그림체 도둑질당한 작가들이 내 그림 지키려 나선 이유 / 스브스뉴스
TLDRThe video script discusses the controversy surrounding the use of AI-generated art in popular webtoons, specifically addressing concerns about the Nobel AI's collection of learning data without permission and potential copyright infringement. It highlights the public's mixed reactions and the challenges in legally protecting artists' works in the face of AI advancements. The script also introduces 'Illuminarty,' a program designed to detect AI-generated images, as a potential solution to curb misuse and protect artistic integrity.
Takeaways
- 🔍 An investigation revealed suspicions that an AI-generated drawing was used in a popular webtoon, sparking controversy.
- 🎨 The artist's usual style differs significantly from the controversial painting, leading to doubts about its authenticity.
- 🔄 The artist replaced the suspected AI-generated cut with another painting, which only intensified the suspicions due to similarities.
- 💭 Public concern over AI use in webtoons primarily revolves around the issue of learning data and potential copyright infringement.
- 🚫 Nobel AI faced criticism for previously collecting learning data without permission, leading to a backlash against its use in commercial works.
- 📈 The development of generative AI requires vast amounts of data, often collected automatically, which can include unauthorized use of copyrighted material.
- 🤖 There are legal grey areas surrounding AI and copyright, as generative AI often falls into the realm of ideas rather than expression.
- 🛑 Copyright infringement becomes a concern when AI-generated works are too similar to existing works, but there are limits to claiming infringement.
- 💡 'Illuminarty' is a program being developed to determine the likelihood of an image being AI-generated, aiming to bring order to the market.
- 🌐 The rapid application of generative AI in various industries calls for urgent discussions on relevant laws and measures to prevent copyright misuse.
Q & A
What is the main controversy surrounding the use of AI in webtoons as mentioned in the transcript?
-The main controversy is the suspicion that an AI-generated drawing was used in a popular webtoon, which raises concerns about copyright infringement and the ethical use of AI in creative works.
How did subscribers react to the change in the artist's painting style?
-Subscribers who enjoyed watching the webtoon immediately felt the difference in the painting style and raised suspicions that the cut was similar to an image generated by Nobel AI, leading to concerns about the use of AI in the artwork.
What is the role of learning data in the development of generative AI?
-Learning data is crucial for improving the accuracy of generative AI. Large amounts of data are collected through automation technology to train the AI, but this process can lead to the use of copyrighted works without permission, raising ethical and legal issues.
Why was Nobel AI criticized in the past?
-Nobel AI was criticized for collecting learning data without permission, which led to concerns about copyright infringement as the images generated by the AI were seen as potentially violating the rights of numerous artists.
What is the legal stance on using learning data without permission?
-In principle, obtaining the consent of the copyright holder is required. However, due to the intensifying competition in AI development, there are exemptions for using existing works in the AI development process, but this can be a complex area with potential for infringement.
How can generative AI potentially infringe on copyrights?
-Generative AI can infringe on copyrights if the final product is substantially similar to an existing work. While AI can operate in the idea space rather than the expression space, if the generated work is too similar to the original, it may cross the line into copyright infringement.
What challenges do writers face with the rise of AI in the creative industry?
-Writers face challenges such as the potential for their work to be used as learning data without consent, the difficulty in proving copyright infringement due to the nature of AI-generated works, and the need for legal protections in the rapidly evolving landscape of AI and creativity.
What is 'Illuminarty' and how does it help in the context of AI-generated images?
-'Illuminarty' is a program designed to determine whether an image is AI-generated by estimating the probability of its AI origin. This tool aims to help form a correct market order and reduce the misuse of technology that can damage the value of art.
How are artists and writers responding to the threat of AI learning their style?
-Some artists and writers are expressing their concerns on social media and taking measures to protect their work. They are also interested in tools like 'Illuminarty' that can help identify AI-generated images, showing a desire for a culture of correct technology usage.
What is the broader impact of generative AI on industries and its rapid application?
-Generative AI is impacting industries by introducing new methods of content creation and value generation. Its rapid application is prompting discussions on the need for legal frameworks and protective measures to address copyright concerns and ensure fair use of technology.
What is the call to action for addressing the issues raised by the use of AI in creative works?
-The call to action is for relevant laws to be discussed and established more quickly to address the issues of copyright infringement and to develop devices or systems that can help reduce reckless infringement, thereby supporting creators during the transition period.
Outlines
🖌️ AI in Art: Controversies and Copyright Concerns
This paragraph discusses the controversy surrounding the use of AI-generated art in popular webtoons. It highlights suspicions that a particular webtoon series may have used a drawing created by an AI called Nobel AI, which has been criticized for collecting learning data without permission, potentially infringing on copyright. The paragraph delves into the broader issue of generative AI and its impact on the art industry, including the challenges in determining copyright infringement due to the use of learning data and the potential for secondary infringement by indiscriminate use of generative AI. It also touches on the need for legal protections for artists and the development of tools, such as 'Illuminarty', to identify AI-generated images and promote the correct use of technology in the art market.
🤖 Rapid AI Integration and the Need for Legal Frameworks
The second paragraph focuses on the rapid application of generative AI in various industries and the urgent need for the development and implementation of relevant laws to address copyright concerns. It discusses the emergence of AI-generated art and the challenges faced by artists and writers in protecting their work from unauthorized use. The paragraph emphasizes the importance of creating a culture of correct technology usage and the potential for tools like 'Illuminarty' to reduce cases of art value damage due to misuse of technology. It concludes with a call for faster legal discussions to mitigate reckless copyright infringement and support authors during the transition period, recommending viewers to watch a related video for further insights.
Mindmap
Keywords
💡AI-generated art
💡Copyright infringement
💡Learning data
💡Webtoon
💡Nobel AI
💡Artificial intelligence development
💡Moral concerns
💡Illustrator's rights
💡Illuminarty
💡Generative AI
💡Transition period
Highlights
A popular webtoon series has sparked controversy due to suspicions of using AI-generated art.
The artist replaced the suspected AI-generated cut with another painting, which only increased suspicions.
The issue of AI learning data without permission is a significant concern in the art community.
Nobel AI has faced criticism for collecting data without permission and potential copyright infringement.
Generative AI technology requires large amounts of data, which often includes unpermitted use of artists' works.
The legality of using AI-generated art is complex, with challenges in determining the ownership of data used for learning.
There is a growing market for AI-generated illustrations, with some creators monetizing these services on talent donation platforms.
Illuminarty is a program developed to determine the likelihood of an image being AI-generated, aiming to bring order to the market.
The development of AI technology is outpacing the establishment of legal frameworks, leading to a transition period with potential copyright infringement.
The application of generative AI is rapidly expanding into various industries, raising discussions about its impact.
Artists and writers are seeking legal protection against the misuse of AI in the creation and distribution of their works.
The distinction between idea and expression in copyright law becomes模糊 when dealing with AI-generated content.
If AI-generated images are too similar to existing works, it may constitute copyright infringement.
The exclusive right of artists over their work may limit the freedom of expression if every individual work is considered an expression.
The community is actively discussing ways to prevent copyright infringement by AI, including the development of tools like Illuminarty.
The misuse of AI technology can damage the value of art and lead to financial loss for creators.
There is a call for faster discussion and establishment of relevant laws to address the issues surrounding AI and copyright.
The video recommends further watching for more insights into the issue of AI in art and its implications.