitimization
Israel is not only fighting a physical battle in Gaza but also a legal one against delegitimization and vilification in international law. The state is combating the misuse of international law to condemn its actions in defense of its citizens and the return of its captives. The strategy involves holding accountable not just Hamas, but all those who support and fund them. This is done through legal avenues to change the paradigm and counteract the portrayal of Israel as a pariah state.
๐ก New Life in Israel for a Russian-Ukrainian Family
The story of an immigrant family from Russia, with Jewish heritage, who decided to move to Israel due to the war with Ukraine. Faced with the challenges of starting anew, including language barriers and financial difficulties, the family found support through CBN Israel, made possible by supporters. The assistance has provided them with much-needed relief and a sense of hope for the future, allowing the wife to pursue her medical career in Israel and the husband to find employment, all while ensuring their child's care.
Mindmap
Keywords
๐กJerusalem Dateline
๐กBenjamin Netanyahu
๐กJoe Biden
๐กHamas
๐กRafah
๐กCivilian casualties
๐กPropaganda
๐กIron Dome
๐กHezbollah
๐กAnti-Semitism
๐กNational Students for Justice in Palestine (NSJP)
Highlights
Israeli Minister Netanyahu says Israel will fight with its nails if the U.S. halts certain ammunition if Israel attacks deeper into Rafah
Israeli leaders respond to President Biden's announcement that the U.S. will stop supplying certain ammunition for Israel's operation to defeat Hamas in Rafah
Netanyahu pledges that if Israel has to go alone in its war against Hamas, they would go it alone
IDF Chief spokesman says the military has what it needs to finish the job despite Biden's weapons embargo
IDF Reserve Lieutenant Colonel Elder says Biden's move helps Hamas and the war will be longer as a result
Middle East analyst says the region is watching and remembers the U.S. withdrawal from Afghanistan, perceiving a betrayal of allies
Biden faces criticism in Washington from both Democrats and Republicans for his decision to withhold weapons from Israel
Israel is also looking ahead to the potential next war against Hezbollah, with Defense Minister Yoav Gallant reinforcing troops
Israel downplaying the threat of President Biden, saying they can go it alone in Rafah
Biden says he made it clear that if Israel goes into Rafah, the U.S. will not supply the weapons used to deal with that problem
Analyst John Hagee discusses the impact of the U.S. decision on Israel and the political and military implications
Hagee says the issue will become a key point in the 2024 U.S. presidential election and could affect voter choices
Analysts say civilian deaths in Gaza are being used as a propaganda tool by Hamas to gain international sympathy
Hamas has inflated the number of civilian casualties in Gaza, using the figures as part of their propaganda campaign
Data scientists find the numbers of casualties reported by the Gaza Ministry of Health to be fake and misleading
The Gaza Ministry of Health cannot provide names for more than 10,000 of the people it claims have died
Hamas has rigged the battlefield by embedding itself within the civilian population and using human shields
Lawsuit filed against two U.S. groups, National Students for Justice in Palestine and American Muslims for Palestine, for fueling pro-Palestinian, anti-Israel protests on university campuses
The groups are alleged to be the campus arm of Hamas, promoting the terrorist group's ideology and inciting hatred and violence
Transcripts
.
COMING UP ON JERUSALEM DATELINE
ISRAELI MINISTER NETANYAHU SAYS
ISRAEL WILL FIGHT WITH ITS
NAILS.
IT HAS TO.
AFTER PRESIDENT BIDEN SAYS THE
U.S. WILL HALT CERTAIN
AMMUNITION IF ISRAEL ATTACKS
DEEPER INTO RAFAH.
OUR CIVILIAN DEATHS IN GAZA ARE
BEING USED AS A PROPAGANDA TOOL
SOME SAY YES AND ADVOCACY
GROUPS THAT INSTIGATED PROTEST.
A U.S. UNIVERSITY CAMPUSES TO
USE AS A SECOND BATTLE FRONT BY
HAMAS.
ALL THIS AND MORE COMING UP ON
THIS EDITION OF JERUSALEM
DATELINE.
>> HELLO AND WELCOME TO THIS
EDITION OF JERUSALEM DATELINE
I'M CHRIS MITCHELL.
ISRAELI LEADERS RESPONDED TO
PRESIDENT JOE BIDEN
ANNOUNCEMENT THAT THE U.S. WILL
STOP SUPPLYING CERTAIN
AMMUNITION FOR ISRAEL'S
OPERATION TO DEFEAT HAMAS IN
RAFAH.
IT REPRESENTS A WATERSHED
MOMENT IN ISRAEL'S HISTORY.
ISRAELI PRIME MINISTER BENJAMIN
NETANYAHU HAD ALREADY PROMISED
EARLIER THIS WEEK THAT IF
ISRAEL HAD TO GO ALONE IN ITS
WAR AGAINST HAMAS THEY WOULD GO
IT ALONE.
AFTER PRESIDENT JOE BIDEN SAID
HE WOULD WITHHOLD KEY IF ISRAEL
LAUNCHED A MAJOR OPERATION IN
RAFAH, NETANYAHU REPEATED HIS
PLEDGE ON THE EVE OF THE
INDEPENDENCE DAY.
>> I FEEL MUCH MORE IN THE WAR
OF INDEPENDENCE 76 YEARS AGO WE
WERE FEW AGAINST MANY.
WE HAD NO WEAPONS.
THERE WAS AN ARMS EMBARGO ON
ISRAEL BUT WITH THE GREATNESS
OF SPIRIT, BRAVERY AND UNITY
AMONG US WE WON.
TODAY WE ARE MUCH STRONGER.
WE'RE DETERMINED.
WE'RE UNITED TO DEFEAT OUR
ENEMY AND THOSE WHO SEEK OUR
SOULS.
IF WE HAVE TO STAND ALONE WE
WILL STAND ALONE.
I'VE ALREADY THAT IF WE HAVE TO
WE WILL FIGHT WITH OUR
FINGERNAILS.
BUT HAVE MUCH MORE THAN
FINGERNAILS AND WITH THE SAME
GREATNESS OF SPIRIT WITH GOD'S
HELP WE WILL WIN TOGETHER.
>> DESPITE BIDEN'S WEAPONS
EMBARGO, IDF CHIEF SPOKESMAN
THE MILITARY HAS WHAT IT NEEDS
TO FINISH THE JOB.
>> LET'S UNLEASH A MACHINE.
THE ARMY HAS MUNITIONS, THE
MISSIONS IT HAS PLANNED AND FOR
THE MISSIONS IN RAFAH TOO.
WE HAVE WHAT WE NEED.
I SAY THIS IN THE CONTEXT OF
EVERYTHING THAT HAPPENED WITH
THE UNITED STATES AND IT'S
IMPORTANT TO SAY IT.
>> IDF RESERVE LIEUTENANT
COLONEL ELDER TOLD CBS NEWS.
BIDEN'S MOVE HELPS HAMAS.
>> UNFORTUNATELY THE WAR WILL
BE LONGER BECAUSE HAMAS TOOK
COURAGE FROM THIS DECISION, HE
SAID.
THE US IS AGAINST NOW SO WE CAN
CONTINUE NOT TO ALLOW THEY
RELEASED THE KIDNAPED.
IT MEANS THAT MORE PEOPLE WILL
PROBABLY BE HATED BECAUSE
ISRAEL WILL HAVE TO DO MORE
FORCE IN ORDER TO MAKE HAMAS
AGREE THESE AGREEMENTS.
>> DRAW SAYS MIDDLE EAST IS
WATCHING THE MIDDLE EAST IS NOT
JUST ISRAEL AND HAMAS.
EVERYTHING I REMIND YOU THAT
THE MIDDLE EAST STILL
REMEMBERING WHAT HAPPENED WITH
THE WITHDRAWAL OF THE US
AFGHANISTAN.
IT WAS JUST TWO YEARS AGO AND
THE US IN THEIR OPINION
BETRAYAL THE ALLIES NOW IT'S
THE SAME IT'S THE SAME MESSAGE.
>> BIDEN ALSO FACING CRITICISM
IN WASHINGTON FROM BOTH
DEMOCRATS AND REPUBLICANS WITH
SOME CONSERVATIVES TELLING THE
ADMINISTRATION IT IS AIDING
HAMAS'S LEADERS AND ITS LAST
FOUR BATTALIONS ARE HOLED UP IN
RAFAH.
SO ISRAEL HAS TO DEFEAT HAMAS
IN RAFAH.
TO WIN HAMAS WINS IF IT
SURVIVES IN RAFAH.
AND JOE BIDEN HAS THREATENED TO
WITHHOLD WEAPONS FROM ISRAEL
FOR FIGHTING IN RAFAH.
THEREFORE JOE BIDEN OBJECT
OBJECTIVELY FAVORS A VICTORY
OVER ISRAEL.
>> ISRAEL IS ALSO LOOKING AHEAD
TO WHAT COULD BE THE NEXT WAR
AGAINST HEZBOLLAH AS DEFENSE
MINISTER YOAV GALLANT
REINFORCED TO THE TROOPS.
ISRAEL'S GOALS OF DESTROYING
THE TERRORIST GROUP TELLING
TROOPS THIS COULD BE A HOT
SUMMER.
BUT FOR NOW THE FOCUS IS
FINISHING OFF HAMAS AND RAFAH
AS ISRAELI FORCES TAKING OUT
TERRORISTS AND KEEPING UP THEIR
OFFENSIVE IN GAZA.
>> ISRAEL IS DOWNPLAYING THE
THREAT OF PRESIDENT THREAT
SAYING THEY CAN GO IT ALONE IN
RAFAH.
HERE'S WHAT BIDEN SAID IN HIS
INTERVIEW WITH CNN.
>> I MADE IT CLEAR THAT IF THEY
GO INTO RAFAH THEY HAVEN'T GONE
ON RAFAH YET.
THEY GO INTO RAFA.
I'M NOT SUPPLYING THE WEAPONS
THAT HAVE BEEN USED
HISTORICALLY TO DEAL WITH RAFAH
AND DEAL WITH CITIES TO DEAL
WITH THAT PROBLEM.
WE'RE GOING TO CONTINUE TO MAKE
SURE ISRAEL IS SECURE IN TERMS
OF IRON DOME, THEIR ABILITY TO
RESPOND TO ATTACKS.
I CAME OUT OF THE MIDDLE EAST
RECENTLY.
BUT IT'S IT'S JUST WRONG.
WE'RE NOT GOING TO SUPPLY
WEAPONS AND ARTILLERY SHELLS
USE THAT AVENUE ARTILLERY AS
WELL.
>> YEAH, ARTILLERY SHELLS.
I'M JOINED BY CBSN MIDDLE EAST
ANALYST JOHN HAGEE TO TALK MORE
ABOUT THE IMPACT OF THE U.S. TO
ISRAEL.
JOHN, WHAT IMPACT IS THIS GOING
TO HAVE HERE IN ISRAEL?
WELL, I THINK, CHRIS, THE
IMPORTANT THING TO REMEMBER IS
PRESIDENT BIDEN I THINK IN
BIDEN'S MIND HE REALLY DOES
HAVE AN IRONCLAD RELATIONSHIP
WITH ISRAEL.
HE'S GOT ONE SMALL PROBLEM AND
THAT IS THAT ISRAELIS ELECTED
AND HAVE ELECTED SINCE 2009
BENJAMIN NETANYAHU AND BIDEN
AND HIS ADMINISTRATION HAVE
BEEN CLEAR THEY WANT OUT.
AND SO EACH STEP ALONG THE WAY
AND NOW IT'S COME TO
WITHHOLDING MILITARY AMMUNITION
BOMBS BECAUSE THEY'RE THEY'RE
DOUBLING DOWN ON THIS TO GET
RID OF NETANYAHU.
AND ANYMORE THEY'RE NOT EVEN
MAKING A SECRET IT.
AND SO THAT'S THEIR POLITICAL
TARGET.
BUT THEY STILL HAVE TO DEAL
WITH AN ISRAEL WHOSE THE NATION
IS ESSENTIALLY BEHIND NETANYAHU
IN FINISHING THE JOB IN RAFA.
HE DOESN'T REALLY HAVE MUCH
CHOICE.
HE KNOWS THAT THE COUNTRY HAS
TO ELIMINATE THIS THREAT.
AND SO YOU HAVE THE THE CLASH
OF THE TWO CAPITALS OF
WASHINGTON AND JERUSALEM.
IT'S NOT TOTAL CLASH OF
CAPITALS BECAUSE THE CONGRESS
MANY PEOPLE IN THE UNITED
STATES ARE SIDING WITH ISRAEL
AGAINST, THE BIDEN
ADMINISTRATION.
AND SO WE'RE GOING TO KEEP
HAVING THIS CLASH UNTIL
ONE SIDE OR THE OTHER GIVES IN
IT APPEARS ISRAEL'S READY TO
MAKE THE MOVE AND CONTINUE IT
THROUGH TO THE END RAFAH.
YEAH, AND AS WE SAW TOM COTTON
IN OUR REPORT AND ALSO LINDSEY
GRAHAM HAD A FIERY
CONFRONTATION WITH FLOYD AUSTIN
,DEFENSE SECRETARY AND BOTH
LEADERS IN THE HOUSE AND SENATE
FOR THE REPUBLICANS HAVE
WRITTEN AN OPEN LETTER TO BIDEN
BASICALLY ASKING HIM TO EXPLAIN
AND GIVE A TIMETABLE FOR WHEN
ISRAEL IS GOING TO BE
RESUPPLIED AND IF THEY'RE NOT
GOING TO BE TELL CONGRESS.
AND SO A LOT GOING ON FROM THE
MILITARY SIDE.
CHRIS, I KNOW YOU'VE BEEN IN
TOUCH WITH A COUPLE HIGH PEOPLE
AND WHAT DID WHAT WAS THEIR
REACTION, THE MILITARY SIDE OF
THINGS?
>> WELL, I WAS TALKING TO
YAAKOV AHMED.
HE'S RETIRED GENERAL BUT HE'S A
FORMER HEAD OF THE IDF MILITARY
INTELLIGENCE.
HE WAS SAYING IT'S NOT JUST
RAFAH BUT THE ACTUALLY THE MORE
IMPORTANT IS WHAT'S GOING ON IN
THE NORTH.
HE BELIEVES THEY HAVE ENOUGH
MUSICIANS TO DEAL WITH THE
OPERATION IN RAFAH.
BUT THE QUESTION IS DO THEY
HAVE ENOUGH MUNITIONS TO DEAL
WITH A FAR GREATER ENEMY
HEZBOLLAH ON THE NORTH AND AND
ALSO CONRICUS WAS TELLING ME
THAT IT REALLY HAS A CHILLING
EFFECT ON IDF ITS ITS MOVEMENTS
AND ITS SUPPLIES.
BUT LONGER, MEDIUM AND LONGER
TERM IS WILL ISRAEL BE ABLE TO
DEPEND ON THE UNITED STATES AND
WILL STRATEGICALLY THEY START
TO LOOK TO OTHER COUNTRIES
OTHER SOURCES OF WEAPONS AND
SUPPLIES THAT THEY CAN ON?
>> AND IT'S INTERESTING, CHRIS,
BECAUSE BOTH BENJAMIN NETANYAHU
AND SOME ANALYSTS ON THE
CONSERVATIVE SIDE HAVE BEEN
SAYING FOR YEARS ISRAEL TO WEAN
ITSELF FROM THE TOTAL
DEPENDANCE ON THE UNITED
STATES.
SO IT'S NOT LIKE THEY'RE
LOOKING FOR A HANDOUT EVERY
SINGLE TIME THEY'RE LOOKING FOR
A WAY TO BUILD THEMSELVES UP SO
THEY DON'T HAVE TO DEPEND ON A
THAT'S RUN AFOUL.
>> YEAH, WE LOOKED AT THE
POLITICAL ISSUE THE MILITARY
TALK ABOUT THE SPIRITUAL ISSUE.
JUST ABOUT A MINUTE LEFT.
WHAT DOES THIS MEAN SPIRITUALLY
FOR THE UNITED STATES?
WELL, I THINK I THINK THAT
WHAT'S HAPPENED NOW IS ISRAEL
IS SQUARELY IN THE HEART OF THE
2024 PRESIDENTIAL ELECTION AND
SO ISN'T GOING TO GET ANY
NEATER AND CLEANER FOR
AMERICANS.
THIS IS GOING TO BECOME AN
ISSUE ON WHICH PEOPLE VOTE.
PEOPLE COME TO THE POLLS AND
NOW BIDEN FINDS HIMSELF ALIGNED
WITH THE SQUAD AND WITH NOW
CHUCK SCHUMER AS WELL ALL ON
THE SIDE THAT IS MUCH
VEHEMENTLY ANTI-ISRAEL AND I
KNOW HOW THEY'RE GOING TO PULL
THEMSELVES BACK FROM THAT.
BUT THE BIDEN CAMPAIGN NEEDS TO
WALK A FINE LINE BECAUSE.
THEY STILL DEPEND ON JEWISH
DONORS, JEWISH FOOT SOLDIERS.
THERE'S THE JEWISH PEOPLE IN
AMERICA ARE GETTING MORE AND
MORE CONCERNED ABOUT THE RANK
ANTISEMITISM IN ALL THESE
PROTESTS AND EVERYTHING.
SO IT'S IT'S NOT GOING TO BE
COOL CALM SUMMER.
YEAH, PROBABLY IN IN A GREAT
INCENTIVE FOR MANY CHRISTIANS
AROUND THE WORLD TO BE PRAYING.
>> ABSOLUTELY.
>> THANK YOU, JOHN.
THANKS.
COMING UP, OUR CIVILIAN DEATH
TOLLS IN GAZA ARE BEING USED AS
A PROPAGANDA TOOL.
CALL THE NUMBER ON YOUR SCREEN
TODAY.
>> IT'S A FREE CALL.
>> CIVILIANS CAUGHT IN THE
CROSSFIRE DURING BATTLE ARE
OFTEN DESCRIBED AS A
CONSEQUENCE OF WAR.
WHILE WE HAVE SEEN THIS DURING
THE WAR IN GAZA BETWEEN ISRAEL
AND HAMAS, SOME ANALYSTS SAY
REPORTING CIVILIAN DEATHS IN
THIS CONFLICT IS BEING USED AS
A PROPAGANDA TOOL.
>> TAKE A LOOK.
TRAGICALLY, PALESTINIANS HAVE
DIED IN THE MORE THAN 200 DAY
WAR.
>> HAMAS BEGAN ON OCTOBER 7TH.
>> OF COURSE WE HAVE TO START
BY SAYING THAT EVERY HUMAN
BEING WHOSE LIFE IS LOST IS A
TERRIBLE TRAGEDY AND WE'RE ALL
CREATED THE IMAGE OF GOD.
>> GIL HOFFMAN, DIRECTOR OF
HONEST REPORTING, A MEDIA GROUP
RECENTLY PUBLISHED AN
INVESTIGATIVE REPORT ON HOW
HAMAS HAS INFLATED THE NUMBER
OF CIVILIAN CASUALTIES IN GAZA.
>> TERRORISTS ARE NOT
JOURNALISTS.
THEY'RE NOT PEOPLE WHO SHOULD
BE TRUSTED AND THERE ARE
NUMBERS THAT THEY'RE PUTTING
OUT ARE PART OF THEIR
PROPAGANDA GAME TO TRY TO WIN
THE WORLD'S.
>> AND IT'S UNFORTUNATELY
WORKING.
THE GAZA MINISTRY OVERSEEN BY
HAMAS PUBLISHES THOSE NUMBERS.
CURRENTLY ITS DEATH TOLL
REPORTING STANDS AT MORE THAN
34,000.
HOFFMAN SAYS THOSE NUMBERS HAVE
BEEN PARROTED THROUGHOUT THE
WAR BY WORLD LEADERS INCLUDING
PRESIDENT BIDEN AND GLOBAL
MEDIA LIKE THE ASSOCIATED
PRESS.
>> YOU KNOW THE WORLD MEDIA
THEY TRY TO BE BALANCED.
SO ISRAEL SAYS THIS ISRAEL SAYS
BASED ON THE STUDIES TAKEN BY
THE TOP EXPERTS IN URBAN
WARFARE, ISRAEL SET A GOLD
STANDARD PREVENTING THE LOSS OF
CIVILIAN LIFE.
SO THEY PUT OUT OUR SIDE AND
THEN THE OTHER SIDE THEY PUT IT
WELL, HAMAS SAYS THAT THAT
ISRAEL IS COMMITTING GENOCIDE.
IT DOESN'T WORK THAT WAY.
YOU DON'T TRUST A DEMOCRATIC
GOVERNMENT THAT'S THE TOP ALLY
OF THE UNITED STATES THE SAME
WAY YOU TRUST A TERROR
ORGANIZATION.
PROFESSOR OF STATISTICS ABRAHAM
WEINER FROM THE WHARTON SCHOOL
,THE UNIVERSITY OF
PENNSYLVANIA WROTE HOW THE GAZA
MINISTRY HEALTH FAKES CASUALTY
NUMBERS.
THE DATA SCIENTISTS STUDIED
HAMAS STATISTICS FROM THE WAR'S
BEGINNING USING A GRAPH AND
HERE'S THE PROBLEM WITH THIS
DATA.
THE NUMBERS NOT REAL THAT MUCH
IS OBVIOUS TO ANYONE WHO
UNDERSTANDS HOW NATURALLY
OCCURRING NUMBERS WORK.
THE CASUALTIES ARE NOT
OVERWHELMINGLY WOMEN AND
CHILDREN AND THE MAJORITY MAY
BE FIGHTERS.
>> THIS DATA ALSO DOES NOT
INCLUDE THE ESTIMATED THOUSAND
HAMAS FIGHTERS KILLED IN COMBAT
OR PALESTINIAN KILLED BY
MISFIRED ROCKETS ESTIMATED BY
SOME TO BE LESS THAN A
THOUSAND.
THE FOUNDATION FOR THE DEFENSE
OF DEMOCRACIES ALSO REPORTED
THIS MONTH THAT THE GAZA HEALTH
MINISTRY CANNOT NAMES FOR MORE
THAN 10,000 IT SAYS HAVE DIED.
>> WE PREVIOUSLY KNEW THEY HAD
INCOMPLETE RECORDS FOR THIS SET
OF PEOPLE OF AT LEAST 10,000.
BUT FROM BOTH WALL STREET
JOURNAL REPORTING AND FROM AN
ITEM ON THE MINISTRY'S OWN
SOCIAL MEDIA FEED THEY'VE
INDICATED THEY DON'T HAVE NAMES
SO THEY CAN'T REALLY IDENTIFY
THESE INDIVIDUALS.
IT'S REALLY ONE MORE DROP IN A
BUCKET ON A BROADER CREDIBILITY
ISSUE.
AS THE NIC ALSO NOTED, THE GAZA
MINISTRY OF HEALTH GOT ITS
INFORMATION UNIDENTIFIED QUOTE
RELIABLE MEDIA SOURCES.
>> AT FIRST THAT WAS ONLY ABOUT
22% BUT THEN IT BECAME AN
INCREASING PERCENTAGE OVER
TIME.
SO WE GOT TO A POINT WHERE
NEARLY 45% OF THE ALLEGED
DECEASED WERE BASED ON THESE
MEDIA REPORTS.
>> IT'S NOT THE ONLY EXAMPLE
SUSPECTED DEATH TOLLS NEAR THE
BEGINNING OF THE WAR THE MEDIA
REPORTED ISRAEL KILLED 500 AT
THE AL AHLI HOSPITAL.
LATER IT WAS DISCOVERED A
MISFIRED ROCKET BY ISLAMIC
KILLED FAR LESS CIVILIANS.
IN THE NEXT DOOR PARKING LOT,
ABU SCHLUPP, THE SPOKESPERSON
FOR ISLAMIC ADMITTED IT WAS A
LIE.
>> YES.
IN ORDER TO RAISE THIS STORY
THE ORGANIZATION MADE SEVERAL
MOVES IT FABRICATED A STORY
THAT THE ROCKET BELONGED TO THE
OCCUPATION.
AND THE TARGET WAS A HOSPITAL
BUILDING.
THEY RELIED SOME OF THE STORIES
SO THE INTERNATIONAL PRESS AND
AFTER THAT THEY PUBLISHED IT TO
THE WHOLE WORLD.
YES.
FIRST OF ALL, I ACKNOWLEDGE
THAT SADLY THERE ARE CIVILIANS
THAT HAVE BEEN KILLED IN
BATTLE.
SADLY AND THAT IS NOT THE
INTENTION OF THE IDF.
I THINK THE IDF HAS GONE TO
LENGTHS IN ORDER TO MINIMIZE
THE AMOUNT OF NONCOMBATANTS
THAT HAVE BEEN AFFECTED BY THIS
WAR.
AND I AS A HUMAN BEING I REGRET
ANY CIVILIAN WHO LOSES HIS LIFE
AS A PART OF A FIGHT THAT THEY
DIDN'T START.
>> FORMER IDF SPOKESMAN
JONATHAN CONRICUS NOW WITH THE
SAYS HAMAS HAS RIGGED THE
BATTLEFIELD.
>> WE REMEMBER WHO EMBEDS
HIMSELF WITHIN THE CIVILIAN
POPULATION AND ABUSES
EVERYTHING THAT SUPPOSED TO BE
PROTECTED UNDER INTERNATIONAL
LAW.
HOSPITALS, SCHOOLS, MOSQUES,
U.N. FACILITIES, INFIRMARIES
AND EVERYTHING ELSE.
THE ORGANIZATIONS THAT DOES
THAT IS HAMAS.
AND HAVE HAMAS CHOSEN FIGHT OUT
IN THE OPEN AND NOT TO USE
CIVILIANS HUMAN SHIELDS NOT TO
TUNNEL UNDERNEATH CIVILIAN
NEIGHBORHOODS AND NOT TO HIDE
BEHIND CIVILIAN THEN OF COURSE
THERE WOULDN'T BE ANY CIVILIAN
CASUALTIES DESPITE THAT HAMAS
USING HUMAN SHIELDS ACCORDING
TO MILITARY HISTORIAN JOHN
SPENCER.
THE RATIO OF CIVILIAN DEATHS TO
COMBATANTS IS NEAR HISTORIC
LOWS FOR URBAN WARFARE.
>> THE FACT THAT ARE CIVILIAN
CASUALTIES IS AN UNFORTUNATE
RESULT OF HAMAS'S STRATEGY AND
TACTICS.
AND IDF IS STILL APPLYING THE
AND THE PRINCIPLES OF
DISTINCTION AND
PROPORTIONALITY.
IT TRIES TO STRIKE ONLY THE
MILITARY ASSETS AND IT TRIES TO
STRIKE WITH JUST ENOUGH FORCE
IN ORDER TO GET THE MILITARY
JOB DONE.
>> EVEN SO HOFFMAN SAYS
REGRETTABLY THE CHARGE OF
GENOCIDE HAS SPREAD WORLDWIDE
WIDE INTO THE STREETS AND
ACROSS SOCIAL MEDIA THAT
ACCUSATION FOR A WAR THAT
STARTED WITH THE HAMAS SENDING
PEOPLE INTO ISRAEL TO KILL AS
MANY JEWS AS THEY COULD AND
ISRAEL DOING EVERYTHING
POSSIBLE TO MINIMIZE CIVILIAN
DEATHS AND UNFORTUNATELY THAT
ACCUSATION IS STILL OUT THERE
AND JUST ANTI-SEMITIC TO
ACCUSED ISRAEL OF THAT.
THE FACTS ARE JUST SO OBVIOUS
TO BE THE OPPOSITE.
UP NEXT SUING ADVOCACY GROUPS
THAT HAVE INSTIGATED PROTEST ON
ABC.COM TO GET THE APP TODAY.
>> A LAWSUIT IS BEING FILED
AGAINST TWO US GROUPS WHICH
FOLLOW HAMAS'S IDEOLOGY THAT
ARE FUELING THE PRO-PALESTINIAN
ANTI-ISRAEL PROTESTS ON US
UNIVERSITY CAMPUSES.
I SPOKE WITH ATTORNEY ARSON
ABOUT HOW THESE GROUPS ARE
BEHIND MUCH OF THE VIOLENCE
SEEING.
>> ARSON.
THANKS FOR BEING WITH US.
YOU'RE PART OF A LEGAL BATTLE
RIGHT NOW IN THE US AND YOU
FILE LAWSUIT IN THE US.
TELL US ABOUT THE LAWSUIT.
>> SURE.
THE LAWSUIT HAS BEEN FILED
AGAINST THE GROUP NATIONAL
STUDENTS FOR JUSTICE IN
PALESTINE AND AMERICAN MUSLIMS
FOR PALESTINE.
NOW THESE GROUPS ARE THE
PRIMARY DRIVERS OF WHAT WE'RE
SEEING HAPPENING ACROSS
CAMPUSES IN THE UNITED STATES
HAVE EFFECTIVELY BECOME A
SECOND FRONT FOR HAMAS SINCE
OCTOBER SEVEN.
AND THESE GROUPS THEY'RE NOT
MERE ADVOCACY ORGANIZATIONS BUT
THEY ARE THE CAMPUS ARM OF THE
HAMAS TERROR GROUP.
ARE ACTING AND SERVING IN
COLLABORATION AND COORDINATION
WITH HAMAS AS PROPAGANDISTS AND
COLLABORATORS ON CAMPUS TO AND
PROMOTE THE HAMAS EXTREMIST
IDEOLOGY TO JUSTIFY THEIR
ACTIONS AND TO INCITE THE
VITRIOL, HATRED AND THE
VIOLENCE THAT WE'RE SEEING ON
CAMPUSES TODAY.
>> SO THEY'RE PART OF THE FUEL
OF WHAT'S ACTUALLY HAPPENING
RIGHT NOW ON COLLEGE CAMPUSES.
ABSOLUTELY.
THEY ARE NOT ONLY PART OF THE
FUEL, THEY ARE THE ONES POURING
FUEL ON THE FIRE OF WHAT WE'RE
SEEING ON CAMPUSES ACROSS
AMERICA TODAY ON OCTOBER 7TH
WHEN THE MASSACRE HAPPENED,
HAMAS CALLED TO MOBILIZE INTO
ACTION.
THE VERY NEXT DAY SJP AND THE
NATIONAL CHAPTERS ACROSS
AMERICA.
AND SO THAT CALL BY CREATED
TOOLKIT OR A MANIFESTO ECHOING
THE VERY TERMINOLOGY, THE VERY
DIRECTIVE THAT WERE ISSUED BY
HAMAS ACROSS CAMPUSES IN THE
UNITED STATES.
AND THAT HAS LED NOT ONLY TO
THE VIOLENCE INCITEMENT AND
HATRED THAT WE'RE SEEING
AGAINST JEWISH STUDENTS ON
CAMPUSES BUT IMPORTANTLY IT HAS
CREATED THE SPACE AND THE
NARRATIVE NECESSARY FOR HAMAS
TO CONTINUE CARRYING OUT THE
ACTS OF TERROR THEY ARE DOING
HERE AGAINST ISRAELIS AND ALSO
IN THE HOLDING OF HOSTAGES AND
CAPTIVES IN GAZA, INCLUDING
ALSO AMERICAN NATIONALS.
>> SO YOU'RE SAYING THE DAY
AFTER OCTOBER 7TH, OCTOBER
EIGHT HAMAS WORKED TOGETHER
THESE GROUPS?
CORRECT.
HAMAS ISSUED A CALL TO ACTION
AND THE VERY NEXT DAY SJP AND
THEIR AFFILIATES THROUGHOUT THE
UNITED STATES THEY ANSWERED
THAT CALL THAT ANSWERED THAT
DIRECTIVE.
THEY CREATED A TOOLKIT A
MANIFESTO FOR THEIR CHAPTERS
ACROSS THE UNITED STATES
ECHOING THE LANGUAGE THE
TERMINOLOGY, THE INSTRUCTIONS
BY THE HAMAS TERROR GROUP AND
PROPAGATED THAT ACROSS
CAMPUSES.
>> AND YOU ALSO HAVE PEOPLE
FROM THAT WERE DAMAGED ON
OCTOBER 7TH AS PART OF THE
PLAINTIFFS IS THAT CORRECT.
THERE ARE NINE PLAINTIFFS
INCLUDING AMERICANS AND
ISRAELIS AS WELL AND THESE
PLAINTIFFS INCLUDE VICTIMS OF
SURVIVORS OF THE ANOTHER
MASSACRE THAT THOSE THAT HAVE
BEEN DISPLACED.
AND THEY ALSO INCLUDE FAMILY
MEMBERS, THOSE THAT HAVE BEEN
MASSACRED BY HAMAS.
WHAT IMPACT DO YOU HOPE THIS
LAWSUIT?
>> QUITE FRANKLY, WE WANT TO
SHUT DOWN SJP.
SJP IS PRIMARY AIM OF HAMAS ON
CAMPUSES ACROSS THE UNITED
STATES.
THEY THE ONES FOMENTING THE
HATRED, THE ANTI-SEMITISM, THE
HARASSMENT JEWISH STUDENTS.
WE NEED TO SHUT THEM DOWN AND
WE CAN DO THAT LEGALLY BY
BRANDING THEM AS A TERRORIST
ORGANIZATION, AS A COLLABORATOR
OF THE HAMAS TERROR GROUP AND
MAKING SURE ONCE AND FOR THEY
CANNOT BE ACTIVE ON CAMPUS.
AND IN ADDITION TO THAT ALSO,
PROVIDING SOME SEMBLANCE OF
JUSTICE TO THE VICTIMS OF THE
TERROR ATTACKS WHO HAVE BEEN
DEEPLY AFFECTED BY ACTIONS OF
SJP AND ON CAMPUSES IN THE US.
>> ISRAEL IS FIGHTING A BATTLE
ON A NUMBER OF FRONTS IN THE
GAZA STRIP AND HEZBOLLAH, THE
HOUTHIES AND IRAN ITSELF.
YOU'RE IN THE LAW OF LEGAL
BATTLE.
WHAT IS THAT LIKE AND WHY IS IT
SO IMPORTANT?
YOU KNOW ISRAEL AS YOU SAID,
WE'RE FIGHTING ON MULTIPLE
BATTLEFRONTS ON THE GROUND IN
GAZA BUT ALSO FIGHTING IN THE
LEGAL ARENA.
AND TODAY WHAT WE'RE SEEING IS
THAT THE STATE OF ISRAEL IS
BEING DEMONIZED AND VILIFIED
AND DELEGITIMIZED AND PAINTED
AS A PARIAH.
WHERE WE'RE SEEING THE
INTERNATIONAL LAW NOT ONLY
BEING MISUSED BUT BEING TURNED
INTO AN ACT OF LAWFARE AGAINST
US FOR THE SIMPLE ACT OF
DEFENDING OUR CITIZENS TRYING
TO BRING BACK OUR CAPTIVES.
WE NEED TO CHANGE THIS PARADIGM
AND WE NEED TO HOLD NOT ONLY
THE PERPETRATORS HAMAS
ACCOUNTABLE BUT ALL THOSE THAT
ENABLE SUPPORT A BIT AND FUND
THEM AND THAT IS HOW WE'RE
USING THE LAW TO GO AFTER ALL
THOSE WHO SUPPORTING HAMAS AND
WILL HOLD THEM ACCOUNTABLE AND
WE WILL DO THAT THROUGH THE
COURTS.
>> YEAH, IT'S AN ATROCITY.
GREAT TO BE WITH YOU.
>> THANK YOU.
STILL AHEAD A YOUNG FAMILY
FINDS A NEW LIFE IN ISRAEL WITH
HELP AND SUPPORT FROM
>> GO TO CBN ABC.COM TO GET THE
APP TODAY IN CHAPTER 19 OF THE
BOOK OF LEVITICUS IT TALKS
ABOUT CARING FOR THE STRANGER
AMONG US, EVEN LOVING THEM LIKE
OURSELVES.
AND THANKS TO THE HELP OF
CBN PARTNERS IMMIGRANT FAMILIES
,THE ONE IN OUR NEXT STORY ARE
FINDING THEIR WAY IN THEIR NEW
HOME.
>> ISRAEL ALIX WAS A POLICE
OFFICER IN RUSSIA BEFORE.
THE WAR WITH UKRAINE BEGAN
BECAUSE OF HIS JEWISH HERITAGE
HE DECIDED TO MOVE TO ISRAEL
WITH HIS WIFE AND THEIR TODDLER
.
WE NEVER ANTICIPATED THAT THE
SITUATION IN RUSSIA WOULD
BECOME WHAT IT IS TODAY.
WE WERE VERY STRESSED AND
CONCERNED THAT ALEX MIGHT BE
CONSCRIPTED AND SENT WAR.
>> I DID NOT SEE A FUTURE FOR
MYSELF AND MY FAMILY IN RUSSIA.
I WANT MY CHILDREN TO GROW UP
WITH OPPORTUNITIES FOR
EDUCATION WITH A BRIGHTER AND
HAPPIER FUTURE.
>> STARTING A NEW LIFE IN
ISRAEL PRESENTED MANY
CHALLENGES FOR THE COUPLE.
MONEY TIGHT AND ALEX AND GINIA
SCRAMBLED TO FIND OPPORTUNITIES
.
>> AFTER WE MANAGED TO ESCAPE
RUSSIA AND COME TO ISRAEL
THINGS WERE VERY TOUGH.
EVERYTHING WAS NEW TO US.
WE DIDN'T KNOW THE LANGUAGE.
WE WERE DESPERATE AT FIRST BUT
WE WERE REALLY SURPRISED BY HOW
AMAZING HOW KIND AND HELPFUL
PEOPLE ARE HERE.
WE HAD NOTHING.
BUYING FURNITURE AND HOUSEHOLD
APPLIANCES WAS NOT POSSIBLE FOR
US.
WE BARELY HAD ENOUGH MONEY FOR
BASIC NEEDS.
>> THEN ONE DAY A UKRAINIAN
REFUGEE HELPED ALEX WHILE AT
THE GROCERY STORE.
THEIR FRIENDSHIP GREW AND HE
TOLD ALEX ABOUT CBN ISRAEL ALEX
AND HIS FAMILY GOT CONNECTED TO
CBN ISRAEL AND THANKS
SUPPORTERS LIKE YOU.
WE MADE IT POSSIBLE FOR ALEX
AND HIS FAMILY TO RECEIVE HELP
.
>> THEY NEEDED THE HELP
CBN PROVIDED IS TRULY GREAT FOR
OUR FAMILY BECAUSE WE ARE IN A
VERY TOUGH POSITION.
MY WIFE IS A DOCTOR.
SHE IS LEARNING HEBREW AND
DOING COURSES THAT WILL ALLOW
HER TO WORK IN THE FUTURE.
WE COULDN'T TO SEND OUR SON TO
DAYCARE SO I HAVE TO BE HIM
WHILE MY WIFE IS STUDYING AND
THEN I GO WORK IN THE EVENINGS.
>> BECAUSE OF YOUR KIND SUPPORT
CBN ISRAEL HELPED ALEX'S FAMILY
TO GET AHEAD.
NOW THEY FEEL LIKE THERE'S HOPE
FOR THE FUTURE.
>> THE FEAR GONE NOW THAT WE
KNOW THAT WE ARE NOT ALONE.
WE'RE VERY THANKFUL YOUR
SUPPORT IS INVALUABLE.
THANK SO MUCH.
>> YOUR ORGANIZATION HAS BEEN A
GREAT HELP.
THANK YOU.
WELL, THAT'S ALL FOR THIS
EDITION OF JERUSALEM DATELINE.
FOR JOINING US.
REMEMBER YOU CAN FOLLOW US ON
SOCIAL MEDIA AND YOU CAN ACCESS
CBN CONTENT THROUGH OUR
CBN NEWS AND OTHER CBN APPS.
AND PLEASE CONTINUE TO PRAY FOR
ISRAEL AT CRITICAL MOMENT AND
HERE ARE A FEW HOSTAGES TO PRAY
BY NAME.
OLMERT EVENT KURT.
OLMERT NEUTRA ABRAHAM MONDA
AGHION BERGER AND ALEXANDER
LOVE ENOUGH.
I'M CHRIS MITCHELL.
WE'LL SEE YOU NEXT TIME ON
5.0 / 5 (0 votes)
Nightly News Full Broadcast - April 29
ABC World News Tonight Full Broadcast - April 28, 2024
Piers Morgan vs Ben Shapiro | On Israel-Hamas, Candace Owens And More
โThe Fiveโ reacts to โchillingโ chants from anti-Israel protesters in Michigan
IDF: Iran launches drones toward Israel
Israel Prepares for Retaliation from Iran | CBN NewsWatch - April 4, 2024