“How DARE You Call Me A Racist!” Piers Morgan vs Cornel West vs Cenk Uygur

Piers Morgan Uncensored
1 May 202444:57

Summary

TLDRThe transcript captures a heated debate on the protests at Columbia University and other campuses, focusing on the Israeli-Palestinian conflict. The discussion involves accusations of bias, with participants arguing about the portrayal of the situation in Gaza and the actions of protesters on campus. The conversation touches on issues of free speech, the role of the media, and the responsibility of universities in addressing student concerns. Tensions rise as the participants challenge each other's perspectives, with allegations of racism and propaganda being thrown around. The debate concludes with a commitment to continue seeking solutions for the conflict and a plea for understanding and empathy towards all parties involved.

Takeaways

  • 🗣️ The debate revolves around protests at Columbia University and the broader implications of the Israeli-Palestinian conflict on campuses.
  • 🏛️ There are allegations of vandalism and harassment at Columbia's Hamilton Hall, with claims that the protesters were violent and disruptive.
  • 🚨 Reports suggest that police have moved to eject students from Hamilton Hall, highlighting a clash between law enforcement and student protesters.
  • 🤔 The conversation brings up the question of where the line is drawn between free speech and unacceptable behavior during protests.
  • 📢 Claims that some protesters are using anti-Semitic rhetoric and symbols, leading to accusations of promoting hate speech.
  • 🤷‍♂️ There is disagreement over whether the actions of the protesters constitute terrorism or are legitimate acts of resistance against perceived oppression.
  • 👮‍♂️ The role of the police and university administration in handling the protests is questioned, with some arguing their response is heavy-handed.
  • 📈 The discussion touches on the issue of double standards, with references to how different groups and causes are treated within the context of protests and free speech.
  • 🌎 The conversation also expands to include the global perspective on the Israeli-Palestinian conflict and the impact of this on the protests.
  • 🚫 There are calls for condemnation of violence on all sides, with some accusing the media and others of being biased in their coverage and responses to the protests.
  • 📚 The importance of academic freedom and the role of universities in fostering open debate are highlighted, with concerns expressed over potential suppression of viewpoints.

Q & A

  • What is the main issue being discussed in the transcript?

    -The main issue discussed is the protests at Columbia University and other campuses in support of Gaza, the reactions to these protests, and the broader implications regarding free speech, Israeli-Palestinian conflict, and accusations of anti-Semitism.

  • Why is there a debate about free speech in this context?

    -The debate about free speech arises because some argue that the protests and chants, such as 'from the river to the sea,' could be seen as promoting violence or anti-Semitic sentiments, while others claim they are expressions of political opinion protected under the First Amendment.

  • What does the term 'intifada' mean in Arabic?

    -The term 'intifada' in Arabic means shaking off, and it is used in the context of uprisings or resistance against oppression, not exclusively related to the Palestinian struggle.

  • What accusations are being made against the protesters at Columbia University?

    -Accusations against the protesters include vandalism, trespassing, harassment of Jewish students and faculty, and potentially holding people against their will after breaking into a building.

  • What is the counter-argument made by the pro-Palestinian activist regarding the accusations of anti-Semitism?

    -The counter-argument is that accusations of anti-Semitism are often used to silence pro-Palestinian activists and that many Jewish students and organizations are, in fact, supporting the protests and standing against the actions of the Israeli government.

  • Why did the police move to eject students from Hamilton Hall at Columbia University?

    -null

  • What historical event is mentioned in relation to the protests at Columbia University?

    -The occupation of Hamilton Hall in 1968 by students protesting South African apartheid is mentioned as a historical event, drawing parallels to the current protests.

  • What is the position of the Fox News contributor on the issue of free speech at universities?

    -The Fox News contributor argues for a First Amendment absolutist position, stating that all speech, even if it's considered hate speech, should be protected under the Constitution, and the government should not decide what is and is not allowed.

  • What concerns are raised about the handling of the protests by the university administrations and the police?

    -Concerns are raised that the university administrations and the police are being used to suppress peaceful protests, with instances of violence by the NYPD against protesters, and accusations of limiting freedom of speech and press.

  • What is the argument made by the pro-Palestinian activist regarding the chanting of 'from the river to the sea'?

    -The argument is that the chant is not inherently anti-Semitic and is a call for resistance against oppression, and that the context of the Palestinian struggle is often misunderstood by those who accuse the chant of promoting the eradication of Israel.

  • How does the debate reflect the broader tensions in the Israeli-Palestinian conflict?

    -The debate reflects the broader tensions by showcasing the differing perspectives on the conflict, including the legitimacy of protests, the impact of historical events on current opinions, the role of free speech in political discourse, and the complexities of addressing accusations of anti-Semitism.

Outlines

00:00

🗣️ Controversial Views on Gaza Conflict

The speaker expresses strong opinions about the situation in Gaza, criticizing the framing of the issue as purely Israeli propaganda. They discuss the harassment of Jewish students and the complexity of the situation, including the actions of protesters at American universities, the demand for humanitarian aid, and the broader implications for community and student safety. The conversation touches on the volatile nature of the protests and the difficulty in addressing the underlying issues.

05:01

🤔 Questioning the Support for Violent Uprisings

The paragraph delves into a contentious conversation about the use of the term 'Intifada', the harassment of Jewish students, and the vandalism associated with the protests. The discussion becomes heated as the speaker defends the actions of pro-Palestinian activists and criticizes the violence perpetrated by authorities against protesters. The dialogue also addresses accusations of anti-Semitism and the speaker's stance against it, while also highlighting the importance of understanding the context behind the slogans and actions of the protesters.

10:02

📢 Free Speech and the Debate on Campus Protests

This section focuses on the issue of free speech in the context of campus protests. It contrasts the government's stance on free speech with the actions taken to limit it, particularly regarding criticism of Israel. The discussion emphasizes the importance of the First Amendment and the potential dangers of allowing the government to decide what constitutes acceptable speech. It also touches on the tension between supporting free speech and opposing certain forms of expression, such as those that may be associated with hate speech or terrorism.

15:03

🏛️ The哥伦比亚 University Protests and the IDF

The speaker condemns the harassment of Jewish students and discusses the protests at Colombia University. They argue against the intimidation of Jewish students for the actions of the Israeli government. The paragraph also addresses the broader context of the Israel-Palestine conflict, including the deaths of journalists and the violence in Gaza. There is a debate about the value of different lives and the accusations of racism in the framing of the conflict.

20:06

🤝 Addressing the Conflict Through Dialogue and Amendment

The paragraph emphasizes the need to separate personal feelings about speech and the issue from government involvement. It discusses the potential consequences of allowing the government to regulate speech, including the possibility of silencing certain viewpoints. The speaker advocates for a clear distinction between personal opinions and the protection of free speech rights, suggesting that anti-Semitic views should not be conflated with support for the First Amendment.

25:08

🕵️‍♂️ Infiltrating the Protest Camp: A Firsthand Account

The speaker describes their experience of infiltrating a pro-Palestinian protest camp at UCLA, highlighting the conditions within the camp and the behavior of the protesters. They claim to have witnessed hate speech and violent tendencies among the protesters, leading to concerns about the safety of journalists and the integrity of the protest movement. The narrative suggests a need for transparency and accountability within the protest camps.

30:08

👨‍🏫 Academic Freedom and the Role of Universities

This section discusses the role of universities in the context of the protests, with a focus on the actions of the administration and the police. The speaker argues against the characterization of the protests as violent and instead points to the actions of authorities as the source of conflict. They also discuss the historical context of university activism and the importance of dialogue and transparency in addressing the concerns of students.

35:09

🌎 Global Perspectives on the Israel-Palestine Conflict

The paragraph touches on the global implications of the Israel-Palestine conflict, with a focus on the role of the media and the perception of different sides. It addresses the accusations of racism and the portrayal of the conflict in the media, suggesting a need for a more balanced and nuanced understanding of the situation. The speaker emphasizes the importance of recognizing the humanity of all individuals involved in the conflict.

40:09

🤬 Accusations of Racism and the Importance of Fair Reporting

The final paragraph is a tense exchange where the speaker defends themselves against accusations of racism, highlighting their past interviews and efforts to address the situation in Gaza fairly. They express frustration with the media's portrayal of the conflict and the labeling of those who defend Palestinians as anti-Semitic. The paragraph ends with a call for an end to the heated debate and a commitment to continue seeking solutions and a better understanding of the situation.

Mindmap

Keywords

💡Gaza

Gaza is a region on the eastern coast of the Mediterranean Sea, often in the news due to the ongoing Israeli-Palestinian conflict. In the video, discussions revolve around the strong views on the situation in Gaza, indicating the human rights concerns and the political unrest in the area.

💡Israeli propaganda

This term refers to the perceived dissemination of information reflecting favorably on Israel's policies, often criticized for being one-sided. In the script, a speaker accuses another of framing the issue solely from an Israeli perspective, suggesting a lack of balance or objectivity in the discourse.

💡Protestors

Individuals who publicly demonstrate their objection to an issue, often advocating for change. The video discusses protestors at universities and their actions, which range from peaceful assembly to alleged violence and vandalism, highlighting the contentious nature of the protests.

💡Humanitarian aid

Assistance provided for humanitarian purposes, often in situations of disaster or conflict. A speaker in the video refers to the need for humanitarian aid for protesters, emphasizing the severity of the situation and the basic needs that are not being met.

💡Free speech

The right to express one's opinions without censorship or restraint, a fundamental principle in democratic societies. The video participants debate the limits of free speech, especially in the context of protests and controversial political issues.

💡Anti-Semitism

Discrimination against Jews, a form of prejudice and racism. The script mentions accusations of anti-Semitism against pro-Palestinian activists as a means to discredit them, showing the complexity of the conflict and the challenges in addressing it without resorting to stereotypes.

💡Campus protests

Demonstrations by students on educational institutions' grounds, often advocating for change or expressing dissatisfaction. The video discusses campus protests at Columbia University and elsewhere, indicating the widespread nature of student activism on this issue.

💡Palestinian solidarity

Expression of support for the Palestinian cause, often in the context of the Israeli-Palestinian conflict. The video features discussions of protests showing solidarity with Palestinians, suggesting a global concern and empathy for their plight.

💡Violence at protests

The occurrence of violent acts during demonstrations, which can involve physical altercations or property damage. The script describes instances of violence at protests, raising questions about the legitimacy and tactics of the protesters, as well as the response from authorities.

💡Cancel culture

A modern social phenomenon where people seek to withdraw support for public figures or social groups that have done something considered unacceptable. The term is used in the video to criticize what is perceived as an attempt to suppress certain viewpoints, particularly in the context of the Israeli-Palestinian debate.

💡Terrorism

The use of violence and intimidation to achieve political aims, often causing fear and harm to civilians. In the video, the term is a point of contention, with different speakers debating whether certain actions by the IDF or other groups constitute terrorism, reflecting the difficulty in reaching a consensus on such a loaded term.

Highlights

The discussion revolves around the protests at Columbia University and the broader implications of the Israeli-Palestinian conflict on campuses.

A participant argues that the framing of the issue has been heavily biased towards Israeli propaganda, neglecting the Palestinian perspective.

There is an agreement that Jewish students should not be harassed or attacked, but a debate on the reasons behind such incidents occurs.

The term 'Intifada' is discussed, with clarification that it means 'uprising' against oppression, not specifically violence.

Reports of vandalism and barricading of Hamilton Hall at Columbia University by protesters are mentioned.

The issue of free speech on campus is brought up, with concerns over potential limits on constitutionally protected speech.

A debate ensues over the use of the phrase 'from the river to the sea,' with accusations of promoting the eradication of Israel.

Javier Deuso shares his experience of infiltrating a pro-Palestinian encampment at UCLA, noting aggression and hate speech.

Cornell West emphasizes the importance of dialogue and transparency regarding university investments linked to the conflict.

The role of the media in shaping public perception of the conflict and the portrayal of protesters is criticized.

Concerns are raised about the harassment and intimidation of Jewish students, with calls for their protection.

The discussion touches on the historical context of the Israeli-Palestinian conflict and the roots of violence.

The validity of the IDF's actions and whether they constitute terrorism is questioned, with differing viewpoints presented.

The heated exchange reflects the deep divisions and strong emotions tied to the conflict, both on campus and in the public discourse.

The necessity for a nuanced understanding of the situation in Gaza and the impact on students and journalists is emphasized.

The debate concludes with a call for protection of all students' rights and safety, regardless of their stance on the conflict.

Transcripts

00:00

that doesn't mean I don't have very

00:02

strong views about what's happening in

00:03

Gaza because you know that I do so what

00:06

where is my lie in all this yeah Piers

00:09

I've just listened to you for 20 minutes

00:11

frame the issue in a purely 100% Israeli

00:16

propaganda way so if you say Hey listen

00:20

the Jewish students shouldn't be

00:21

harassed or attacked of course I agree

00:23

I've you agree with me so why have I

00:25

lied yeah no no no stop interrupting

00:30

the protesters wreaking havoc at some of

00:32

America's top universities have a deadly

00:34

serious point unfortunately many of them

00:36

fundamentally unserious people Nothing

00:38

captured the insanity of this moment

00:40

better than a PhD candidate at Columbia

00:42

University stepping out to demand

00:44

humanitarian aid for the

00:46

protesters I guess it's ultimately a

00:48

question of what kind of community and

00:51

obligation Colombia feels it has to its

00:52

students um do you want students to die

00:56

of dehydration and starvation or get

00:58

severely ill even if they disagree with

01:00

you if the answer is no then you should

01:02

allow basic I mean it's crazy to say

01:04

because we're on an ivy Le campus but

01:06

this is like basic humanitarian Aid

01:07

we're asking for it seems like you're

01:09

sort of saying we want to be

01:11

revolutionaries we want to take up this

01:12

building now would you please bring us

01:15

food with a completely straight face she

01:18

demands urgent assistance for protesters

01:20

to spare them from dehydration

01:21

starvation and severe illness as she and

01:25

her mob friends voluntarily occupied a

01:27

private building in support of gar and

01:29

people actually facing dehydration

01:32

starvation and severe illness well

01:34

students protesting for peace is nothing

01:35

new they have every right to do it but

01:37

clearly they're are limits under the law

01:39

and at this point they're doing a better

01:40

job of Israeli propaganda than Israel's

01:44

government police have moved into eject

01:46

students from Columbia's Hamilton Hall

01:48

after reports they vandalized and

01:50

barricaded the famous building as the

01:51

university said this was because of the

01:53

protest as actions not because of their

01:55

cause officers Clash for students at

01:57

other campuses overnight including UCLA

01:59

Los Angeles where pro-israel protesters

02:01

moved on their Rivals and police

02:03

patients ran out it's all begin

02:05

unpleasant shades of the BLM riots in

02:08

2020 a fundamentally just cause which

02:10

became toxic and divisive fueled by

02:12

people who know little about the issues

02:13

a lot about causing chaos and quite AP

02:16

from apart from the absurdity of the

02:17

individuals involved it raises serious

02:19

questions and contradictions many of

02:21

former president Trump's feces critics

02:23

shuted at his blat Crackdown on most

02:26

2020 protests how does St Joe Biden's

02:28

supporters defend the SE we're

02:30

witnessing now and on the other hand

02:32

many of the staunchest offenders of free

02:33

speech have being the loudest supporters

02:35

of Israel and the fiercest critics of

02:36

the campus protesters so where is the

02:38

line and is it the police or the

02:40

protesters who've crossed it well in a

02:42

moment we'll debate all this with an

02:43

All-Star panel but first joining me now

02:45

is pro Palestinian activist Nardin kwani

02:48

who organized protests outside Columbia

02:50

and City University in New York last

02:52

night um okay Nadine welcome back to

02:55

uncensored you were there last night

02:57

there's a current ban uh on you and

03:00

others from Colombia dated from last

03:03

week uh saying that you are considered

03:05

Persona onr on all Colombia University

03:08

own property due to alarming and

03:10

concerning Behavior so why were you back

03:14

there I wasn't inside the gates of

03:16

Colombia I was outside of Colombia and

03:19

you know I'm able to be able to protest

03:22

outside of Colombia in support of the

03:23

students as a New Yorker just like New

03:25

Yorkers have been consistently showing

03:27

outside of the gates of Colombia um in

03:30

support of the students even before they

03:32

launched the GZA solidarity encampment

03:35

uh my organization within our lifetime

03:37

mobilized in support of Colombia

03:40

students uh from Jewish voice for peace

03:42

and from students for justice in

03:44

Palestine who are both suspended um

03:47

months ago and you know we're just

03:49

continuing that tradition that support

03:52

um from the community to the students so

03:54

we had a a protest that started at NYU

03:58

went to the new school made a stop at

04:00

fit the Fashion Institute of Technology

04:03

uh we made our way over to Colombia by

04:05

train and then ended at cuni so just

04:09

showing solidarity to all of the

04:11

encampments but it's not quite a

04:12

straightforward as just showing

04:13

solidarity uh mobs inside and outside

04:16

the campus have been chanting into F and

04:19

anyone who knows the history of the uh

04:22

conflict between Palestine and Israel

04:24

knows what in means it means a violent

04:26

Uprising they've been chanting from The

04:28

River To The Sea which of course course

04:29

involves the eradication of Israel we've

04:32

seen Jewish students being harassed uh

04:34

by by the mob we've seen Jewish

04:37

professors not being allowed in to teach

04:39

because of fears for their safety uh

04:41

we've seen others being held in

04:43

effective captivity following the

04:45

breaking in the violent breaking in of

04:48

an historic building uh all of this uh a

04:51

lot of it is Criminal from trespass to

04:54

vandalism to actually potentially

04:57

kidnapping people if you're not letting

04:58

them out when you break in um how do you

05:01

how do you so no kidnappings have happen

05:03

hang on I'm just saying potentially

05:05

potentially it could be categorized as

05:06

that so my question for you is why would

05:08

you support all this why do you support

05:11

chanting about a violent Uprising why

05:13

are Jewish students being harassed in

05:15

this manner why would you support the

05:17

wanton vandalism involved in smashing

05:19

into an historic

05:21

building so I'm going to try to answer

05:23

this in the order of everything you said

05:25

first of all an uh means shaking off in

05:28

Arabic or Uprising it's not just using

05:30

the Palestinian context but against

05:32

people fighting against oppression

05:34

everywhere and the City University of

05:36

New York where I was a student in

05:37

undergrad and for law school actually

05:40

investigated SJP um for the use of the

05:43

word in in previous um years they

05:47

released a report in 2016 that is public

05:49

right now you can find it um online that

05:52

clarifies that Ina is not an

05:54

anti-semitic there have been two inter

05:56

hang on there have been two inter the

05:57

first and second inter in the in the

06:00

conflict uh in the last 30 years been

06:02

these two Infamous interf fathers which

06:04

led to the deaths of many many people on

06:07

both sides both were violent uprisings

06:10

and so when people CH about when you

06:12

have a pro Palestinian when a pro

06:14

Palestinian group started as boycotts

06:17

started as strikes are you going to let

06:18

me respond because you actually made a

06:20

lot of accusations and I'm going to try

06:22

to respond to all of them in order okay

06:24

well you not going back and forth are

06:26

you going to try and deny that either

06:27

inap was violent

06:31

I believe that the Israeli colonizers

06:33

the zionists made it violent by

06:35

attacking peaceful protests just like we

06:37

saw the NYPD attack protesters at cuni

06:41

and at Colombia that made the situation

06:43

that wasn't previously violent violence

06:45

and all the acts of terrorism

06:46

perpetrated by Pro Palestinians against

06:49

Israelis during the two iners what do

06:51

you think of those I'm not here to

06:52

debate the first and second and the with

06:55

you I'm told you the definition of the

06:57

word you can

07:01

you're being disingenuous when people

07:02

when Pro Palestinian groups in a new

07:04

outside of New York University chant

07:06

about in they know what they're doing

07:08

and Jewish people know what they're

07:10

doing they are invoking the first and

07:12

second which involves which

07:15

involves protr has been chanting in for

07:19

decades so you know this and and let's

07:21

go back let's go to the second phrase

07:23

you say from The River To The Sea now

07:25

they want to make a problem with that

07:26

any chance that we say you know there's

07:28

this accusation of of anti-Semitism

07:30

because every single Pro Palestinian

07:32

activist has been accused of of

07:35

anti-Semitism as a way to silence them

07:37

even though just you know you mentioned

07:39

Jewish students before so many of these

07:41

Jewish students are standing with us are

07:43

with the protest inside and outside many

07:45

are not many are being hared Jewish

07:47

voice for peace was suped many je many

07:50

Jewish students are not and they're

07:51

being harassed and we're seeing the

07:52

videos of they're being harassed they're

07:54

being threatened they're being banned

07:55

from

07:57

going hared they've been but you're not

08:01

in Gaza doing this you're doing in the

08:03

middle of New York what does this have

08:05

to do with being in Gaza we're here as

08:07

New Yorkers as Arabs Muslims and

08:09

Palestinians and we're harassed daily

08:11

constantly not just since October 7th

08:14

but for as long as we have lived here

08:16

and you know that's constantly ignored

08:18

uh but when Palestinian students are

08:20

finally speaking up against the

08:22

slaughter of their people and Gaza and

08:24

all over Palestine you know it becomes a

08:26

problem now they want to you know pay

08:28

attention um to these things you know I

08:31

think every uh Palestinian organization

08:34

including my own has made it clear that

08:36

we stand against anti-Semitism and that

08:38

these smears of anti-Semitism against

08:40

Pro Palestinian activists are a

08:43

long-held tradition by the Zionist Lobby

08:45

by Zionist organizations as an attempt

08:48

to discredit people if protesters get

08:51

violent is that acceptable resistance to

08:54

the

08:56

oppression I haven't seen any violence

08:59

um happen happening at protest so I

09:00

don't even know why this um is a

09:02

question nobody's advocating for violent

09:05

protest and nobody say Jus including

09:08

myself would it be justified I just

09:10

answered that you're just repeating the

09:12

same question I feel like you're being

09:13

disingenous when I've already made this

09:15

you didn't answer if it would be

09:18

justified I just said it's not

09:20

acceptable how could it be justified

09:22

right so the only violence that we see

09:24

being Unleashed which is completely

09:26

unacceptable is by the nyp who have maed

09:30

protesters they ma people at NYU which I

09:33

saw with my own eyes

09:35

they last night they whipped out their

09:37

bons they beat people until they bled

09:40

people got people got punched in the

09:42

face they were bleeding from their teeth

09:44

you know this is the violence that's

09:46

complet because a howling vient that's

09:48

because a howling violent mob chanting

09:50

into broke into an historic building on

09:53

a private property it's not their

09:55

property they committed acts of

09:57

vandalism they committed acts of

09:58

trespass they were holding people

09:59

against their will they've been

10:01

threatening and harassing Jewish

10:02

students I'm sorry that's not a peaceful

10:04

protest right these people are not

10:06

protesting peace will were Colombia

10:08

students forced to stay inside the

10:10

journalism school you know the NYPD

10:13

literally poked open poked their head in

10:15

an open door and told the cuni

10:17

journalism students that if they left

10:19

that building they would be arrested

10:21

Colombia admin came to say that they

10:23

should have the right to report that

10:25

they can't limit um the freedom of

10:27

speech the freedom of the press and the

10:29

NYPD actually threatened Colombia um

10:31

Administration so the only people who

10:33

were being held against their will um

10:36

were the Colombia students by the NYPD

10:39

um and other students who were not part

10:40

of the journalism School part of the

10:42

other schools or in their dorms were

10:43

also ordered to shelter in place by the

10:46

Columbia Administration so everything

10:48

you've brought up from the violence to

10:50

people being held against their will

10:51

this is being perpetuated by the POS

10:54

people in positions of Power by the

10:56

administrations of these universities

10:58

and by the police Police Department who

11:00

was being used to crush peaceful protest

11:02

who was being used to show up in riot

11:04

gear and turn an otherwise peaceful

11:06

situation um into a riot never forget

11:09

that in 1968 150 protesters occupied the

11:13

same exact Hall that the students of

11:16

Colombia are were occupying as of last

11:18

night and forced to come out of Hamilton

11:20

Hall which they renamed hins Hall in

11:22

honor of the 5-year-old Palestinian girl

11:25

who was killed who had to sit in a car

11:27

with her family member for hours her

11:30

family members for hours while they

11:32

decayed while they rotted after being

11:33

killed by the Israeli Army and she

11:36

starved um to death nobody was able to

11:38

get to her um so you know okay the this

11:41

in 1968 Hamilton Hall was occupied by

11:44

over 150 students uh protesting South

11:47

African apartheid and this kind of

11:48

police violence wasn't used against them

11:50

and they are remembered in history as

11:52

Heroes so continuing the long held

11:54

tradition of University activism this is

11:57

what they were doing at this is what we

11:59

were doing at cuni and all the

12:01

encampments that we see not just in the

12:03

US but all seven continents I have to

12:05

move on because I have I have four other

12:07

guest but I appreciate you joining me

12:08

thank you very much but joining me now

12:09

is the independent presidential

12:10

candidate Cornell West who teaches at

12:12

Columbia and joins some of the student

12:14

protests the Fox News contributor cat

12:15

Tim former BLM supporter Javier deuso of

12:18

preu pru who broke into a pro

12:20

Palestinian encampment at UCLA and The

12:23

Young Turks founder Jen yugar uh Kat I

12:25

want to start with you because I know

12:26

you've got a a slight time constraint um

12:29

so I want to start with you and just

12:30

talk about one aspect of this which is

12:32

the whole issue of free speech in this

12:35

debate and we're going to get into the

12:36

two sides part of it in a moment with

12:39

the other guest but from a free speech

12:42

perspective what is your take on what

12:44

we're seeing

12:46

here so I've been very open about my

12:50

about this issue I think there's been

12:52

not quite enough focus on the Free

12:55

Speech issue I think that for example

12:58

you could look at Texas government

12:59

Abbott who in 2019 was saying there has

13:02

to be free speech on campuses there has

13:04

to be the first amendment on campuses

13:06

then on March 27th he signed something

13:09

that limits speech on campus including

13:11

constitutionally protected speech

13:14

including criticism of Israel's

13:16

government I think that what the

13:18

Constitution says is is very very clear

13:20

that that even hate speech is Free

13:22

Speech right so you can debate whether

13:25

something is or is not hate speech and

13:26

the debate you just have with your last

13:27

guest proves that there is some dis

13:29

agreement on that and the main point is

13:31

the government should not be the one

13:33

deciding what is and is not uh we have

13:35

Indi a spokesperson for the Indiana uh

13:38

police department saying hate speech

13:39

isn't free speech well that just simply

13:41

isn't true and it's the whole idea of

13:44

what it's always been which is that you

13:46

don't want the government to be in the

13:47

position of deciding what speech is and

13:49

is not allowed because that is going to

13:52

be dangerous for anyone including

13:54

including Jew Jewish students right I

13:56

mean there there was no free speech

13:58

obvious ly in Hitler's Germany right and

14:02

saying that Free Speech something is

14:04

First Amendment protected free speech is

14:06

not that you don't have to say you agree

14:07

with it and you can totally bring up the

14:10

fact that maybe it's been less

14:12

consistent in terms of uh all of a

14:14

sudden now a lot of these University

14:15

presidents are super pro- free speech

14:18

when it comes to this when they haven't

14:19

been in the past but to me that's not

14:21

going to cause me to be hypocritical on

14:23

this issue I'm I'm a First Amendment

14:24

absolutist I was in 2019 I was before

14:27

2019 and I still am today what if you

14:29

are chanting

14:31

inter given the history of

14:34

interfers between Israel and Palestine

14:37

uh twice in the last 30 years we know

14:39

what interfers have been there there've

14:41

been violent uprisings with many people

14:44

dying and what if you chart from The

14:45

River To The Sea which which Jewish

14:47

people believe absolutely means the

14:50

eradication of Israel I was just asking

14:52

first amendment I will come to everybody

14:53

else cat cat has to go so I I want to

14:56

just get this free speech part of the

14:57

debate out the way cat

14:59

the first amendment is actually clear on

15:01

on that where it's you have to have a

15:03

very very very specific exception where

15:06

that would not be allowed so for example

15:08

a peaceful protest where people are

15:10

Marching and saying from the river to

15:11

the sea is constitutionally protected

15:13

speech an incident where you were

15:16

targeting a specific Jewish student and

15:19

chanting that at that student where a

15:21

protest had become

15:22

violent then that maybe would not be but

15:25

it but it's very very narrow and and

15:26

it's supposed to be very very narrow

15:28

where there has to be um it has to be

15:30

directed and likely to produce imminent

15:33

action and also true threats those are

15:36

the only exceptions which are very very

15:37

narrow and and the law is clear on this

15:40

but if you have people and we've seen

15:42

pictures of them inside and outside

15:44

campus who appear to be supporting Hamas

15:47

rhetoric who are wearing maybe Insignia

15:51

relating to Hamas or hisb or whatever if

15:53

you're brazenly

15:54

supporting organizations groups of

15:57

people that are deemed to be Terri s by

16:00

large sways of the world does that cross

16:02

the line This is utter nonsense Piers

16:05

can I just answer the question you got

16:08

you got genocide taking place you got

16:10

IDF terrorism taking place you can't say

16:12

a mumbling word about 12 universities

16:14

that's been leveled to the ground

16:17

hundreds and hundreds and hundreds of

16:18

professors have been killed students

16:20

have been killed you're a journalist yes

16:22

have you talked about the 112

16:24

journalists who have been killed brother

16:26

I have lies

16:31

hang

16:33

hang UNF you just start you start lying

16:37

man it's ridiculous I'm not lying about

16:40

anything you are I agree with Cornell

16:43

West completely you're totally utterly

16:45

lying through your framing the framing

16:50

of I can't hear you both speak at the

16:53

same time Cornell just to be clear I

16:55

have posted sorry hang on hang on I have

16:59

posted about the journalists who've died

17:02

in Gaza right I have posted about this I

17:05

have highlighted the deaths of those

17:07

journalists right put it in the

17:09

framework well I I'm going to I was

17:12

gonna come to you about the framework no

17:14

you're not all the vandalism about one

17:17

Hall and you hardly can say a mumbling

17:19

word about universities libraries gone

17:22

completely School rooms gone completely

17:25

you see how truncated and narrow your

17:27

framework is you just lying man you

17:29

ought to be shame of yourself when you

17:31

say lying what you're trying to imply

17:33

that I don't care about the other stuff

17:35

you've just mentioned I'm say that's

17:38

definitely right not have the same value

17:41

as an Israeli life that's what I'm

17:43

saying okay let me bring in let me bring

17:46

in let me bring okay let me bring in J

17:49

just to be clear I haven't I haven't

17:50

lied about anything right I haven't

17:52

talked about what's happened in Gaza yet

17:54

because we haven't come to that part of

17:56

the debate but Chen I don't believe

17:58

you've always seemed to me to be one of

18:00

the more rational voices in Mr debate

18:02

prepared to accept what Hamas did was

18:04

horrendous and so on I don't believe

18:06

that you think it's right that Jewish

18:08

students should be intimidated and

18:10

harassed on you come right back to the

18:12

thing again can I just answer this for

18:14

we are debating the protest okay come on

18:16

Brother come on man I don't think it's

18:18

right they should be subjected to

18:20

intimidation okay nobody no that's right

18:24

not speak I'll come back girl has a

18:28

whole name after her because she and

18:31

15,000 other children have been killed

18:33

by the IDF terrorist that you don't even

18:36

call terrorist but you can call the

18:38

students terrorist that's not a double

18:40

standards man that's just outright

18:42

mendacity hiding criminality on your

18:45

show and you're supposed to be

18:46

uncentered concerned about the truth you

18:48

just said I called them terrorists I

18:50

haven't called I haven't called them

18:51

terrorists that ironically is a lie Jen

18:54

I want to bring you in uh you're getting

18:55

very angry about this too just to be

18:57

clear I I am expressing an opinion that

18:59

what has happened at Colombia has

19:01

crossed a line and that if I'm a Jewish

19:03

student there I think it's completely

19:05

outrageous I'm being intimidated and

19:07

harassed for the actions of Israel's

19:09

government thousands of miles away that

19:12

doesn't mean I don't have very strong

19:14

views about what's happening in Gaza

19:16

because you know that I do so what where

19:18

is my lie in all this yeah Piers I've

19:21

just listened to you for 20 minutes

19:23

frame the issue in a purely 100% Israeli

19:28

propag Anda way so if you say Hey listen

19:32

Jewish students shouldn't be harassed or

19:33

attacked of course I agree I've got je

19:36

so why have I lied yeah no no no stop

19:40

interrupting but what you don't talk

19:42

about is you say from the river to the

19:44

sea is an unacceptable change did you

19:45

mention to the audience in these last 20

19:47

minutes that Benjamin Netanyahu actually

19:49

said it recently not only that he's

19:52

actually doing it he's in the middle of

19:55

wiping out the Palestinians from the

19:56

river to the sea that is the grotesque

19:59

violence he has slaughtered

20:02

25,000 women and children they were all

20:06

innocent so when Hamas kills 860

20:09

innocent Israeli civilians I call them

20:11

out and I say that is terrible but when

20:14

Israel Slaughters

20:16

25,000 women and children we we're

20:19

saying oh I don't like a pro Palestinian

20:23

chant chant that's what we're concerned

20:26

about and now you turn to the the vi

20:28

that has happened on college campuses

20:30

there is one case of overwhelming

20:33

violence and that happened last night at

20:35

UCLA and it was pro-israeli protesters

20:38

that violently attacked the peace

20:41

protesters that didn't do anything they

20:43

attacked an old lady and said oh yeah

20:46

good luck trying to defend yourself old

20:47

lady these are vicious vigilante Thugs

20:52

and they have done more violence than

20:55

all of the peace protesters in the

20:56

country combined where are the arrest

20:59

where are the where's the outrage

21:01

where's the indignation you pretend that

21:03

you care about protecting students but

21:05

you only care about protecting one side

21:08

whereas the other side is assaulted no I

21:10

don't actually no because debased and

21:12

humiliated all you want to do is cancel

21:15

their speech you want you're part of

21:17

cancel culture and admit it right now

21:19

you're talking about protesting people

21:21

Americans resp can Americans way okay

21:24

this is not the United States of Israel

21:26

fine America

21:29

to protest a foreign government okay let

21:32

me respond just to be clear you've lost

21:33

the right wing L the left wing you've

21:36

lost America America's not going to

21:38

stand here and let Israel keep shouting

21:40

or we can have to speak and who's going

21:42

to be arrested all right you can keep

21:44

shout give you 20 minutes to do

21:45

propaganda go ahead now it's not

21:47

propaganda I I have many views about all

21:49

of this we're talking specifically about

21:51

the protests at Colombia which I think

21:53

have crossed the line I'm by the way you

21:55

talk about cancel culture I'm entitled

21:57

to my view without you Dr West screaming

22:00

liar genocide supporter and all this

22:03

other

22:04

[ __ ] let me let me let me make it

22:07

clear you do you condemn them I'm do the

22:09

same thing you are do you condemn them

22:11

you Pro violence can I answer the

22:13

question if this was Jewish students

22:15

that were breaking into this building

22:18

violently no you don't have to go with a

22:20

hypothetical sorry I am going to go with

22:22

a hypothetical because you're trying to

22:23

make out that somehow I'm only doing

22:25

this because I'm Pro Israel's government

22:27

I'm not pro Israel's government what I'm

22:29

What I Am pro is the safety of Jewish

22:31

students being protected because they

22:33

are not responsible for the actions of

22:35

an Israel government thousands of miles

22:37

away they're entitled having paid

22:39

$400,000 for their education you say no

22:42

you don't want to protect the peace Pro

22:43

I don't think more rules should be

22:45

allowed to go on so when you talk about

22:47

this is a private University campus they

22:50

are entitled to not have their buildings

22:52

desecrated in this manner and they are

22:54

entitled eventually to have the police

22:56

remove be honest be honest when they

22:58

were doing it in a public space you were

23:01

everybody in media in American Media

23:02

said how dare they do it in a public

23:04

space they do it in a private place you

23:06

go how dare they do it in a private

23:07

place you shouldn't be breaking into

23:08

building full you know what when Martin

23:10

Luther King in Selma Alabama cross the

23:13

Edmond Pettis Bridge you know what they

23:14

said how dare they interrupt the bridge

23:17

how dare they go in a public place how

23:19

dare those protesters civil rights

23:21

leaders should know their role should

23:23

know their place boy that's what people

23:25

like everyone in American Media is

23:27

saying right now to the people in favor

23:29

of not slaughtering any more

23:31

Palestinians you guys sound exactly like

23:34

bull Conor okay I Kat I know you have to

23:36

go I just want to just bring you back in

23:38

just briefly look this is an incredibly

23:40

as you can tell this is a very

23:42

incendiary debate and passions run very

23:44

high about this is anything you've just

23:46

been listening to uh giving you any more

23:49

clarity about how we resolve this

23:51

situation because presumably these

23:53

protests are not going to go away uh

23:56

they may get bigger in number they may

23:58

affect more universities this is this is

24:01

a bad situation getting progressively

24:03

quickly worse what do we do about

24:07

this right again going back to what I

24:10

was saying before I think that the law

24:13

on these things is clear I think that we

24:16

want to be careful to not give up any of

24:18

our rights as Americans in response to

24:21

things that we see there was also a

24:23

bipartisan legislation proposed uh about

24:26

having anti-Semitism monitor on campuses

24:29

I mean what could go wrong there right

24:32

and I've I've been open as a First

24:34

Amendment absolutist and I've had people

24:35

send me videos of things like smash

24:38

Windows well is this free speech cat

24:40

obviously not and I'm not saying that it

24:42

is I think that the robust debate

24:45

surrounding this proves all the more

24:47

reason why there are strong

24:49

disagreements on what counts as what and

24:51

what means this or what means that that

24:54

we should not have the government be in

24:55

the position to decide ever what you can

24:58

and cannot say because any of these

24:59

rules that some people are pushing for

25:02

that would you know some of the the

25:03

slogans that the Palestinian protesters

25:05

are chanting to silence any of that

25:07

could then based on what else someone

25:09

else thinks could be used to say prevent

25:12

an IDF soldier from coming to campus to

25:14

speak so I think that there are two

25:17

separate things that we need to keep how

25:18

you feel about the speech personally how

25:21

you feel about the issue personally and

25:23

then how you feel about the government

25:24

involvement in it those are two

25:26

completely separate things and it's not

25:28

not the same to be proir Amendment and

25:30

anti-semitic you make some great points

25:32

cat we've got to let you go thank you

25:34

very much indeed for joining us I

25:35

greatly appreciate it thank you I want

25:37

to bring in jav derusso you've been

25:38

waiting patiently you posted on X

25:41

yesterday Breaking Inside the UCLA

25:43

anti-israel encampment journalist cam

25:46

Higby and I snuck into the ongoing

25:48

encampment to see what was going on cam

25:50

was caught after asking too many common

25:52

sense questions and physically removed

25:54

by the protesters we have a bit of

25:56

footage of that I think about the same

25:59

wristbands as the anti-s semis so that

26:00

we could sneak into their camp and woo

26:02

CH out the ghetto first of all they had

26:04

gender neutral buckets to urate and poop

26:07

in the whole place smelled like musty

26:09

terrorists and [ __ ] but the fact that

26:11

they were forcing out conversation and

26:13

journalists makes it clear that they

26:15

don't have the answers to explain why

26:17

they're there and I was overhearing the

26:19

most racist conversations about white

26:21

people just in general these people are

26:23

literally BLM rebranded and more

26:26

extreme look that's pretty inflammatory

26:29

stuff but you're here now

26:32

um do you think what you did last night

26:34

was the right thing to

26:38

do absolutely and first of all thank you

26:40

for having me pierce it was the right

26:42

thing to do I'm somebody I hate

26:44

propaganda from either side I hate being

26:46

told what I'm supposed to believe so I

26:48

like to go in and see for myself so I

26:50

snuck into the camp it was very easy I

26:52

just put on a tacky outfit and went and

26:53

bought the same wristbands from Staples

26:55

and I saw the conditions that were back

26:57

there I saw saw the sanitation hazards

26:59

of them all using the same bucket to

27:01

poop in and I saw the I overheard the

27:04

conversations that they were having in

27:05

there it was full of hate speech it was

27:07

full of just calling for the Bloodshed

27:10

of Zionist it was them being angry and

27:12

It ultimately started to get violent

27:14

once my friend cam Hick's cover was

27:16

blown once they realized as they were

27:18

describing him as a white Republican

27:20

they immediately knew that they had to

27:21

kick him out and they locked arms they

27:24

were shoving him up the stairs and then

27:25

back down the stairs to get him out of

27:27

the encampment and it just goes to show

27:29

how aggressive these college students

27:31

are getting I'm all for free speech I'm

27:33

all for freedom of expression but that

27:35

is limited once you start one

27:37

prohibiting these students who pay a lot

27:38

of money to go to these college campuses

27:40

to go to class as well as you start

27:42

becoming violent towards journalists and

27:44

people who are just there trying to get

27:46

an inside story on what's actually

27:48

happening on these universities that we

27:50

are being asked to pay for U Dr West

27:53

coming back to you Donald Trump got

27:55

horrendous criticism for cracking down

27:57

on the BLM protest in

27:59

2020 is Biden not just doing the same

28:02

here and is there a double standard in

28:04

the way that people are looking at these

28:07

two different

28:09

situations Ian one anytime you have

28:12

massive military

28:14

occupation of a community that's what

28:17

BLS was about that's what the black

28:19

lives matter was about which that's a

28:20

400y year Affair I don't know whether

28:22

the brother would want to do that in the

28:24

1960 to see who was using the urine with

28:27

King and Malcolm and fny L and others

28:30

but there were other issues they were

28:32

zeroing in on it's called American

28:35

terrorism it's called American gym club

28:37

or American police murdering other young

28:40

people of different colors disply

28:42

chocolate right but when you have

28:44

massive military occupation that is a

28:47

massive breakdown of a community if you

28:49

can't have a leadership of a university

28:52

that can have a dialogue about three

28:54

claims we want transparency about your

28:57

investment

28:58

we don't want you to invest in genocide

29:01

occupation and ethnic cleansing and we

29:04

want amnesty you can have a dialogue at

29:06

Brown they said they're gonna have a

29:07

dialogue they're gonna have a vote but

29:09

no no not Colombia and the others

29:12

they've become such a corporation they

29:14

tied to their donors they're tied to

29:15

their money Masters they're tied to

29:17

their benefactors they don't give a damn

29:19

about what the students think the

29:21

students are just Canon f for their

29:23

reputation who are highly talented

29:26

worked very hard but have hard hardly

29:28

any voice and when you don't have a

29:30

voice and you you move in a nonviolent

29:32

way and brother Pierce you should know

29:34

the two first anti fathers were

29:36

nonviolent they shot him down like dogs

29:39

that's why Hamas didn't appear till 1988

29:42

and you had the vicious occupation in

29:44

1948 if they had shot mther King Jr down

29:47

and Rosa Parks down and so forth there's

29:49

no doubt that black folk would have

29:51

responded that's why we the black people

29:53

haven't created a black version of the

29:55

Klux Clan because we had leaders like

29:57

Martin and leaders like Fanny L you

29:59

shoot them down like a dog it's going to

30:01

be a very different situation that's

30:04

what we're okay but let me ask you let

30:05

me ask you a question are gonna have

30:08

fults okay let me ask you a question my

30:11

question for you we're talking about the

30:13

main issue of genocide this ain't no

30:16

game this ain't no game it's not a game

30:19

people are dying though

30:21

understand

30:24

unell you must let me respond you teach

30:28

teach you teach at Columbia and you

30:29

joined these protests Theological

30:31

Seminary across the street I've been in

30:33

the camps I didn't see anything that the

30:35

other brother saw but you know if he he

30:37

makes his judgment he makes his judgment

30:39

but given that there has been clear

30:40

intimidation and harassment of Jewish

30:42

students it's been broadcast we've seen

30:44

the videos of it you cannot be happy as

30:47

a professor there that Jewish students

30:50

are being harassed and intimidated

30:52

because people are critical of what an

30:54

Israel government's doing thousands of

30:56

miles away that is my

30:58

point of course of course that goes

31:02

without saying I try to be a decent

31:03

person in my life you

31:05

agree that D you agree with me all you

31:08

want to talk about is prot not all I

31:11

want to talk about cor but that is

31:13

actually this debate organization that

31:16

are banded back in October did you say a

31:18

word about that when you got massive

31:20

children at universities and the

31:22

hospitals completely leveled and you

31:24

have something on your Twitter rather

31:26

than make that part of the framing of

31:28

the issue then in fact you become an

31:30

extension of propaganda and that's why I

31:33

call you a racist because it means then

31:35

that how dare

31:39

honestly I'm how

31:44

dare you would not frame it in that way

31:46

I'm sorry but you you how dare you call

31:48

me a racist what you don't know is I

31:51

before I did this debate I did a long

31:53

interview with one of the IDF spokesmen

31:56

in which I went after him about their

31:58

planned invasion of Rafa because I think

32:00

it would be a catastrophic mistake so

32:02

don't call me a racist and don't assume

32:04

you don't assume believe the Palestinian

32:07

life has the same value as Israeli life

32:09

absolutely not fiber in when it comes to

32:12

Palestinian predic absolutely believe

32:15

palestin I believe Palestinian lives

32:18

matter just as much as any other lives

32:21

and I've always said that always it's

32:23

not manifesting your framing brother

32:25

it's not manifesting your don't throw

32:28

around the word racist without any

32:30

evidence to support the fact that I'm a

32:32

racist hear a lot of evidence and I've

32:35

been hearing the evidence and I throw it

32:36

around it's not throwing around it's a

32:38

reality me me me saying it is wrong that

32:41

Jewish students are being harassed is

32:43

not racism because I'm not also I'm not

32:46

also talking about

32:48

unaza I

32:50

think ingenuous all right J I'll bring

32:53

you in no please okay look piers you

32:58

keep going back to the most obvious

33:00

question in the world should Jewish

33:01

students be uh protected from harassment

33:04

or assault obviously obviously you both

33:07

agree with me does that RAC let finish

33:10

let me finish let me finish so that's

33:15

the most obvious point in the world and

33:16

I already told you that I have Jewish I

33:18

have a nephew who wears a star David on

33:20

a college campus I I will go and help

33:24

the people that are escorting them to

33:27

their classes Etc that is not an issue

33:30

but what you just did was you spent now

33:32

20 to 30 minutes framing it like that is

33:34

the biggest issue in everyone is saying

33:37

oh no we should attack the Jewish

33:38

students when no one is saying that in

33:41

reality hold on in

33:43

reality vigilante thugs last night

33:47

attacked a peace protesters at UCLA who

33:49

had done nothing wrong it was a violent

33:52

attack they beat them with sticks they

33:55

pepper sprayed them and yet I ask you a

33:58

simple question you've got now an 20 to

34:02

30 minutes of propaganda saying all the

34:05

Palestinian protesters the peace

34:06

protesters they hate the Jews they're

34:08

anti-semites anti-semites all the Jews

34:11

are in danger Etc and I'm saying of

34:13

course let's protect them and then you

34:15

make it seem like that's the 98% of the

34:17

issue when in reality the only

34:19

protesters that have been massively

34:20

violent are the pro-israel protesters

34:23

and to this second not only did you

34:25

mention it for about 2 and a half

34:27

seconds

34:29

still haven't condemn them so do you

34:31

condemn them peers the violent thugs I

34:34

delber I deliberately I deliberately

34:37

held off writing or commenting about

34:39

what was going in Colombia for quite a

34:41

few days and I will do the same about

34:43

what happened at UCLA until I've

34:45

actually established for well hang on

34:48

sorry it happened overnight and I will

34:50

wait and see the facts and when I get

34:52

the facts I will pass judgment without

34:54

fear or favor and certainly without any

34:56

racism now heavy you were there last

34:58

night no hold on on the racism charge no

35:02

no because we are everyone who defends

35:04

Palestinians in this country no matter

35:06

what they say like I'm a perfect example

35:08

I condemn Hamas I want to protect the

35:10

Jewish students I want a beautiful Pro

35:13

Palestine and Israel I want two states

35:15

and we're called anti-semites including

35:18

by your guest 247 the minute someone

35:21

calls never you lives don't matter all a

35:24

sudden everybody catches feelings ex I

35:26

haven't only goes one way it only goes

35:29

one way

35:31

right in this country I have never

35:34

called you an anti-semite I've never

35:35

called Dr West Ani I've never called

35:38

either of you racist and yet both of you

35:40

have gone along with calling me a racist

35:42

even though I'm not so yeah if you're

35:43

going framing look at your are you going

35:45

to ignore the framing piers are you

35:48

going to ignore the framing you know you

35:50

framed it this way and Piers you're not

35:52

Al

35:53

not hold on Pi let me give you a little

35:55

bit of credit you are open to the

35:57

Palestinian position 20% of the time to

36:00

that's why I come back on this show but

36:02

the American Media is filled with racist

36:05

against Muslims American politicians are

36:08

racist against Muslims and they Revel in

36:10

it blood rivers of blood in Gaza and

36:14

American politicians and the American

36:15

Media say not enough kill them more

36:17

Israel kill them more anyone who objects

36:20

to the wide Slaughter of those people is

36:23

called an anti-semite American Media is

36:25

sick just to be clear uh you were all

36:28

booked to take part in a debate

36:30

specifically about the protests at

36:31

Colombia so when you're asking why am I

36:33

focusing on the protest at Colombia that

36:36

is why you were all booked for this

36:37

segment and debate so don't try and be

36:39

disingenuous with viewers and make out

36:41

that you were booked for any wider

36:43

purpose because you weren't I wanted to

36:45

debate all the issues around what's

36:47

going on in colia what is interesting to

36:49

me let talk about let me let's talk

36:51

about let meish those peace prot the

36:53

same ones that came I'm sorry you don't

36:55

just keep talking on my show propaganda

36:58

against like people like

37:01

you RAC or war is always great peace is

37:05

always the bad guys it's

37:07

absurdity I agree with you about it

37:09

being AB peers do you get that we are

37:11

vomiting your propaganda we can't stand

37:14

it anymore it isn't just about you it's

37:16

all of media all of the politicians with

37:20

their non-stop propaganda that the

37:21

people in favor of Peace the people who

37:23

want to protect innocent lives are

37:25

somehow Pro terrorists are the B guys or

37:28

the anti-semites or the racists Etc

37:30

we're sick of the overwhelming

37:33

propaganda I'm pretty sick of being

37:35

Races by you guys so we've all got

37:37

across

37:38

let whether IDF or terrorist are the IDF

37:42

a terrorist organization killing

37:43

innocent children yes or no I do not

37:46

believe they're a terrorist organization

37:48

no oh come on of course teror they're at

37:52

War there's a big difference between

37:53

being a war being at War and being a

37:55

terrorist you may think they are

37:58

and you may think they are Jank you've

37:59

asked me a question I do not think they

38:02

are okay Bas on what do I think the ID

38:06

matter do I think the IDF has very

38:08

serious questions to answer about the

38:10

way they are executing this war

38:11

absolutely do we have international

38:13

criminal courts do we have Criminal

38:15

Courts and laws and rules to uh to hold

38:18

them to account absolutely and do I want

38:21

them to be held to account damn right I

38:24

do yeah and do I think they should be

38:25

invading Rafa no I do

38:28

don't mean that much to you man come on

38:30

oh it does mean as much to me let me

38:31

bring in Javier

38:32

again

38:34

talking this debate has got very

38:36

unpleasant for reasons that are slightly

38:38

lost on me given what the debate was

38:40

supposed to Corell let Javier speak okay

38:44

Javier you were there has been very

38:46

patient Javier you were there last night

38:48

and it's been pictured by uh Chen as it

38:51

was simply a bunch of very violent

38:53

pro-israel protesters attacking

38:56

completely innocent Pro Palestinian

38:58

protesters what was your experience

39:01

there what did you

39:03

see I mean that's not what happened

39:06

there and it's not what's happened at

39:07

any of these universities I don't know

39:08

why he's trying to portray it as if the

39:10

pro Palestinians are there peacefully I

39:12

also have a video on my Twitter of a pro

39:14

Palestinian chasing after a Jewish man

39:16

trying to tase him because she didn't

39:17

like what was on his sign I also saw a

39:20

man go and spit on a woman's dog simply

39:22

because she was on Design This Side so

39:25

no it's not this situation where you

39:27

have the prop Palestinians who are just

39:29

sitting there in their encampment and

39:30

not doing anything these people have

39:32

continuously been violent and I mean

39:34

even just looking over at what happened

39:35

in Colombia you're not busting into

39:37

windows and breaking into buildings if

39:39

you're there to be peaceful and to be

39:41

protesting peacefully that's not the

39:43

case so you are disingenuous think if

39:45

you're going to sit here and pretend

39:46

that the pro Palestinians are just being

39:48

innocent I don't understand how you

39:50

could even see it in that

39:52

way are you going to sit here there's

39:54

videos online are you going to sit here

39:56

and lie everyone and say that the pro

39:59

side didn't

40:01

attack well you both spoke over each

40:03

other so we didn't hear what either

40:04

person said okay all right let me just

40:06

ask Javier who's obviously lying about

40:09

this there's videos online of the

40:11

pro-israel side clearly attacking the

40:13

pro Palestinian side with sticks and

40:15

fireworks and pepper spray are you going

40:17

to sit here and lie on television and

40:19

say to everyone that the that that that

40:22

didn't happen because I go ahead you

40:24

lose all credibility go ahead liar they

40:27

were fighting back they were fighting

40:29

back and don't call me a liar I'm not

40:30

here to sit here name call him be

40:31

childish like you at your big age but oh

40:34

yeah you just called the pro Palestinian

40:36

side there is a woman who was put in the

40:37

hospital she was inent all of a sudden

40:40

yeah you just they were being dirty you

40:42

don't sit there and poop in a gender

40:44

neutral bucket and sit there and act

40:46

like you're not dirty I call the health

40:47

department it is filthy the way that

40:49

they're behaving is filthy I don't hate

40:51

Muslims but I do hate Muslim extremism I

40:53

have a lot of fundamental issues with

40:55

the Muslim extremism that's going on

40:57

world if the only way that you can get

40:59

your point across is going and raping

41:00

and beheading people then you're

41:02

probably a terrorist you're probably an

41:04

extr I have an issue with that I do have

41:06

an issue with the fact that you show an

41:08

ankle and you're killed in some of these

41:10

nations oh no I'm racist racist I don't

41:14

have any issue with Muslims in general I

41:17

didn't say did I not just say extrem I

41:19

just said extremist but you chose to

41:20

hear what you wanted to

41:23

hear [ __ ] into a bucket I wasn't even

41:25

just talking about the Muslims talking

41:27

about and the encampment the encampment

41:29

is disgusting they're all sitting there

41:31

with unwashed behinds protesting and

41:33

screaming out for the Bloodshed of Jews

41:34

and Christians worldwide so yeah I have

41:36

a problem with that I have a fundamental

41:39

issue with that that such a big

41:43

deal I lie where was the LIE the LIE

41:47

who's paying you Javier who's paying you

41:50

Javier Palestinian side started the

41:52

aggression they started the violence

41:54

when they went they attacked that Jewish

41:55

girl went the hospital that night and

41:57

then to escalate don't know what you're

42:00

talking about I mean that's that's

42:02

ridiculous that's like saying Turner

42:05

created he was the cause of the whole

42:07

issue of white supremacy because he's

42:09

responding to white supremacy that's

42:11

ridiculous and you know it's ridic why

42:13

are we still talking about white

42:15

supremacy in 2024 why are we still

42:17

talking about that hundreds of years

42:19

later what do white people do that black

42:22

people can how is white supremacy even

42:24

still on the Forefront of your mind

42:25

you're stuck in the past you're stuck in

42:27

these dated issues and

42:28

that's now you're really revealing your

42:31

ignorance brother you don't think white

42:32

supremacy has anything to do with what's

42:34

going on in Gaza how am I ignorant I've

42:36

been black for 27 years and I have never

42:39

been inferior to a white person what is

42:41

the white supremacy that has affecting

42:43

your life I would like to hear it nobody

42:45

in your family like to hear it what can

42:47

I do that a white

42:48

person right you one of the few black

42:51

people never been mistreated okay all

42:53

right all right I see I see saying that

42:55

I've never been mistreated every graic

42:57

has been mistreated why people get

42:59

mistreated all because Dem is getting

43:02

mistreated there is Prejudice from every

43:04

single demographic so I don't understand

43:06

what you think that that is so unique to

43:08

black people for all right you know what

43:11

I I've got to bring this I've got to

43:13

bring this debate to an end it was

43:14

supposed to be specifically about the

43:16

protest I'm sorry that it got so heated

43:19

and personally abusive I would like to

43:21

make it clear it wasn't your fault I

43:24

would like I would like to make it clear

43:25

to Corell and to CH I'm not a racist and

43:29

I genuinely care about the safety of

43:32

Jewish students of that University

43:33

that's it and that doesn't mean I don't

43:35

care about what's happening in Gaza or

43:37

the journalists there or the

43:38

universities there or any of those

43:39

things because actually I do and I've

43:41

expressed my concern about that in your

43:44

reporting let's see it in your reporting

43:46

well if you bother to watch it Cornell

43:48

you would know if you bother to watch it

43:50

you would know over and over and over

43:52

again brother that's why I come on your

43:53

show then you would not then you would

43:55

not call me a racist

43:57

yeah well I'm sorry you don't have a

43:59

right to call me a racist without

44:00

evidence and you didn't have any oh

44:02

please brother when the evidence is

44:03

overwhelming you can't even say the IDF

44:05

is B of terrorist and Palestinians but

44:07

Hamas terrorizes all the time

44:09

Palestinian lives don't mean the same as

44:11

Israeli lives for you ad it wrestle with

44:14

that in the Midnight Hour wrestle with

44:16

that midnight terrorism when you're at

44:19

War I don't think you understand the

44:21

definition of Terror I value every life

44:24

I value every life as equally important

44:27

even yours Corell how would white suac I

44:30

want you to tell me that I'm the

44:30

blackest person in LA county I've got to

44:33

leave it there look I value all of your

44:35

lies I value coming on the program I'm

44:37

sorry things got so personal but uh we

44:39

move on and we'll continue debating it I

44:42

believe that out of all the debate

44:43

hopefully we will get some solutions and

44:45

we'll get to a better place so thank you

44:46

for joining me

Rate This

5.0 / 5 (0 votes)

関連タグ
University ProtestsIsraeli-PalestinianFree SpeechCampus ConflictPolitical DebateHumanitarian AidProtests on CampusSecurity ConcernsMedia BiasTerrorism AllegationsFirst Amendment
日本語の要約は必要ですか?